18.7万年前的高速远程古滑坡:来自陕西华县莲花寺滑坡体上覆黄土光释光(OSL)测年的证据
详细信息 本馆镜像全文    |  推荐本文 | | 获取馆网全文
摘要
在渭河盆地东南缘的华山山前断裂北侧,对分布于陕西华县莲花寺一带数平方千米的黄土之下松散堆积的角砾岩的成因存在多种不同的认识,笔者根据地貌和堆积物特征支持其为高速远程滑坡的观点,并确定滑坡分为早、晚两期,后期还叠加了崩塌。野外调查发现覆盖于滑坡体上的黄土最大厚度达9m,根据第四纪黄土平均堆积速率估算的年龄与前人认为的滑坡时代大相径庭。为了准确厘定陕西华县莲花寺滑坡的形成时代,对覆盖于滑坡体上的黄土进行了5个剖面的样品采集,应用光释光(OSL)方法开展了系统的测年,结果5个剖面角砾岩之上最底部的黄土年龄在130.2±5.6~187.3±7.7ka之间,显示角砾岩之上堆积的黄土并不是同时形成的,其堆积的先后可能与古地形有关,角砾岩之上最底部黄土的最老年龄(187.3±7.7ka)代表了陕西华县莲花寺第二次滑坡形成时代的上限,即陕西华县莲花寺高速远程滑坡至少形成于18.7万年前。这是首次准确获得陕西华县莲花寺古滑坡的时代上限,亦是目前国内报道最老的高速远程滑坡,对滑坡的研究具有重要意义。同时,讨论了华县莲花寺高速远程滑坡的诱因可能是华山山前断裂的地震活动。
The study area is located in transition zone between the Qinling orogenic belt and Weihe basin of the southeast in Ordos block,is about 15km east of Huaxian,Shaanxi Province.Huashan piedmont fault is a crust-structural and geomorphologic boundary between the Qinling orogenic belt and the east of Weihe basin.The loose-accumulated breccia,in an area of 4 ~6km occurs under the loess in north-part of Huashan piedmont fault,Lianhuasi area in Huaxian.There are several viewpoints of origin of loose-accumulated breccia under loess.According to the field survey of landform characteristics and deposits,the authors prefer the viewpoint of high-speed remote landslide.We found that the landslide is composed of slide bed,slip,sliding surface,the posterior wall of the landslide,landslide perimeter,landslides depression and so on;the landslides can be divided into early and late two stages,and collapse superimposed in late stage landslide.Early stage landslide is corresponding to the chair circle landscape in hilltop of Zhangjiashan,breccia is deposits in Baiya Lake hole depth 60.10m to 70.23m,with a thickness of 10.13m.Late stage landslide corresponds to lower chair circle landscape in the southern of Baoyu valley,breccia is deposits in Baiya Lake hole depth 33.74 ~ 50.15m in thickness of 16.41m.What is the age of late stage landslide? Most researchers think that it is associated with M_S= 51/2 Huaxian earthquakes of November 3,1072 or M_S = 8 Huaxian earthquakes of January 23,1556.However,we find that the maximum thickness of loess covered in the landslides is up to 9m during the field investigation,so,it must be formed in at least the tens of thousands years ago according to the Quaternary loess accretion rate projections.In order to constraint accurately the age of Lianhuasi landslides of Huaxian,Shaanxi Province,we gather 17 OSL samples from loess accumulated above late stage landslide in five cross section selected,breccia were collected.We carried out OSL dating of bottom of the loess cover on landslides from five cross section are from 130.2±5.6ka to 187.3±7.7ka,it means that bottom loess cover on landslides formed in different time,it may be related to the ancient landform.The oldest age have been get 187.3±7.7kaB.P.,it represent the late stage landslides of Lianhuasi of Huaxian formed in 187.3kaB.P.ago.It is the first time to accurately obtain the upper boundary of age of late landslides of Lianhuasi of Huaxian,this paper reports that it is the oldest highspeed and runout landslide in China,it is of a very important significance in landslide research.So that,the reasonable interpretation of Huaxian Lianhuasi landslides is induced by seismic activity of Huashan piedmont fault.
