用户名: 密码: 验证码:
应急预案辅助设计及评价问题研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
近年来,各类突发公共事件的频繁发生使得应急管理逐渐引起社会的广泛关注。应急预案是应急管理工作中的重要组成部分,是开展应急救援的基础。做好应急预案的相关管理工作是降低突发事件风险、及时有效地开展应急救援工作的重要保障。
     为了更好地应对可能发生的各类突发公共事件,近年来各地区、各有关部门和各类生产经营单位按照党中央、国务院的统一部署和要求,在预案方面做了大量工作。截至目前,国家突发公共事件预案体系已经基本建立起来。据不完全统计,我国目前各级各类预案已达200多万件,基本覆盖了各类突发公共事件。
     但是,从整体上看,我国现有的应急预案与实际的应用还有很大差距,存在很多亟待解决的问题。主要表现在:应急预案的编制设计过程中缺乏科学的方法支撑,导致应急预案中的应对方案过于笼统、可操作性差;缺乏对应急预案的综合评价的理论和方法,尤其是缺少突发事件发生后对应急预案实施效果进行评价的方法;对应急预案完全实施的期望过高,缺乏对应急预案灵活性设计方面的思考以及在此基础上对应急预案有效性进行评价的方法。针对这些问题,本文的研究内容具体如下:
     (1)基于案例推理的应急预案处置方案辅助设计方法研究。本文将人工智能领域中的案例推理方法引入到应急预案处置方案辅助设计中,以期提高方案设计的科学性。建立了应急案例库,设计了应急案例的概念树.本体模型.元模型的三层架构的存储模式,设计了相似案例的检索算法,开发了原型系统对该方法的实用性进行验证。
     (2)应急预案的综合评价问题研究。本研究将应急预案的评价分为事前的先验性评价及事后对实施效果进行评价(后效评价)。总结了现有研究中对先验性评价的研究成果,重点研究了应急预案的后效评价。基于目前尚没有对应急预案实施后的效果进行定量化评价研究的现状以及危化品泄露事故在应急管理中的重要地位,本文以危化品泄露事故为例,首次将多层次灰色评价方法引入到应急预案实施效果评价中来,建立了基于灰色多层次评价的危化品泄露事故应急预案后效评价模型。
     (3)基于弹性视角的应急预案有效性评价研究。本文首先从突发事件定义、突发事件特性以及组织本身管理三个角度分析并总结了目前我国大多数应急预案在突发事件应对中无法完全按照预案本身刚性实施的现状及其原因,指出应急预案不应该只是一个刚性的文本文件,而应该是具有弹性的,这样才能够适应越来越复杂的突发事件的情形,不断提高其实际的可用性。在此基础上给出了应急预案弹性的定义,提出了基于弹性视角的应急预案有效性评价的思路框架,并辅以美国911案例阐述了应急预案无法刚性实施时可以通过提高组织的应急恢复弹性而取得应急响应成功。进一步根据该框架抽象出基于弹性视角的应急预案有效性评价的概念模型,并基于实施理论对该概念模型的合理性进行理论验证。
     在论文的最后部分对以上工作进行总结,并对未来工作进行展望。
     本文的研究可以为我国各级应急管理人员在应急预案的方案设计及预案评价方面的管理工作提供决策支持与参考,有助于不断提高应急预案对突发事件处置的有效程度,使得应急预案可以更有效地应对突发事件以减少损失。
In recent years, various types of public emergencies happened frequently.As a result, emergency management has gradually attracted more and more public attention. As an important part of the emergency management, contingency plans management is a basic work of emergency rescue effort. Making contingency plans for emergency management is important guarantee to the successful emergency rescue work through reducing the risk, and carrying out timely and effective implementation of the plans.
     In order to better respond to possible types of public emergencies, various localities and departments and the various types of production units have done a lot of work on emergency plans management to meet the requirement and unified arrangement of the State Council. So far, the national system of public emergency plan has been basically established. And according to incomplete statistics, the number of China's current levels of various types of plans has reached two million, covering almost all kinds of public emergencies.
     However, on the whole, there are still some gaps between written plans and implementation in real response to emergency. Thus, there are still many problems need to be solved to improve the efficiency of contingency plans. The main problems are as follows: firstly, lacking of guidance of scientific method to support the historical experience learning when designing and making contingency plans; secondly, lacking of comprehensive evaluation theory and method to evaluate contingency plans.Especially lacking of evaluation method to evaluate the implementation efficiency of the contingency plans after the emergency; thirdly, emphasizing too much expectation on the fully implementation of contingency plans, lacking of consideration on flexibility in the design of contingency plans and related evaluation ideas and method to evaluate effectiveness of contingency plans.To solve these problems, the contents of this research are as follows:
     Firstly, research on aid-design method for executive solution of contingency plans based on case-based reasoning. This article applied the case-based reasoning method, which belongs to the field of artificial intelligence to aided design of contingency plans execute solution through retrieving the similar cases and their solutions. We built emergency case base, and designed the three-tier storage model based on concept tree, ontology model and element model, and then designed Case retrieval algorithm, and lastly developed a prototype system to verify the practicality of the method. This method can provide plan makers decision support by quickly retrieving the historical experience of similar cases when they design contingency plans execute solution.
