用户名: 密码: 验证码:
期货交易风险管理决策模型研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
期货交易作为一种现代投资手段,对经济的发展日益起着重要的作用。随之产生的风险成为投资者不得不面临的问题。如何尽可能地降低期货交易产生的风险,以获取最大的利润,成为值得广泛关注的研究内容。
     文章的主要工作表现在以下几个方面:
     第一,以条件风险价值(CVaR)为风险计量指标,测定期货风险的价值。其一,根据CVaR风险评估对波动性的要求,采用GARCH模型,解决期货合约波动率的聚集效应、厚尾效应和时变方差效应,同时,通过加入GED分布,有效地提高了预测结果的准确度。其二,SV模型对金融市场收益率分布也有着较好的刻画能力,本研究采用马尔科夫链蒙特卡洛模拟的极大似然法,估计SV模型的参数,并计算了沪铜的CVaR值,结果表明,SV模拟能够很好地反映沪铜的风险水平。
     第二,采用VaR技术计算保证金。所不同的是,用蒙特卡罗模拟解决传统VaR模型对价格波动极端状况时的低估问题,同时用EGARCH模型估计波动性和用t分布代替正态分布,提高蒙特卡洛模拟法计算VaR的准确性。根据对上海期货交易所铜期货保证金水平的实证结果,模拟的保证金算法能够适应铜期货合约风险管理的需求,保证金水平反映了市场风险状况,有效的降低了投资者交易成本。
     第三,分别构建了GARCH-X模型和DC-MSV模型来预测动态套期保值比率。GARCH-X套期保值模型在二元GARCH模型中添加了误差矫正项,考虑了短期收益率的波动对条件方差和协方差的影响,更好的预测了收益率波动的变化,提高了套期保值的准确性。DC-MSV模型反映了推动资产价格波动因素的有效信息,更加完整的估计资产收益的交叉相关性,得到的最小方差时变套期比更加精确的反映资产价格的波动变化。
As a modern investment means, future transaction plays important role in economic development day by day. Therefore emerged risk becomes the question that investors have to face. How to reduce the risk of future transaction as much as possible, making the most profit, has been a research contents worthing wide attention.
     The main work includes following several parts:
     Firstly, taking conditional value at risk(CVaR) as risk measure index, measuring value at risk of futures. According to the requirements of CVaR risk measuring to volatility, using GARCH model, solving agglomerative effect、Fat-Tail effect and time-varying variance effect of futures volatility. Through adding GED distribution, improving accuracy of prediction results effectively. SV model has good ability to characterize financial return distribution, the paper adopt maximum likelihood method of markov chain-monte carlo simulation, estimating parameters of SV model, and calculate the CVaR value of Shanghai copper, the results showed that SV model can reflect risk level of Shanghai copper effectively.
     Secondly, calculate margin using VaR model. Differently, adopt Monte Carlo simulation method to solve the question that VaR model underestimate price volatility in extreme situation, using EGARCH model estimate volatility and using t-distribution instead of normal distribution, improving the accuracy of VaR in the method of Monte Carlo. According to the empirical results of margin level of Shanghai copper, the method can meet the demand of copper future risk management, margin level reflects market risk situation, reducing the cost of future transaction.
     Thirdly, separately construct GARCH-X and DC-MSV model to forecast dynamic hedging ratio. Through introducing error correction term, considering the effect of spot price fluctuation to future price, building dynamic hedging model based on bivariate GARCH model. DC-MSV reveals the valid information of the factors which drive the price fluctuation of assets, and fully estimates the cross correlativity of price fluctuation of assets, the time-varying hedging ratio can reflect fluctuation of asset price more precise.
引文
[1]中国期货业协会,期货市场教程[M],中国财政经济出版社,2001
    [2]约翰·赫尔.期权、期货和其他衍生产品(第三版)[M],华夏出版社,1999
    [3]Markowits MH.Portfolio selection[J].Journal of Finance,1954,7:77-91.
    [4]Sharp W.Capital asset price:a theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk[J].Journal of Finance,1964,19:425-442.
