用户名: 密码: 验证码:
大型活动安全风险模糊评价方法及预警管理系统设计
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
近年来大型活动的数量、规模、国际化程度呈逐年上升态势,但据我国公安机关安全检查情况调查,62%的大型活动存在各种安全问题。举办大型活动具有人群聚集、情况复杂的特点,容易产生安全隐患和管理上的疏漏,极易导致灾难性事故的发生。因此,进行大型活动安全风险与预警的研究是非常及时、重要和有意义的。本研究依托国家科技支撑“十一五”计划《社会治安风险、动态预警技术研究》课题,在对大型活动风险因素评价的基础上建立预警系统,旨在为大型活动的管理者及时快速地提供决策依据,有效地预防大型活动事故发生。
     本研究主要介绍了研究背景及意义,提出了研究内容,确定了研究方法与技术路线。针对国内外大型活动场所风险管理研究现状,重点分析了国内外大型活动、风险评价和预警理论与方法的研究现状。基于机理分析方法论的大型活动风险分析,从原则性机理、原理性机理、流程性机理和操作性机理的不同层次对典型的大型活动中容易出现的突发灾难性事件进行了全新的剖析,在此基础之上进行梳理归纳,把影响大型活动安全的风险因素分为活动本身、人、物和环境四个部分,并结合突发事件的原理性机理和流程性机理进行详细说明。探讨了模糊网络分析法及其应用。大型活动是一个复杂巨系统,具有风险因素众多、各因素间关联性强的特点。针对此特点,探索性地提出了将模糊层次分析方法(F—AHP)中的利用模糊数学原理来进行判断矩阵“模糊化”的思想在网络分析方法(ANP)中延续,实施模糊网络分析方法(F—ANP)对大型活动进行风险评价,同时提出采用模糊三角数与网络分析相结合的方法,对大型活动预警中的若干可监控的指标进行分析评价。进行了面向大型活动的预警系统设计。通过对监控与启动机制流程进行研究,建立了一套针对大型活动不同事故类型的分类启动体系;针对大型活动的特殊性从预警的对象、范围、功能模块、内容方面提出了预警系统的模型;给出预警系统的构成,对预警对策系统进行更深一步的研究。为验证自建指标体系与评价方法的科学性与可行性,选取三个有代表性的大型活动进行实证研究。论文最后总结本研究的成果,并提出需要进一步改进、深化的主要问题。
Along with the rising of quantity, scale and degree of internationalization of Large-scale activities in recent years, 62% of these activities have security problems, according to the safety inspection of Ministry of Public Security. Due to the crowded site and complex situation, there are potential security risks and negligence in Safety Management, leading to catastrophic accidents and bringing irreparable damage or death. It is timely, important and meaningful to study assessment and early warning systems of Large-scale activities. This research derives from the national Eleventh Five-year project Study on the Risk Warning Technology for Social Security. In the research, an early warning system is given based on assessment of risk factors, and should be able to effectively curb the high trend of the occurrence of catastrophic incidents.
     This research introduces the background, significance, research method and technological design of the research. It focuses on the current status of research home and abroad on the theory and practice of Large-scale activities, their risk assessment and early warning. The typical catastrophic accidents are analyzed based on rule, principle, optimization, and operation mechanism analysis methodology. The impact of Large-scale activities risk factors are divided into four groups: activity factors, human factors, material factors and environmental factors. A new approach based on Fuzzy Analytical Network Hierarchical for establishment of an analytical risk assessment model to evaluate the risk index is proposed, for Large-scale activities are characterized by the complex giant system, Large number of risk factors and inter-dependence among factors. Based on fuzzy Analytical Network Hierarchical Processing method, some monitoring indicators of early warning system are given and calculated with analysis. A set of classifying system is established based on the research of monitoring and initiating process. An early warning system is designed according to the subject, area, function modules, content of Large-scale activity. Besides, the composition of the early warning system is given for further research on the early warning strategy. Three cases were selected to do empirical research in order to verify the validity and feasibility of the indicator system. Finally, the dissertation summarizes the findings of the research and poses some areas for further improvement and exploration.