     Secondly, research on comprehensive evaluation of contingency plans. In this study, the evaluation of contingency plans was divided into two types, the pre-evaluation and post-evaluation of the effect (after-effect evaluation). It summarized existing studies on the pre-evaluation at first, and then focused on the evaluation of emergency plans in the after-effects. This paper took hazardous chemicals spill incident as an example and applied multi-level and grey evaluation model method to the evaluation of contingency plans and built the evaluation model of incident of hazardous chemicals spill plans implementation.
     Thirdly, research on effectiveness evaluation of contingency plans based on resilient perspective. This paper analyzed the reasons why current contingency plans were hard to be fully implemented in the real response from three following perspectives, namely definition of contingency, features of contingency and organization management. Contingency plan should not be just a rigid text file, but should be flexible, so as to meet the increasingly complex emergency situations, and constantly improve its actual availability. On this basis, the paper proposed the definition of flexibility of contingency plans. Then it proposed an thinking framework to evaluate the effectiveness of contingency plans based on resilient view, and it explained that when contingency plan of an organization can't be fully implemented, it can still make organization attain successful response by improving organization resilient potential, which is supported by the 911 case study.Furthermore, a conceptual model was abstracted based on the framework proposed above, and the rationality of the conceptual model was validated theoretically based on implementation theory.
     Finally, the paper summarized the work has been done above, and proposed the prospect of future work.
     This research can provide contingency planners and managers of all government levels efficient decision support on execution solution design, and evaluation of contingency plans. Thus it can help improve contingency plans to play more and more active roles in real response to emergency and reduce great loss in the future.
引文
[1]王湛.突发公共事件应急管理过程及能力评价研究[D].武汉:武汉理工大学管理学院,2008.
    [2]杨芳,储胜利.企业应急预案编制的难点及对策研究[J].中国安全生产科学术,2011,7(1):127-130.
    [3]Robert T.Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act[R].2000.
    [4]Australian Emergency Manual series, Emergency Management in Australia, Concepts and Principles, Manual Number 1, Commonwealth of Australia 2004.
    [5]《国家突发公共事件总体应急预案》[EB/OL][2005-8-7]http://www.gov.cn/yjgl/2005-08/07/content_21048.htm
    [6]薛斓,张强,钟开斌著.防范与重构:从SARS事件看转型期中国的危机管理[J].改革,2003(3).
    [7]唐承沛.中小城市突发公共事件应急管理体系与方法[D].上海:同济大学管理学院,2007.
    [8]韩大元,莫于川.应急法制论[M].北京:法律出版社,2005.
    [9]姜兰.论我国突发事件应急管理体系的构建[D].上海:华东政法大学,2007.
    [10]Richard A. Rotanz. Handbook of disaster research [M].2006,468-476.
    [11]Nudell, M. and Antokol, N.The Handbook for Effective Emergency and Crisis Management [M]. Lexington Books, Lexington.1998.
    [12]Seymour, M.and Moore, S. Effective Crisis Management:Worldwide Principles and Practice, [M]. London.2000.
    [13]Mitroff,I. Managing crises before they happen:what every executive and manager needs to know about crisis management[M]. Amacom, NewYork.2001.
    [14]Boin, A., tHart, P., Stern, E. and Sundelius, B. The Politics of crisis management:public leadership under pressure[M]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.2005.
    [15]McConnell A and Drennan L.Mission Impossible? Planning and Preparing for Crisis[J]. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management,2006,14(2):59-70.
    [16]《国家突发公共事件总体应急预案》[EB/OL][2005-8-7] http://www.gov.cn/yjgl/2005-08/31/content_27872.htm
    [17]张红.英美两国应急预案制度及其借鉴意义[J].中国应急管理,2008(3):20-24.
    [18]陆立德,徐旭初.防灾预案研究[J].灾害学,1992,7(2):36-38.
    [19]吴宗之,刘茂.重大事故应急预案分级、分类体系及其基本内容[J].中国安全科学学报,2003,13(1):15-18.
    [20]刘功智,刘铁民.重大事故应急预案编制指南[J].劳动保护,2004(4):25-26.
    [21]刑娟娟.2004.重大事故的应急救援预案编制技术[J].中国安全科学学报.2004,14(1):57-59.
    [22]Ronald W. Perry, Michael K. L, et al. Preparedness for Emergency Response:Guidelines for the Emergency Planning Process[J]. Disasters,2003,27(4):336-350.
    [23]Alexander, D. Towards the development of a standard in emergency planning[J]. Disaster Prevention and Management,2005,14(2):158-175.
    [24]CRS Report for Congress. Pandemic Influenza:An Analysis of State Preparedness and Response Plans[R]. September 24,2007.
    [25]Nakanishi Y. Assessing Emergency Preparedness of Transit Agencies:A foucus on Performance Indicators[C]. The 82nd Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board Washington, D. C., January,2003.
    [26]Michael K. L. Assessing emergency preparedness in support of Hazardous facility risk analyses:Application to siting a US hazardous waste incinerator [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,1995,40(3):297-319.
    [27]Kaji A H, Lewis R J. Assessment of the Reliability of the Johns Hopkins/Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Hospital Disaster Drill Evaluation Tool[J]. Annals of Emergency Medicine., In Press, Corrected Proof.