    [5]Linter J.The valuation of risk assets and the selection of risky investment in stock portfolios and capital budgets[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1965,47:13-37.
    [6]Jorion P.Value at Risk:The New Benchmark for ConLrollinn Market Risk[M].New York:The Mc Graw-Hill Companies Inc.
    [7]徐元铖 国外风险价值模型研究现状 外国经济与管理 2005年6月 p44-51
    [8]Ederington,L1 H1 The Hedging Performance of the New Futures Market s[J].Journal of Finance,1979,(34):157-1701
    [9]Lien,D1,& Luo,X1 Estimating multiperiod hedge ratios in cointegrated market s[J]1 Journal of Futures Market s,1993,(13):909-9201
    [10]Ghosh,A1 Hedging with stock index futures:Estimation and forecasting with error correction modell[J]Journal of Futures Market s,1993,(13):743-7521
    [11]Chou,W1 L1,Fan,K1 K1,& Lee,C1 F1 Hedging with the Nikkei index futures:The conventional model versus the error correction model[J]1 Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,1993,(36):495-5051
    [12]Fama E F.The behavior of stock market prices[J].Journal of Business.1965(38):34-105.
    [13]Hagerman R L.Notes:More evidence return on the distribution of security[J].Journal of Finance.1978(33):1213-1221
    [14]Basel Committee on Banking Supervision the International convergence of capital measurement and capital standards:arevised framework[S],http://www.bis.org,2004:44-69.
    [15]Allen M.Building a Role Model.Risk,1994,(7):73-80
    [16]David Li.Value at Risk Based On the Volatility,Skeweness and Kurtosis,www.Gloriatnundi.Org
    [17]Kevin Dowd.Financial Management[J].Financial Analysts Journal 1999,7/8:65-75
    [18]Penza P,Bansal V K.Measuring Market Risk with Value at Risk.New York:John Whey and Sons,Inc,2001
    [19]Rachel Campbell,Ronald Huisman,Kees Koedijk.Optimal portfolio selection in a Value-at-Risk framework.Journal of Banking&Finance,2001,(25):1789-1804
    [20]Christoffersen P.F.,Errunza V.R..Towards a global financial architecture:capital mobility and risk management.Emerging Market Review,2000,(1):2-19
    [21]Bollerslev T.Generalised autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticy.Journal of Econometrics,1986,(31):307-327.
    [22]Nelson D.B..Conditional heteroscedasticity in asset returns:a new approach.Econometrica,1991,(2):347-370
    [23]郑文通.金融风险管理的VaR方法及其应用.国际金融研究,1997,(9):58-62
    [24]姚刚.风险值测定法浅析.经济科学,1998,(1):55-60
    [25]叶青.基于GARCH和半参数法的VaR模型及其在中国股市风险分析中的应用.统计研究,2000,(12):25-29
    [26]马超群等.风险价值的完全参数方法及其在金融市场风险管理中的应用.系统工程理论与实践,2001,(4):34-37
    [27]陈守东,俞世典.基于GARCH模型的VaR方法对中国股市的分析.吉林大学社会科学学报,2002,(4):11-17
    [28]刘宇飞.VaR模型及其在金融监管中的应用.经济科学,1999,(1):39-50
    [29]戴国强,徐龙炳,陆蓉.VaR方法对我国金融风险管理的借鉴及应用.金融研究,2000,(7):25-28
    [30]王春峰,金融市场风险管理[M].天津:天津大学出版社,2001
    [31]李亚静,朱宏泉,何跃.基于VaR的风险分析理论和计算方法[J].预测.2000,5.36-39
    [32]田新时,刘汉中,李耀.沪深股市一般误差分布((GED)下的VaR计算[J].管理工程学报.2003,17(1).25-28.
    [33]杨晓光,马超群,文风华.VaR之下厚尾分布的最优资产组合的收敛性.管理科学学报.2002,5(1).65-68
    [34]范英.VaR方法及其在股市风险分析中的应用初探[J].中国管理科学,2000:8(3)p26-32.