引文
[1]李超等.大型社会活动项目管理手册.北京:科技出版社,2005
    [2] Nelson H E,Maclennan H A.Emergency Movement,SFPE Handbook of fire Protection Engineering.NFPA Quincy MA,USA,1988,(21)
    [3] Z.fang.On the relationship between crowd density and movement velocity . firesafety juronal 1998,(21)
    [4]邓明艳.论大型节庆活动与宁波旅游发展.宁波大学学报(人文科学版), 2002,(12)
    [5]李力,崔卫华.城市旅游节庆的构成要素及牵动效应.安全,1999,(12)
    [6]朱佩军.大力开发我国“节庆”和“节文化”旅游资源.渝州大学学报,1998, (15)
    [7]赵睿.通过节庆活动激发太原旅游活力.]沧桑.200l,(24)
    [8]任常兴,吴宗之.城市公共场所人群拥挤踩踏事故分析.北京:中国安全科学学报,2005,15(12),102-106
    [9]王起全,金龙哲,向衍荪.大型公共活动风险控制研究与分析.北京:中国安全科学学报,2007,l-4
    [10]吴晓智,徐强.大型活动的安全风险分析.应用基础与工程科学学报,2006, 14
    [11]叶明海,嵇方.大型社会活动安全事故成因分析及预警组织模型构建.灾害学,2006,21-56
    [12]胡志莹,叶明海.大型社会活动人群拥挤事故防范系统研究.灾害学,2006, 2l
    [13]孙超,吴宗之.公共场所踩踏事故分析.安全,2007,l,ll-16
    [14]田玉敏.人群疏散中“非适应性”行为研究.灾害学,2006,(21)
    [15] C.B.Chapman.Risk analysis for large projects:model,method and cases.England publishing,l986.23-25
    [16]牛晓霞.车站、机场、码头火灾风险管理定量方法的研究.安全科学,2001, (12)
    [17]郑双中.城市建筑火灾分析.安全科学,2002,(23)
    [18]战俊红,张晓辉.中国公共安全管理概论.北京:当代中国出版社.2007
    [19] A.Charnes,W.W.Cooper,E.Rhodes.Measuring the efficiency of decision making units.European Journal of operational Research,1978,2:429-444.
    [20]朱乔,数据包络分析(DEA)方法综述与展望.系统工程理论方法应用,1994, 3(4):1-9.
    [21]魏权龄.评价相对有效性的DEA方法一运筹学的新领域.北京:中国人民大学出版社,1988.
    [22] Zhu Qiao.DEA: a review and vision for future research.Systems Engineering-Theory Methodology Application,1994,4:1-9.
    [23] L.M.Seiford,Thrall R.M. Recent development in DEA : the mathematical programming approach to frontier analysis.Journal of Econometrics,1990, 46(1-2):(Oct-Nov)7-38.
    [24] L.M.Seiford. Data Envelopment Analysis :the evolution of state of the art (1978-1995) .Journal of Production Analysis,1996,7:99-137.
    [25] L.M.Seiford . A DEA biolography (1978一1994)in data envelopment analysis : theory ,methodology and applications.A.Charnes,W.W.Cooper, ete(editor).Boston : Kluwer Academic Publishers ,1994.
    [26]王斌等.模糊DEA方法及在相对经济效益评价中的应用.青岛建筑工程学报, 1997,18(1):74-78.
    [27]李光金等.具有三角模糊要素的DEA模型.系统工程学报,1996,11(4):37一44.
    [28]杨印生等.机遇Fuzzy集理论的数据包络分析模型.见:第二届全国模糊分析设计学术交流会论文集,1993:009一066.
    [29]杨印生,李树根.灰色DEA方法及其在方案评价中的应用.技术经济,1992(6).
    [30] A.Charnes.Compositive Data Envelopment Analysis and Multi-objeetive Programming.In :The University of Texas at Austin,Center for Cybemetic Studies RePort,CCS,1988,
    [31]李树根等.Banach空间的DEA模型.东北运筹学与应用数学.大连:大连理工大学出版社,1996.
    [32]段永瑞.数据包络分析一理论和应用.上海:上海科学普及出版社,2006.
    [33]李树根,扬印生. DEA有效决策单元集合的结构.吉林工业大学学报,1991, (3):1-4.
    [34]冯俊文.C2R和C2GS2的DEA有效性问题.系统工程与电子技术,1994,(7):42-51.
    [35] A.Charnes,L.Neralic . Sensitivity Analysis of the Additive Model in DEA .European Journal of Operational Research,1990,48(7):332-341.
