用户名: 密码: 验证码:
新闻语篇中的隐性评价与动态读者定位
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
新闻语篇为了保持其“客观性”和“公正性”的准则,常常将修辞手段和意识形态隐藏起来,形成一种隐性的、动态的评价模式,巧妙地引导读者接受作者的价值定位,即所谓的“狗哨”策略。本研究的出发点是新闻语篇是一种价值负载的,由意识形态决定的,并潜在影响读者世界观和信仰的语篇。而在读者的价值和信仰系统“自然化”过程中起重要作用的修辞手段是评价。
     根据刘(2007)的观点,语言具有两种基本功能:描写功能和评价功能。评价功能是语言的一个重要特征,是作者或说话者表达态度的重要手段。综观评价的研究领域,不同学者从不同的视角对评价进行了探讨。他们分别从叙事结构、哲学角度、语用学、语法、系统功能、基于语料库等方面对评价做了大量的研究,提出了同评价相关的概念或术语。但这些研究都是趋于静态的,且都不是针对特定的机构语篇和考虑语境的。
     本文的研究目的是为了更好地理解英语新闻的特性,提出关于当代英语“硬新闻”中评价资源的分析框架,并应用到具体的语篇分析。分析框架主要建立在评价理论(Appraisal Theory)的基础上,突出评价的语篇语境,包括局部词汇一语法语境、局部摘引语境和整体语篇语境的相互作用。分析从话语发生和动态的角度出发,重点放在对语篇的整体“评价渠”的建构。语篇语境和评价的构成条件可以揭示动态读者定位。
     新闻报道的“客观性”准则需要新闻作者隐性地表达自己的观点。隐性评价策略通常是依赖语境的,需要分析者采取动态的观点。本文提出的分析框架从微观到宏观层面上对语境中的评价进行分析。在微观层面,主要分析在局部词汇语法和语义语境以及摘引语境中的评价手段和评价的韵律性特征。首先,评价可以大体分为三个基本层面:评价种类,评价模式和评价负载。评价种类依据评价理论框架(Appraisal Framework)分为三类:情感,判断和鉴别。评价模式涉及的是外显价值(inscribed values)和诱发价值(evoked values),即态度外显(attitudinalinscriptions)和态度标记(attitudinal tokens);其中态度标记又可以细分为唤起(evocation)和激发(provocation)。评价负载指的是评价价值可以是肯定的或否定的,高兴的或不高兴的,满意的或不满意的等等这种对比。在英语新闻语篇中,新闻作者常借助局部词汇语法语境中的态度标记即唤起和激发等评价手段来表达自己的态度和观点。这些评价手段具体细分为:通过信息内容唤起评价;通过类比或比喻激发评价;通过反预期激发评价;强化;通过所指激发评价;通过认知情态化激发评价;态度联想;主格和受格。这些隐性的评价手段常常是依赖语境的,在语境中动态地引导读者理解语篇中间接的评价意义。总之,微观层面的分析突出了评价的词汇—语法语境,探讨了语境和评价之间的互相作用。
     局部摘引语境中的评价属于分析框架中微观层面的另一个组成部分。声音价值作为新闻作者的评价策略可以从两个层面来分析:评价负载和评价方式。评价负载指新闻作者对价值定位的依附与偏离。评价方式涉及摘引评价的种类,评价的直接性与评价责任的关系。Sinclair(1986)区分了自言和摘引,指出摘引行为即是评价行为。摘引由三个部分组成:声音来源,摘引表达和被引内容。新闻语篇中摘引通常行使三种隐性评价功能:作者认同、作者疏远和言据信誉。这三种评价功能分别通过摘引的三个组成部分的相互作用表现出来。在评价方式层面,评价可根据不同的摘引语境区分为直接评价话语和报告性评价话语,其中报告性评价话语又可以分为不同的子类型,这些子类型区分了不同的评价来源和评价目标,反映了新闻作者的隐性评价策略,表明评价责任从作者向读者的逐渐转移。
     对评价采取动态的观点需要从话语发生的角度进行分析。对评价策略在整体语篇语境中的分析构成本框架的宏观层面。这一层面的分析从整体语篇语境出发,从阶段(phase)和进程(stage)入手,分析新闻语篇的“评价渠”(evaluativegroove)和语篇价值(text'S axiology),探讨评价手段是怎样在语篇语境的影响下,建构间接的评价意义和动态地定位读者。
     总体来说,本文的理论基础为系统功能语言学(SFL)中的评价理论(AppraisalTheory),并吸取了关于互文性研究,Macken-Horirak(2003)语境中的评价理论模式,White(2006)关于新闻语篇中评价手段研究和Wortham and Locher(1996)提出的“腹语手段”的精髓。
     本文所选语料来自the Times,the Daily Telegraph,the Guardian等大幅报纸的新闻专页和CBS、CNN等在线网上新闻。语境中的动态评价模式为新闻报道中的评价提供了更全面、更系统化的理论阐释,使读者对新闻语篇的“客观性”得到更深刻的理解。分析框架蕴含了对评价分析观点的转变:需要动态的观点。传统的批评性语篇分析忽视动态读者定位的研究,语境中的评价模式可以更好地揭示意识形态定位的动态性过程。
In order to preserve the professional norm of "objectivity",news writers often employ the implicit evaluative strategies in the news text,which position the readers in a subtle and dynamic way.This is the so-called "dog-whistle" politics.The starting point for this dissertation is the view that,contrary to any claims to 'objectivity' on the part of the media industry,news reporting is a mode of rhetoric in the broadest sense of the word.It is a value-laden,ideologically determined discourse with a clear potential to influence the media audience's assumptions and beliefs about the way the world is and the way it ought to be.A key aspect of this rhetorical and ultimately ideological functionality is evaluation.