    [28]Burns K J, Robinsonk, Lowe E G. Evaluation of responses of an air medical helicopter program during a comprehensive emergency response drill [J]. Air Medical Journal.2007, 26(3):139-143.
    [29]Wang C, Wei S, Xiang H, et al. Evaluating the effectiveness of an emergency preparedness training programme for public health staff in China [J]. Public Health,2008,122(5): 471-477.
    [30]杨惫源,宋峰.对地震应急预案的科学性、可操作性和体系性的讨论[J].国际地震动态,2002(2):1-5.
    [31]许兆亭,孟昭威,尹燕福.灭火预案编制中存在的问题及对策明.灭火指挥与救援.2005,24(3):333-336.
    [32]Boppana V. Ramabrahmam, B. Sreenivasulu, Mangalam M. Mallikarjunan. Model on-site emergency plan[J]. Case study:toxic gas release from an ammonia storage terminal. J. Loss Prev. Process Ind,1996,9(4):259-265.
    [33]Jenkins. L. Selecting Seenarios for Environmental Disaster Planning[J]. EuropeanJoumal of Operational Research,2000,121 (2):275-286.
    [34]Elba Urbina and Brian Wblshon. National review of hurricane evacuation Plans and polieies:a comparion and contrast of state practices[J]. Transportation Research Part A:Policy and Practice,2003,37(3):257-275.
    [35]Boppana V. Ramabraham, G. Swaminathan. Disaster management plan for chemical process industries. Case study:investigation of release of chlorine to atmosphere[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2005,13(1):57-62.
    [36]Asit Kumar Patra. Influnce of wind speed profile and roughness paremeters on the downsind extension of vulnerable zones during dispersion of toxic dense gases[J]. Journal of Loss Prewention in the Process Industries,2006,19(5):495-497.
    [37]Ibrahim Mohamed Shaluf.Disaster Prevention and Management[J].2007,16(5):704-717.
    [38]Turner, B. A. and Pedgeon, N. F. Man-Made Disasters (2nded) [M]. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford.1997.
    [39]Bohari, A. M. and Rashid, B. Natural and un-natural disasters in Asia:the function of Geographical information system[C]. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Disaster Management. Surabaya,3-5 May.2001.
    [40]Kishore, K. Disasters in Asia and the Pacific:an overview. available at:www.adpc.ait.ac.th/general/adpc.html.
    [41]Kaplan, L. G. Emergency and Disaster Planning Manual[M]. McGraw-Hill, NewYork, NY.1996.
    [42]Shrivastava, P., Mitroff, I., Miller, D. and Miglani, A. Understanding industrial crisis. Journal of Management Studies [J].1998,25:4-5.
    [43]Richardson, B. Socio-technical disaster:profile and prevalence. Disaster Prevention and Management[J].1994,3(4):41-69.
    [44]Mitroff,I.I. Crisis management:cutting through the confusion. Sloan Management Review[J].1988,29(2):15-20.
    [45]Haddow, G. D. and Bullock, J. A. Introduction to Emergency Management[M]. Butterworth-Heinemann, Stoneham, MA.2003.
    [46]UNEP-APELL Disasters Database, available at: www.unepie.org/pc/apell/disasters/lists/disasterdate.html.2003.
    [47]Emergency and humanitarian action:natural disaster profile,2003. available at:www.who.int/disasters/
    [48]唐浦裙.城市应急管理系统框架模型的研究[D].上海:同济大学经济与管理学院,2006.
    [49]杨静,陈建明,赵红.应急管理中的突发事件分类分级研究[J].管理评论,2005,17(4):37-41.
    [50]金磊.试论防灾预案学团[J].地质勘探安全,1999(1):39-40.
    [51]赵红,汪亮.从美国联邦应急计划看美国国家应急管理运行机制团[J].项目管理技术,2004(1):26-30.
    [52]万军,汪军.应急管理中的政府责任和权力综述[J].兰州学刊,2004(4):217-220.
    [53]郭济.政府应急管理实务[M].北京:中共中央党校出版社,2004.
    [54]朱小奇.论金融机构突发事件应急管理机制[J].求索,2004(7):34-36.
    [55]赵林度.基于危机资源管理的城市安全应急网络研究[J].东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2004,6(4):48-51.
    [56]Gwyndaf Williams, Stuart Batho, Lynne Russell. Responding to urban crisis:The emergency planning response to the bombing of Manchester city centre [J]. Cities,2000,17(4): 293-304.
    [57]王明旭.突发公共卫生事件应急管理[M].北京:军事医学科学出版社.2004.
    [58]David A. McEntire. Searehing for a Holistic Paradigm and Policy Guide:A Proposal For the Future of Emergency Management[J]. Intemational Journal of Emergeney Management, 2003,1(3):298-308.
    [59]Dymon, U. J. An Analysis of Emergency Map Symbology[J]. International Journal of Emergency Management,2003,1(3):227-237.
    [60]Jean-Luc Wybo, Harriet Lonka. Emergency Management and the Information Society:how to improve the synergy[J]. International Journal of Emergency Management,2002, 1(2):183-190.
    [61]Eleftherios Iakovou, Christos Douligeris. An information management system for the emergency management of hurricane disasters[J]. International Journal of Emergency Management.2001,2(3/4):243-262.
    [62]周治新.完善应急联动系统建设有效应对突发公共事件[J].中国公共安全,2006(6):138-141.