    [36]杨印生等.带有参数的C2R模型的灵敏度分析.系统工程与电子技术, 1997, (12):59-62.
    [37] B.Golany.An Interactive MOLP Precedure for the Extension of DEA to Effectiveness Analysis .Journal of the Operational Research Society, 1988;(39):725-734.
    [38]朱乔,陈遥.一种预测的新方法.数理统计与管理,1991,(6).
    [39]唐小丽,冯俊文. ANP原理及其应用展望.统计与决策2006.
    [40] T.L.Saaty. Proceedings of The fifth International Symposium on The Analytic Hierarchy Process, ISAHP’99,Kobe JAPAN
    [41]许树柏.层次分析原理.天津:天津大学出版社1988.
    [42]王莲芬,许树柏.层次分析法引论.北京:中国人民大学1990.
    [43]懂劭忱,刘茂.城市公共安全预警系统的初步探讨.城市公共安全,2005年,78-81.
    [44]嵇方.会展活动安全事故成因分析及预警模型研究.同济大学硕士论文,2007.
    [45] Tae Yoon,Kying Joo Oh,Insuk Sohn,Changha Huang.Usefulness of artificial nural networks for early warning system of economic crisis.Exper System With Applica- tions.2004.
    [46] Liu,S.;Lindholm,C.K..Assessing early warning signals of currency crises :a fuzzy clustering approach.International Journal of Intelligent Systems in Accounting ,Finance and Management,2006,14(4):179-202.
    [47] Manetsch,T.J..An approach to early warning of slowly evolving crises with reference to food shortage forecasting.IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man and Cybernetics,1984,14(3):391-397.
    [48] IIIS;IEEE Comput.Soc.;IOHE;Bytes For All;Integrated Tech. SolutionsLtd.PISTA'03.International Conference on Politics and Information Syst- ems :Technologies and Applications,2003.Orlando,FL, USA,International Inst.of Informatics and Systemics,2004.
    [49] Maeda,Y.;Kurita,N.;Ikeda,S..Lecture Notes in Computer Science,v 4012 LNAI,New Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence-Joint JSAI2005 Workshop Post-Proceedings,2006:446-457.
    [50] Tung,W.L.;Quek,C.;Cheng,P..GenSo-EWS:a novel neural-fuzzy based early warning system for predicting bank failures.Neural Networks,2004, 17(4):567-587.
    [51] Canbas,S.;Cabuk,A.;Kilic,S.B..Prediction of commercial bank failure via multivariate statistical analysis of financial structures :The Turkish case.European Journal of Operational Research,2005,16(2):528-546.
    [52] IEEE;ICIC Int.;National Natural Sci.Found.of China;Beijing Jiaotong Univ.; Kaosiung Univ. of Appl. Sci.First International Conference on Innovative Computing,Information and Control,2006.Los Alamitos,CA,USA,IEEE Comput.Soc,2006.
    [53]王静敏,张平.我国失业保障监测预警指标体系的构建.吉林省经济管理干部学院学报.2006,6:3-5.
    [54]苏博,刘鲁,方锋锋.基于逐步回归的中国粮食价格预警研究.企业经济.2006,1:131-133.
    [55]夏丽华,王芳,王德辉.基于MODIS数据的城市光化学污染预警系统及预警等级研究.地理科学.2006,26(6):712-716.
    [56]宇仁德,田启华,祁素升.基于GIS的城市交通安全预警系统.交通与计算机. 2006,24(6):95-98.
    [57]李明.城市房地产预警技术研究.数理统计与管理.2006,25(3):315-320.
    [58]佘廉.灾害预警管理丛书.石家庄:河北科学技术出版社,2003.
    [59]李锦生.基于社会经济协调发展的消费预警研究.学术交流.2006, 10:120-123.
    [60]兰徐民,温勇,潘金洪.人口安全预警指标体系及其量化探讨.西北人口.2006,6:41-45.
    [61]迟春洁.能源安全预警研究.理论新探.2006,22:29-31.
    [62]李志强,詹锋,周丽琴.基于BP网络算法的区域协调发展预测与预警研究.统计研究.2006,4:24-26.
    [63]黄媛,杨建思.用于地震预警系统中的快速地震定位方法综述.国际地震动态.2006,12:l-4.
    [64]江春发,王仁谦.用GIS技术建立台风跟踪预警系统.用GIS技术建立台风跟踪预警系统.2003,24(l):60-63.
