用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于平衡记分卡的企业战略实施研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
全球化是当前市场竞争的一个显著发展趋势,相比于战略制定,如何开展战略实施,提升企业的国际竞争力就成为了一个更加重要的课题。在复杂多变的环境中,有效的战略执行和实施对维持企业的竞争优势具有十分关键的作用。所以,对战略执行和战略实施的理论进行研究是很有必要的。
     论文全面深入地分析了企业战略实施管理研究与实践现状,研究当前战略实施研究领域的成果与存在的不足,以平衡记分卡为基础理论框架,对企业战略实施管理进行系统分析,确定企业战略实施管理路径。明确平衡记分卡对企业战略管理的适用性及对现行战略实施过程中存在问题的处理,针对建筑施工企业特点对平衡记分卡进行改进,构建五维平衡记分卡,分析基于平衡记分卡的资源配置过程,构建基于平衡记分卡的战略反馈与学习流程。
     针对研究领域中对平衡记分卡因果关系的质疑,本文研究平衡记分卡战略地图的因果逻辑,分析其存在的合理性及其对平衡记分卡应用于战略实施过程的重要意义。研究认为在平衡记分卡中存在基于概率的因果关系。以建筑施工企业为对象,采用结构方程模型对五维平衡记分卡因果关系进行实证分析,研究结果验证了建筑施工企业五维平衡记分卡中存在基于概率的因果关系。
     企业的战略实施离不开资源的支持,本文将企业预算管理与平衡记分卡理论相结合,构建基于平衡记分卡的预算管理框架,以战略预算分配资本预算,以作业预算分配经营预算,构建了整合的预算管理体系。并对企业预算目标确定过程进行博弈分析,为消除企业预算分配过程中的利益博弈给出具体的改进措施。同时,本文研究了企业无形资产对企业战略目标实现的支持作用,从人力资本、信息资本和组织资本三个方面研究无形资产准备度状况,使企业无形资产与企业战略能够协调一致,保证企业战略目标的实现。
     本文研究战略性绩效评价对企业战略实施的意义,分析战略绩效评价指标选择的影响因素,在对各维度指标设计深入分析的基础上,以建筑施工企业为例构建基于平衡记分卡的相互支撑、互为因果、财务与非财务指标相结合、定量指标与定性指标相结合的多层次战略绩效指标体系。针对平衡记分卡没有对企业绩效进行综合评价的缺点,比较不同的绩效评价方法,结合平衡记分卡指标体系的特点,经过综合分析,采用模糊综合评价方法对企业战略实施综合绩效进行整体评价。
A significant trend in the current market competition is Globalization. Compared to Strategy formulation, how to carry out the strategy to enhance the international competitiveness of enterprises has become a more important issue. The strategy implementation is the most important factor which affects the implementation of the strategy and business value in the complex environment. Effective strategy implementation plays a very crucial role to preserve the competitive advantage. Therefore, it is essential to study the theory and practice of the strategy implementation.
     In the paper, the status of the theory and the practices of strategy implementation and the research achievements and shortcomings are analyzed deeply. And then, the strategy implementation management is analyzed based on the framework of the balanced scorecard (BSC) theory, the applicability of BSC for enterprises strategy management is nailed down, the problems in the processes of putting the strategy into action are deal with, and the route is constructed to implement the strategy based on the BSC. A five perspective BSC is built aimed at the charactors in construction enterprises, and a strategy feedback and learning flow is constructed based on BSC.
     Aimed at the questioning to the cause-and-effect relationship of BSC, the causal logic of the balanced scorecard strategy maps is studied, the rationality of the cause-and-effect relationship and the important meaning for application of BSC into strategy implementation are analyzed. The analysis shows that the cause-and-effect relationship is exist based on the probability in BSC. And then, in the paper the five perspective cause-and-effect relationship is analyzed empirically to be existed in construction enterprises based on Structural Equation Modeling.
