统计预测、经验预测、物理预测——近期国际地震预测预报研究的启示
|
摘要
从"统计预测"、"经验预测"、"物理预测"的角度讨论了世纪之交地震预测预报研究的国际进展。"统计预测"包括地震预测预报方法的统计检验、"统计地震学",以及统计物理在地震预测预报中的应用;"经验预测"包括搜索可能的前兆异常的尝试、建立将可能的前兆异常现象与地震孕育过程联系起来的简单模型、发现对地震预测预报研究具有重要意义的新现象,以及地球介质变化的动态监测试验;"物理预测"包括地震孕育和发生的物理模型、地震断层带性质的观测和实验研究,以及对震源的直接探测和钻探。讨论了"统计预测"、"经验预测"、"物理预测"之间的关系,对"把经验预测或统计预测变成物理预测"的发展战略提出质疑。
Studies of earthquake forecast/prediction in the turn of the centuries were discussed in the perspective of "statistical","empirical",and "physical" approaches. "Statistical" approaches include the statistical test of earthquake prediction schemes,"statistical seismology",and application of statistical physics to earthquake forecast/prediction. "Empirical" approaches include the searching of candidate earthquake precursors,construction of simple models relating observed anomalies to the process of earthquake preparation,finding of new observational phenomena with implications for earthquake forecast/prediction,and monitoring of time-dependent properties of earth medium. "Physical" approaches include the models of earthquake preparation and occurrence,observation and experiment of the properties of earthquake fault zone,and detection and drilling of earthquake sources. Relation between "statistical","empirical",and "physical" approaches was discussed,questioning the strategy "transforming empirical/statistical approaches to physical ones" which has been well-accepted in China.
Studies of earthquake forecast/prediction in the turn of the centuries were discussed in the perspective of "statistical","empirical",and "physical" approaches. "Statistical" approaches include the statistical test of earthquake prediction schemes,"statistical seismology",and application of statistical physics to earthquake forecast/prediction. "Empirical" approaches include the searching of candidate earthquake precursors,construction of simple models relating observed anomalies to the process of earthquake preparation,finding of new observational phenomena with implications for earthquake forecast/prediction,and monitoring of time-dependent properties of earth medium. "Physical" approaches include the models of earthquake preparation and occurrence,observation and experiment of the properties of earthquake fault zone,and detection and drilling of earthquake sources. Relation between "statistical","empirical",and "physical" approaches was discussed,questioning the strategy "transforming empirical/statistical approaches to physical ones" which has been well-accepted in China.
引文
[1]Jordan,T.H.et al.,2007,Collaboratoryfor the Study of Earthquake Predictability.28th Workshop of the International Schoolof Geophystics,31Mayto6June.Erice,Italy.
吴忠良,1999.地震预测统计检验的地震学问题:对目前地震预测问题争论的评述(之二).中国地震,15(1):14~22。
吴忠良、陈运泰,2002.地震预测与统计物理.物理,31(6):365~371。
吴忠良、蒋长胜,2005.近期国际地震预测预报进展的几个侧面.中国地震,21(1):103~112
吴忠良、蒋长胜,2006.地震前兆检验的地球动力学问题:对地震预测问题争论的评述(之三).中国地震,22(3):236~241。
吴忠良、张天中,2003.绪言.中国地震局监测预报司编:地震参数——数字地震学在地震预测中的应用,北京:地震出版社,1~6。
Aki K.,2004.Anewviewof earthquake and volcano precursors.Earth Planets Space,56:689~713.
Ben-Zion Y.and Lyakhovsky V.,2002.Accelerated seismic release andrelated aspects of seismicty patterns on earthquake faults.Pureappl.Geophys.,159:2385~2412.
Ben-Zion Y.and Sammis C.G.,2003.Characterization of fault zones.Pure appl.Geophys.,160:677~715.
Ben-Zion Y.,Dahmen K.,Lyakhovsky V.,Ertas D.and Agnon A.,1999.Self-driven mode switchingof earthquake activityonafaultsystem.EPSL,172:11~21.
Ben-Zion Y.,Eneva M.and Liu Y.-F.,2003a.Large earthquake cycles and intermittent criticality on heterogeneous faults due toevolving stress and seismicity.J.Geophys.Res.,108(B6):doi:10.1029/2002JB002121.
Ben-Zion Y.,Peng Z.G.,Okaya D.,Seeber L.,Armbruster J.G.,Ozer N.,Michael A.J.,Baris S.and Aktar M.,2003b.Ashallowfault-zone structure illuminated bytrapped wavesinthe Karadere-Duzce branch of the North Anatolian Fault,western Turkey.Geophys.J.Int.,152:699~717.
Biagi R.F.,Ermini A.,Kingsley S.P.,Khatkevich Y.M.and Gordeev E.I.,2000.Groundwater Ion content precursors of strongearthquakes in Kamchatka(Russia).Pure appl.Geophys.,157:1359~1377.
Blanpied M.L.,Lockner D.A.and Byerlee J.D.,1992.An earthquake mechanismbased on rapid sealing of faults.Nature,359:574~576.
Boullier A.,Ohtani T.,Fujimoto K.,Ito H.and Dubois M.,2001.Fluidinclusionsin pseudotachylytesfromthe Nojimafault,JapanJ.Geophys.Res.,106:21965~21977.
Chavarria J.A.,Malin P.,Catchings R.D.and Shalev E.,2003.Alook inside the Andreas Fault at Parkfield through verticalseismic profiling.Science,302:1746~1748.
Crampin S.,2001.Developing stress-monitoring sites using cross-hole seismology to stress-forecast the times and magnitudes of futurearthquakes.Tectonophysics,338:233~245.
Crampin S.and Chastin S.,2003.Areviewof shear-wave splittinginthe crack-critical crust.Geophys.J.Int.,155:221~240.
Crampin S.,Volti T.and Stef偄nsson R.,1999.Asuccessfully stress-forecast earthquake.Geophys.J.Int.,138:F1~F5.