    [63]赵军,刘士爱,黄旭义.基于DDYGIsS的城市应急联动指挥研究与实现[J].测绘科学,2006,31(5):134-136.
    [64]曹立,吴明辉,应晶.基于网格的城市应急联动中心方案设计研究[J].计算机应用研究,2004(10):61-63.
    [65]S. Gwynne, E. R. Galea, M. Owen, P. J. Lawrence, L. Filippidis. A Review of the methodologies used in the computer simulation of evacuation from the built environment[J]. Building and Environment,1999,34 (6):741-749.
    [66]Owen M, Galea ER, Lawerence PJ. The Exodus Evaluation Model Applied to Building Evacuation scenarios[J]. Journal of Fire Protection Engr,1996,8(2):65-86.
    [67]Donegan HA, Pollock AJ, Taylor IR. Egress Complexity of a building [C]. In:Kashiwagi TL, Editor.Proceedings of Fourth International symposium on Fire Safety Science:601-612.1994.
    [68]Ketchell N, Cole SS, Webber DM. The EGRESS code for Human Movement and Behavior in Emergency Evacuation[J]. In:Smith RA, Dickie JF, editors. Engineering for Crowd Safety, Elasevier.1993:361-370.
    [69]Ozel F. Simulation modeling of human behavior in buildings [J]. Simulation,1992, 58(6):377-384.
    [70]Kisko Tm, Francis RL. A Computer Program to Determine Optimal Evacuation Plans[J]. Fire Safety Journal,1985,9(2):211-220.
    [71]Taylor IR. A revised Interface for Evacnet+[C]. In:Franks C, Grayson S, editors Proceedings of Seventh International for Science and Engineering Conference, InterFlam,1996.
    [72]Fraser-Mitchell JN. The lessons Learnt During the Development of CRISPII,A Monte Carlo Simulation for Fire Assesment[C].In:Franks C, Grayson S. editors. Proceedings of the Seventh International Fire Science and Engineering Conference. Interflam,1996:631-639.
    [73]Fraser-Mitchell JN. An Object-Oriented Simulation for Fire Risk Assessment [C].In: Kashawaga T. Editor. Proceedings of the Fourth International Symposium of Fire Safety Science 1994:793-804.
    [74]F. R. B. Cruz, J. MacGregor Smith, R.O. Mederios. An M/G/C/C State-dependent Network Simulation Model [J]. Computers & Operations Research,2005,32(4):919-941.
    [75]GI Mould. Assessing Systems for Offshore Emergency Evacuation[J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society,2001,52(4):401-408.
    [76]Takashi Nagatani, Ryoichi Nagai. Statistical characteristics of evacuation without visibility in random walk model[J]. Physica A,2004,341(1):638-648.
    [77]Ryoichi Nagai, Takashi Natani,Motoshige Taku Adachi. Effect of exit configuration on evacuation of rom without visibility [J]. Physica A,2004,343(15):712-724.
    [78]Thomas J. Cova, Justin P. Johnson.. A network flow model for lane-based evacuation routing[J]. Transportation Research,2003,37(7):579-604.
    [79]Kostas G.. Zografos. Analytical Framework for Minimizing Freeway-Incident Reponse Time [J]. Journal of Transportation Engieering.1993,119(4):535-549.
    [80]Geoffrey N.Berlin, Jon C. Liebman. Mathematical Analysis of Emergency Ambulance Location[J]. Socio-Economic Planning Scences,1974,8(6):323-328.
    [81]C. S. Revelle, H. A. Eiselt. Location Analysis:A Synthesis and Survey[J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2005,165(1):1-19.
    [82]何建敏,刘春林.应急管理与应急系统:选址、调度与算法[M].北京:科学出版社,2005.
    [83]贾传亮,池宏,计雷.基于多阶段灭火过程的消防资源布局模型[J].系统工程,2005,23(9):12-15.
    [84]G Barbarosoglu, Y Arda. A Two-Stage Stochastic Programming Framework for Transportation Planning in Disaster Response[J]. Journal of Operational Research Society,2004,(55):43-53.
    [85]赵卫东,李旗号,盛昭瀚.基于案例推理的决策问题求解研究[J].管理科学学报,2000,4(3):29-36.
    [86]Kolodner J L. Improving human decision making the rough case-based reasoning techniques [J].AI Magazine.1991,12(3):52-59.
    [87]Hinrichs T R, Kolodner J. The roles of adaptation in case-based design [C]. In:Proceedings of Case-based Reasoning workshop. Washington.1991:121-132.
    [88]Aamodt A and Plaza E. Case-based reasoning:foundational issues methodological variations and system approaches[J]. AI Communications,1994,7(1):39-59.
    [89]Watoson I. Case-based reasoning is a methodology not a technology[J]. Knowledge-based System,1999,12(5,6):303-308.
    [90]Marvin Minsky. A Framwork for Reprexenting Knowledge [R]. Technical Report, AIM-306,1974.
    [91]李茹,任海涛等.基于案例的推理在农业专家系统中的应用[J].计算机工程与应用,2004,(25)196-198.
    [92]汤文宇,李玲娟.CBR方法中的案例表示和案例库的构造[J].西安邮电学院学报,2006,11(5):75-78.
    [93]房明.基于CBR技术推广研究与应用研究[D].武汉:华中科技大学.2004.