     Enterprises can not do the strategy without the support of resources. In the paper the budget management is connected with BSC to build a budget management framework. In integrated budget management system, the capital budget is distributed by strategy budget, and the operating budget by the Activity-Based Budgeting. The budget process is analyzed with Game theory. The specific measure is given to eliminate the game in the budget allocation process. At the same time, supporting role of the intangible assets to the strategic objectives is studied in this paper. The strategy readiness is analyzed in three aspects: human capital, information capital and organization capital, so that the intangible assets can be coordinated with the strategy for the strategic objectives’achievement.
     In the paper, the factors are analyzed, which influent the strategic performance evaluation indicators. A multi-level performance indicators system in construction enterprises is designed in which the indicators are mutual supported, interacted with each other, financial indicators are combined with non-financial, quantitative indicators are combined with qualitative indicators. After different performance evaluation methods are analyzed comparatively, aimed at the shortage that the performance cannot be evaluated comprehensively in BSC, fuzzy integrated performance evaluation model is accepted to evaluate the performance of enterprises comprehensively combining the characteristics of balanced scorecard indicators.
引文
1韦华宁.我国企业战略执行现状调查与分析.商业时代[J]. 2005, (20): 33-34
    2 Kaplan R.S. & Norton D.P. The balanced scorecard measures that drive performance. Harvard Business Review[J]. 1992, 70(1): 71-79
    3 Hafeez K., Zhang Y. & Malak N. Determining key capabilities of a firm using analytic hierarchy process. International Journal of Production Economics [J]. 2002, (76): 39-51
    4 Milis & Mercken. The use of the balanced scorecard for the evaluation of information and communication technology projects. International Journal of Project Management[J]. 2004, (22): 87-97
    5 Abran A. & Buglione L. A multidimensional performance model for consolidating balanced scorecards. Advances in Engineering Software[J]. 2003, (34): 339-349
    6 Kaplan R.S. & Norton D.P. Putting the Balanced Scorecard to Work. Harvard Business Review[J]. 1993, (9-10): 71-73
    7 Kaplan R.S. & Norton D.P. Using the Balanced Scorecard as a Strategic Management System. Harvard Business Review[J]. 1996, (1-2): 76-78
    8 Kaplan R.S. & Norton D.P. The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy Balanced Scorecard into Action. Boston: Harvard Business School Press[M], 1996.
    9 Kaplan R.S. & Norton D.P. Having Trouble with Your Strategy? Then Map IT! Harvard Business Review[J]. 2000, (9-10): 167-176
    10 Kaplan R.S. & Norton D.P. The Strategy-Focused Organization: How Balanced scorecard Companies Thrive in the New Business Environment. Boston: Harvard Business School Press[M]. 2001
    11 Kaplan R.S. & Norton D. P. Strategy Maps, Boston: Harvard Business School Press[M]. 2003
    12 Michael E. Porter, From Competitive Advantage to Corporate Strategy, HBR[M]. 1987, (5-6): 43-59
    13 Andrews K. The Corporate Strategy[M], Homewood, Irwin. 1971: 18-46
    14 David J. Collis & Cynthia A. Montgomery, Corporate Strategy: A resource-based view [M]. McGraw- Hill Company. 1998
    15 [美]丹尼尔·A·雷恩.管理思想的演变[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社, 2000: 540-546
    16 Porter M. E. What Is Strategy [J]. Harvard Business Review. 1996, (11-12): 61-78
    17 Goya, Dennis A. & Chittiaeddi. Kumar, Sense-making and sense-giving in strategic change initiation Strategic [J]. Management Journal. 1991, (12): 433-448
    18 Floyd, Steven W. & Lane Peter J. Strategizing throughout the organization: managing role conflict in strategic renewal [J]. Academy of Management Review. 2000, (25): 154-177
    19 R. Charan, C. Colvin. Why CEOs Fail [J]. Forture. 1999, 6(21): 69
    20刘冀生,许宏强.从经济学角度研究企业战略.清华大学学报[J]. 2001, (5): 72-77
    21芮明杰.中国企业发展的战略选择[M].上海:复旦大学出版社. 2000
    22项保华.战略管理——艺术与实务[M].北京:华夏出版社. 2001
    23项保华,叶庆祥.企业竞争优势理论的演变和构建-基于创新视角的整合与拓展.外国经济与管理[J]. 2005, (3): 19-26
    24许惠龙,康荣平,隐形冠军:全球最优秀的公司.管理世界[J]. 2003,(7): 150-152
    25康荣平,柯银斌.格兰仕集团的成长?战略与核心能力.管理世界[J]. 2001, (1): 189-195
    26思先.战略执行与执行力[R].长江商学院内部研究资料.