     According to Liu(2007),there are two levels of meaning functioning in discourse:descriptive and evaluative,and evaluation is an important feature of language.A literature review of evaluation reveals that some related notions to evaluation have been conducted from different perspectives such as narratological approach,philosophical approach,pragmatic approach,grammatical approach, systemic-functional approach etc.But these approaches are rather static and none of them is institution-specific and context sensitive.The purpose of the thesis is to provide a descriptive framework of evaluation in hard news reports and sets about the applications of the framework to discourse analysis in order to develop new insights into the nature of the contemporary,English-language 'broadsheets'.The framework is based on Appraisal Theory and puts the textual context into the foreground.It focuses on the interplaying of the evaluative devices with the local lexico-grammatical context,the attributing context and the global textual context.The analysis is taken from the logogenetic and the dynamic perspective,with the focus on the cumulative build-up of the evaluative meanings which creates a global evaluative groove.The considerations of the textual context and the conditioning environments of the evaluation are significant in illuminating the dynamic reader positioning.
     The 'trope' of objectivity of news reports requires the journalistic author's implicit point of view.Implicit evaluative devices employed by the writer are usually text dependent,the analysis of which requires a dynamic perspective from the analysts.The analytical framework proposed by the thesis conducts the analysis from the micro-to-macro level.At the micro-analytical level,the analysis focuses on the evaluative mechanisms in local lexico-grammatical context and attributing context which realize the prosodic evaluative meanings.Evaluation can be conducted on three dimensions:the category of attitude,the mode of evaluation and the loading of evaluation.The category of attitude includes affect,judgement and appreciation;the mode of evaluation is a distinction between inscribed values and evoked values or attitudinal inscriptions and attitudinal tokens;the loading of evaluation is construed by the positive or negative evaluative values including happy or unhappy,satisfied or unsatisfied,etc.In journalistic discourse,a significant part of the evaluative loading is carried out by indirect mechanisms(including evocations and provocations)in local lexico-grammatical context which serve to guide,prime and condition readers to respond to the depicted events in positive or negative terms.They include evocation via informational content,provocation via analogy or metaphor,provocation via counter-expectancy,intensification,provocation via reference and predication, provocation via epistemic modalization,attitudinal associations,and affectedness and agency,etc.In the analysis,the local textual environment of the implicit evaluative strategies is put into foreground and the interplaying of attitudinal markers in local context is explored.
     The local attributing context constitutes the other part of the micro-level analytical framework.Two dimensions are distinguished in analysis of the voicing values as evaluative strategies by the news reporter:the loading of evaluation and the mode of evaluation.On the dimension of the loading of evaluation,positive or negative evaluations are reflected in terms of the alignment or disalignment of the news reporter to the reported value position.On the dimension of the mode of evaluation,it is indicated that a clear relationship exists between types of evaluative utterances,kinds of quotations,and their evaluative function in media discourse. Sinclair(1986)distinguishes averral and attribution and points out the evaluative nature of attribution.Attribution consists of three parts:the source of voice,the attributing expressions and the attributed proposition.They often combine together and interact with one another to perform the implicit evaluative functions of authorial endorsement,authorial distancing and evidential standing.On the dimension of the mode of evaluation,attribution can be divided into Direct Evaluative Utterances (DEU)and Reported Evaluative Utterances(REU)according to the different attributing contexts.The Reported Evaluative Utterances can also be divided into different sub-types according to different evaluative sources and targets.This division and classification reflects the shifting of the responsibility of evaluation and displays a dynamic reader positioning.