    [94]王悦,范君晖,田书格.基于案例推理专家系统中的案例表示方法[J].上海工程技术大学学报,2005,19(1):42-46.
    [95]胡亚辉,徐燕申,牛文铁.CBR技术中实例表达的研究与应用[J].机械工程师,2003(2):16-18.
    [96]张建华,刘仲英.案例推理和规则推理结合的紧急预案信息系统[J].同济大学学报,2002,30(7):890-894.
    [97]李玲娟,汤文宇,王汝传.基于XML的案例表示和案例库构造方法[J].计算机应用研究,2007,24(11):70-73.
    [98]孔月萍,周继,于军琪,等.人工智能及其应用[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2007.
    [99]Raman Lopez de Mantaras. Case-based Reasoning[M]. Springer Verlag Heidelberg,2001.
    [100]路云,吴应宇,达庆利.基于案例推理技术的企业可持续竞争能力的模型建立与应用[J].管理工程学报,2005,19(3):1-5.
    [101]周凯波,魏莹等.基于案例推理的金融危机预警支持系统[J].计算机工程与应用,2001(14):18-21.
    [102]路云,吴应宇,达庆利.基于案例推理技术的企业经营决策支持模型设计[J].中国管理科学,2005,13(2):81-87.
    [103]张光前,邓贵仕,许文.基于事例推理方法在企业知识管理中的应用[J].东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2002,4:89-92.
    [104]张建华,刘仲英.案例推理和规则推理结合的紧急预案信息系统[J].同济大学学报,2002,30(7):890-894.
    [105]Ahdus Salam Khan, Ac;him Hoffmxnn. Ac;quiring Adaptation Knowledge for CBR with MIKAS[M].Springer-Verlag Heidelherg,2001.
    [106]李明.Multi-Agent的范例推理[J].重庆师范学院学报(自然科学版),2001,3(18):57-59.
    [107]张光前,邓贵仕,李朝晖.基于事例推理的技术及其应用前景[J].计算机工程与应用,2002,38(20):52-55.
    [108]柳炳祥,盛昭翰.基于案例推理的企业危机预警系统设计[J].中国软科学,2003(3):67-70.
    [109]郭艳红,邓贵仕.基于事例的推理研究综述[J].计算机工程与应用,2004(21):1-5.
    [110]Rissland E L, Ashlcy K D. Creodit assignment and the problem of competing factors in case-based reasoning[C]. In:Kolodncr ed.Case-Based Reasoning, Proceedings from a Workshop, Claearwater Beach, Florida, Morgan-Kauffman Pnbl,1988.
    [111]Cain T, Pazzani M J, Silverstein G. Using domain knowledge to in-fluence similarity judgment[C]. In:Proceedings of Case-based Reasoning workshop, Washington Morgan Kaufmann,1991:191-202.
    [112]Stanfill C. Memory-based reasoning applied to English pronunciation[C]. In:Proceedings AAAI-87, Seattle,1987:577-581.
    [113]Surma J. Enhancing similarity measures with domain specific; know-ledge[C]. In:Preprints Second European Workshop on Case-Based Reasoning, AcknoSoft Press,1994:365-372.
    [114]王玉,邢渊,阮雪榆.基于事例的推理循环中人工神经网络和遗传算法的4种应用模型[J].上海交通大学学报,2000,37(2):202-204.
    [115]Dubois D, Prade H, Testemale C. Weighted fuzzy pattern matching[J]Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 1988(28):351-362.
    [116]Dubois D, Esteva F,Garcia P et al.Fuzzy modelling of case-based and decision[C]. In: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Case-based Reasoning, Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence 1266, Springcr-Vcrlag,1997:599-610.
    [117]Schaaf J W. Fish and shrink:A next step towards efficient case retrieval inlarge scaled case bases[A]. Advances in Case-based Reasoning[C]. Lausanne:Third European Workshop,1996.362-376.
    [118]Sutcliffe K., Vogus T. Organizing for Resilience, In Cameron, K. (ed.), Positive Organizational Scholarship[M]. Berrett-Koehler Publishers Inc., San Francisco, CA, 2003,94-110.
    [119]Hinrichs T R, Koloder J. The roles of adaptation in case-based design[C]. In:Proceedings of Case-based Reasoning workshop, Washington,1991:121-132.
    [120]Kolodncr J L. Case-based reasoning[C]. San Mateo, CA, Kaufman.1993.
    [121]Hanney K, Keane M T. The adaptation knowledge bottleneck:How to easy it by learning from Cases[C]. In:Proceedings of the Second International Conference on case-based Reasoning Lecture Notes in Computer Science,1997(1266):359-370.
    [122]Leake D B, Kinley A, Wilson D. A case study of case-based CBR[C]. In:Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Case-based Reasonig, Lecture Notes in Arrificial Intelligence 1266, Springer-Verlag,1997:371-382.
    [123]Purvis L. Athalye S. Towards improving Case adaptability with a genetic algorithm[C]. In: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Case-based Reasoning,Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence 1266, Springer-Verlag,1997:403-412.
    [124]Schweizer B. and Sklar A. Probabilistic Metric Spaces[M]. North Holland,1983.