    [35]Manganelli,S and Engle,R F.Value at risk models in Finance[R].European Central Bank Working Paper,2001,75:64-78.
    [36]Beder T.,(1995).VaR's seductive but dangerous[J],Financial Analysts Journal,51:PP12-24.
    [37]Dave,R.and G.Stahl,(1997).On the Accuracy of VaR Estimatcs Based on the Variance-Covariance Approach,http://222.olsen.ch/research
    [38]Crnkovic,C.and J.Drachman,(1995).A Universal Tool to Discriminate Among Risk Management Techniques,Corporate Risk Management,J.P.Morgan.
    [39]Artzner P,Delbaen F,Eber J H,Heah D.Thinking coherently.Risk,1997,(10):33-49
    [40]Artzner P,Delbaen F,Eber J H,Heah D.Coherent Measure of Risk.Mathematical Finance,1999,(3):203-228
    [41]Frittelli,Rosazza Gianin.Putting order in risk measures.In:Szego,G(Ed),"Beyond VaR"(special issue).Journal of Banking&Finance,2002,(6):372-379
    [42]Giorgio S.Measure of Risk.Journal of Banking & Finance,2002,(26):1253-1272
    [43]Beder T.S...VaR:Seductive but dangerous.Financial Analysts Journal,Capital Market Risk Advisors,Inc,1995,12-14
    [44]Rockafeller R.T.,Uryasev S..Optimization of Conditional Value-at-Risk.The Journal of Risk,2000,(3):21-41
    [45]Rockafeller R.T.,Uryasev S...Conditional Value-at-Risk for General Loss Distributions.Journal of Banking and Finance,2001,(7):1443-1471
    [46]Uryasev S.Conditional value-at-risk:optimization algorithm and applications.Financial Engineering News,2000,(3):1-5
    [47]Jonas Palmquist,Stanislav Uryasev,Pavlo Krokhmal.Portfolip Optimization with Conditional Value-at-Risk Objective and Constraints.http://www.ise.ufl.edu/uryasev.1999
    [48]Alexander G.J.,Baptista A.M..Economic Implcations for Using a Mean-VaR Model for Portfolio Selection:A Comparison with Mean-Variance Analysis.Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control.2002,(26):1159-1193
    [49]Fredrik Anderson,Helmut Mausser,Dan Rosen,Stanislav Uryasev.Credit Risk Optimizaion with Conditional Value-at-Risk Criterion.Mathematical Progaram,2001,(89):273-291
    [50]陈金龙,张维.CVaR与投资组合优化统一模型[J].系统工程理论方法应用,2002,(01)
    [51]林辉,何建敏.VaR在投资组合应用中存在的缺陷与C VaR模型.财贸经济,2003,(12).46-49[36]
    [52]岳瑞锋,李振东,杨晓萍.风险管理的CVaR方法及其简化模型.河北省科学院学报,2003,(3):134-138
    [53]刘小茂,李楚霖,王建华.风险资产组合的均值—CVaR有效前沿(Ⅰ).管理工程学报,2003,(1):29-33
    [54]田新民,黄海平.基于条件VaR(CVaR)的投资组合优化模型及比较研究.管理工程学报,2004,(7):41-50
    [55]王树娟,黄渝祥.基于GARCH-CVaR模型的我国股票市场风险分析.同济大学学报自然科学版,2005,(2):121-124
    [56]Bernanke B.Clearing and settlement during the crash[C].Rev.Financial Study,1990,3(1):1332151.
    [57]鲍建平.国内外期货市场保证金制度比较研究及其启示[J].世界经济,2004,(12).
    [58]鲍建平,王乃生,吴冲锋.上海期铜保证金水平设计的实证研究[J].系统工程理论方法应用,2005,(01)
    [59]迟国泰,刘轶芳,冯敬海.基于牛顿插值原理的期货价格波动函数及保证金随动模型[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2005,(03).
    [60]Bernanke B.Clearing and settlement during the crash[C].Rev.Financial Stud,1990,3(1):133-151.