Crampin S.,Volti T.and Stef偄nsson R.,2004.Response to“Astatistical evaluation of a‘stress-forecast’earthquake”by T.Seher&I.G.Main.Geophys.J.Int.,157:194~199.
Cyranoski D.,2004.Aseismic shift inthinking.Nature,431:1032~1034.
Dey S.and Singh R.P.,2003.Surface latent heat fluxas an earthquake precursor.Natural Hazards and Earth SystemSciences,3:749~755.
Eftaxias K.,Kapiris P.,Dologlou E.,Kopanas J.,Bogris N.,Antonopoulos G.,Peratzakis A.and Hadjicontis V.,2002.EManomalies before the Kozani earthquake:a study of their behavior throughlaboratory experiments.Geophys.Res.Lett.,29(8):doi:10.1029/2001GL013786.
Eftaxias K.,Kapiris P.,Polygiannakis J.,Bogris N.,Kopanas J.,Antonopoulos G.,Peratzakis A.and Hadjicontis V.,2001.Signature of pending earthquake fromelectromagnetic anomalies.Geophys.Res.Lett.,28:3321~3324.
Evans R.(eds.),1997.Special section-Assessment of schemes for earthquake prediction.Geophys.J.Int.,131:413~533.
Faulkner D.R.,Mitchell T.M.,healy D.and Heap M.J.,2006.Slip on‘weak’faults by the rotation of regional stress in thefracture damage zone.Nature,444:922~925,doi:10.1038/nature05353.
Field E.D.(eds.),2007.Special Issue-Regional Earthquake Likelihood Models.Seism.Res.Lett.,78(1):1~140.
Fuis G.S.,Clayton R.W.,Davis P.M.,Ryberg T.,Lutter W.J.,Okaya D.A.,Hauksson E.,Prodehl C.,Murphy J.M.,Benthien M,L.,Baher S.A.,Kohler M.D.,Thygesen K.,Simila G.and Keller G.R.,2003.Fault systems of the1971 San Fernando and1994Northridge earthquakes,southern California:Relocated aftershocks and seismic images fromLARSEII.Geology,31:171~174,doi:10.1130/0091~7613(2003)031.
Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.,Tomida N.,Ohtani T.andIto H.,1999.Characterization of fault gouge fromGSJ Hirabayashi core samplesandimplicationsforthe activityof the Nojimafault,In:Ito H.,Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.and Lockner D.(eds.),Proceedings of theInternational Workshop onthe Nojima Fault Core and Borehole Data Analysis,Tsukuba:Japan,103~109.
Geller R.J.(eds.),1996.Special section-Debate on evaluation of the VAN method.Geophys.Res.Lett.,23:1291~1452.
Geller R.J.,Jackson D.D.,Kagan Y.Y.and Mulargia F.,1997.Earthquakes cannot be predicted.Science,275:1616~1617.
Gr毢t A.and Snieder R.,2005.Monitoringrapidtemporal changein a volcano withcoda waveinterferometry,Geophys.Res.Lett.,32:L06304,doi:10.1029/2004GL021143.
Gupta H.K.,2001.Short-termearthquake forecasting may be feasible at Koyna,India.Tectonophysics,338:353~357.
Harris R.A.,1998a.Forecast of the1989Loma Prieta,California,earthquake.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,88:898~916.
Harris R.A.(eds.),1998b.Special section-Stress triggers,stress shadows,andimplication for seismic hazard.J.Geophys.Res.,103:24347~24572.
Harris R.A.,2003.Stress triggers,stress shadows,and seismic hazard.In:Lee W.H.K.,Kanamori H.,Jennings P.C.andKisslinger C.(eds.),International Handbook of Earthquake and Engineering Seismology.Amsterdam:Academic Press,1217~1232.
Harris R.A.and ArrowsmithJ.R.(eds.),2006.Special issue-the2004Parkfield earthquake andthe Parkfield Earthquake PredictionExperiment.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,96:S1~S409.
Hirono T.,Lin W.,Yeh E.C.,Soh W.,Hashimoto Y.,Sone H.,Matsubayashi O.,Aoike K.,Ito H.,Kinoshita M.,MurayamaM.,Song S.R.,Ma K.F.,HungJ.H.,Wang C.Y.and Tsai Y.B.,2006.High magnetic susceptibility of fault gouge withinTaiwan Chelungpufault:Nondestructive continuous measurements of physical and chemical propertiesinfault rocksrecoveredfromHoleB,TCDP.Geophys.Res.Lett.,33:L15303,10.1029/2006GL026133.
Huang Q.,Oncel O.and Sobolev G.A.,2002.Precursory seismicity changes associated with theMW=7.41999August17Izmit(Turkey)earthquake.Geophys.J.Int.,151:235~242.
Huang Q.,Sobolev G.A.and Nagao T.,2001.Characteristics of the seismic quiescence and activation patterns before theM=7.2Kobe earthquake,January17,1995.Tectonophysics,337:99~116.
Ito Y.,Obara K.,Shiomi K.,Sekine S.and Hirose H.,2007.Slowearthquakes coincident withepisodictremors andslowslipeventsScience,315:503~506,doi:10.1126/science.1134454.
Jackson D.D.,2004.Earthquake prediction and forecasting.In:IUGG(eds.),State of the Planet:Frontiers and Challenges,Washington DC:AGU,225~348.
Kanamori H.,and Fuis G.,1976,Variation of P-wave velocity before and after the Galway Lake earthquake(ML=5.2)andthe GoatMountain earthquakes(ML=4.7,4.7),1975,inthe Mojave Desert,California.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,66:2017~2037.
Kano Y.,Mori J.,Fujio R.,Ito H.,Yanagidani T.,Nakao S.and Ma K.F.,2006.Heat Signature onthe Chelunpufault associatedwiththe1999Chi-Chi,Taiwan earthquake.Geophys.Res.Lett.,33:L14306,doi:10.1029/2006GL026733.
Keilis-Borok V.I.and Shebalin P.N.(eds.),1999.Special issue-Dynamics of lithosphere and earthquake prediction.Phys.EarthPlanet.Interi.,111:179~327.