    [125]Ahdns Salam Khan, Achim Hoffmann. Acquiring Adaptation Knowledge for CBR with MIKAS[M]. Springer-Verlag Heidelberg,2001.
    [126]Koloener J. Maintaining organization in a dynamic long-term memory [J]. Cognitive Science,1983,7(4),243-280.
    [127]Zhong Zhang and Qiang Yang. Feature Weight Maintenance in Case bases using Introspective Learning [J]. Journal of Intelligent Information Systems.2001:1-23.
    [128]杨瑾,尤建新,蔡依平.基于案例推理的供应商选择决策支持系统研究[J].计算机工程与应用,2006(06):19-23.
    [129]杨晔.基于案例的推理在增值税纳税申报系统中的应用[J].计算机应用,2004,24(1):11-13.
    [130]张荣梅,涂序彦.基于CBR的交通事故处理智能决策支持系统[J].计算机工程与应用,2002(2):247-249.
    [131]汪季玉,王金桃.基于案例推理的应急决策支持系统研究[J].管理科学,2003,16(6):46-48.
    [132]Jay F. Nunamaker JR, Zhang Dong-song. A Knowledge Management Framework for the Support of Decision Making in Humanitarian Assistance/Disaster Relief. [J]Knowledge and Information Systems,2002 (4):370-385.
    [133]F. Ricci, P. Avesani, A. Perini. Cases on Fire:Applying CBR to Emergency Management [J]. New Review of Applied Expert System,1996,6:175-190.
    [134]刘烯,面向城市应急指挥的职能决策系统的研究与实现[D].广州:广东工业大学,2007.
    [135]郭泳亨,卢兴华,刘云.基于案例库的应急决策支持系统研究[J].控制管理.2006(22):148-150.
    [136]韩仁均.基于案例推理的航天发射应急空间智能决策支持系统的应用[D].重庆:重庆大学,2007.
    [137]郭泳亨,卢兴华,刘云.基于案例库的应急决策支持系统研究[J].微计算机信息,2006,22(8):148-150.
    [138]Smith, N. Modern linguistics. Foreign Language Teaching and Study press.1983,30-31.
    [139]Gruber, T. R. A translation approach to portable ontologies[J]. Knowledge Acquisition,1993,5(2):199-220.
    [140]Watson L. Applying Case-based Reasoning Technique for Enterprise Systems [M].UK Morgan Kaufmann Publishers Inc, California.1997.
    [141]Dvir G, Langholaz G, Schneider M. Matching Attributes in a Fuzzy Case Based Reasoning[C]. IEEE,1999:33-36.
    [142]张本生,于永利.CBR系统案例搜索中的混合相似度方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,2002,22(3):131-136.
    [143]安监总局 : 我 国 应急预案体系 已经进一步完善[EB/OL][2009-04-16]http://cjb.newssc.org/html/2009-04/16/content_502011.htm
    [144]黄典剑,宁绪成.石油化工企业应急预案评价方法研究[J].石油化工安全技术,2006,22(5):17-19.
    [145]张勇,贾传亮,王建军.基于模糊综合评价方法的突发事件应急预案评估[J].中国管理科学,2004,12(专辑):154-156.
    [146]刘吉夫,朱晶晶等.我国自然灾害类应急预案评价方法研究(I):完备性评价.中国安全科学学报,2008,18(2):6-11.
    [147]刘吉夫,朱晶晶等.我国自然灾害类应急预案评价方法研究(II)责任矩阵评价.中国安全科学学报,2008,18(4):6-15.
    [148]于瑛英,池宏.基于网络计划的应急预案的可操作性研究[J].公共管理学报,2007,4(2):100-107.
    [149]Eileen K.. Outcome evaluation in planning:Why they aren't done more often and whether the American Planning Association support their use[D]. University of Cincinnati.2004
    [150]于瑛英.应急预案制定中的评估问题研究[D].北京:中国科学技术大学,2008.
    [151]Crews D. T. The case for emergency management as a profession[J]. Australian Journal of Emergency Management,2001,16(2):2-3
    [152]池宏,计雷,湛爱群.由突发事件能上能引发的动态博弈网络技术的探讨[J].项目管理技术,2003,(1).
    [153]张兵.城市规划实效伦[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,1998,30-39.
    [154]孙施文,周宇.城市规划实施评价的理论与方法[J].城市规划汇刊,2003,144(2):15-20.
    [155]Seasons M. Monitoring and Evaluation in Municipal Planning[J]. Journal of the American Planning Association Research Library,2003,69(4):430.
    [156]Alexander ER, If Planning Isn't Everything, May be It's Something[J]. Town Planning Review Quarterly,1981,52(2):135-139.
    [157]高建明,曾明荣.我国危险化学品安全生产的现状及对策[J].中国安全生产科学技术.2005,1(3):52-56.
    [158]胡笙煌.主观指标评价的多层次灰色评价法[J].系统工程理论与实践,1996(1):12-20.
    [159]刘思峰,党耀国,方志耕,等.灰色系统理论及其应用[M].北京:科学出版社,1999.
    [160]邓聚龙.灰色系统理论[M].北京:国防工业出版社,1985.
    [161]傅立.灰色系统理论及其应用[M].北京:科学技术文献出版社,1999.
    [162]李大建,王凤山.地空导弹总体性能多层次灰色评价[J].中国管理科学,2004,12(5):107-110.