    27杨林.组织学习?战略调整与企业持续竞争优势.经济经纬[J]. 2008, (1): 101-103
    28周绍朋.企业制定和实施发展战略必须处理好的五个关系.经济管理[J]. 2008, (9): 22-24
    29杨丽,孙国辉, Martin Eppler.战略执行影响因素研究.中央财经大学学报[J]. 2009, (5): 48-52
    30许德音,周长辉.中国战略管理学研究现状评估.管理世界[J]. 2004, (5): 76-87
    31 Paul R. Niven. Balanced scorecard step-by -step [M]. New York: John wiley. 2002
    32于斌,冯林,高向丽.企业战略执行理论研究新趋势.科学学与科学技术管理[J]. 2007, (12): 134-138
    33 Alexandros P. An Integrated Methodology for Putting the Balanced Scorecard into Action. European Management Journa[J]. 2005, 23(2): 214-227
    34 Paula van Veen-dirks, Martin. Wijn. Sstrategic control: meshing critical success factors with the balanced scorecard. Long range planning[J]. 2002, (35): 407-427
    35 Kenneth R. Thompson, Nicholas J. Mathys. The Aligned Balanced Scorecard: An Improved Tool for Building High Performance Organizations. Organizational Dynamics[J]. 2008, 37(4): 378–393
    36 Alan C. Maltz, Aaron J. Shenhar and Richard R. Reilly, Beyond the Balanced Scorecard: Refining the Search for Organizational Success Measures. Long Range Planning[J]. 2003, (36): 187–204
    37 PBM SIG, The performance-based management handbook: Establishing an integrated performance measurement system. http: //www. orau. gov/
    38 Brown M. G, Balbridge award winning quality: How to interpret the malcolm balbridge award criteria [M]. Malwaukee: ASQ Quality Press, 2002: 12-23
    39刘建波.基于平衡记分卡的企业经营绩效管理体系研究.经济师[J]. 2007, (2): 182-183
    40江瑞勇.平衡计分卡与战略执行.财经界[J]. 2006,(6): 49-50
    41 Aaron D. Crabtree , Gerald K. DeBusk, The effects of adopting the Balanced Scorecard on shareholder returns. Advances in Accounting, incorporating Advances in International Accounting[J]. 2008, (24): 8-15
    42张子刚,程志勇.平衡计分卡(BSC)在战略管理中的应用研究.科技管理研究[J]. 2005, (1): 125-128
    43 Kaplan R.S. Norton D.P. Linking the balanced scorecard to strategy. California management Review[J]. Fall. 1996, (b4): 53-79
    44 Norriklit H. The balanced scorecard: a critical analysis of some of its assumption. Management Accounting research[J]. 2000,11(l): 65-68
    45 Atkinson Waterhouse. A stakeholder approach to strategic performance measurement [J]. Sloan manage review. 1997, 38(3): 25-37
    46 Ittner C. Larcker D. Are Nonfinancial Measures Leading Indicators of Financial Performance? An Analysis of Customer Satisfaction Journal of Accounting Research[J]. 1998, 36: 1-35
    47 Margaret A. Abernethy, Malcolm Horne Anne M. Lillis, Mary A. Malina, Frank H. Selto. A multi-method approach to building causal performance maps fromexpert knowledge. Management Accounting Research[J]. 2005,(16): 135-155
    48李延喜,李宁.评价企业战略价值的现金增加值法.中国软科学[J]. 2003, (11): 78-82
    49 Ittner C. & Larcker D. Coming up short on non-fnancial performance measurement. Harvard Business Review[J]. 2003, (11): 88–95
