青少年的创伤暴露程度与创伤后应激障碍的关系——核心信念挑战、主观害怕程度和侵入性反刍的作用
详细信息 本馆镜像全文    |  推荐本文 | | 获取馆网全文
摘要
采用创伤暴露程度问卷、核心信念量表、主观害怕程度问卷、反刍问卷和创伤后应激障碍问卷,以雅安地震6个月后的310名中学生为被试,考察其创伤暴露程度、核心信念挑战、主观害怕程度、侵入性反刍与创伤后应激障碍之间的关系。结果发现,雅安地震6个月后青少年的创伤后应激障碍的发生率及整体水平较低,其中男生水平低于女生,高一年级学生水平相对高于初一、初二和高二年学生。结构方程模型的结果显示,创伤暴露程度可以通过核心信念挑战对创伤后应激障碍起正向预测作用,也可以通过核心信念挑战经侵入性反刍的多重中介来正向预测创伤后应激障碍;创伤暴露程度还可以通过主观害怕程度经侵入性反刍的多重中介来正向预测创伤后应激障碍。但是创伤暴露程度不能直接通过侵入性反刍预测创伤后应激障碍,也不能通过主观害怕程度直接预测创伤后应激障碍。
The Yaan earthquake in 2013,another destructive natural disaster that occurred in Sichuan,China after the Wenchuan earthquake in 2008,has caused widespread loss of life and property.Adolescent survivors of this earthquake experienced significant psychological reactions,and posttraumatic stress disorder(PTSD) is often considered to be the most frequent one in the aftermath of disasters.Many researchers,to date,have examined the reason for the high prevalence of PTSD,and found that the severity of traumatic exposure was a precondition of PTSD.However,not all the traumatized people been exposed to traumatic events would experience PTSD.This can be attributed to the differences in cognitive reaction.The shattered world assumption suggests that the extent of core beliefs being challenged by traumatic event can activate the development of different cognitive reactions and elicit the development of PTSD.According to the cognitive evaluation theory,people exposed to traumatic events can also take different strategies to cope the traumatic clues,and negative coping strategies,such as intrusive rumination,are important risk factors for PTSD.What calls for special attention is that both the shattered world assumption and the cognitive evaluation theory emphasize the effect of cognition after traumatic exposure in the developing process of PTSD,and they also share the same limit in clinical intervention for PTSD by ignoring the role of emotion.Thus,some researchers suggest that more attention should be paid to people's emotive reactions,such as fear,in the PTSD study.And based on the model of fear network,traumatic exposure can make people experience more fear for the trauma,which may in turn increase the likelihood of the appearance of PTSD.While traumatic exposure,core beliefs challenge,intrusive rumination and subjective fear were theoretically speculated as important risk factors,the specific paths how traumatic exposure elicits PTSD by these factors are unclear.Furthermore,the predictive utility of these risk factors has not been evaluated in an integrated model,and the relationship between cognitive reactions and emotive reactions in the developing process of PTSD has not been examined.In addition,previous researchers mainly studied the general adults or college students,and few focused on the adolescent survivors after disaster.Regarding the above limitations,the current study aimed to explore the role of core beliefs challenge,intrusive rumination,and subjective fear in the association between traumatic exposure and PTSD among adolescent survivors six months after the Yaan earthquake.310 adolescent survivors were selected from several junior and senior middle schools in the county of Lushan,the area most severely affected by the Yaan earthquake.Participants completed Traumatic Exposure Questionnaire,Subjective Fear Questionnaire,Core Beliefs Inventory,The Event Related Rumination Inventory and The Revised Child PTSD Symptom Scale six months after the Yaan earthquake.The results found that both the mean level and the prevalence of PTSD were relatively low.The mean level of PTSD of male students was lower than that of female students,and the mean level of PTSD of grade 1 students in senior middle school was higher than that of all the other grade students who participated in the survey.The analysis of structural equation model found that the severity of traumatic exposure had positive effect on PTSD by core beliefs challenge and by that via the multiple mediator effect of intrusive rumination.Moreover,traumatic exposure could positively affect PTSD by the severity of subjective fear via the multiple mediator effect of intrusive rumination.However,the severity of traumatic exposure had no effect on PTSD by intrusive rumination or subjective fear.
