灾害链灾情累积放大研究方法进展
详细信息 本馆镜像全文    |  推荐本文 | | 获取馆网全文
摘要
近年来全球范围内频发的重大自然灾害事件,表明一种灾害引发一系列次生灾害的灾害链现象使得灾情通过累积放大效应而大大超过单一灾种灾情,深入研究灾害链灾情累积放大过程是有效防范巨灾风险的前提。首先,本文梳理了国内外研究中不同视角下对灾害链现象的理解,认为灾害链一般性概念中应当包含孕灾环境、致灾因子链、承灾体以及它们在时间和空间上复杂相互作用关系,只有从地理学的综合性角度出发,才能正确而完整的理解灾害链过程灾情累积放大机制。其次,按研究思路的差异,综述了当前研究灾害链灾情累积放大过程的5类方法,包括经验地学统计方法、概率模型、复杂网络模型、灾害模拟以及多学科理论方法。从描述灾害链要素在时间和空间上复合作用的角度出发,分别讨论了它们在刻画灾害链灾情放大过程中的优势与不足。选取了影响较大、灾害引发关系典型的地震灾害链与台风灾害链,从灾种维度综述上述几种方法在实际应用中的概况及进展。最后,提出综合多种方法发展与完善灾害链灾情累积放大效应过程的动态模拟是灾害链的研究趋势,其中关键在于模拟灾害链系统各要素的时间与空间上的耦合,研究思路从"静态—描述—解释"向"动态—过程—模拟"的转变是理解灾害链、灾害系统复杂性的重要途径。
In recent years, the frequent catastrophic disasters have caused great losses of human lives and properties in the world. This indicates that disaster losses may be accumulated and amplified through disaster chains,in which one disaster triggers another, and so forth. The losses are much heavier in disaster chains than in a single disaster. Disaster chain is a typical complex form of regional disaster system. Understanding the amplification mechanisms of disaster chains is very important in catastrophe risk governance. This review first focuses on the concepts and understandings of disaster chain and summarizes a comprehensive definition from the geographic perspective through literature research. It is found that disaster chains have two common features, including the casualty relationship between different disasters and the spatial and temporal expansion of disaster losses. Only under a geographical framework, a sound and complete understanding of the disaster chain concept may be possible. A regional disaster system includes the environment, hazards, and exposure units and the complex spatial and temporal interactions of these elements. Second, considering the different research philosophies, five method categories in recently disaster chain research are summarized and analyzed. The five categories include empirical statistics methods, probabilistic models, complex network models, disaster system simulations, and multidisciplinary theories. The appropriateness and disadvantages of each category of methods are discussed with respect to their utility in describing disaster chain loss accumulation and amplification. Empirical statistics methods are a classical one that often use weighted average of a series of indicators. They have great advantage in taking into consideration various geographic factors and the modeling process is simple. But these methods cannot reveal the disaster chain evolution and processes. Probabilistic models can generate an overview of all possible events after a disaster have happened, as well as calculate the conditional probability. But they have the same problem as the statistics models. Disaster chain is a typical complex network. So the complex network theory may be used to describe the evolution of disaster chain networks. Such method should consider the spatial and temporal features of the disaster chain components in order to make the result more precise. Simulation methods are a promising one that can support the understanding of disaster chains dynamics, as well as the mechanism of the accumulation and amplification of disaster chain losses. However, simulation precision should be improved by including the spatial and temporal features of disaster chains in the future. Two types of important disaster chains, the seismic and typhoon disaster chains were used as examples to show the practical application of these methods. Finally, this review shows that the main trend of disaster chain research is to build and improve the dynamical model of disaster chain loss accumulation and amplification processes. The key is to connect all the factors spatially and temporally in a disaster chain system. It is necessary to transform the research approaches from "static-descriptive-explanatory" to "dynamic-process oriented-simulation" in order to understand the complexity of a disaster system.
引文
钞柯.2012.基于知识元的突发事件连锁反应模型研究[D].大连:大连理工大学.[Chao K.2012.Research on emergency chain reaction model based on knowledge unit[D].Dalian,China:Dalian University of Technology.]
    陈长坤,纪道溪.2012.基于复杂网络的台风灾害演化系统风险分析与控制研究.灾害学,27(1):1-4.[Chen C K,JiD X.2012.Risk analysis and control for the evolution disaster system of typhoon based on complex network.Journal of Catastrophology,27(1):1-4.]