Keilis-Borok V.I.,1990.The lithosphere of the Earth as a nonlinear system with implications for earthquake prediction.Rev.Geophys.,28:19~34.
Keilis-Borok V.,Ismail-Zadeh A.,Kossobokov V.and Shebalin P.,2001.Non-linear dynamics of the lithosphere and intermediate-termearthquake prediction.Tectonophysics,338:247~260.
Keilis-Borok V.,Shebalin P.,Gabrielov A.and Turcotte D.,2004.Reverse tracing of short-termearthquake precursors.Phys.EarthPlanet.Inter.145:75~85.
Knopoff L.,2000.The magnitude distribution of declustered earthquakesin Southern California.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.,97:1188011884.
Knopoff L.,Aki K.,Allen C.R.,Rice J.R.and Sykes L.R.(eds.),1996.Earthquake prediction:the scientific challenge.ColloquiumProceedings,Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA,93:3719~3837.
Knopoff L.,Landoni J.A.and Abinante M.S.,1992.Dynamical model of an earthquake fault withlocalization.Phys.Rev.,A467445~7449.
Kossobokov V.G.,Romashkova L.L.,Keilis-Borok V.I.and Healy J.H.,1999.Testing earthquake prediction algorithms:statisticallysignificant advance prediction of the largest earthquakesinthe Circum-Pacific,1992~1997.Phys.Earth Planet.Interi.,111:187~196.
Li Y.G.,Aki K.,Vidale J.E.and Alvarez M.G.,1998.Delineation of the Nojima fault ruptured in theM7.2Kobe,Japan,earthquake of1995usingfault zone trapped waves.J.Geophys.Res.,103:7247~7263.
Li Y.G.,Chen P.,Cochran E.S.,Vidale J.E.and Burdette T.,2006.Seismic evidence for rock damage and healing onthe SanAndreas Fault associated withthe2004M6.0Parkfield earthquake.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,96:S349~S363,doi:10.1785/0120050803.
Li Y.G.,Vidale J.E.,Aki K.and Xu F.,2000.Depth-dependent structure of the Landersfault zone fromtrapped waves generatedby aftershocks.J.Geophys.Res.,105:6237~6254.
Lockner D.,Naka H.,Tanaka H.,Ito H.andIkeda R.,1999.Permeability and strength of core samplesfromthe Nojimafault of the1995Kobe earthquake.In:Ito H.,Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.and Lockner D.(eds.),Proceedings of the International Workshop onthe Nojima Fault Core and Borehole Data Analysis,Tsukuba:Japan,USGS Open File Report00~129,147~152.
Ma K.F.,Tanaka H.,Song S.R.,Wang C.Y.,Hung J.H.,Tsai Yi.B.,Mori J.,Song Y.F.,Yeh E.C.,Sone H.,KuoL.W.and Wu H.Y.,2006.Slip zone and energetics of a large earthquake fromthe Taiwan Chelungpu-fault Drilling Project.Nature,444:473~476,doi:10.1038/nature05253.
Main I.G.and Al-Kindy F.H.,2002.Entropy,energy,and proximityto criticalityin global earthquake populations.Geophys.Res.Lett.,29(7):doi:10.1029/2001GL014078.
MainI.G.,1995.Earthquakes as critical phenomena:implicationsfor probabilistic seismic hazard analysis.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,85:1299~1308.
Main I.,1996.Statitical physics,seismogenesis,and seismic hazard.Rev.Geophys.,34:433~462.
Manaker D.M.,Michael A.J.and Brgmann R.,2005.Subsurface structure and kinematics of the Calaveras-Hayward Fault stepovefromthree-dimensional Vpandseismicity,San Francisco Bay Region,California.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,95:446~470,doi:101785/0120020202.
Matsu ura M.,Mora P.,Donnellan A.and Yin X.C.(eds.),2002.Special section-Earthquake processes:physical modelling,numerical simulation,and data analysis.Pure appl.Geophys.,159:1905~2536.
Mazzotti S.and Adams J.,2004.Variability of near-termprobability for the next great earthquake on the Cascadia subduction zone.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,94:1954~1959.
McEvilly T.V.and Johnson L.R.,1974.Stability of P and S velocities fromcentral California quarry blasts.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,64:343~353.
Melbourne T.I.and Webb F.H.,2002.Precursorytransient slip duringthe2001MW=8.4Peruearthquake sequencefromcontinuouGPS.Geophys.Res.Lett.,29(21):doi:10.1029/2002GL015533.
Michael A.J.,1997.Testing prediction methods:earthquakes clustering versus a Posisson model.Geophys.Res.Lett.,24:1891~1894.
Molchan G.M.,1997.Earthquake prediction as a decision-making problem.Pure appl.Geophys.,149:233~247.
Mooney W.D.and Ginzburg A.,1986.Seismic measurements of the internal properties of fault zone.Pure appl.Geophys.,124:141~157.
Mora P.,Matsu ura M.,Madariaga R.and Minster J.-B.(eds.),2000.Special section-Microscopic and macroscopic simulation:towards predictive modelling of the earthquake process.Pure appl.Geophys.,157:1817~2383.
Mulargia F.,1997.Retrospective validation of the time association of precursors.Geophys.J.Int.,131:500~504.
Nadeau R.M.and Dolenc D.,2005.Nonvolcanic tremors deep beneath the San Andreas fault.Science,307:389,doi:10.1126/science.1107142.
Nakamura A.,Hasegawa A.,Hirata N.,Iwasaki T.and Hamaguchi H.,2002.Temporal variations of seismic wave velocity associatedwith1998M6.1Shizukuishi earthquake,Pure appl.Geophys.,159:1183~1204.
Niu F.,Silver P.G.,Nadeau R.M.and McEvilly T.V.,2003.Migration of seismic scatterers associated with the1993Parkfieldaseismic transient event,Nature,426:544~548.
Obara K.,2002.Nonvolcanic deeptremor associated with subductionin southwest Japan.Science,296:1679~1681,doi:10.1126/science.1070378.