    [65]肖宏斌,李有宏,王青川,李海红.青海省泥石流预警模型.气象科技.2006, 34(6):754-757.
    [66]顾乾屏,张程,张颖,陈顺发.分区域的企业财务危机预警模型比较研究.山西财经大学学报.2006,28(6):127-132.
    [67]黄德忠,陈晋.企业资产风险预警系统研究.财会通讯(理财版).2006,11: 28-30.
    [68]庞建敏.企业信用风险度量和预警决策支持系统研究.金融研究.2006,3: 111-117.
    [69]蒋元涛.基于现金流量的投资企业财务风险预警分析.财贸研究.2005,4:84-87.
    [70]杨孝伟.对企业人才流失预警指标体系及运行模式的探究.集团经济研究. 2006,5:197-198.
    [71]李蔚.工业企业营销安全预警指标体系的理论研究.中国工业经济.2002,8: 87-93.
    [72]张红梅.移动客户离网率分析及预警系统的设计与实现.桂林电子工业学院学报.2003,23(3):14-17.
    [73]黄继鸿,雷战波,凌超.经济预警方法研究综述.系统工程,2003,21(2): 64-70.
    [74] Engel . R . F . Autoregressive Conditional Hetereskedasticity With Estimates of Variance od U.K. Inflation.Econometrica,1982(50):987-1008.
    [75] Juliane Yim ,Healther Mitichell. Comparision of Country Risk Models : hybrid neural netwoks,logit models,discriminant analysis and cluster techniques.Expert Systems With Applications,2005 (28):137-148.
    [76]邢武晋.一种宏观经济监测预警系统的开发.系统工程,1998,16(06):20-23.
    [77]王慧敏.自回归条件异方差模型在宏观经济预警中的应用.运筹与管理, 1998,7(04): 58-61.
    [78]俞欢军,王建成,胡上序.基于概率模式识别方法的宏观经济预警系统的进一步研究.系统工程理论与实践,1999(09):42-48.
    [79]陈安.应急管理的机理体系.安全.2007,06.P10-P12.
    [80]亓菁晶,陈安.突发事件与应急管理的机理体系.中国科学院院刊.2009,03.
    [81]吕浩,王超.重大突发事件的扩散机理研究.武汉理工大学学报(信息与管理工程版).2006,09.P7-P10.
    [82]王超,佘廉.水运交通灾害的致灾机理及其对策研究.珠江水运.2004, 5.P19-P20.
    [83]陈安,陈宁,倪慧荟等.现代应急管理——理论与方法.北京:2009.
    [84]祝江斌,王超,冯斌.城市重大突发事件扩散的微观机理研究.武汉理工大学学报(社会科学版).2006,10.P710-P713.
    [85]张庆云,陶诗言,彭京备.我国灾害性天气气候事件成因机理的研究进展.大气科学.2008,7.P815-P825.
    [86]李铁,蔡美峰.地震诱发煤矿瓦斯灾害成核机理的探讨.煤炭学报.2008, 10.P1112-P1116.
    [87]吴国斌,钱刚毅,雷丽萍.突发公共事件扩散影响因素及其关系探析.武汉理工大学学报(社会科学版).2008,8.P465-P469.
    [88]孙宏才,田平.网络层次分析法(ANP)与科学决策.决策科学理论与方法.2003
    [89]常大勇,张丽丽.经济管理中的模糊数学方法.北京:北京经济学院出版社, 1995.
    [90] T.L.Saaty. Fundamentals of The Analytic Network Process.Dependence and Feedback in Decision-making with A Single Network.2004
    [91]李海凌.模糊综合评价在工程项目风险评价中的应用研究.西华大学学报(自然科学版)2005.
    [92]邱东.多指标综合评价方法的系统分析.中国统计出版社.1991
    [93]冯俊文.模糊德尔菲层次分析法及其应用.数学的实践与认识.2006
    [94]曹纯.模糊AHP中权重向量的一种新算法.西北民族学院学报(自然科学版). 1999
    [95]杨艺.城市消防预警系统的模糊综合评价方法研究.计算机科学.2005
    [96]王超,樊宏烨.我国危机预警方法研究现状评析.交通企业管理.2005,12:6-7.