引文
American Psychiatric Association.(2000).Diagnostic andstatistical manual of mental disorders.New York:American Psychiatric Publishing,Inc.
    Arnberg,F.K.,Johannesson,K.B.,&Michel,P.O.(2013).Prevalence and duration of PTSD in survivors 6 years aftera natural disaster.Journal of Anxiety Disorders,27,347–352.
    Bargai,N.,Ben-Shakhar,G.,&Shalev,A.Y.(2007).Posttraumatic stress disorder and depression in batteredwomen:The mediating role of learned helplessness.Journal of Family Violence,22,267–275.
    Barron,G.C.(2011).Depressive rumination in an analysandafter a traumatic treatment.The Psychoanalytic Quarterly,80,287–304.
    Baschnagel,J.S.,Gudmundsdottir,B.,Hawk Jr,L.W.,&Gayle Beck,J.(2009).Post-trauma symptoms followingindirect exposure to the September 11th terrorist attacks:The predictive role of dispositional coping.Journal ofAnxiety Disorders,23,915–922.
    Birrer,E.,&Michael,T.(2011).Rumination in PTSD as wellas in traumatized and non-traumatized depressed patients:A cross-sectional clinical study.Behavioural and CognitivePsychotherapy,39,381–397.
    Cénat,J.M.,&Derivois,D.(2014).Assessment of prevalenceand determinants of posttraumatic stress disorder anddepression symptoms in adults survivors of earthquake inHaiti after 30 months.Journal of Affective Disorders,159,111–117.
    Cahill,S.P.,Rothbaum,B.O.,Resick,P.A.,&Follette,V.M.(2009).Cognitive-behavioral therapy for adults.In E.B.Foa,T.M.Keane,M.J.Friedman&J.A.Cohen(Eds.),Effective treatments for PTSD:Practice guidelines from theinternational society for traumatic stress studies(Vol.2,pp.139–222).New Yor:Guilford Press.
    Cann,A.,Calhoun,L.G.,Tedeschi,R.G.,Kilmer,R.P.,Gil-Rivas,V.,Vishnevsky,T.,&Danhauer,S.C.(2010).The CoreBeliefs Inventory:A brief measure of disruption in theassumptive world.Anxiety,Stress&Coping,23,19–34.
    Cann,A.,Calhoun,L.G.,Tedeschi,R.G.,Triplett,K.N.,Vishnevsky,T.,&Lindstrom,C.M.(2011).Assessingposttraumatic cognitive processes:The event related rumination inventory.Anxiety,Stress,&Coping,24,137–156.
    Carmassi,C.,Akiskal,H.S.,Bessonov,D.,Massimetti,G.,Calderani,E.,Stratta,P.,...Dell?Ossoa,L.(2014).Genderdifferences in DSM-5 versus DSM-IV-TR PTSD prevalenceand criteria comparison among 512 survivors to theL?Aquila earthquake.Journal of Affective Disorders,160,55–61.
    Chuen Yee Lo,B.,Lau,S.,Cheung,S.-H.,&Allen,N.B.(2012).The impact of rumination on internal attentionswitching.Cognition&Emotion,26,209–223.
    Clohessy,S.,&Ehlers,A.(1999).PTSD symptoms,responseto intrusive memories and coping in ambulance serviceworkers.British Journal of Clinical Psychology,38,251–265.
    Cox,B.J.,Enns,M.W.,&Taylor,S.(2001).The effect ofrumination as a mediator of elevated anxiety sensitivity inmajor depression.Cognitive Therapy and Research,25,525–534.