Ohnaka M.and Shen L.,1999.Scaling of the shear rupture process fromnucleationto dynamic propagation:implications of geometricirregularity of the rupturing surfaces.J.Geophys.Res.,104:817~844.
Ohnaka M.,1996.Nonuniformity of the constitutive lawparameters for shear rupture and quasistatic nucleation to dynamic rupture:aphysical model of earthquake generation processes.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA,93:3795~3802.
Okaya D.,Henrys S.and StemT.,2002.Double-sided onshore-offshore seismic imaging of a plate boundary:‘super-gathers’acrossSouthIsland,NewZealand.Tectonophysics,255:247~263.
Oncel A.O.and Wyss M.,2000.The major asperities of the1999MW=7.4Izmit earthquake defined bythe microseismicityof thetwodecades before it.Geophys.J.Int.,143:501~506.
Pandolfi D.,Bean C.J.and Saccorott G.,2006.Coda wave interferometric detection of seismic velocity changes associated with the1999M=3.6event at Mt.Vesuvius,J.Geophys.Res.,33:L06306,doi:10.1029/2005GL025355.
Pepke S.L.,Carlson J.M.and ShawB.E.,1994.Prediction of large events on a dynamical model of a fault.J.Geophys.Res.,99:6769~6788.
Peng Z.G.,Ben-Zion Y.,Michael A.J.and Zhu L.P.,2003.Quantitative analysis of seismic fault zone wavesinthe rupture zoneof the1992Landers,California,earthquake:evidence for a shallowtrapping structure.Geophys.J.Int.,155:1021~1041.
Rastogi B.K.and Mandal P.,1999.Foreshocks and nucleation of small-to moderate-sized Koyna earthquakes(India).Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,89:829~836.
Richon P.,Sabroux J.-C.,Halbwachs M.,Vandemeulebrouck J.,Poussielgue N.,Tabbagh J.and Punongbayan R.,2003.Radonanomalyinthe soil of Taal volcano,the Philippines:a likely precursor of theM7.1Mindoro earthquake(1994).Geophys.Res.Lett.,30(9):doi:10.1029/2003GL016902.
Rogers G.and Dragert H.,2003.Episodic tremor and slip on the Cascadia subduction zone:the chatter of silent slip.Science,300:1942~1943,doi:10.1126/science.1084783.
Romachkova L.L.,Kossobokov V.G.,Panza G.F.and Costa G.,1998.Intermediate-termpredictions of earthquakes in Italy:Algorithm M8.Pure appl.Geophys.,152:37~55.
Rundle J.B.,Klein W.,Tiampo K.and Gross S.,2000.Linear pattern dynamicsin nonlinear threshold systems.Phys.Rev.,E61:2418~2431.
Rundle J.B.,Turcotte D.L.,Shcherbakov R.,Klein W.and Sammis C.,2003.Statistical physics approach to understanding themultiscale dynamics of earthquake fault systems.Rev.Geophys.,41(4):doi:10.1029/2003RG000135.
Sato H.,Hirata N.,Koketsu K.,Okaya D.,Abe S.,Kobayashi R.,Matsubara M.,Iwasaki T.,Ito T.,Ikawa T.,Kawanaka T.,Kasahara K.,Harder S.,2005.Earthquake source fault beneath Tokyo.Science,309:462~464,doi:10.1126/science.1110489.
Scholz C.H.,1990.The Mechanics of Earthquakes and Faulting.Cambridge Univ.Press,NewYork,135~141.
Seher T.and Main I.G.,2004.Astatistical evaluation of a‘stress-forecast’earthquake.Geophys.J.Int.,157:187~193.
Shelly D.R.,Beroza G.C.,Ide S.and Nakamula S.,2006.Low-frequency earthquakesin Shikoku,Japan,andtheir relationshiptoepisodic tremor and slip.Nature,442:188~191,doi:10.1038/nature04931.
Snieder R.and Hagerty M.,2004.Monitoring change in volcanic interiors using coda wave interferometry:application to ArenVolcano,Costa Rica,Geophys.Res.Lett.,31:L09608,doi:10.1029/2004GL019670.
Sobolev G.,2001.The examples of earthquake preparationin Kamchatka and Japan.Tectonophysics,338:269~279.
Sornette D.,2000.Critical Phenomena in Complex Systems.Berlin:Springer-Verlag,1~412.
Sornette A.and Sornette D.,1990.Earthquake rupture as a critical point:consequences for telluric precursors.Tectonophysics,179:327~334.
Sornette D.and Sammis C.G.,1995.Critical exponents fromrenomalization group theory of earthquakes:implications for earthquakeprediction.J.Phys.I.,5:607~619.
Tanaka H.,Tomida N.,Sekiya N.,Tsukiyama Y.,Fujimoto K.,Ohtani T.and Ito H.,1999.Distribution,deformation andalteration of fault rocks alongthe GSJ core penetrating the Nojima fault,Awaji Island,southwest Japan,In:Ito H.,Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.and Lockner D.(eds.),Proceedings of the International Workshop onthe Nojima Fault Core and Borehole Data Analysis,Tsukuba:Japan,81~101.
Tiampo K.F.,Rundle J.B.,McGinnis S.and Gross S.J.,2002.Eigenpatterns in southern California seismicity.J.Geophys.Res.,107(B12):doi:10.1029/2001JB000562.
Vere-Jones D.and Ogata Y.,2003.Statistical principles for seismologists.In:Lee W.H.K.,Kanamori H.,Jennings P.C.andKisslinger C.(eds.),International Handbook of Earthquake and Engineering Seismology.Amsterdam:Academic Press,1573~1586.
1586.Westerhaus M.,Wyss M,Yilmaz R.and Zschau J.,2002.Correlating variations of b values and crustal deformation duringthe1990smay have pinpointedthe rupture initiation of theMW=7.4Izmit earthquake of1999August17.Geophys.J.Int.,148:139~152.
Wyss M.and Dmowska R.(eds.),1997.Special issue-Earthquake prediction,state-of-the-art.Pure appl.Geophys.,149:1~264.