     The dynamic perspective requires a logogenetic and more global view of the operation of evaluative mechanisms,which constitutes the macro-analytical-level.At this level,attending to the global context,the thesis explores the meta-relations of phases and stages which are set up within the local context(both lexico-grammatical and attributing)by which the instantial text's axiology or the evaluative groove is construed and the reader is positioned dynamically by a relational reading.
     The framework is based on the Appraisal Theory which is developed broadly within the theoretical framework of SFL and draws inspirations from the study of intertextuality,Macken-Horirak's(2003)model of contextual Appraisal,White's (2006)framework of evaluative semantics in media discourse and Wortham and Locher's(1996)"ventriloquating techniques".The texts are types which frequently occur in the news coverage(as opposed to the commentaries,columns and editorial) of the so-called 'broadsheet' or 'highbrow' media.The tiles are the Times,the Guardian,the Daily Telegraph and CBS,CNN online news.The main contributions of the dissertation are firstly to set up a descriptive framework which provides fuller and more theoretically principled accounts of the evaluative aspect of news reporting.It adjusts our view towards the so-called 'objective' hard news or the discourse of reporter-voice.The framework also implies the perspectival shifts in reading appraisal: coding of an item is itself a fragile process and it needs a more dynamic or synoptic perspective.It reveals the dynamic reader positioning which is neglected in the area of CDA.
引文
Abraham,W.(Ed.),(1991).Discourse particles:Descriptive and theoretical investigations on discourse particles in German.Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
    Aikhenvald,A.Y.(Ed.),(2003).Studies in Evidentiality.Oxford:John Benjamins Publishing Company.
    Almeida,E.(1992).A category system for the analysis of factuality in newspaper discourse.Text,12,233-62.
    Amis,M.(1997).The King's English.London:HarperCollins.
    Anderson,B.(1986).Evidentials,paths of change and mental maps:typologically regular asymmetries.In W.Chafe & J.Nichols(Eds.),Evidentiality:the Linguistic Coding of Epistemology(pp.273-312).Norwood:N.J.Ablex.
    Bagnall,N.(1993).Newspaper language.Oxford:Focal Press.
    Bakhtin,M.(1973).Problems of Dostoevsky'spoetics.Michigan:Ann Arbor.
    Bakhtin,M.(1981).The Dialogical imagination.Austin:University of Texas Press.
    Bakhtin,M.(1986).The problem of speech genres.In V.McGee,(trans.),Speech genres and other late essays(pp.60-101).Austin:University of Texas Press.
    Bamberg,M.(1991).Narrative as perspective taking:the role of emotionals,negations and voice in the construction of the story realm.Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy,2,275-90.
    Barton,E.(1993).Evidentials,argumentation,and epistemological stance.College English,55,745-769.
    Bednarek,M.(2006).Evaluation in media discourse.Analysis of a newspaper corpus.London/New York:Continuum.
    Bell,A.(1991).The language of news media.Oxford:Blackwell.
    Bell,A.(1995).Language and the media.Annual Review of Applied Linguistics,15,23-41.
    Bernstein,B.(1970).Class,codes,and control.Volume 1:Theoretical studies towards a sociology of language.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
    Bernstein,B.(1973).Class,codes,and control.Volume 2:Applied studies towards a sociology of language.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
    Bernstein,B.(1975).Class,codes,and control.Volume 3:Towards a theory of educational transmissions.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
    Bernstein,B.(1990).Class,codes,and control.4:The structure of pedagogic discourse.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
    Bernstein,B.(1999).Official knowledge and pedagogic identities.In F.Christie(Ed.),Pedagogy and the shaping of consciousness:Linguistic and social processes(pp.246-261).London:Continuum.
    Besnier,N.(1990).Language and affect.Annual Review of Anthropology,19,419-452.
    Biber,D.,& Finegan,E.(1988).Adverbial stance types in English.Discourse Processes,11,1-34.
    Biber,D.,& Finegan,E.(1989).Styles of stance in English:Lexical and grammatical marking of evidentiality and affect.Text,9,93-124.
    Biber,D.Johansson,S.,Leech,G.,Conrad,S.,& Finegan,E.(1999).Longman grammar of spoken and written English.Harlow:Longman.
    Bolivar,A.(2001).The negotiation of evaluation in written text.In M.Scott,& G.Thompson(F_As.),Patterns of text.In honour of Michael Hoey(pp.129-58).Amsterdam/Philadelphia:John Benjamins.