    [61]Figlewski S.Hedging performance and basic risk in stock index futures.The Journal of Finance.1984,39:657-670.
    [62]L.Ederington.The Hedging Performance of the New Futures Markets.Journal Of Finance.1979,34(1).
    [63]Y W Cheung,K S Lai.A Fractional Cointegration A-nalysis of Purchasing Power Parity.Journal ofBusiness and Economic Statistics.1993,11(1):103-112.
    [64]Lien D,Tse Y K,Albert K C.Evaluating the Hedging performance of the constant correlation GARCH model.Applied Financial Economics.2002,(12):791-798.
    [65]Lawrence Galitz.Financial Engineering Tools and Techniques to Manage Financial Risk[C].Pitman Publishing,1994.
    [66]Kathryn D.M.Determination of The Recommended Hedging Ratio.American Journal of Agricultural Economics.1983,(65):603-605.
    [67]Howard C T,D'Antonio L J.A risk-return measure ofhedging effectiveness.Journal of Financial and Quan-titative Analysis.1984,(19):101-112.
    [68]Hsin C W,Kuo J,Lee C F.Anewmeasure to compare thehedging effectiveness of foreign currency futures versus op-tions.Journal of Futures Markets,1994,(14):685-707.
    [69]Shalit H.Mean-gini hedging in futures markets.Jour-nal of Futures Markets.1995,(15):617-635.
    [70]Cecchetti S G,Cumby R E,Figleski S.Estimation of the optimal futures hedge.Review of Economics and Statistics,The.1988,70(4):623-630.
    [71]Sergio H.L.Market crashes and informational avalanches.Review of economic studies.1996,65(4):741-759.
    [72]Robert A.C.Optimal replication of contingent claims under transaction costs[J].Review of Futures Markets.2000.(8):222-239.
    [73]聂永红,林孝贵,黄定谋.二重套期保值策略软件的设计与实现[J].广西科学院学报,2004,(03)
    [74]Donald L,Soojong K.Provisional liquidation of fut-tures hedge programs[J].Energy Economics,2006,(28):266-273.
    [75]Jean P.L.Huyen P.Financial Engineering Tools and Techniques to Manage Financial Risk[C].Pitman Publishing,1996.
    [76]Sheng-Syan Chen.Hedging effectiveness of currency option and currency futures.The Journal of Futures Markets,2003,6:289-305.
    [77]Basle Committee on Banking Supervision.An Internal Model-Baded Approach to Market Risk Capital Requirements.http://www.bis.org
    [78]王春峰.金融市场风险管理.第一版.天津:天津大学出版社,2001
    [79]罗开位,侯振挺,李致中.期权定价理论的产生与发展[J].系统工程,2000,(06).
    [80]Nolan,J.P.Stable Distributions:Models for Heavy Tailed Data.Springer Verlag,2005.
    [81]Tang.Shieh.A strategy for acquiringcustomer requirement patterns using laddering technique andART2 neural network.Advanced Engineering Informatics.2006,16(3):229-240.
    [82]So,Yu.Optimal replication of contingent claims under transaction costs[J].Review of Futures Markets,2006,(8):222-239.
    [83]Chen,So.Exponential hedging and entropic penalties[J].Math.Finance,2006,(12):99-123.
    [84]Wu,Shieh.A PDE representation of the density of the minimal entropy martingale measure in stochastic volatility markets[J].Pure Mathematics,2006,(5):1-21.
    [85]Danielsson,Zigrand.What Happens When You Regulate Risk? Evidence from a Simple Equilibrium Model[J].Math.Finance,2006,(12):99-123.
    [86]Sullivan,Stoumbos,Brooks.Optimal replication of contingent claims under transaction costs[J].Rev Fut Markets,2005,(8):222-239.
    [87]Bekiros,Georgoutsos.Conditional value-at-risk:optimization algorithms and applications.Financial Engineering News,2005,2(3 Issue14):1-5.
    [88]Khindanova,Rachev,Schwartz.Beyond VaR.from measuring risk to managing risk[J].ALGO Research Quarterly,2001,1(2):5 20.