引文
1单修正.1556年华县地震人口死亡原因浅析.灾害学,1988,(4):94-96Shan Xiuzheng.Analysis on population death reasons of Huaxian earthquake in 1556.Journal of Catastrophology,1988,(4):94-96
    2宋立胜.1556年华县8级大震死亡人数初探.灾害学,1989,(4):68-72Song Lisheng.Preliminary study on the number of the deaths of the great Huaxian earthquake in 1556.Journal of Catastrophology,1989,(4):68-72
    3李祥根,冉勇康.华山北坡及渭南塬前活断层.华北地震科学,1983,1(2):10-19Li Xianggen,Ran Yongkang.Active faults in the north slope of Huashan Mountain and the front of the Weinan tableland.North China Earthquake Sciences,1983,1(2):10-19
    4贺明静.华县大地震与断裂活动.地震研究,1986,9(4):427-432He Mingjing.The great 1556 Huaxian earthquake and the related faulting.Journal of Seismological Research,1986,9(4):427-432
    5贺明静,胡孟春,吕莲.渭河盆地东南部断裂带第四纪构造活动与地震.西北地震学报,1987,9(3):45-50He Mingjing,Hu Mengchun,L(u|¨)Lian.The Quaternary tectonic activity and earthquakes along the fault belt in the southeast of Weihe basin.Northwestern Seismological Journal,1987,9(3):45-50
    6国家地震局鄂尔多斯周缘活动断裂系课题组.鄂尔多斯周缘活动断裂系.北京:地震出版社,1987.124-129The Research Group on“Active Fault System around Ordos Massif",State Seismological Bureau.Active Fault System around Ordos Massif.Beijing:Seismological Publishing House,1987.124-129
    7张安良,米丰收,种瑾.1556年陕西华县大地震形变遗迹及华山山前断裂古地震研究.地震地质,1989,11(3):73-82Zhang Anliang,Mi Fengshou,Chong Jin.Deformation relics of the1556 Huaxian(Shananxi,China)great earthquake and the study of palaeoseismicity on the frontal fault zone of the Huashan Mts.Seismology and Geology,1989,11(3):73-82
    8彭建兵,米丰收,苏生瑞等.渭河盆地活动断裂与地质灾害.西安:西北大学出版社,1992.10-35Peng Jianbing,Mi Fengshou,Su Shengrui et al.Active Faults and Geological Hazard in Weihe Basin.Xi'an:Northwest University Press,1992.10-35
    9易明初.新构造运动及渭延裂谷构造.北京:地震出版社,1993.101-108Yi Mingchu.Neotectonic Movement and Weiyan Rift Structure.Beijing:Seismological Publishing House,1993.101-108
    10陕西省地震局.秦岭北缘活动断裂带.北京:地震出版社,1996.14-22Seismological Bureau of Shaanxi Province.The Active Fault Zone in the North Edge of Qinling Range.Beijing:Seismological Publishing House,1996.14-22
    11原廷宏,冯希杰.一五五六年华县特大地震.北京:地震出版社,2010.1-120Yuan Tinghong,Feng Xijie.The 1556 Great Huaxian Earthquake.Beijing:Seismological Publishing House,2010.1-120
    12王景明.1556年陕西华县大地震的地面破裂.地震学报,1980,2(4):430~439Wang Jingming.Ground ruptures during the large earthquake of1556,Huaxian County,Shanxi.Acta Seismologica Sinica,1980,2(4):430~439
    13侯建军.1556年陕西省华县大震的地震地质条件.西北地震学报,1985,7(1):66-74Hou Jianjun.The seismic and geologic conditions of the earthquake in Huaxian,Shanxi(M=8.0,Jan.23,1556).Northwestern Seismological Journal,1985,7(1):66~74
    14徐锡伟,张宏卫,邓起东.渭河盆地华山山前断裂带古地震遗迹及其重复间隔.地震地质,1988,10(4):206Xu Xiwei,Zhang Hongwei,Deng Qidong.The paleoearthquake traces on Huashan front fault zone in Weihe basin and its earthquake intervals.Seismology and Geology,1988,10(4);206