    50 Ittner C. Larcker D. & Randall T. Performance implications of strategic performance measurement in financial services firms. Accounting, Organizations and Societ y [J]. 2003, (28): 715-741
    51 Bernard Wong-On-Wing. Reducing confict in balanced scorecard evaluations. Accounting, Organizations and Societyt[J]. doi: 10.1016/j. aos. 2006, (5): 001
    52 Norriklit H. The balanced scorecard: what is the score? A rhetorical analysis of the balanced scorecard. Accounting, organizations and society[J]. 2003, 28: 591-619
    53 Ittner C.D. and Larcker D.F. Innovations in performance measurement: trends and research implications. Journal of Management Accounting Research[J]. 1998, (10): 205- 239
    54 Olve N.J. Roy and M. Wetter. Performance Drivers: A Practical Guild to Using the Balanced Scorecard[M]. England, John Wiley & Sons Ltd. 1999
    55李延喜,张悦玫,李宁.基于战略地图的战略性绩效评价体系研究.科研管理[J]. 2005, (1): 145-151
    56白胜.平衡计分卡中的因果关系链解析.财会月刊(理论版)[J]. 2008, (6): 36-37
    57 Malina M. Selto F. Causality in Performance Measurement Models, Working paper[M]. Naval Postgraduate School. 2004
    58余泳.战略地图提升绩效驱动力.人力资源管理[J]. 2009, (4): 55-56
    59张悦玫,栾庆伟.基于平衡计分卡的战略实施框架研究.中国软科学[J]. 2003, (2): 86-90
    60 R.S. Kaplan and D.P. Norton. Measuring the strategic readiness of intangible assets[J]. Harvard Business Review, February, 2004: 23-31
    61李东,李庆华,王翔.战略地图的开放结构:链接因素?影响机制和能力分析应用.管理工程学报[J]. 2006, (2): 148-150
    62赵洪磊,吴维库.以平衡计分卡为基础的战略实施研究.商业研究[J]. 2005, (11): 91-94
    63 Russ Banham. Revolution in Planning. CFO[J]. August, 1999
    64 Hackett. Benchmarking Solutions, www. thgi. com, June 14, 2001
    65彭成勤.企业全面预算管理的现状及对策.商业经济[J]. 2009, (4): 51-53
    66 C.Y. Baldwin, K.B. Clark. Capital-Budgeting System and Capabilities Investments in U. S. Companies after the Second World War. Business History Review[J], spring, 1994: 73-109
    67 R.L. Hayes, D.A. Garvin. Managing as if tomorrow mattered. Harvard Business Review[J]. 1986, (5-6): 71-79
    68 Eelke Wiersma. For which purposes do managers use Balanced Scorecards?An empirical study. Management Accounting Research[J]. doi: 10. 1016/j. mar. 2009, (6): 001
    69 Montealegre R. A process model of capability development: lessons from the electronic commerce strategy at bolsa de valodres de guayaquil. Organ Sci[J]. 2002, 13(5): 514-531
    70 R. Zachary Finney, Noel D. Campbell, C. Michael Powell, Strategies and resources: Pathways to success? Journal of Business Research[J]. 2005, (58): 1721-1729
    71 Morgan R.M. Relationship marketing and marketing strategy: the evolution of relationship strategy within the organization. Handbook of Relationship Marketing[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publication], 2000: 481-504
    72 Arbaugh J.B. Reversing the Spirituality Lenses: Challenges and Opportunities for Developing a Spiritual Perspective on Strategy. www. leaderu.com/offices/ ben_arbaugh/ben_arbaughreversing.html. Accessed: October 8, 2003