    陈长坤,李智,孙云凤.2008.基于复杂网络的灾害信息传播特征研究.灾害学,23(4):126-129.[Chen C K,Li Z,SunY F.2008.Study on characteristics of disaster information transmission based on complex networks.Journal ofCatastrophology,23(4):126-129.]
    陈长坤,孙云凤,李智.2009.冰雪灾害危机事件演化及衍生链特征分析.灾害学,24(1):18-21.[Chen C K,Sun Y F,Li Z.2009.Characteristic analysis of evolution and derivation chain of risk events caused by snow and ice disaster.Journal of Catastrophology,24(1):18-21.]
    陈建平,丁火平,王功文,等.2004.基于GIS和元胞自动机的荒漠化演化预测模型.遥感学报,8(3):254-260.[Chen JP,Din H P,Wang G W,et al.2004.Desertification evolution modeling through the integration of GIS and cellularautomata.Journal of Remote Sensing,8(3):254-260.]
    陈香,陈静,王静爱.2007.福建台风灾害链分析:以2005年"龙王"台风为例.北京师范大学学报:自然科学版,43(2):203-208.[Chen X,Chen J,Wang J A.2007.Analysisof typhoon disaster chain in Fujian:a case study of typhoon Longwang in 2005.Journal of Beijing Normal University:Natural Science,43(2):203-208.]
    崔云,孔纪名,吴文平.2012.汶川地震次生山地灾害链成灾特点与防治对策.自然灾害学报,21(1):109-116.[CuiY,Kong J M,Wu W P.2012.Cause characteristics andprevention/control strategies of the secondary mountaindisaster chain of the Wenchuan Earthquake.Journal ofNatural Disaster,21(1):109-116.]
    邓睿,黄敬峰.2011."莫拉克"台风引起的滑坡泥石流灾害HJ-1图像遥感监测研究.国土资源遥感,(1):106-109.[Deng R,Huang J F.2011.The monitoring of landslideand debris flow caused by typhoon Morakot based on HJ-1 images.Remote Sensing for Land&Resources,(1):106-109.]
    董磊磊.2009.基于贝叶斯网络的突发事件链建模研究[D].大连:大连理工大学.[Dong L L.2009.Modeling emergency events chain based on Bayesian Networks[D].Dalian,China:Dalian University of Technology.]
    葛月.2012.突发公共事件台风的衍生网络模型研究[D].大连:大连理工大学.[Ge Y.2012.Research of the derivednetwork model about the public emergency of typhoon[D].Dalian,China:Dalian University of Technology.]
    郭增建,秦保燕.1987.灾害物理学简论.灾害学,(2):25-33.[Guo Z J,Qin B Y.1987.Brief discussion on disasterphysics.Journal of Catastrophology,(2):25-33.]
    国家汶川地震灾后重建规划组.2008.国家汶川地震灾后恢复重建总体规划[DB/OL].2012-09-23[2014-11-07].www.gov.cn/wcdzzhhfcjghzqyj-g.pdf[State PlanningGroup of Post-Wenchuan Earthquake Restoration and Reconstruction.2008.The state overall planning for PostWenchuan Earthquake restoration and reconstruction[DB/OL].2012-09-23[2014-11-07].www.gov.cn/wcdzzhhfcjghzqyjg.pdf]
    胡明生,贾志娟,吉晓宇,等.2012a.基于改进萤火虫群的区域灾害链挖掘方法.计算机应用与软件,29(11):29-31,86.[Hu M S,Jia Z J,Ji X Y,et al.2012a.Regional disaster chain mining approach based on improved glowwormswarm optimization.Computer Applications and Software,29(11):29-31,86.]
    胡明生,贾志娟,刘思,等.2012b.基于蚁群优化的历史灾害关联分析方法.计算机应用与软件,29(10):62-64.[HuM S,Jia Z J,Liu S,et al.2012b.Approach for historicaldisaster correlation analysis based on ant colony optimization.Computer Applications and Software,29(10):62-64.]
    黄崇福.2006.综合风险管理的地位、框架设计和多态灾害链风险分析研究.应用基础与工程科学学报,14(S):29-37.[Huang C F.2006.Role of integrated risk management,framework design and study on risk analysis ofpolymorphic disaster chain.Journal of Basic Science andEngineering,14(S):29-37.]