    [89]Bams,Lehnert,Wolff.The Microstructure Approach to Exchange Rate.Cambridge and London:MIT Press,2005,.
    [90]Tezuka,Murata,Tanaka,Yumae.On the Measurement of the International Propagation of Shocks.NBER Working Paper,2005,No.7354.
    [91]Panigirtzoglou,Skiadopoulos.Autoregressive modeling and money-income causality detection.Journal of Monetary Economics,2004,7:85106.
    [92]Aguilar,Nydahl.Optimization of conditional value-at-risk.Journal of Risk,2000,2(3):21-24.
    [93]Cochrane JH.Production-based asset pricing and the link between stock returns and the economic fluctuations.Journal of Finance,The.2002,(46):209-237.
    [94]刘国旗.非线性GARCH模型在中国股市波动预测中的应用研究[J].统计研究,2000,(01)
    [95]陈泽中,李锋,杨启智.中国股票市场的ARCH效应研究[J].浙江统计,2000,(04)
    [96]惠晓峰,柳鸿生,胡伟,何丹青.基于时间序列GARCH模型的人民币汇率预测[J].金融研究,2003,(05)
    [97]任兆璋,宁忠忠.人民币汇率预期与人民币NDF汇率的实证研究[J].学术研究,2005,(12)
    [98]戴晓枫,肖庆宪.时间序列分析方法及人民币汇率预测的应用研究[J].上海理工大学学报,2005,(04)
    [99]李凯,张稳瑜.基于ARCH族高频日汇率波动的实证分析[J].现代管理科学,2005,(03)
    [100]李文浩.2007年欧元区经济综述[J]南方金融,2008,(01).
    [101]Black F,Scholes M.The Pricing of option liabilities of Political Economy[J].1973,15(4):637-659.
    [102]Campbell R,Huisman R,Koedijk K.Optimal portfolio selection in a Value-at -Risk framework.Journal of Banking & Finance.2001,25.
    [103]Kupiec Paul H.Techniques for verifying the accuracy of risk measurement models.Journal of Derivatives.1995,3(2):73-84.
    [104]刘庆富,仲伟俊,华仁海,刘晓星.EGARCH-GED模型在计量中国期货市场风险价值中的应用[J].管理工程学报,2007,(01).
    [105]张跃军,范英,魏一鸣.基于GED—GARCH模型的中国原油价格波动特征研究[J].数理统计与管理,2007,(03).
    [106]李付军.SV-GED模型在中国股市的VaR与ES度量及分析[J].系统工程理论方法应用,2006,(01).
    [107]田晓兰,柳金甫.基于GED的混合ARCH模型[J].北京交通大学学报,2007,(03).
    [108]Rockafellar R T.Convex Analysis.Princeton,NJ:Princeton Univ Press,1970,.
    [109]French,K.R.,and Roll,R.Stock return variance:thearrival of information and the reaction of traders[J].Jour-nal of financial economics,1986,(17):5-26.
    [110]Kupiec Paul H.Techniques for verifying the accuracy of risk measurement models.Journal of Derivatives.1995,3(2):73-84.
    [111]Kim S,Shephard N,Clib S.Stochastic volatility:likelihoodinference and comparison with ARCH models.Review ofEconomic Studies.1998,65:361-393.
    [112]Sandmann G,Koopman S J.Estimation of stochastic vola-tility models via Monte Carlo maximum likelihood.Jour-nal of Econometrics.1998,87:271-301.
    [113]Heynen R,Kemna A,Vorst T.Analysis of the term struc-ture of implied volatilities.Journal of Financial andQuantitative Analysis.1994,29(1):31-56.
    [114]Taylor S T.Modeling financial time series.New York:John Wiley&Sons Ltd,1986,183-195.
    [115]Nakatsmna T.Bayesian Analysis of ARMA-GARCH Models:A Markov Chain Sampling Approach[J].Rutgers University,2000.