    15谢毓寿.1556年关中大地震的震级.灾害学,1992,7(1):10-13Xie Yushou.On magnitude of 1556 Guanzhong great earthquake.Journal of Catastrophology,1992,7(1):10-13
    16潘建雄,吴业彪,张玉岫等.关于1556年华县大地震及岳阳地震的讨论.地震地质,1993,15(3):261-267Pan Jianxiong,Wu Yebiao,Zhang Yuxiu et al.A discussion on earthquakes in Huaxian,Shanxi Province,and in Yueyang,Hunan Province,in 1556.Seismology and Geology,1993,15(3):261-267
    17环文林,时振梁,李世勋.对1556年8 1/4级大地震震中位置和发震构造的新认识.中国地震,2003,19(1):20-32Huan Wenlin,Shi Zhenliang,Li Shixun.The new recognizes for epicenter location and seismogenic structure of 1556 MS 1/4 large earthquake.Earthquake Research in China,2003,19(1):20-32
    18孟河清.陇海铁路华山地区的泥石流.水土保持通报,1986,(2):60-63Meng Heqing.Mud-rock flows in Huashan area of LanzhouLianyungartg railway.Soil and Water Conservation Bulletin,1986,(2):60~63
    19王汝雕.陕西华县大地震引发世界罕见的地震次生灾害链——从山西荣河蒲州陕西朝邑三城的工程场地条件谈起.山西地震,2006,126(2):4-7Wang Rudiao.Huaxian,Shaanxi strong earthquake infrequent secondary disaster chain caused by the earthquake in the world-talk from engineering ground condition.Earthquake Research in Shanxi,2006,126(2):4-7
    20李昭淑,崔鹏.1556年华县大地震的次生灾害.山地学报,2007,25(4):425-430Li Zhaoshu,Cui Peng.The secondary disasters of great Huaxian earthquake in 1556.Journal of Mountain Science,2007,25(4):425-430
    21周群英.陕西华县莲花寺秦岭北坡特大山崩的年代及成因探析.陕西教育学院学报,2010,26(3:):86—90Zhou Qunying.Ancient landslide at the pediment of the Qinling Mountains near Lianhuasi,Hua County,Shaan'xi Province.Journal of Shaanxi Institute of Eduction,2010,26(3:):86-90
    22张伯声.在块断构造基础上说明秦岭两侧河流的发育.地质学报,1964,44(4):405-417Zhang Bosheng.The bearing of block faulting to stream development on both sides of the chinling ranges.Acta Geologica Sinica,1964,44(4):405~417
    23殷跃平主编.中国典型滑坡.北京:中国大地出版社,2007.111-113Yin Yueping eds.Landslides in China——Selected Case Studies.Beijing:China Land Press,2007.111-113
    24刘东生.黄土与环境.北京:科学出版社,1985.458-460Liu Tungsheng.Loess and Environment.Beijing:Science Press,1985.458-460
    25鹿化煜,周亚利,Mason J A等.中国北方晚第四纪气候变化的沙漠与黄土记录——以光释光年代为基础的直接对比.第四纪研究,2006,26(6):888-894Lu Huayu,Zhou Yali,Mason J A et al.Late Quaternary climatic changes in Northern China——New evidences from sand dune and loess records based on optically stimulated luminescence dating.Quaternary Sciences,2006,26(6):888-894
    26赖忠平.基于光释光测年的中国黄土中氧同位素阶段2/1和3/2界限位置及年代的确定.第四纪研究,2008,28(4):883-891Lai Zhongping.Locating and dating the boundaries of MIS 2/1 and3/2 in Chinese loess using luminescence techniques.Quaternary Sciences,2008,28(4):883-891
    27张家富,莫多闻,夏正楷等.沉积物的光释光测年和对沉积过程的指示意义.第四纪研究,2009,29(1):23-33Zhang Jiafu,Mo Dowen,Xia Zhengkai et al.Optical dating of sediments from China and its implication for depositional processes.Quaternary Sciences,2009,29(1):23-33