    居丽丽,穆海振.2012.上海台风、大雾和高温灾害链的建立和分析.第十四届中国科协年会第14分会场:极端天气事件与公共气象服务发展论坛.石家庄:2012-09-08.[Ju L L,Mu H Z.2012.Establishment and analysis on typhoon,heavy fog and high temperature disaster chain inShanghai.The 14th annual of china association for science and technology:the extreme weather events and public meteorological services development forum.Shijiazhuang,China:September 8th-10th,2012.]
    黎夏,叶嘉安,刘小平,等.2007.地理模拟系统:元胞自动机与多智能体.北京:科学出版社.[Li X,Ye J A,Liu X P,et al.2007.Dili moni xitong:yuanbao zidongji.Beijing,China:Science Press.]
    李藐,陈建国,陈涛,等.2010.突发事件的事件链概率模型.清华大学学报:自然科学版,50(8):1173-1177.[Li M,Chen J G,Chen T,et al.2010.Probability for disasterchains in emergencies.Journal of Tsinghua University:Science&Technology,50(8):1173-1177.]
    李永善.1988.灾害的放大过程.灾害学,(2):18-24.[Li Y S.1988.Amplification process of disaster.Journal of Catastrophology,(2):18-24.]
    李智.2010.基于复杂网络的灾害事件演化与控制模型研究[D].长沙:中南大学.[Li Z.2010.Jiyu fuza wangluo dezaihai shijian yanhua yu kongzhi moxing yanjiu[D].Changsha,China:Central South University.]
    刘健利,温家洪,尹占娥,等.2009.灾害系统模拟技术和方法述评.灾害学,24(1):106-111.[Liu J L,Wen J H,YinZ E,et al.2009.Simulation technologies and methods fordisaster system:a review.Journal of Catastrophology,24(1):106-111.]
    刘文方,肖盛燮,隋严春,等.2006.自然灾害链及其断链减灾模式分析.岩石力学与工程学报,25(S1):2675-2681.[Liu W F,Xiao S X,Sui Y C,et al.2006.Analysis of natural disaster chain and chain-cutting disaster mitigationmode.Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,25(S1):2675-2681.]
    路光.2013.基于分层认知模型的突发事件衍生网络研究[D].大连:大连理工大学.[Lu G.2013.Research onemergency derivative network based on layered cognitivemodel[D].Dalian,China:Dalian University of Technology.]
    倪子建,荣莉莉.2013.面向灾害关联的灾害超网模型.系统管理学报,22(3):407-414.[Ni Z J,Rong L L.2013.Supernetwork of the emergency for association of disasters.Journal of Systems&Management,22(3):407-414.]
    潘安定,唐晓春,刘会平.2002.广东沿海台风灾害链现象与防治途径的设想.广州大学学报:自然科学版,1(3):55-61.[Pan A D,Tang X C,Liu H P.2002.Preliminary research into the typhoon disaster chain in Guangdongcoastal area.Journal of Guangzhou University:NaturalScience Edition,1(3):55-61.]
    裘江南,刘丽丽,董磊磊.2012.基于贝叶斯网络的突发事件链建模方法与应用.系统工程学报,27(6):739-750.[Qiu J N,Liu L L,Dong L L.2012.Modeling methodand application of emergent event chain based on Bayesian network.Journal of Systems Engineering,27(6):739-750.]
    史培军.1991.灾害研究的理论与实践.南京大学学报,(专刊):37-42.[Shi P J.1991.Theory and practice of disastersystem research.Journal of Nanjing University,(specialedition):37-42.]
    史培军.1996.再论灾害研究的理论与实践.自然灾害学报,5(4):8-19.[Shi P J.1996.Theory and practice of disasterstudy.Journal of Natural Disasters,5(4):8-19.]
    史培军.2002.三论灾害研究的理论与实践.自然灾害学报,11(3):1-9.[Shi P J.2002.Theory on disaster science anddisaster dynamics.Journal of Natural Disasters,11(3):1-9.]
    史培军.2005.四论灾害研究的理论与实践.自然灾害学报,14(6):1-7.[Shi P J.2005.Theory and practice of disastersystem research in a fourth time.Journal of Natural Disasters,14(6):1-7.]