    Dalgleish,T.(2004).Cognitive approaches to posttraumaticstress disorder:the evolution of multirepresentationaltheorizing.Psychological Bulletin,130,228–260.
    Dai,Y.,Lei,M.,Zhou,X.,Yao,M.,Jiang,L.J.,Chen,X.,&Liu,Y.(2014).The effect of trauma expose on posttraumatic stressdisorder after the Wenchuan earthquake:The role of resilienceas a moderator.Psychological Development and Education,30,61–67.[戴艳,雷鸣,周宵,姚梅,蒋林洁,陈希,刘瑶.(2014).创伤暴露程度对中学生创伤后应激障碍的影响:复原力的调节作用.心理发展与教育,30,61–67.]
    Dekel,R.,Solomon,Z.,Elklit,A.,&Ginzburg,K.(2004).World assumptions and combat-related posttraumatic stressdisorder.The Journal of Social Psychology,144,407–420.
    Dell'Osso,L.,Carmassi,C.,Massimetti,G.,Stratta,P.,Riccardi,I.,Capanna,C.,...Rossi,A.(2013).Age,genderand epicenter proximity effects on post-traumatic stresssymptoms in L'Aquila 2009 earthquake survivors.Journalof Affective Disorders,146,174–180.
    Egan,S.J.,Hattaway,M.,&Kane,R.T.(2014).Therelationship between perfectionism and rumination in posttraumatic stress disorder.Behavioural and CognitivePsychotherapy,42,211–223.
    Ehlers,A.,&Clark,D.M.(2008).Post-traumatic stressdisorder:The development of effective psychologicaltreatments.Nordic Journal of Psychiatry,62,11–18.
    Fan,F.,Zhang,Y.,Yang,Y.Y.,Mo,L.,&Liu,X.C.(2011).Symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder,depression,andanxiety among adolescents following the 2008 Wenchuanearthquake in China.Journal of Traumatic Stress,24,44–53.
    Fani,N.,Tone,E.B.,Phifer,J.,Norrholm,S.D.,Bradley,B.,Ressler,K.J.,...Jovanovic,T.(2012).Attention bias towardthreat is associated with exaggerated fear expression andimpaired extinction in PTSD.Psychological Medicine,42,533–543.
    Farnsworth,J.K.,&Sewell,K.W.(2011).Fear of emotion asa moderator between PTSD and firefighter socialinteractions.Journal of Traumatic Stress,24,444–450.
    Foa,E.B.,Johnson,K.M.,Feeny,N.C.,&Treadwell,K.R.H.(2001).The child PTSD symptom scale:A preliminaryexamination of its psychometric properties.Journal ofClinical Child Psychology,30,376–384.
    Foa,E.B.,Riggs,D.S.,Massie,E.D.,&Yarczower,M.(1995).The impact of fear activation and anger on the efficacy ofexposure treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder.BehaviorTherapy,26,487–499.
    Foa,E.B.,Steketee,G.,&Rothbaum,B.O.(1989).Behavioral/cognitive conceptualizations of post-traumatic stress disorder.Behavior Therapy,20,155–176.
    Folkman,S.(1984a).Personal control and stress and copingprocesses:A theoretical analysis.Journal of Personalityand Social Psychology,46,839–852.
    Folkman,S.(1984b).Stress,appraisal,and coping.New York:Springer Publishing Company.
    Forbes,D.,Parslow,R.,Creamer,M.,Allen,N.,Mc Hugh,T.,&Hopwood,M.(2008).Mechanisms of anger andtreatment outcome in combat veterans with posttraumaticstress disorder.Journal of Traumatic Stress,21,142–149.
    Freedy,J.R.,Resnick,H.S.,&Kilpatrick,D.G.(1992).Conceptual framework for evaluating disaster impact:Implications for clinical intervention.In L.S.Austin(Ed.),Responding to disaster:A guide for mental healthprofessionals(pp.6–14).Washington,DC:AmericanPsychiatric Press.