    [163]陈力,宣国良.后发企业的知识整合能力提升研究[J].情报科学,2005,23(12):1892-1898.
    [164]唐炎钊,邹珊刚.企业技术创新能力的多层次灰色评价[J].科技进步与对策,1999,16(5):46-49.
    [165]王立新,李勇,任荣明.基于灰色多层次方法的企业技术创新风险评估研究[J].系统工程理论与实践,2006,26(7):98-104
    [166]Waugh, W. L. Living with Hazards, Dealing with Disasters:An Introduction to Emergency Management[M]. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, NY,2000
    [167]Tierney, K. J., Lindell,M. K. and Perry. Facing the Unexpected:Disaster Preparedness and Response in the United States[R]. Joseph Henry Press, Washington, DC.2001.
    [168]Brown, C.and Eriksson, K. A plan for (certain)failure:possibilities for and challenges of more realistic emergency plans[J]. International Journal of Emergency Management. 2008,.5 (3/4):292-310.
    [169]Schwartz, P., Inevitable Surprises:Thinking Ahead in a Time of Turbulence[C]. Gotham, NewYork,2003.
    [170]Mcconnell A and Drennan L.Mission Impossible? Planning and Preparing for Crisis[J]. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management,2006,14(2):59-70.
    [171]Clark, L Mission improbable:Using fantasy documents to tame disaster[D]. Chicago Press,1999.
    [172]Marks, A. The real first responders:citizens? Christer Science Monitor, [EB/OL][2005-07-14]http://www.csmonitor.com/2005/0714/p03s01-ussc.html
    [173]Schneider, S.K. Flirting with Disaster:Public Management in Crisis Situations[M]. M. E. Sharpe, Armonk, NY.1995.
    [174]Kathleen. T. Conceptualizing and measuring organizational and community resilience: Lessons from the emergency response following the September 11,2001 attack on the World Trade Center. Newark, DE:University of Delaware Disaster Research Center.2003.
    [175]Richard A. Rotanz. From Research to Praxis:The Relevance of Disaster Research for Emergency Management[M].2006,468-476.
    [176]Ibrahim Mohamed Shaluf, Disaster types[J]. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2007,16(5):704-717.
    [177]Boin,A. Lessons from CrisisResearch[J]. International Studies Review,2004,6(1): 165-194.
    [178]Perry, R. W. and Quarantelli, E. L. What Is a Disaster? New Answers to Old Questions[M], Xlibris, Philadelphia.2005.
    [179]Turner, B. A. and Pedgeon, N. F. Man-Made Disasters (2nded) [M]. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford.1997.
    [180]Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, "Disaster minology" available at:http://pdm.medicine.wise.edu/vocab.htm.2002.
    [181]Denis, H. Scientists and disaster management[J]. Disaster Prevention and Management, 1995,4(2):14-19.
    [182]Keller, A. Z. and Al-Madhari, A. F. Risk management and disasters [J]. Disaster Prevention and Management,1996,5(5):19-22.
    [183][EB/OL][2006-01-08]http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2006-01/08/content-4023946.ht m.
    [184]Simon A. Booth. Crisis Management Strategy:Competition and Change in Modern enterprises [M]. London:T. J. Press Ltd.,1993.
    [185]Ianl.Mitroffl. Managing Crises Before Happen[M]. NewYork:American Management Association,2001.
    [186]Charles F.Hermann(ed.). Intemational Crisis:Insights from Behavioral Research [M]. NewYork:FreePress,1972.
    [187]Uriel Rosenthal & Michael T. Charles (ed.). Coping with Crisis:The Management of Disasters, Riots and Terrorisism[M]. Springfield:Charles C. Thomas.1989.
    [188]Rosenthal, U., Boin, R.A. and Comfort, L. (Eds.) Managing Crises:Threats, Dilemmas and Opportunities[C]. Springfield, IL:Charles C. Thomas.2001.
    [189]Lagadec. Preventing chaos in a crisis:Strategies for prevention control, and damage limitation(J. M. Phelps, Trans) [M]. New York:Mc Graw Hill.1993.
    [190]Gerard J. Hoetmer. and Drabek, Thomas E. Emergency Management:Principles and Practice for Local Government[C]. Washington D. C.:ICMA.1991.
    [191]Patrick Lagadec, Crisis Management in the Twenty-FirstCentury:"Unthinkable" Events in "Inconceivable" Contexts[M].2007,489-508.
    [192]National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States[R].2004:18.
    [193]Perry, R. W. Disaster Exercise Outcomes for Professional Emergency Personnel and Citizen Volunteers[J]. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management,2004,12(2):64-75.
    [194]Younge, P. Exercise Triton 04-Lessons from the UK's Largest Flood Scenario. Blueprint[J]. The Magazine of the Emergency Planning Society, Autumn,2005:10-11.
    [195]Lagadec, P. and Carli, P. Crossing the Rubicon[J].Crisis Response,2005,1(3):39-41
    [196]Kartwz, J. Crisis response planning:Toward a contingent analysis[J]. Journal of the American Planning Association,1985,50(1):9-21.
    [197]Turner, B.1. The role of flexibility and improvisation in emergency response[C]. In T.Horlick-Jones, A. Amendola & R. Casale(Eds.), National risk and civil protection London:Taylor& Francis.1995.