    [97] Sinha, A. P., & May, J. H. (2005). Evaluating and tuning predictive data mining models using receiver operating characteristic curves. Journal of Management Information Systems, 21(3), 249–280.
    [98] Witten, I. H., & Frank, E. (2005). Data mining: practical machine learning tools and techniques (2nd ed.). San Francisco, CA: Morgan Kaufman.
    [99] Zhao, H. (2008). Instance weighting versus threshold adjusting for cost-sensitive classification. Knowledge and information systems.doi:10.1007/s10115-007-007 9 -1.
    [100] Ryu, Y. U., & Yue, W. T. (2005). Firm bankruptcy prediction: Experimental comparison of isotonic separation and other classification approaches. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Part A, 35(5), 727–737.
    [101]Pompe, P. P. M., & Bilderbeek, J. (2005). Bankruptcy prediction: the influence of the year prior to failure selected for model building and the effects in a period of economic decline. International Journal of Intelligent Systems in Accounting, Finance and Management, 13(2), 95–112.
    [102]Gudmundsson and Eliasson, 2007, Economic Challenges Ahead: A Cooldown But No. Meltdown.LandsbankiResearch.http://www.landsbanki.is/Uploads /documents /070605_macro_outlook.pdf.
    [103] Ergungor, E., Thompson, James, 2005. Systemic banking crises. Policy Discussion Papers. Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, Number 9, February 2005.
    [104] Davis, E.P., Zhu, H., 2005. Commercial property prices and bank performance. BIS Working Paper No 175.
    [105]Craig, R.S., Davis, E.P., Garcia, A, 2005. Sources of procyclicality in East Asian financial systems. In: Gerlach, S., Gruenwald, P. (Eds.), Procyclicality of Financial Systems in Asia. Palgrave McMillan.
    [106] Chan, Nicholas, Getmansky, Mila, Haas, Shane M., Lo, Andrew, 2006. Systemic risk and hedge funds. In: Carey, M., Stulz, R. (Eds.), The Risks of Financial Institutions. University of Chicago Press, pp. 235–330.
    [107] Berg, Andrew, Borensztein, Eduardo, Pattillo, Catherine, 2004. Assessing early warning systems: how have they worked in practice? IMF Working Paper, WP/04/52. International Monetary Fund, Washington.
    [108] Huang WC, Chou CC. Drought early warning system in reservoir operation: Theory and practice. Water Resour Res 2005;41. doi:10.1029/2004WR003830. W11406.
    [109] Fabbrocino G, Iervolino I, Orlando F, Salzano E. Quantitative risk analysis of oil storage facilities, in seismic areas. J Hazard Mater 2005;12:361–9.
    [110] Talaslidis DG, Manolis GD, Paraskevopoulos E, Panagiotopoulos C, Pelekasis N, Tsampoulos JA. Risk analysis of industrial structures under extreme transient loads. Soil Dyn Earthquake Eng 2004;24:435–48.
    [111] Salzano E, Di Carluccio A, Garcia Agreda A, Fabbrocino G, Manfredi G, The interaction of earthquakes with process equipment in the framework of risk assessment. In: Proceedings of the 41st annual loss prevention symposium, American Institute of Chemical Engineers, 2007 Spring National Meeting. Houston, TX, 2007. p. 122–37.
    [112] Antonioni G, Spadoni G, Cozzani V. A methodology for the quantitative risk assessment of major accidents triggered by seismic events. J Hazard Mater2007;147:48–59.
    [113] Campedel M, Cozzani V, Garcia-Agreda A, Salzano E. Extending the quantitative assessment of industrial risks to earthquake effects. Risk Anal 2008;28:1231–46.
    [114]Cho, H.-N., Choi, H.-H., Kim, Y.-B., 2002. A risk assessment methodology for incorporating uncertainties using fuzzy concepts. Reliability Engineering &System Safety 78 (2), 173–183.
    [115]Dokas, I.M., Nordlander, T.E., Wallace, R.J., 2007. Fuzzy fault tree representation and maintenance based on frames and constraint technologies: a case study. In: Proceedings K-CAP’07 Workshop on Knowledge Capture and Constraint Programming, October 28–31, 2007, Whistler, British Columbia, Canada.
    [116]Fleming, G., Van der Merwe, M., McFerren, G., 2007. Fuzzy expert systems and GIS for cholera health risk prediction in southern Africa. Environmental Modelling & Software 22 (4), 442–448.