    G?k?en,C.,?ahing?z,M.,&Annagür,B.B.(2013).Does anon-destructive earthquake cause posttraumatic stress disorderA cross-sectional study.European Child&AdolescentPsychiatry,22,295–299.
    Gershuny,B.S.,Cloitre,M.,&Otto,M.W.(2003).Peritraumatic dissociation and PTSD severity:Doevent-related fears about death and control mediate theirrelationBehaviour Research and Therapy,41,157–166.
    Ginzburg,K.(2004).PTSD and world assumptions followingmyocardial infarction:A longitudinal study.AmericanJournal of Orthopsychiatry,74,286–292.
    Goldenberg,I.,&Matheson,K.(2005).Inner representations,coping,and posttraumatic stress symptomatology in acommunity sample of trauma survivors.Basic and AppliedSocial Psychology,27,361–369.
    Grills-Taquechel,A.E.,Littleton,H.L.,&Axsom,D.(2011).Social support,world assumptions,and exposure aspredictors of anxiety and quality of life following a masstrauma.Journal of Anxiety Disorders,25,498–506.
    Grubaugh,A.L.,Zinzow,H.M.,Paul,L.,Egede,L.E.,&Frueh,B.C.(2011).Trauma exposure and posttraumaticstress disorder in adults with severe mental illness:Acritical review.Clinical Psychology Review,31,883–899.
    Hu,E.,Koucky,E.M.,Brown,W.J.,Bruce,S.E.,&Sheline,Y.I.(2013).The role of rumination in elevating perceivedstress in posttraumatic stress disorder.Journal of InterpersonalViolence,doi:10.1177/0886260513511697
    Janoff-Bulman,R.(1989).Assumptive worlds and the stress oftraumatic events:Applications of the schema construct.Social Cognition,7,113–136.
    Janoff-Bulman,R.(1992).Shattered assumptions.New York:Free Press.
    Janoff-Bulman,R.(2010).Shattered assumptions:Towards anew psychology of trauma.New York:Simon and Schuster.
    Jovanovic,T.,Norrholm,S.D.,Fennell,J.E.,Keyes,M.,Fiallos,A.M.,Myers,K.M.,...Duncan,E.J.(2009).Posttraumatic stress disorder may be associated withimpaired fear inhibition:Relation to symptom severity.Psychiatry Research,167,151–160.
    Kleim,B.,Grey,N.,Wild,J.,Nussbeck,F.W.,Stott,R.,Hackmann,A.,...Ehlers,A.(2013).Cognitive changepredicts symptom reduction with cognitive therapy forposttraumatic stress disorder.Journal of Consulting andClinical Psychology,81,383–393.
    Kraaij,V.,Garnefski,N.,&van Gerwen,L.(2003).Cognitivecoping and anxiety symptoms among people who seek helpfor fear of flying.Aviation,Space,and EnvironmentalMedicine,74,273–277.
    Krause,E.D.,Kaltman,S.,Goodman,L.A.,&Dutton,M.A.(2008).Avoidant coping and PTSD symptoms related todomestic violence exposure:A longitudinal study.Journalof Traumatic Stress,21,83–90.
    Leiner,A.S.,Kearns,M.C.,Jackson,J.L.,Astin,M.C.,&Rothbaum,B.O.(2012).Avoidant coping and treatmentoutcome in rape-related posttraumatic stress disorder.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,80,317–321.
    Lilly,M.M.,Valdez,C.E.,&Graham-Bermann,S.A.(2011).The mediating effect of world assumptions on the relationshipbetween trauma exposure and depression.Journal ofInterpersonal Violence,26,2499–2516.
    Lindstrom,C.M.,Cann,A.,Calhoun,L.G.,&Tedeschi,R.G.(2013).The Relationship of core belief challenge,rumination,disclosure,and sociocultural elements to posttraumaticgrowth.Psychological Trauma:Theory,Research,Practice,and Policy,5,50–55.
    Linley,P.A.,&Joseph,S.(2004).Positive change followingtrauma and adversity:A review.Journal of Traumatic Stress,17,11–21.