    史培军.2008.从南方冰雪灾害成因看巨灾防范对策.中国减灾,2008(2):12-15.[Shi P J.2008.Cong nanfangbingxue zaihai chengyin kan juzai fangfan duice.DisasterReduction in China,2008(2):12-15.]
    史培军.2009.五论灾害研究的理论与实践.自然灾害学报,18(5):1-9.[Shi P J.2009.Theory and practice of disastersystem research in a fifth time.Journal of Natural Disasters,18(5):1-9.]
    王铎.2010.基于关联度的突发事件网络模型研究[D].大连:大连理工大学.[Wang D.2010.Network model of emergency events based on correlation[D].Dalian,China:Dalian University of Technology.]
    王建伟,荣莉莉.2008.突发事件的连锁反应网络模型研究.计算机应用研究,25(11):3288-3291.[Wang J W,RongL L.2008.Research on chain-reacting network model ofemergency events.Application Research of Computers,25(11):3288-3291.]
    王静爱,雷永登,周洪建,等.2012.中国东南沿海台风灾害链区域规律与适应对策研究.北京师范大学学报:社会科学版,(2):130-138.[Wang J A,Lei Y D,Zhou H J,etal.2012.Regional features and adaptation countermeasures of typhoon disaster chains in southeast coastal region of China.Journal of Beijing Normal University:Social Science,(2):130-138.]
    王静爱,周洪建,袁艺,等.2013.区域灾害系统与台风灾害链风险防范模式:以广东为例.北京:中国环境出版社.[Wang J A,Zhou H J,Yuan Y,et al.2013.Quyu zaihai xitong yu taifeng zaihailian fengxian fangfan moshi:yiGuangdong weili.Beijing,China:China EnvironmentPress.]
    文传甲.1994.论大气灾害链.灾害学,9(3):1-6.[Wen C J.1994.On atmosphere disaster chain.Journal of Catastrophology,9(3):1-6.]
    翁文国,倪顺江,申世飞,等.2007.复杂网络上灾害蔓延动力学研究.物理学报,56(4):1938-1943.[Weng W G,NiS J,Shen S F,et al.2007.Dynamics of disaster spreadingin complex networks.Acta Physica Sinaca.56(4):1938-1943.]
    肖东升.2009.基于GIS和CA的地震灾害压埋人员情景分析与评估理论[D].成都:西南交通大学.[Xiao D S.2009.Study on scenario analysis and evaluating theory ofseismic buried personnel based on GIS and CA[D].Chengdu,China:Southwest Jiaotong University.]
    肖盛燮,冯玉涛,王肇慧,等.2006.灾变链式阶段的演化形态特征.岩石力学与工程学报,25(S1):2629-2633.[Xiao S X,Feng Y T,Wang Z H,et al.2006.Shape characteristics of evolvement chain-styled phases of disasters.Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,25(S1):2629-2633.]
    杨德宽,王雪华,裘江南,等.2012.基于知识元网络的突发事件模型组合调用.系统工程,30(9):87-93.[Yang D K,Wang X H,Qiu J N,et al.2012.Emergency model integrate based on knowledge element net.System Engineering,30(9):87-93.]
    姚清林.2007.自然灾害链的场效机理与区链观.气象与减灾研究,30(3):31-36,75.[Yao Q L.2007.Field effectand regional conversion as the mechanism of natural hazard chains.Meteorology and Disaster Reduction Research,30(3):97-93.]
    叶金玉,林广发,张明锋.2014.福建省台风灾害链空间特征分析.福建师范大学学报:自然科学版,30(2):99-106.[Ye J Y,Lin G F,Zhang M F.2014.Spatial characteristicsof typhoon disaster chains in Fujian Province.Journal ofFujian Normal University:Natural Science Edition,30(2):99-106.]
    于海峰.2013.基于知识元的突发事件系统结构模型及演化研究[D].大连理工大学.[Yu H F.2013.Research onstructure model and evolution of emergency systembased on knowledge element[D].Dalian,China:DalianUniversity of Technology.]
    余世舟,张令心,赵振东,等.2010.地震灾害链概率分析及断链减灾方法.土木工程学报,43(S):479-483.[Yu S Z,Zhang L X,Zhao Z D,et al.2010.Probability analysis ofearthquake disaster chain and chain-cutting disaster mitigation method.China Civil Engineering Journal,43(S):479-483.]