    [116]Luc Bauwens,Michel Lubrano.Bayesian Inference on GARCH Models Using the Gibbs Sampler[J].Econometrics Journal,1998,(1).
    [117]Kupiec P H,White A P.Regulatory competition and efficncy of alternative derivative product marging systems.Journal of Futures Markets,1996,16:943968.
    [118]Fenn G D,Kupiec P.Prudent margin policy in a futures style settlement system.Journal of Futures Markets,1993,13:389-408.
    [119]Gay G D,Hunter W C,Kolb R W.A comparative analysis of futures contract margins.Journal of Futures Markets,1986,15:805-831.
    [120]Chung Y P.A Transactions Data Test of Stock Index Futures Market Efficiency and Index Arbitrage Profitability.Journal of Finance,The.1991,46(5):1791-1809.
    [121]Roll R.A mean/variance analysis of tracking error[J].Journal of Portfolio Management,1992,18(4):13-22.
    [122]Rudolf M,Wolter H J,Zimmernann H.A linear model for tracking error minimization [J].Journal of Banking&Finance,1999,23(1):85-103.
    [123]Markowitz.H.M.Portfolio Selection.Journal of Finance,1952,(12):151-158.
    [124]邹安华.商品期货套期保值交易策略的实证研究[D].武汉大学,2005.
    [125]杜承栎.最优套期保值比率确定模型研究[D].西南财经大学,2007.
    [126]丁飞鹏.最优套期保值比率[D].华中师范大学,2007.
    [127]王玉刚.基于非线性组合的最小方差套期保值模型研究[D].大连理工大学,2006.
    [128]Johnson.The theory of hedging and speculation in commodity futures[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1960,27(3):139-151.
    [129]Stein J L.The simultaneous determination of spot and futures price.American Economic Review,1961,51:1012-1025.
    [130]W.Tong.An Examination Of Dynamic Hedging.Journal Of International Money AndFinance.1996,15:19-35.
    [131]Cecchetti S G,Cumby R E,Figleski S.Estimation of the optimal futures hedge.Review of Economics and Statistics,The.1988,70(4):623-630.
    [132]Dickey,Fuller.Likelihood Ratio Statistics for Autoregressive Time Series With A Unit Root.Econometrica,1981,49(3):355-367.
    [133]Koutmos,G.,and Booth,G.G.Asymmetric volatility transmis-sion in international stock markets [J].Journal of InternationalMoney and Finance,1995,14(6):747-762.
    [134]Miyakoshi,T.Spillovers of stock return volatility to Asian equity markets from Japan and US.International Financial Markets,Institutions&Money.2003,:13.
    [135]Theo Nijman and Enrique Sentana.Marginalization and contemporaneous aggregation in multivariate GARCH processes.Journal of Econometrics,1996,71(1-2):71-87.
    [136]Johansen,S.,and Juselius,K.Maximum Likelihood Estimation and Inference on Cointegration—With Applications to the Demand for Money[J].Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics.1990,52:169-210.
    [137]Jun Yu.Multivariate stochastic volatility models:Bayesian estimation and model comparison[J].Econometric Reviews,2006,25(2-3):361-384.
    [138]欧祖军.基于Bayes方法的非参数估计[D].东南大学,2005.
    [139]Gerlach.R,Tuyl.F.MCMC methods for comparing stochastic volatility and GARCH models[J].International Journal of Forecasting,2006,22:91-107.
    [140]余素红,张世英,宋军.基于GARCH模型和SV模型的VaR比较[J].管理科学学报,2004,7(5):61-66.
    [141]Cecchetti,S.G.,Cumby,R.E.,and Figlewski,S.Estimation of the Optimal Futures Hedge[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1988,70(4):623-630.
    [142]Baillie,R.,Myers,R.Bivariate GARCH estimation of the optimal commodity futures hedge[J].Journal of Applied Econometrics,1991,6(3):109-124.
    [143]Gerlach.R,Tuyl.F.MCMC methods for comparing stochastic volatility and GARCH models[J].International Journal of Forecasting,2006,22:91-107.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700