    Brown,P.,& Levinson,S.(1987).Politeness:Some universals of language use.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Bublitz,W.(1992).Transferred negation and modality.Journal of Pragmatics,18,551-77.
    Bublitz,W.(2002).Anmerkungen zur emotiven prosodie des textes.In:W.Bublitz,M.von Roncador,& H.Vater(Eds.),Philologie,typologie und sprachstruktur(pp.25-40).Frankfurt:Peter Lang.
    Bublitz,W.(2003).Emotive prosody:How attitudinal frames help construct context.In E.Mengel,Schmid,J.& M.Steppat(Eds.),Anglistentag Bayreuth-Proceedings(pp.381-92).Trier:Wissenschaftlicher Verlag Trier.
    Butt,D.(1988).Randomness,order and the latent patterning of texts.In D.Birch,&M.O'Toole(Eds.),Functions of style(pp.74-97).London/New York:Pinter Publishers.
    Butt,D.(1991).Some basic tools in a linguistic approach to personality.In Literacy in social processes(Papers from the inaugural Australian systemics Conference,held at Deakin University,January 1990).
    Caffi,C.,& Janney,W.(1994).Toward a pragmatics of emotive communication.Journal of Pragmatics,22,32-373.
    Caldas-Coulthard,C.R.(1994).On reporting:The representation of speech in factual and fictional narratives.In M.Coulthard(Ed.),Advances in written text analysis (pp.295-308).London:Routledge.
    Caldas-Coulthard,C.R.(2003).Cross-cultural representation of"Othemess" in media discourse.In G.Weiss,& R.Wodak(Eds.),Critical discourse analysis:Theory and interdisciplinarity(pp.273-96).Houndmills:Palgrave Macmillan.
    Calsamiglia,H.,& Ferrero,C.(2003).Role and position of scientific voices:reported speech in the media.Discourse Studies,Vol 5(2),147-173.
    Carter,R.(1988).Front pages:Lexis,style and newspaper reports,In M.Ghadessy (Ed.),Registers of written English:Situational factors and linguistic features(pp.21-34).London:Pinter Publishers.
    Carter,R.,& Nash,W.(1990).Seeing through language:A guide to styles of English writing.Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
    Chafe,W.(1982).Integration and involvement in speaking,writing and oral literature.In Tannen,D.(Ed.),Spoken and written language:Exploring orality and literacy (pp.35-54).Norwood:N.J.Ablex.
    Chafe,W.(1986).Evidentiality in English conversation and academic writing.In:Chafe,W.,& J.Nichols(Eds.),Evidentiality:the linguistic coding of epistemology(pp.261-272).Norwood:N.J.Ablex.
    Chafe,W.,& J.Nichols(Eds.),(1986).Evidential#y:the linguistic coding of epistemology.Norwood:N.J.Ablex.
    Charmell,J.(1994).Vague language.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
    Channell,J.(2000).Corpus-based analysis of evaluative lexis.In S.Hunston,& G.Thompson(Eds.),Evaluation in text:Authorial stance and the construction of discourse(pp.38-55).
    Charaudeau,P.(1997).Le discours d'information médiatique:La construction du miroir social.Paris:Nathan.
    Charles,M.(2003)."This mystery...":A corpus-based study of the use of nouns to construct stance in theses from two contrasting disciplines.Journal of English for Academic Purposes,2,13-26.
    Chouliaraki,L.,& Fairclogh,N.(1999).Rethinking critical discourse analysis.Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press.
    Christie,E,& Martin,J.R.(Eds.),(1997).Genres and institutions:Socialprocesses in the workplace and school.London:Cassell.
    Clark,H.,& Gerrig,R.(1990).Quotations as demonstrations.Language,66,210-234.
    Clark,K.(1992).The linguistics of blame:Representations of women in the Sun's reporting of crimes of sexual violence.In M.Toolan(Ed.),Language,text and context(pp.68-79).London and New York:Routledge.
    Clayman,S.E.(1990).From talk to text:Newspaper accounts of reporter source interactions.Media,Culture and Society,12,67-86.
    Coffin,C.(1997).Constructing and giving value to the past:An investigation into second school history.In F.Christie,& J.R.Martin(Eds.),Genre and institutions:Social processes in the workplace and school(pp.314-330).London:Casscll.
    Coffin,C.(2000).History as discourse:Construals of time,cause and appraisal.Ph.D thesis.Department of Linguistics,University of New South Wales.
    Coffin,C.(2002).The voices of history:Theorizing the interpersonal semantics of historical discourses.Text,22(4),503-528.