    73克莱顿.克里斯坦森.资源配置:企业新战略的致使因素. IT时代周刊[J]. 2005, (6): 58
    74 David Wainwright, Teresa Waring. Three domains for implementing integrated information systems: redressing the balance between technology, strategic and organizational analysis. International Journal of Information Management[J]. 2004, (24): 329-346
    75王大震等.成本/时间综合优化网络资源调度策略及价格算法.北京理工大学学报[J]. 2004, (7): 617-619
    76杜义飞等.基于资源交换的战略均衡研究.管理工程学报[J]. 2006, (4): 101-105
    77饶扬德.基于资源整合观的企业战略重构.工业技术经济[J]. 2005, (7): 5-7
    78张鸣.战略管理和作业基础预算研究.财会通讯[J]. 2006, (4): 6-9
    79王晓林.基于战略的预算管理探讨.财会月刊(综合) [J]. 2008, (7): 25-26
    80华琦.平衡记分卡在企业绩效管理中的应用.管理天地[J]. 2006, (12): 170-171
    81殷俊明,王平心.战略导向预算管理的系统观.系统科学学报[J]. 2009, (7): 46-49
    82王贤斌.论无形资产的战略地位及其信息的战略披露.重庆工学院学报[J]. 2006, (3): 68-71
    83董必荣.战略无形资产?商誉与企业持续竞争优势.财会通讯(学术版)[J]. 2006, (9): 8-10
    84 Thomas A. Stewart., Brainpower, Fortune[J]. 1991, (3): 44-48
    85 Thomas A. Stewart. Intellectual capital: The new wealth of organizations. New York. Doubleday, 1998: 67-69
    86 R.S. Kaplan, and D.P. Norton, Measuring the Strategic Readiness of Intangible Assets. Harvard Business Review[J]. 2004, (3): 125
    87 John Bronson, speaking at the balanced scorecard collaborative conference on human capital. Naples, Florida. February 2002: 27
    88 Karen S. Cravens, Elizabeth Goad Oliver. Employees: The key link to corporate reputation management. Business Horizons[J]. 2006,(49): 293-302
    89李丽.平衡记分卡在人力资源部门的应用探讨.财经论坛[J]. 2006, (10): 66-67
    90丁宁宁.企业战略与人力资源协同的分类和比较分析.技术经济与管理研究[J]. 2007, (3): 42-43
    91刘俊勇.人力资本准备度的衡量与提升.首席财务官[J]. 2007, (3): 95
    92刘俊勇.“战略伞”下的信息资本.首席财务官[J]. 2006, (4): 86
    93 Peter Weill, Marianne Broadbent. Leveraging the New Infrastructure: How Market Leaders Capitalize on the new information technology[M]. Boston, Harvard Buisiness School Press 2000
    94沈波.企业信息资源配置与企业绩效——基于协同与战略的研究视角.情报理论与实践[J]. 2008, (4): 535-538
    95 C. O’Chatman, D. Caldwell. People and organizational culture: A profile compareison to assessing person-organization fit. Acacemy of management journal[J]. 1991, 9: 487-516
    96 Peter Senge. The fifth discipleine: The art and practice of the learning organization. Doubleday, 1991: 235
    97毛建军,武德昆,高俊山.组织学习能力与企业绩效关系实证研究.北京科技大学学报[J]. 2008,(7) : 820-836
    98 D. Garvin, A. March. Anote on knowledge management. Harvard Business Review[J]. 1997, 11: 396-431
    99 Braam G. Nijssen E. 2004. Performance effects of using the balanced scorecard: a note on the Dutch experience. Long Range Planning[J]. 2004, 37 (4): 335-349
    100 Prajogo D. Sohal A. The multidimensionality of TQM practices in determining quality and innovation performance—an empirical examination. Technovation [J]. 2004, 6(24): 443-453
    101贺颖奇,陈佳俊.企业战略控制与业绩评价.中国审计[J]. 2004, 16: 63