Wyss M.and Martirosyan A.H.,1998.Seismic quiescence before the M7,1988,Spitak earthquake,Armenia.Geophys.J.Int.,134:329~340.
Wyss M.,Shimazaki K.and Ito A.(eds.),1999.Special section-Seismicity pattern,their statistical significance and physicalmeaning.Pure appl.Geophys.,155:203~726.
Xu H.J.and Knopoff L.,1994.Periodicity and chaosin a one-dimensional dynamical model of earthquakes.Phys.Rev.,E50:3577~3581.
Yin X.C.,Mora P.,Doonellan A.and Matsuura M.(eds.),2006a.Special issue-Computational earthquake physics partⅠ.Pureappl.Geophys.,163:1737~2047.
Yin X.C.,Mora P.,Doonellan A.and Matsuura,M.(eds.),2006b.Special issue-Computational earthquake physics partⅡ.Pureappl.Geophys.,163:2259~2593.
Zhao D.and Negishi H.,1998.The1995Kobe earthquake:Seismic image of the source zone and its implications for the rupturenucleation.J.Geophys.Res.,103:9967~9986.
Zoback M.D.,2006,SAFODpenetrates the San Andreas Fault.Scientific Drilling,2:32~33,doi:10.2204/iodp.sd.2.07.2006.
吴忠良,1999.地震预测统计检验的地震学问题:对目前地震预测问题争论的评述(之二).中国地震,15(1):14~22。
吴忠良、陈运泰,2002.地震预测与统计物理.物理,31(6):365~371。
吴忠良、蒋长胜,2005.近期国际地震预测预报进展的几个侧面.中国地震,21(1):103~112
吴忠良、蒋长胜,2006.地震前兆检验的地球动力学问题:对地震预测问题争论的评述(之三).中国地震,22(3):236~241。
吴忠良、张天中,2003.绪言.中国地震局监测预报司编:地震参数——数字地震学在地震预测中的应用,北京:地震出版社,1~6。
Aki K.,2004.Anewviewof earthquake and volcano precursors.Earth Planets Space,56:689~713.
Ben-Zion Y.and Lyakhovsky V.,2002.Accelerated seismic release andrelated aspects of seismicty patterns on earthquake faults.Pureappl.Geophys.,159:2385~2412.
Ben-Zion Y.and Sammis C.G.,2003.Characterization of fault zones.Pure appl.Geophys.,160:677~715.
Ben-Zion Y.,Dahmen K.,Lyakhovsky V.,Ertas D.and Agnon A.,1999.Self-driven mode switchingof earthquake activityonafaultsystem.EPSL,172:11~21.
Ben-Zion Y.,Eneva M.and Liu Y.-F.,2003a.Large earthquake cycles and intermittent criticality on heterogeneous faults due toevolving stress and seismicity.J.Geophys.Res.,108(B6):doi:10.1029/2002JB002121.
Ben-Zion Y.,Peng Z.G.,Okaya D.,Seeber L.,Armbruster J.G.,Ozer N.,Michael A.J.,Baris S.and Aktar M.,2003b.Ashallowfault-zone structure illuminated bytrapped wavesinthe Karadere-Duzce branch of the North Anatolian Fault,western Turkey.Geophys.J.Int.,152:699~717.
Biagi R.F.,Ermini A.,Kingsley S.P.,Khatkevich Y.M.and Gordeev E.I.,2000.Groundwater Ion content precursors of strongearthquakes in Kamchatka(Russia).Pure appl.Geophys.,157:1359~1377.
Blanpied M.L.,Lockner D.A.and Byerlee J.D.,1992.An earthquake mechanismbased on rapid sealing of faults.Nature,359:574~576.
Boullier A.,Ohtani T.,Fujimoto K.,Ito H.and Dubois M.,2001.Fluidinclusionsin pseudotachylytesfromthe Nojimafault,JapanJ.Geophys.Res.,106:21965~21977.
Chavarria J.A.,Malin P.,Catchings R.D.and Shalev E.,2003.Alook inside the Andreas Fault at Parkfield through verticalseismic profiling.Science,302:1746~1748.
Crampin S.,2001.Developing stress-monitoring sites using cross-hole seismology to stress-forecast the times and magnitudes of futurearthquakes.Tectonophysics,338:233~245.
Crampin S.and Chastin S.,2003.Areviewof shear-wave splittinginthe crack-critical crust.Geophys.J.Int.,155:221~240.
Crampin S.,Volti T.and Stef偄nsson R.,1999.Asuccessfully stress-forecast earthquake.Geophys.J.Int.,138:F1~F5.
Crampin S.,Volti T.and Stef偄nsson R.,2004.Response to“Astatistical evaluation of a‘stress-forecast’earthquake”by T.Seher&I.G.Main.Geophys.J.Int.,157:194~199.
Cyranoski D.,2004.Aseismic shift inthinking.Nature,431:1032~1034.
Dey S.and Singh R.P.,2003.Surface latent heat fluxas an earthquake precursor.Natural Hazards and Earth SystemSciences,3:749~755.
Eftaxias K.,Kapiris P.,Dologlou E.,Kopanas J.,Bogris N.,Antonopoulos G.,Peratzakis A.and Hadjicontis V.,2002.EManomalies before the Kozani earthquake:a study of their behavior throughlaboratory experiments.Geophys.Res.Lett.,29(8):doi:10.1029/2001GL013786.
Eftaxias K.,Kapiris P.,Polygiannakis J.,Bogris N.,Kopanas J.,Antonopoulos G.,Peratzakis A.and Hadjicontis V.,2001.Signature of pending earthquake fromelectromagnetic anomalies.Geophys.Res.Lett.,28:3321~3324.
Evans R.(eds.),1997.Special section-Assessment of schemes for earthquake prediction.Geophys.J.Int.,131:413~533.
Faulkner D.R.,Mitchell T.M.,healy D.and Heap M.J.,2006.Slip on‘weak’faults by the rotation of regional stress in thefracture damage zone.Nature,444:922~925,doi:10.1038/nature05353.