    张卫星,周洪建.2013.灾害链风险评估的概念模型:以汶川5.12特大地震为例.地理科学进展,32(1):130-138.[Zhang W X,Zhou H J.2013.Concetural model of disaster chain risk assessment:taking Wenchuan Earthquakeon 12 May 2008 as a case.Progress in Geography,32(1):130-138.]
    仲秋雁,郭艳敏,王宁,等.2012.基于知识元的非常规突发事件情景模型研究.情报科学,30(1):115-120.[ZhongQ Y,Guo Y M,Wang N,et al.2012.Research on unconventional emergency scenario model based on knowledgeelement.Information Science,30(1):115-120.]
    周成虎,欧阳,马廷,等.2009.地理系统模拟的CA模型理论探讨.地理科学进展,28(6):833-838.[Zhou C H,Ou Y,Ma T,et al.2009.Theoretical perspectives of CA-basedgeographical system modeling.Progress in Geography,28(6):833-838.]
    周洪建,王曦,袁艺,等.2014.半干旱区极端强降雨灾害链损失快速评估方法:以甘肃岷县“5.10”特大山洪泥石流灾害为例.干旱区研究,31(3):440-445.[Zhou H J,Wang X,Yuan Y,et al.2014.Rapid-assessing methods ofloss in extremely heavy rainfall disaster chain in semiaridregion.Arid Zone Research,31(3):440-445.]
    朱伟,陈长坤,纪道溪,等.2011.我国北方城市暴雨灾害演化过程及风险分析.灾害学,26(3):88-91.[Zhu W,ChenC K,Ji D X,et al.2011.Analysis on the risk and evolution process of rainstorm disaster in cities of North China.Journal of Catastrophology,26(3):88-91.]
    Anonymous.2011.Chain reaction.Nature Geoscience,4(5):269-269.
    Badal J,Vazquez-Prada M,Gonzalez A.2005.Preliminaryquantitative assessment of earthquake casualties and damages.Natural Hazards,34(3):353-374.
    Barabasi A L,Albert R.1999.Emergence of scaling in randomnetworks.Science,286(5439):509-512.
    Buesseler K O,Jayne S R,Fisher N S,et al.2012.Fukushimaderived radionuclides in the ocean and biota off Japan.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of theUnited States of America,109(16):5984-5988.
    Carpignano A,Golia E,Di Mauro C,et al.2009.A methodological approach for the definition of multi-risk maps atregional level:first application.Journal of Risk Research,12(3-4):513-534.
    Chavoshi S H,Delavar M R,Soleimani M,et al.2008.Towarddeveloping an expert GIS for damage evaluation after anearthquake(case study:Tehran).Proceedings of the 5thInternational ISCRAM conference,Washington,WA:May 5th.
    Crisci G M,Rongo R,Di Gregorio S,et al.2004.The simulation model SCIARA:the 1991 and 2001 lava flows atMount Etna.Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research,132(2-3):253-267.
    Delmonaco G,Margottini C,Spizzichino D.2006.ARMONIAmethodology for multi-risk assessment and the harmonisation of different natural risk maps[DB/OL].2010-07-19[2014-11-07].http://forum.eionet.europa.eu/eionet-air-climate/library/public/2010_citiesproject/interchange/armonia_project/armonia_project_5/download/1/ARMONIA_PROJECT_Deliverable%203.1.1.pdf
    Duenas-Osorio L,Vemuru S M.2009.Cascading failures incomplex infrastructure systems.Structural Safety,31(2):157-167.
    FEMA.1995.National mitigation strategy:partnerships for building safer communities[DB/OL].1995-12-06[2014-11-07].http://hazardmitigation.calema.ca.gov/docs/1995_National_Mitigation_Strategy_web.pdf
    Gitis V G,Petrova E N,Pirogov S A.1994.Catastrophechains:hazard assessment.Natural Hazards,10(1-2):117-121.
    Helbing D.2013.Globally networked risks and how to respond.Nature,497:51-59.
    Helbing D,Kühnert C.2003.Assessing interaction networkswith applications to catastrophe dynamics and disastermanagement.Physica A:Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications,328(3-4):584-606.
    Huang R Q,Fan X M.2013.The landslide story.Nature Geoscience,6:325-326.
    IPCC.2012.A special report of working groups I and II of theintergovernmental panel on climate change.Cambridge,UK:Cambridge University Press:1-19.