    102 Nilsson, Owe N. Control System in Multibusiness Companies: From Performance Management to Strategic Management. European Management Journal[J]. 2001,(19): 344-358
    103瞿燕舞,华志忠,马剑虹.战略导向的概念?先行因素及其绩效影响机制研究综述.管理学报[J]. 2009, (3): 420-425
    104邱洋,易树平,周成刚.基于战略的绩效管理研究与应用.价值工程[J]. 2008, (8): 121-123
    105孙世敏,贾春香.基于价值创造的企业战略绩效评价体系的构建.财务研究[J]. 2005, (10): 52-54
    106 Banker R.D. Chang H. Janakiraman S.N. & Konstans C. A balanced scorecard analysis of performance metrics. European Journal of Operational Research[J]. 2004, (154): 423-436
    107 Milis K. & Mercken R. The use of the balanced scorecard for the evaluation of information and communication technology projects. International Journal of Project Management[J]. 2004, (22): 87-97
    108 Alain Abran, Luigi Buglione. A multidimensional performance model for consolidating Balanced Scorecards. Advances in Engineering Software[J]. 2003, (34): 339-349
    109 Mary A. Malina, Frank H. Selto. Choice and change of measures in performance measurement models. Management Accounting Research[J]. 2004, (15): 441-469
    110郑敏芝,宋延军.战略性绩效管理:组织发展的推进器.技术经济与管理研究[J]. 2009, (3): 63-66
    111张悦玫,李延喜,栾庆伟.战略性绩效评价模型的创建及评价实现.管理科学[J]. 2004, (12): 2-9
    112王化成,刘俊勇.企业业绩评价模式研究—兼论中国企业业绩评价模式选择.管理世界[J]. 2004, (4): 82-91
    113 A. Needly, C. Adams, M. Kennerley. The scorecard for measuring and managing business success. Person Education Limited[M]. 2002
    114颜志刚.超越平衡计分卡的探索:业绩三棱镜与动态多维业绩框架.财会通讯[J]. 2004, (5): 25-28
    115 Marshall W. Mayer.绩效测量反思-超越平衡记分卡.机械工业出版社[M], 2005: 6
    116刘亦晴,杨静.基于活动的盈利能力分析方法研究.商业时代[J]. 2006, (22): 41-42
    117 Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton. Transforming the balanced scorecard from performance measurement to strategic management. Accounting Horizons[J]. 2001, 15(1): 87-104Nohria N. & Berkley J. An Action Perspective: The Crux of the New Management. California Management Review[J], Summer. 1994: 70-92
    119 Braam, G., Nijssen E. Performance effects of using the balanced scorecard: a note on the Dutch experience. Long Range Planning[J]. 2004, 37(4): 335–349
    120贺颖奇,陈佳俊.企业战略控制与业绩评价.中国审计[J]. 2004, (16): 63-65
    121 Nilsson, Owe N. Control System in Multibusiness Companies: From Performance Management to Strategic Management. European Management Journal[J]. 2001, (19): 344-358
    122 Berg, N. The allocation of strategic funds in a large diversified industrial company[M]. Boston: Harvard Business School Press,1963
    123 Cyert, R.M., March, J.G. A behavioral theory of the firm[M]. New York: Prentice Hall, 1963
    124 Ackerman, R.W. Influence of integration and diversity on the investment process[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly. 1968, 15(8): 341-351
    125 Bower, J.L., Doz,Y. Resource allocation: a social and political process[J]. Strategic Management. 1978, 65(5): 25-66