    Liu,Y.N.,Xu,Y.,&Yu,S.K.(2010).Research on terrormanagement:New development,criticism and controversy.Advances in Psychological Science,18,97–105.[刘亚楠,许燕,于生凯.(2010).恐惧管理研究:新热点、质疑与争论.心理科学进展,18,97–105.]
    Ma,X.H.,Liu,X.,Hu,X.,Qiu,C.J.,Wang,Y.C.,Huang,Y.,...Li,T.(2011).Risk indicators for post-traumatic stressdisorder in adolescents exposed to the 5.12 Wenchuanearthquake in China.Psychiatry Research,189,385–391.
    Margolin,G.,Ramos,M.C.,&Guran,E.L.(2010).Earthquakesand children:The role of psychologists with families andcommunities.Professional Psychology:Research andPractice,41,1–9.
    Mc Farlane,A.C.(1988).The longitudinal course ofposttraumatic morbidity:The range of outcomes and theirpredictors.The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease,176,30–39.
    Meiser-Stedman,R.,Dalgleish,T.,Yule,W.,&Smith,P.(2012).Intrusive memories and depression following recentnon-traumatic negative life events in adolescents.Journalof Affective Disorders,137,70–78.
    Michael,T.,Halligan,S.L.,Clark,D.M.,&Ehlers,A.(2007).Rumination in posttraumatic stress disorder.Depressionand Anxiety,24,307–317.
    Mikkelsen,E.G.E.,&Einarsen,S.(2002).Basic assumptionsand symptoms of post-traumatic stress among victims ofbullying at work.European Journal of Work andOrganizational Psychology,11,87–111.
    Nie,Y.G.,Lin,C.D.,Peng,Y.S.,Ding,L.,&Gan,X.Y.(2008).The development characteristic of adolescents'socialadaptive behavior.Acta Psychologica Sinica,40,1013–1020.[聂衍刚,林崇德,彭以松,丁莉,甘秀英.(2008).青少年社会适应行为的发展特点.心理学报,40,1013–1020.]
    Nolen-Hoeksema,S.(1991).Responses to depression and theireffects on the duration of depressive episodes.Journal ofAbnormal Psychology,100,569–582.
    Nygaard,E.,&Heir,T.(2012).World assumptions,posttraumatic stress and quality of life after a naturaldisaster:A longitudinal study.Health and Quality of LifeOutcomes,10,76–83.
    Pan,X.,Liu,W.Z.,Deng,G.H.,Liu,T.S.,Yan,J.,Tang,Y.X.,...Xu,M.(2013).Symptoms of posttraumatic stressdisorder,depression,and anxiety among junior high schoolstudents in worst-hit areas 3 years after the Wenchuanearthquake in China.Asia-Pacific Journal of Public Health,doi:10.1177/1010539513488625
    Peen,J.,Dekker,J.,Schoevers,R.A.,Ten Have,M.,de Graaf,R.,&Beekman,A.T.(2007).Is the prevalence ofpsychiatric disorders associated with urbanizationSocialPsychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology,42,984–989.
    Preacher,K.J.,&Hayes,A.F.(2008).Asymptotic andresampling strategies for assessing and comparing indirecteffects in multiple mediator models.Behavior ResearchMethods,40,879–891.
    Priebe,S.,Grappasonni,I.,Mari,M.,Dewey,M.,Petrelli,F.,&Costa,A.(2009).Posttraumatic stress disorder sixmonths after an earthquake.Social Psychiatry andPsychiatric Epidemiology,44,393–397.
    Pyszczynski,T.,&Kesebir,P.(2011).Anxiety buffer disruptiontheory:A terror management account of posttraumaticstress disorder.Anxiety,Stress,&Coping,24,3–26.
    Scherer,K.R.(1999).Appraisal theory.In T.Dalgleish&M.J.Power(Eds.),Handbook of cognition and emotion(pp.637–663).New York,NY:John Wiley&Sons.