    [198]Tinerney K.,Lindel M., Perry R. Facing the unexpected[M]. Joshph Henry Press,Washington, DC,2001.
    [199]Wengerm D., Quarantelli E. L., Dynes R. Disaster analysis:local emergency management offices and arrangements, Disaster Research Center, University of Delaware, Newark, DE,1986.
    [200]THart,P. Preparing Policy Makers for Crisis Management:TheRole of Simulations[J]. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management,1997,5(4):207-215.
    [201]Auf der Heide, E. Disaster response:principles of preparation and coordination[C]. CV Mosby, St. Louis, MO.1989.
    [202]Scott S. Building organizational resilience potential:An adaptive strategy for operational continuity in crisis[D]. Arizona State University.2007.
    [203]Scott S. Measuring resilience potential:An adaptive strategy for organizational crisis planning[J]. Journal of Contingencies and crisis management,2009,17(1):11-23.
    [204]Sutcliffe, K., Vogus, T. Organizing for resilience[M]. Berrett Koehler Publishers, Inc.2003.
    [205]Godschalk, D.Urban hazards mitigation:Creating resilient cities[J]. Natural Hazards Review,2003,4(3):136-143.
    [206]Beunza, D.,& Stark, D. Survival and sensemaking:Organizational resilience in a Wall Street trading room after 9/11. Barcelona, Spain:Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Department of Economics and Business.2004.
    [207]Freeman, S., Hirschhorn, L., & Maltz, M. Organizational resilience and moral purpose Sandler 0'Neill & Partners in the aftermath of Septemberll,2001[R]. University of Pennsylvania:Graduate Division.School of Arts&Sciences, Center for Organizational Dynamics.2004.
    [208]Kendra, J.,&Wachtendorf, T. Elements of Community resilience in the World Trade Center attack. Newark, DE:University of Deleware, Disaster Research Cernter.2001.
    [209]Geoffrey T. Ramesh Kolluru and Mark Smith. Leverating public-private partnerships to improve community resilience in times of disaster[J]. International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,2009,39(5):343-364.
    [210]Laporte T. The United States Air Traffic Control System:Increasing Reliability in the Midst of Rapid Growth, In Mayntz, R. and Hughes, T. (eds), The Development to Large Technical Systems[M].Westview Press, Boulder, CO,1998,.215-244.
    [211]Rochlin G. Defining'High Reliability'Organizations[C]. In Roberts, K. (ed.), New Challenges to Understanding Organizations, Macmillan, NewYork,1993.11-32.
    [212]Rochlin 0 G., Roberts K., Laporte T. The Self-designing High Reliability Organization: Aircraft Carrier Flight Operations at Sea[J]. Naval War College Review, 1987,40 (4):76-90.
    [213]Weick K., Sutcliffe K., Obstseld D. Organizing For High Reliability:Process of Collective Mindfulness, in Straw, B. and Sutton, R. (eds), Research in Organizational Behavior, JAI Press,Greenwich, CT,81-123.
    [214]Kendra J., WachteneorfT. Elements of Community Resilience in the World Trade Center Attack[R]. University of Deleware, Disaster Research Center, Newark, DE.2001.
    [215]Klein R., Nichool R.,Thomalla F. The Resilience of Coastal Megacities to Weather-Related Hazards:A Review Paper Presented at the Future of Disaster Risk:Building Safer Cities, Washington, DC,2002,December.
    [216]Longstaff P. Security, Resilience, and Communication in Unpredictable Environments Such as Terrorism, Natural Disasters and Complex Technology[D], Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.2005.
    [217]Sheffi, Y. MIT center for transportation and logistics[J].Journal of Commerce,2006, January,1.
    [218]The Agile Supply Chain:Competing in Volatile Markets[J]. Industrial Marketing Management,2000,29(1):37-44.
    [219]Resilience in the Food Chain:A Study of Business Continuity Management in the Food and Drink Industry[R]. Final Report on behalf of the Department for Food and Rural Affairs, July 2006.
    [220]Wildavsky, A. Searching for safety. New Brunswick, NJ,USA;Transaction Publishers.1991.
    [221]Sapountzaki, K. Social resilience to environmental risks[J]. Management of Environmental Quality,2007,18(3):274.
    [222]Hamel G., Valikangas L. The Quest for Resilience[J]Harvard Business Review,2003,81(9): 52-63.
    [223]Horne & Orr J, Assessing Behaviors that Create Resilient Organizations[J]. Employment RelationsToday,1998,24(4):29-39.
    [224]Coutu D. How Resilience Works [J], Harvard Business Review,2002,80(5):46-55.
    [225]Larry A. Mallak. Measuring resilience in health care provider organizations [J]. Health Management.1998,24(4):148-152.
    [226]Weick K E. The collapse of sense making in organizations:the Mann Gulch disaster[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,1993,38(4):628-652.
    [227]Weinberg A., Science and its Limits:The Regulators Dilemma[J]. Issues in Science and Technology,1986,2(1):59-72.
    [228]Maskin E. Nash equilibrium and welfare optimality[J]. Review of Economic Studies,1999,66:23-38.
    [229]Maskin E. Mechanism design:how to implement social goals?Februaty,2008. The article is a revised version of Eric Maskin's Nobel Memorial Price Lecture delivered on December 8,2007 in Stockholm.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700