    126 Aharoni,Y. The foreign investment process[M]. Boston:Harvard Business School Press. 1966C. Argyris. Teaching Smart People How to Learn. Harvard Business Review[J], May-June 1991: 99-109
    128 H. Mintzberg. Crafting Strategy. Harvard Business Review[J]. July-August, 1987: 66-75
    129项宝华.战略管理—艺术与实务.北京:华夏出版社[M], 2001罗素.西方哲学史(下).商务印书馆[M]. 1996: 201
    131 Magretta. Why business models matter. Harvard Business Review[J]. 2002, (5): 80-85
    132 De Hass, M, Kleingeld, A. Multilevel design if performance measurement system: enhancing strategic dialogue throughout the organization. Management Accounting Research[J]. 1999, (10): 233-261Robert Kaplan, David Norton, Linking the balanced scorecard to strategy. California Management Review[J], Fall, 4: 53-79
    134 Reichheld, F. F. and Sasser, W. E. Zero defections: quality comes to services. Harvard Business Review[J]. September October, 1990: 105-111Turney, P. Activity-Based Management: Making the Investment in Quality Count. American Accounting Association, Albuquerque, New Mexico. 1992
    136孔茨.管理学[M].机械工业出版社, 2000: 104
    137 Teemu Malmimj. Bananced scorecards in finnish companies: A research note. Management accounting research[J]. 2001, 12(2)侯杰泰,温忠麟等.结构方程模型及其应用[M].教育科学出版社, 2007
    139李怀祖.管理研究方法论[M].西安:西安交通大学出版社, 2004
    140 Richard A. Johnson, Dean W. Wichern.实用多元统计分析[M].北京:清华大学出版社, 2003
    141 Guieford, J. P. Fundamental Statistics in Psychology and Education[M]. New York: McGraw- Hill. 1965Hope, J. & Fraser, R. Who needs budgets? Harvard Business Review[J]. 2003: 108-115
    143杰里米·霍普,罗宾·弗雷泽著.胡金涛译.超越预算:管理者如何跳出年度绩效评估的陷阱[M].北京:中信出版社, 2005
    144 SHRM/Balanced Scorecard Collaborative. Aligning HR With Organization[J] Strategy Survey Research Study July 2002: 62-67
    145于增彪,袁光华,刘桂英,邢如其.关于集团公司预算管理系统的框架研究[J].会计研究. 2004, (8): 22-29安东尼,戈文达拉扬.管理控制系统[M].北京:机械工业出版社, 1999
    147汪家常,韩伟伟.战略预算管理问题研究.管理世界[J]. 2002,(5): 137-138
    148 Stephen C. Hansen, David T. Otley, Wim A. Van Der Stede. PracticeDevelopment in Budgeting: An Overview and Research Perspective[J]. Journal of Management Accounting Research. 2003, (15): 95-116殷俊明.平衡计分卡研究述评.科技管理研究[J]. 2005, (3): 44-48
    150高伟明,马笑渊.预算博弈以及对策分析.财政研究[J]. 2004, (4)
    151蔡靓萌,陈佳鹏.基于博弈的企业全面预算框架分析.市场论坛[J]. 2009, (7): 43-45
    152 Peter Weill and Marianne Broadbent. Leveraging the New Infrastructure: How Market Leaders Capitalize on the New Information Technology. Boston: Harvard Business School Press[M], 2000C. O’Reilly, J. Chatman, and D. Caldwell. People and Organizational Culture: A Profile Comparison to Assessing Person-Organization Fit. Academy of Management Journal[J]. 1991, (9): 235-238
    154徐永智,华惠川.对主成分分析三点不足的改进.科技管理研究[J]. 2009, (6): 128-130
    155陈培友,李星.模糊综合评判算法的改进.黑龙江科技学院学报[J]. 2006, (6): 396-399
    156陈通,王伟.基于模糊平衡计分卡的绩效评估体系研究.西安电子科技大学学报[J]. 2007, (1): 29-33

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700