    Kappes M S.2011.Multi-hazard risk analysises:a conceptand its implementation[D].Wien,Austria:University ofVienna.
    Kappes M S,Keiler M,von Elverfeldt K,et al.2012.Challenges of analyzing multi-hazard risk:a review.Natural Hazards,64(2):1925-1958.
    Karafyllidis I.2004.Design of a dedicated parallel processorfor the prediction of forest fire spreading using cellularautomata and genetic algorithms.Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence,17(1):19-36.
    Keefer D K.2002.Investigating landslides caused by earthquakes:a historical review.Surveys in Geophysics,23(6):473-510.
    Khan F I,Abbasi S A.2001.An assessment of the likelihoodof occurrence,and the damage potential of domino effect(chain of accidents)in a typical cluster of industries.Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,14(4):283-306.
    Li J,Chen C K.2014.Modeling the dynamics of disaster evolution along causality networks with cycle chains.Physica A:Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications,401:251-264.
    Li X,Yeh A G O.2000.Modelling sustainable urban development by the integration of constrained cellular automataand GIS.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,14(2):131-152.
    Li Y,Gong J H,Zhu J,et al.2013.Spatiotemporal simulationand risk analysis of dam-break flooding based on cellularautomata.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,27(10):2043-2059.
    Lubos B,Karsten P,Dirk H.2006.Modeling the dynamics ofdisaster spreading in networks.Physica A:Statistical Mechanics and its Applications,363(1):132-140.
    Perucca L P,Esper Angillieri M Y.2009.Evolution of a debrisrock slide causing a natural dam:the flash flood of RioSanta Cruz,Province of San Juan-November 12,2005.Natural Hazards,50(2):305-320.
    Selva J.2013.Long-term multi-risk assessment:statisticaltreatment of interaction among risks.Natural Hazards,67(2):701-722.
    Shi P J,Shuai J B,Chen W F,et al.2010.Study on large-scaledisaster risk assessment and risk transfer models.International Journal of Disaster Risk Science,1(2):1-8.
    Shi P J,Wang J A,Xu W,et al.2012.Formation mechanism,process and risk evaluation system of disaster chain.Proceedings of the international disaster and risk conference.Davos,Switzerland:August 25th.
    Stone R.2008.Wenchuan Earthquake-Scientists race againstthe clock to gauge landslide risk.Science,320(5882):1408.
    Travis J.2005.Hurricane Katrina-Scientists'fears come trueas hurricane floods New Orleans.Science,309(5741):1656-1659.
    UN.2002.Johannesburg plan of implementation of the worldsummit on sustainable development[EB/OL].2014-11-07[2014-11-07].http://www.un.org/esa/sustdev/documents/WSSD_POI_PD/English/WSSD_Plan Impl.pdf
    UNEP.1992.Agenda 21[EB/OL].2011-10-03[2014-11-07].http://www.unep.org/Documents.Multilingual/Default.asp?Document ID=52
    UN-ISDR.2005.Hyogo framework for action 2001-2015:building the resilience of nations and communities to disasters.World conference on disaster reduction.Kobe,Hyogo,Japan:January 18th.
    Wang J J,Gao H Y,Xin J F.2010.Application of artificial neural networks and GIS in urban earthquake disaster mitigation.International conference on intelligent computationtechnology and automation.Changsha,China:May 11st-12nd.
    Wang J X,Gu X Y,Huang T R.2013.Using Bayesian networks in analyzing powerful earthquake disaster chains.Natural Hazards,68(2):509-527.
    Watts D J,Strogatz S H.1998.Collective dynamics of smallworld'networks.Nature,393(6684):440-442.
    Weng W G,Ni S J,Yuan H Y,et al.2007.Modeling the dynamics of disaster spreading from key nodes in complexnetworks.International Journal of Modern Physics C,18(5):889-901.
    Wolfram S.1984.Computation theory of cellular automata.Communications in Mathematical Physics,96(1):15-57.
    Xu L F,Meng X W,Xu X G.2014.Natural hazard chain research in China:a review.Natural Hazards,70(2):1631-1659.
    Xu M Z,Wang Z Y,Qi L J,et al.2012.Disaster chains initiated by the Wenchuan Earthquake.Environmental EarthSciences,65(4):975-985

版权所有:© 2023 中国地质图书馆 中国地质调查局地学文献中心