    [117]Iliadis, L.S., 2005. A decision support system applying an integrated fuzzy model for long-term forest fire risk estimation. Environmental Modelling & Software 20 (5), 613–621.
    [118]Lei, Z., Yamada, Y., Huang, J., Xi, Y., 2006. Intelligent early-warning support system for enterprise financial crisis based on case-based reasoning. Journal of Systems Science and Complexity 19 (4), 538–546.
    [119]Berg, A., & Pattillo, C. (1999). Predicting currency crises: The indicators approach and an alternative. Journal of International Money and Finance, 18, 561 ?586.
    [120]Bussière, M., & Fratzscher,M. (2002). Towards a new early warning system of financial crises. European Central Bank Working Paper, 02/145. Available at www.ecb.int.
    [121]Fuertes, A. M., & Kalotychou, E. (2004). Towards the optimal design of an early warning system for sovereign debt crises, EMGWorking Paper 04-04. Available at www.cass.city.ac.uk/emg
    [122] Dirk Glaesser.Crisis Management in The Tourism Industry.Butterworth Heinemann,2003:41-57.
    [123] Ryan .Crime Violence , terrorism and tourism.Tourism management , 1993 , June : 173-83.
    [124] W.Adams. whose lives count?: TV coverage of natural disasters.Journal of Communication, 1986,36:113-22.
    [125] Tversky, Kahnemann. Judgment under uncertainty : Heuristics and biases. Science , Vol.185, 1974:1124-1131.
    [126] Joan.C.Henderson. Communicating in a Crisis: Fight SQ 006.Tourism Management ,2003,24:279–287.
    [128]周民.我国应对突发公共事件预案体系基本形成.中国个体防护装备,2004, 6,7-8.
    [129]佘从国,席酉民.我国企业预警研究理论综述.工业企业管理,2003,5,23-30.
    [130]王洪波,宋国良.风险预警机制.北京,经济管理出版社,2002.10
    [131] [美]罗伯特·希斯,危机管理.北京:中信出版社,2004.
    [132]陈宝智.安全原理第二版.北京:冶金出版社, 2002.
    [133]罗云,宫运华.安全生产预警技术研究.安全,2005 ,3.
    [134] Nicholas JiBahr. System Safety Engineering and Risk Assessment : A PracticalApproach[R]. Washington , DC: Hernandez Engineering Inc , 1997:230.
    [135]佟瑞鹏,吴宗之.大型社会活动风险管理及网络模型的构建.见:国际安全科学与技术学术研讨会会议文集
    [136]佟瑞鹏,吴宗之,王起全.大型群众性活动风险评价指标及控制对策研究.应用基础与工程科学学报,2006,14
    [137]孙超,任彦斌.大型群众性活动人群管理控制.中国职业安全健康协会2006年学术年会论文集,2006,5
    [138]叶明海,嵇方.大型群众性活动人员流动管理模型研究.同济大学学报, 2006,17
    [139]木村清.公共场所的事故预防.2001年中日产业安全研讨会论文集
    [140]佟瑞鹏,冯志斌.关于大型群众性活动事故预防与控制的探讨.见:中国职业安全健康协会2006年学术年会论文集,2006,5
    [141]冯志斌,孙超.大型社会经营活动安全问题探讨.中国安全科学学报,2006, 16
    [142]林志伟.浅议大型群众性活动的道路交通管理.治安防范,2005
    [143]姜传胜,李伟,杨铸.重视步行人流组织,评估疏散安全能力,确保大型活动人员安全-从疏散安全角度解读《北京市大型群众性活动安全管理条例》
    [144]张维平.关于突发公共事件预警管理系统活动内容和方法.应急救援,2006, 6
    [145]付岩.旅游节庆活动的危机预警系统构建.[学位论文],2005,12
    [146]张青松,刘茂,赵国敏.改进的疏散时间计算模型在奥运赛场中的应用.2007, 9
    [147]金磊.前车之鉴乃后事之师—中外长大赛事及历届奥运会的事故灾难与安全对策.北京规划建设,2003 (2);25-28
    [148]《大型群众性活动事故预防与控制对策研究及其应用技术报告》
    [149]杨霞.大型群众性活动安全管理存在的问题及对策.北京人民替察学院学报, 2005, 7(4):24-26
    [150]北京市公园风景名胜区安全管理规范.北京市人民政府.2005,01,24
    [151]北京市大型群众性活动安全管理条例.北京市人民政府,2004,01
    [152]夏保成,西方公共安全管理.北京:化学工业出版社安全科学与工程出版中心,2006年6月,第一版
    [153]王振海,陈洪泉.城市公告安全管理-以青岛为个案的分析.青岛:中国海洋大学出版社,2005,6
    [154]中国灾害预防协会,市民公告安全应急指南.北京:北京大学出版社,2006
    [155]陈之昌,刘舒.首都社会安全研究报告2006.北京:同心出版社,2006
    [156]贾征,刘化杰.社区治安与综合治理.北京:中国社会出版社,2005
    [157]“城市典型公共场所环境安全隐患评价技术及控制对策研究”通过了成果鉴定验收,2004年25卷2期《安全》起止页码:43-43
    [158]董杰等.北京2008年奥运会对突发事件的风险管理
    [159]周勇等.大型体育活动应对突发公共事件的干预与对策研究
    [160]艾德春.我国煤炭供需平衡的预测预警研究[学位论文].中国矿业大学,2008.