    Tedeschi,R.G.,&Calhoun,L.G.(1995).Trauma andtransformation:Growing in the aftermath of suffering.Thousand Oaks:CA:Sage.
    Tolin,D.F.,&Foa,E.B.(2006).Sex differences in traumaand posttraumatic stress disorder:A quantitative review of25 years of research.Psychological Bulletin,132,959–992.
    Triplett,K.N.,Tedeschi,R.G.,Cann,A.,Calhoun,L.G.,&Reeve,C.L.(2011).Posttraumatic growth,meaning in life,and life satisfaction in response to trauma.PsychologicalTrauma:Theory,Research,Practice,and Policy,4,400–404.
    van der Kolk,B.A.(2006).Clinical implications of neuroscienceresearch in PTSD.Annals of the New York Academy ofSciences,1071,277–293.
    Wagner,S.L.,Mc Fee,J.A.,&Martin,C.A.(2009).Effects oftraumatic stress on firefighters'world assumptions.Traumatology,15,75–84.
    Wang,L.,Long,D.,Li,Z.Q.,&Armour,C.(2011).Posttraumatic stress disorder symptom structure in Chineseadolescents exposed to a deadly earthquake.Journal ofAbnormal Child Psychology,39,749–758.
    Wen,Z.L.,Chang,L.,Kit-Tai,H.,&Liu,H.Y.(2004).Testing and application of the mediating effects.ActaPsychologica Sinica,36,614–620.[温忠麟,张雷,侯杰泰,刘红云.(2004).中介效应检验程序及其应用.心理学报,36,614–620.]
    Wei,Y.,Wang,L.,Wang,R.,Cao,C.,Shi,Z.,&Zhang,J.(2013).Prevalence and predictors of posttraumatic streedisorder among Chinese youths after an earthquake.SocialBehavior&Personality:An International Journal,41,1613–1624.
    Wickrama,K.A.S.,&Kaspar,V.(2007).Family context ofmental health risk in Tsunami-exposed adolescents:Findings from a pilot study in Sri Lanka.Social Science&Medicine,64,713–723.
    Williams,A.D.,&Moulds,M.L.(2008).Negative appraisalsand cognitive avoidance of intrusive memories in depression:A replication and extension.Depression and Anxiety,25,26–33.
    Wu,X.C.,Zhang,Y.D.,Lin,C.D.,&Zang,W.W.(2013).The effect of disaster exposure on PTSD of orimary andsecondary students:Mediating and moderating effect.Psychological Development and Education,29,641–648.[伍新春,张宇迪,林崇德,臧伟伟.(2013).中小学生的灾难暴露程度对创伤后应激障碍的影响:中介和调节效应.心理发展与教育,29,641–648.]
    Wu,Y.,Hung,F.,&Chen,S.(2002).“Changes or not”is thequestion:The meaning of posttraumatic stress reactions oneyear after the Taiwan Chi-Chi earthquake.Journal of theChinese Institute of Engineers,25,609–618.
    Zalta,A.K.,Gillihan,S.J.,Fisher,A.J.,Mintz,J.,Mc Lean,C.P.,Yehuda,R.,&Foa,E.B.(2014).Change in negativecognitions associated with PTSD predicts symptom reductionin prolonged exposure.Journal of Consulting and ClinicalPsychology,82,171–174.
    Zhou,X.,Wu,X.C.,An,Y.Y.,&Chen,J.L.(2014).The rolesof rumination and social support in the associationsbetween core belief challenge and post-traumatic growthamong adolescent survivors after the Wenchuan earthquake.Acta Psychologica Sinica,46,1509–1520.[周宵,伍新春,安媛媛,陈杰灵.(2014).青少年核心信念挑战对创伤后成长的影响:反刍与社会支持的作用.心理学报,46,1509–1520.]

版权所有:© 2023 中国地质图书馆 中国地质调查局地学文献中心