    28李晓妮,卢演俦,王旭龙.洛川黄土细颗粒混合矿物红外释光信号异常衰减的初步研究.第四纪研究,2007,27(4):553-558Li Xiaoni,Lu Yanchou,Wang Xulong.A preliminary study of anomalous fading of polymineral grain IRSL signals from the Luochuan loess.Quaternary Sciences,2007,27(4):553-558
    29杜金花,卢演俦,王旭龙等.晋豫间黄河峡谷黄土状沙丘的光释光年代学探讨.第四纪研究,2010,30(5):946-955Du Jinhua,Lu Yanchou,Wang Xulong et al.Optically Stimulated Luminescence dating of loess-like sand-dune along the Yellow River valley between Henan and Shannxi provinces.Quaternary Sciences,2010,30(5):946-955
    30王旭龙,卢演俦,李晓妮.黄土细颗粒单测片再生法光释光测年的进展.核技术,2005,28(5):383-387Wang Xulong,Lu Yanchou,Li Xiaoni.Progess in luminescence dating of Chinese loess by single-aliquot regenerative-does(SAR)protocol.Nuclear Techniques,2005,28(5):383-387
    31 Kang Shugang,Lu Yanchou,Wang Xulong.Closely-spaced recuperated OSL dating of the last interglacial paleosol in the southeastern margin of the Chinese Loess Plateau.Quaternary Geochronology,2011,6(2011):480-490
    32殷志强,程国明,李小林等.中更新世早中期以来黄河上游与三峡库区滑坡形成机理与气候变化关系研究.第四纪研究,2010,30(1):37-45Yin Zhiqiang,Cheng Guoming,Li Xiaolin et al.Relationships between landslide forming mechanisms and climate changes since early Mid-Pleistocene in the upper reaches of Yellow River and the Three Gorges Reservoir area.Quaternary Sciences,2010,30(1):37-45
    33 Prescott J R,Hutton J T.Cosmic ray contribution to dose rates for luminescence and ESR dating:Large depths and long term time variations.Radiation Measurements,1994,23:497-500
    34 Highland L M,Bobrowsky Peter.The Landslide Handbook——A Guide to Understanding Landslides.Reston,Virginia:U.S.Geological Survey Circular 1325,2008.129
    35许强,黄润秋.5.12汶川大地震诱发大型崩滑灾害动力特征初探.工程地质学报,2008,16(6):721-729Xu Qiang,Huang Runqiu.Kinetics characteristics of large landslides triggered by May 12~(th)Wenchuan earthquake.Journal of Engineering Geology,2008,16(6):721-729
    36殷跃平.汶川八级地震滑坡特征分析.工程地质学报,2009,17(1):29-38Yin Yueping.Features of landslide triggered by the Wenchuan earthquake.Journal of Engineering Geology,2009,17(1):29-38
    37王兰生,王小群,许向宁等.岷江叠溪古堰塞湖的研究意义.第四纪研究,2012,32(5):998-1010Wang Lansheng,Wang Xiaoqun,Xu Xiangning et al.Significances of studying the Diexi paleo-dammed lake at the upstream of Minjiang River,Sichuan,China.Quaternary Sciences,2012,32(5):998-1010
    38李海龙,张岳桥,李建华.青藏高原东缘南北向河流系统及其伴生古堰塞湖研究.第四纪研究,2010,30(4):812-824Li Hailong,Zhang Yueqiao,Li Jianhua.Meridional river systems and ancient dammed lakes on the east margin of the Tibetan Plateau.Quaternary Sciences,2010,30(4):812-824
    39黄润秋.中国西部地区典型岩质滑坡机理研究.第四纪研究,2003,23(6):640-647Huang Runqiu.Mechanism of large scale landslides in Western China.Quaternary Sciences,2003,23(6):640-647

版权所有:© 2023 中国地质图书馆 中国地质调查局地学文献中心