    [161]柴建设等.北京大型体育赛事突发事件及应急处理
    [162]张青松等.体育赛场人群疏散过程滞留人数定量模型研究
    [163]刘强等.运动场馆人流疏散及其模型探讨
    [164]戎明彦.奥运会体育场馆聚集人群及其疏散风险的研究
    [165]冯志斌等.大型社会经营活动的安全管理构想
    [166]吴娇蓉等.大型活动广场访客聚集行为控制指标研究
    [167]林丽君.美国大型活动的安全保卫计划
    [168]Jeremy Larken, Practical emergency management
    [169]Jelisaveta Muskatirovic, Public safety-Warning systems and emergency action plans
    [170]Federal Role in the Security of Religious Venues In America.美国政府科技报告(NTIS)索取号:ADA445404/XAB
    [171]Emergency Responder Guidelines, August 1, 2002.美国政府科技报告(NTIS)原始索取号:PB2002-109008/XAB
    [172]Matthews, J.RAMSES: decision-aid for the security of the 1992 Winter Olympic Games
    [173]Olympic Security: U.S. Support to Athens Games Provides Lessons for Future Olympics.美国政府科技报告(NTIS)索取号:PB2005-106874/XAB
    [174]Quick-Reaction Report on DoD Support for the 1996 Paralympics and Centennial Olympic Games.美国政府科技报告(NTIS)原始索取号: ADA370819/XAB
    [175]Wen Tang;Tao Ruan Wan;Patel, S.Crowd Behavior, Crowd Control, and the Use of Non-Lethal Weapons.
    [176]pan, t. j.Real-time crowd movement on large scale terrains
    [177]NATO, Greece and the 2004 Summer Olympics.美国政府科技报告(NTIS)原始索取号:ADA429691/XAB
    [178]Musse, S.R.;Thalmann, D.Hierarchical model for real time simulation of virtual human crowds
    [179] Spearpoint M,The effect of pre-evacuation distributions on evacuation times in the simulex model.Journal of Fire Protection Engineering, 2004, 14: 12~14
    [180] Togawa K,Study of Fire Escapes Basing on the Observations of Multiple Currents .Tokyo: Report No·14, Building Research Institute, Ministry ofConstruction,Japan,1995
    [181]Pauls J L, Effective width model for evacuation flow in buildings .Proceedings of Workshop on Engineering Applications of Fire Technology .National Bureau of Slandards, 1980. 215~232
    [182] Predtechensk VM, Milinsk A I. Planning for Foot Traffic Flow in Buildings . New Delhi: Amerind Publishing,1978
    [183] Fruin J. Pedestrian Planning and Design . The Metropolitan Association of Urban Designers and Environmental Planners. NewYork, 1971
    [184] Stahl F. BFIRES II: A Behavior-based Computer Simulation of Emergency Egress During Fires . Fire Technology, 1982, 18(1): 49~65
    [185] Poyner B, Robinson D, Hughes N, et al. Safety in Football Stadia: A Method of Assessment .London:Scicon Scientific Control Systems Limited, 1972
    [186] Purser D A, Bensilum M. Quantification of behaviour for engineering design standards and escape time calculationsm.Safety Science, 2001, 26, 157~182

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700