Field E.D.(eds.),2007.Special Issue-Regional Earthquake Likelihood Models.Seism.Res.Lett.,78(1):1~140.
Fuis G.S.,Clayton R.W.,Davis P.M.,Ryberg T.,Lutter W.J.,Okaya D.A.,Hauksson E.,Prodehl C.,Murphy J.M.,Benthien M,L.,Baher S.A.,Kohler M.D.,Thygesen K.,Simila G.and Keller G.R.,2003.Fault systems of the1971 San Fernando and1994Northridge earthquakes,southern California:Relocated aftershocks and seismic images fromLARSEII.Geology,31:171~174,doi:10.1130/0091~7613(2003)031.
Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.,Tomida N.,Ohtani T.andIto H.,1999.Characterization of fault gouge fromGSJ Hirabayashi core samplesandimplicationsforthe activityof the Nojimafault,In:Ito H.,Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.and Lockner D.(eds.),Proceedings of theInternational Workshop onthe Nojima Fault Core and Borehole Data Analysis,Tsukuba:Japan,103~109.
Geller R.J.(eds.),1996.Special section-Debate on evaluation of the VAN method.Geophys.Res.Lett.,23:1291~1452.
Geller R.J.,Jackson D.D.,Kagan Y.Y.and Mulargia F.,1997.Earthquakes cannot be predicted.Science,275:1616~1617.
Gr毢t A.and Snieder R.,2005.Monitoringrapidtemporal changein a volcano withcoda waveinterferometry,Geophys.Res.Lett.,32:L06304,doi:10.1029/2004GL021143.
Gupta H.K.,2001.Short-termearthquake forecasting may be feasible at Koyna,India.Tectonophysics,338:353~357.
Harris R.A.,1998a.Forecast of the1989Loma Prieta,California,earthquake.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,88:898~916.
Harris R.A.(eds.),1998b.Special section-Stress triggers,stress shadows,andimplication for seismic hazard.J.Geophys.Res.,103:24347~24572.
Harris R.A.,2003.Stress triggers,stress shadows,and seismic hazard.In:Lee W.H.K.,Kanamori H.,Jennings P.C.andKisslinger C.(eds.),International Handbook of Earthquake and Engineering Seismology.Amsterdam:Academic Press,1217~1232.
Harris R.A.and ArrowsmithJ.R.(eds.),2006.Special issue-the2004Parkfield earthquake andthe Parkfield Earthquake PredictionExperiment.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,96:S1~S409.
Hirono T.,Lin W.,Yeh E.C.,Soh W.,Hashimoto Y.,Sone H.,Matsubayashi O.,Aoike K.,Ito H.,Kinoshita M.,MurayamaM.,Song S.R.,Ma K.F.,HungJ.H.,Wang C.Y.and Tsai Y.B.,2006.High magnetic susceptibility of fault gouge withinTaiwan Chelungpufault:Nondestructive continuous measurements of physical and chemical propertiesinfault rocksrecoveredfromHoleB,TCDP.Geophys.Res.Lett.,33:L15303,10.1029/2006GL026133.
Huang Q.,Oncel O.and Sobolev G.A.,2002.Precursory seismicity changes associated with theMW=7.41999August17Izmit(Turkey)earthquake.Geophys.J.Int.,151:235~242.
Huang Q.,Sobolev G.A.and Nagao T.,2001.Characteristics of the seismic quiescence and activation patterns before theM=7.2Kobe earthquake,January17,1995.Tectonophysics,337:99~116.
Ito Y.,Obara K.,Shiomi K.,Sekine S.and Hirose H.,2007.Slowearthquakes coincident withepisodictremors andslowslipeventsScience,315:503~506,doi:10.1126/science.1134454.
Jackson D.D.,2004.Earthquake prediction and forecasting.In:IUGG(eds.),State of the Planet:Frontiers and Challenges,Washington DC:AGU,225~348.
Kanamori H.,and Fuis G.,1976,Variation of P-wave velocity before and after the Galway Lake earthquake(ML=5.2)andthe GoatMountain earthquakes(ML=4.7,4.7),1975,inthe Mojave Desert,California.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,66:2017~2037.
Kano Y.,Mori J.,Fujio R.,Ito H.,Yanagidani T.,Nakao S.and Ma K.F.,2006.Heat Signature onthe Chelunpufault associatedwiththe1999Chi-Chi,Taiwan earthquake.Geophys.Res.Lett.,33:L14306,doi:10.1029/2006GL026733.
Keilis-Borok V.I.and Shebalin P.N.(eds.),1999.Special issue-Dynamics of lithosphere and earthquake prediction.Phys.EarthPlanet.Interi.,111:179~327.
Keilis-Borok V.I.,1990.The lithosphere of the Earth as a nonlinear system with implications for earthquake prediction.Rev.Geophys.,28:19~34.
Keilis-Borok V.,Ismail-Zadeh A.,Kossobokov V.and Shebalin P.,2001.Non-linear dynamics of the lithosphere and intermediate-termearthquake prediction.Tectonophysics,338:247~260.
Keilis-Borok V.,Shebalin P.,Gabrielov A.and Turcotte D.,2004.Reverse tracing of short-termearthquake precursors.Phys.EarthPlanet.Inter.145:75~85.
Knopoff L.,2000.The magnitude distribution of declustered earthquakesin Southern California.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.,97:1188011884.
Knopoff L.,Aki K.,Allen C.R.,Rice J.R.and Sykes L.R.(eds.),1996.Earthquake prediction:the scientific challenge.ColloquiumProceedings,Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA,93:3719~3837.
Knopoff L.,Landoni J.A.and Abinante M.S.,1992.Dynamical model of an earthquake fault withlocalization.Phys.Rev.,A467445~7449.
Kossobokov V.G.,Romashkova L.L.,Keilis-Borok V.I.and Healy J.H.,1999.Testing earthquake prediction algorithms:statisticallysignificant advance prediction of the largest earthquakesinthe Circum-Pacific,1992~1997.Phys.Earth Planet.Interi.,111:187~196.
Li Y.G.,Aki K.,Vidale J.E.and Alvarez M.G.,1998.Delineation of the Nojima fault ruptured in theM7.2Kobe,Japan,earthquake of1995usingfault zone trapped waves.J.Geophys.Res.,103:7247~7263.
Li Y.G.,Chen P.,Cochran E.S.,Vidale J.E.and Burdette T.,2006.Seismic evidence for rock damage and healing onthe SanAndreas Fault associated withthe2004M6.0Parkfield earthquake.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,96:S349~S363,doi:10.1785/0120050803.
Li Y.G.,Vidale J.E.,Aki K.and Xu F.,2000.Depth-dependent structure of the Landersfault zone fromtrapped waves generatedby aftershocks.J.Geophys.Res.,105:6237~6254.
Lockner D.,Naka H.,Tanaka H.,Ito H.andIkeda R.,1999.Permeability and strength of core samplesfromthe Nojimafault of the1995Kobe earthquake.In:Ito H.,Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.and Lockner D.(eds.),Proceedings of the International Workshop onthe Nojima Fault Core and Borehole Data Analysis,Tsukuba:Japan,USGS Open File Report00~129,147~152.
Ma K.F.,Tanaka H.,Song S.R.,Wang C.Y.,Hung J.H.,Tsai Yi.B.,Mori J.,Song Y.F.,Yeh E.C.,Sone H.,KuoL.W.and Wu H.Y.,2006.Slip zone and energetics of a large earthquake fromthe Taiwan Chelungpu-fault Drilling Project.Nature,444:473~476,doi:10.1038/nature05253.
Main I.G.and Al-Kindy F.H.,2002.Entropy,energy,and proximityto criticalityin global earthquake populations.Geophys.Res.Lett.,29(7):doi:10.1029/2001GL014078.
MainI.G.,1995.Earthquakes as critical phenomena:implicationsfor probabilistic seismic hazard analysis.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,85:1299~1308.
Main I.,1996.Statitical physics,seismogenesis,and seismic hazard.Rev.Geophys.,34:433~462.
Manaker D.M.,Michael A.J.and Brgmann R.,2005.Subsurface structure and kinematics of the Calaveras-Hayward Fault stepovefromthree-dimensional Vpandseismicity,San Francisco Bay Region,California.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,95:446~470,doi:101785/0120020202.
Matsu ura M.,Mora P.,Donnellan A.and Yin X.C.(eds.),2002.Special section-Earthquake processes:physical modelling,numerical simulation,and data analysis.Pure appl.Geophys.,159:1905~2536.
Mazzotti S.and Adams J.,2004.Variability of near-termprobability for the next great earthquake on the Cascadia subduction zone.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,94:1954~1959.
McEvilly T.V.and Johnson L.R.,1974.Stability of P and S velocities fromcentral California quarry blasts.Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,64:343~353.
Melbourne T.I.and Webb F.H.,2002.Precursorytransient slip duringthe2001MW=8.4Peruearthquake sequencefromcontinuouGPS.Geophys.Res.Lett.,29(21):doi:10.1029/2002GL015533.
Michael A.J.,1997.Testing prediction methods:earthquakes clustering versus a Posisson model.Geophys.Res.Lett.,24:1891~1894.
Molchan G.M.,1997.Earthquake prediction as a decision-making problem.Pure appl.Geophys.,149:233~247.
Mooney W.D.and Ginzburg A.,1986.Seismic measurements of the internal properties of fault zone.Pure appl.Geophys.,124:141~157.
Mora P.,Matsu ura M.,Madariaga R.and Minster J.-B.(eds.),2000.Special section-Microscopic and macroscopic simulation:towards predictive modelling of the earthquake process.Pure appl.Geophys.,157:1817~2383.
Mulargia F.,1997.Retrospective validation of the time association of precursors.Geophys.J.Int.,131:500~504.
Nadeau R.M.and Dolenc D.,2005.Nonvolcanic tremors deep beneath the San Andreas fault.Science,307:389,doi:10.1126/science.1107142.
Nakamura A.,Hasegawa A.,Hirata N.,Iwasaki T.and Hamaguchi H.,2002.Temporal variations of seismic wave velocity associatedwith1998M6.1Shizukuishi earthquake,Pure appl.Geophys.,159:1183~1204.
Niu F.,Silver P.G.,Nadeau R.M.and McEvilly T.V.,2003.Migration of seismic scatterers associated with the1993Parkfieldaseismic transient event,Nature,426:544~548.
Obara K.,2002.Nonvolcanic deeptremor associated with subductionin southwest Japan.Science,296:1679~1681,doi:10.1126/science.1070378.
Ohnaka M.and Shen L.,1999.Scaling of the shear rupture process fromnucleationto dynamic propagation:implications of geometricirregularity of the rupturing surfaces.J.Geophys.Res.,104:817~844.
Ohnaka M.,1996.Nonuniformity of the constitutive lawparameters for shear rupture and quasistatic nucleation to dynamic rupture:aphysical model of earthquake generation processes.Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci.USA,93:3795~3802.
Okaya D.,Henrys S.and StemT.,2002.Double-sided onshore-offshore seismic imaging of a plate boundary:‘super-gathers’acrossSouthIsland,NewZealand.Tectonophysics,255:247~263.
Oncel A.O.and Wyss M.,2000.The major asperities of the1999MW=7.4Izmit earthquake defined bythe microseismicityof thetwodecades before it.Geophys.J.Int.,143:501~506.
Pandolfi D.,Bean C.J.and Saccorott G.,2006.Coda wave interferometric detection of seismic velocity changes associated with the1999M=3.6event at Mt.Vesuvius,J.Geophys.Res.,33:L06306,doi:10.1029/2005GL025355.
Pepke S.L.,Carlson J.M.and ShawB.E.,1994.Prediction of large events on a dynamical model of a fault.J.Geophys.Res.,99:6769~6788.
Peng Z.G.,Ben-Zion Y.,Michael A.J.and Zhu L.P.,2003.Quantitative analysis of seismic fault zone wavesinthe rupture zoneof the1992Landers,California,earthquake:evidence for a shallowtrapping structure.Geophys.J.Int.,155:1021~1041.
Rastogi B.K.and Mandal P.,1999.Foreshocks and nucleation of small-to moderate-sized Koyna earthquakes(India).Bull.Seism.Soc.Amer.,89:829~836.
Richon P.,Sabroux J.-C.,Halbwachs M.,Vandemeulebrouck J.,Poussielgue N.,Tabbagh J.and Punongbayan R.,2003.Radonanomalyinthe soil of Taal volcano,the Philippines:a likely precursor of theM7.1Mindoro earthquake(1994).Geophys.Res.Lett.,30(9):doi:10.1029/2003GL016902.
Rogers G.and Dragert H.,2003.Episodic tremor and slip on the Cascadia subduction zone:the chatter of silent slip.Science,300:1942~1943,doi:10.1126/science.1084783.
Romachkova L.L.,Kossobokov V.G.,Panza G.F.and Costa G.,1998.Intermediate-termpredictions of earthquakes in Italy:Algorithm M8.Pure appl.Geophys.,152:37~55.
Rundle J.B.,Klein W.,Tiampo K.and Gross S.,2000.Linear pattern dynamicsin nonlinear threshold systems.Phys.Rev.,E61:2418~2431.
Rundle J.B.,Turcotte D.L.,Shcherbakov R.,Klein W.and Sammis C.,2003.Statistical physics approach to understanding themultiscale dynamics of earthquake fault systems.Rev.Geophys.,41(4):doi:10.1029/2003RG000135.
Sato H.,Hirata N.,Koketsu K.,Okaya D.,Abe S.,Kobayashi R.,Matsubara M.,Iwasaki T.,Ito T.,Ikawa T.,Kawanaka T.,Kasahara K.,Harder S.,2005.Earthquake source fault beneath Tokyo.Science,309:462~464,doi:10.1126/science.1110489.
Scholz C.H.,1990.The Mechanics of Earthquakes and Faulting.Cambridge Univ.Press,NewYork,135~141.
Seher T.and Main I.G.,2004.Astatistical evaluation of a‘stress-forecast’earthquake.Geophys.J.Int.,157:187~193.
Shelly D.R.,Beroza G.C.,Ide S.and Nakamula S.,2006.Low-frequency earthquakesin Shikoku,Japan,andtheir relationshiptoepisodic tremor and slip.Nature,442:188~191,doi:10.1038/nature04931.
Snieder R.and Hagerty M.,2004.Monitoring change in volcanic interiors using coda wave interferometry:application to ArenVolcano,Costa Rica,Geophys.Res.Lett.,31:L09608,doi:10.1029/2004GL019670.
Sobolev G.,2001.The examples of earthquake preparationin Kamchatka and Japan.Tectonophysics,338:269~279.
Sornette D.,2000.Critical Phenomena in Complex Systems.Berlin:Springer-Verlag,1~412.
Sornette A.and Sornette D.,1990.Earthquake rupture as a critical point:consequences for telluric precursors.Tectonophysics,179:327~334.
Sornette D.and Sammis C.G.,1995.Critical exponents fromrenomalization group theory of earthquakes:implications for earthquakeprediction.J.Phys.I.,5:607~619.
Tanaka H.,Tomida N.,Sekiya N.,Tsukiyama Y.,Fujimoto K.,Ohtani T.and Ito H.,1999.Distribution,deformation andalteration of fault rocks alongthe GSJ core penetrating the Nojima fault,Awaji Island,southwest Japan,In:Ito H.,Fujimoto K.,Tanaka H.and Lockner D.(eds.),Proceedings of the International Workshop onthe Nojima Fault Core and Borehole Data Analysis,Tsukuba:Japan,81~101.
Tiampo K.F.,Rundle J.B.,McGinnis S.and Gross S.J.,2002.Eigenpatterns in southern California seismicity.J.Geophys.Res.,107(B12):doi:10.1029/2001JB000562.
Vere-Jones D.and Ogata Y.,2003.Statistical principles for seismologists.In:Lee W.H.K.,Kanamori H.,Jennings P.C.andKisslinger C.(eds.),International Handbook of Earthquake and Engineering Seismology.Amsterdam:Academic Press,1573~1586.
1586.Westerhaus M.,Wyss M,Yilmaz R.and Zschau J.,2002.Correlating variations of b values and crustal deformation duringthe1990smay have pinpointedthe rupture initiation of theMW=7.4Izmit earthquake of1999August17.Geophys.J.Int.,148:139~152.
Wyss M.and Dmowska R.(eds.),1997.Special issue-Earthquake prediction,state-of-the-art.Pure appl.Geophys.,149:1~264.
Wyss M.and Martirosyan A.H.,1998.Seismic quiescence before the M7,1988,Spitak earthquake,Armenia.Geophys.J.Int.,134:329~340.
Wyss M.,Shimazaki K.and Ito A.(eds.),1999.Special section-Seismicity pattern,their statistical significance and physicalmeaning.Pure appl.Geophys.,155:203~726.
Xu H.J.and Knopoff L.,1994.Periodicity and chaosin a one-dimensional dynamical model of earthquakes.Phys.Rev.,E50:3577~3581.
Yin X.C.,Mora P.,Doonellan A.and Matsuura M.(eds.),2006a.Special issue-Computational earthquake physics partⅠ.Pureappl.Geophys.,163:1737~2047.
Yin X.C.,Mora P.,Doonellan A.and Matsuura,M.(eds.),2006b.Special issue-Computational earthquake physics partⅡ.Pureappl.Geophys.,163:2259~2593.
Zhao D.and Negishi H.,1998.The1995Kobe earthquake:Seismic image of the source zone and its implications for the rupturenucleation.J.Geophys.Res.,103:9967~9986.
Zoback M.D.,2006,SAFODpenetrates the San Andreas Fault.Scientific Drilling,2:32~33,doi:10.2204/iodp.sd.2.07.2006.
版权所有：© 2023 中国地质图书馆 中国地质调查局地学文献中心