    Coffin,C.,& O'Halloran,K.(2005).Finding the global groove:Theorising and analyzing dynamic reader positioning using APPRAISAL,corpus and a eoncordancer.Critical Discourse Studies,2/2,143-163.
    Coffin,C.,& O'Halloran,K.(2006).The role of Appraisal and corpora in detecting covert evaluation.Functions of Language,13/1,77-110.
    Conboy,M.(2002).The press andpopular culture.London:Sage.
    Conrad,S.,& Biber,D.(2000).Adverbial marking of stance in speech and writing.In S.Hunston,& G.Thompson(Eds.),Evaluation in text:Authorial stance and the construction of discourse(pp.56-73).Oxford:Oxford University Press.
    Cotter,C.(1996).Engaging the reader:The changing use of connectives in newspaper discourse.In J.Arnold,R.Blake,B.Davidson,S.Schwenter & J.Solomon (Eds.),SocioIinguistic variation:Data,theory,and analysis(pp.34-56).Stanford:CSLI Publications.
    Cotter,C.(2001).Discourse and media.In D.Schiffrin,D.Taunen,& H.Hamilton (Eds.),The handbook of discourse analysis(pp.416-36).Oxford:Blaekwell.
    Crystal,D.,& Davy,D.(1969).Investigating English style.London:Longman.
    Crompton,E(1997).Hedging in academic writing:Some theoretical problems.English for Specific Purposes,16(4),271-287.
    Coulmas,F.(1986).Reported speech:Some general issues.In E Coulmas(Ed.),Direct and indirect speech(pp.1-28).Berlin:Mouton de Gruyter.
    Curran,J.,& Seaton,J.(1988).Power without responsibility.London:Routledge.
    Curran,J.,& Seaton,J.(1991).Power without responsibility:The press and broadcasting in Britain,4~(th)ed.London:Routledge.
    Dascal,M.,& Weizman,E.(1987).Contextual exploitation of interpretation clues in text-understanding:An integrated model.In J.Verschueren,& M.Bertuecelli-Papi(Eds.),The pragmatic perspective.Selected papers from the 1985 International Pragmatics Conference(pp.31-46).Amsterdam:Benjamins.
    Dendale,P.,& Tasmowski,L.(200 l).Introduction:Evidentiality and related notions.Journal of Pragmatics,33,339-348.
    Dik,S.C.(1989).The theory of Functional Grammar.Part Ⅰ:The structure of the clause.Dordrecht:Foals.
    Du Bois,J.W.(1986).Self-evidence and ritual speech.In W.Chafe,& J.Nichols (Eds.),Evidentiality:The linguistic coding of epistemology(pp.313-336).Norwood:N.J.Ablex.
    Eggins,S.,& Slade,D.(1997).Analysing casual conversation.London/Washington:Cassell.
    Fairclough,N.(1988).Discourse representation in media discourse.Sociolinguistics,17,125-39.
    Fairclough,N.1989.Language and power.London:Longman.
    Fairclough,N.(Ed.),(1992a).Critical language awareness.London:Longman.
    Fairclough,N.(1992b).Discourse and social change.Cambridge:Polity Press.
    Fairclough,N.(1995a).Media discourse.London:Edward Arnold.
    Fairclough,N.(1995b).Critical discourse analysis.London:Longman.
    Fairelough,N.(2001).Language and power.UK:Longman.
    Fairclough,N.(2003).Analyzing discourse:Textual analysis for social research.London:Routledge.
    Field,M.(1999).The role of factive predicates in the indexiealization of stance:A discourse perspective.Journal of Pragmatics,27,799-814.
    Fisherman,M.(1980).Manufacturing the news.Austin:University of Texas Press.
    Fowler,R.G.(1991a).Language in the news:Discourse and ideology in the press.London:Routledge.
    Fowler,R.G.(1991b).Critical linguistics.London:Routlege.
    Fowler,R.G.(1996).On critical linguistics.In C.R.Caldas-Coulthard & M.Coulthard,(Eds.),Texts and practices.Readings in critical discourse analysis (pp.3-14).London:Routlege.
    Fowler,R.,Hodge,B.,Kress,G.,& Trew,T.(1979).Language and control.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul
    Fraser,B.(1980).Hedged performatives.In P.Cole,& J.L.Morgan(Eds.),Syntax and semantics.Vol.3(pp.187-210).New York:Academic Press.
    Fraser,B.(1990).Perspectives on politeness.Journal of Pragmatics,(14),219-236.
    Freedland,J.(2004).An elegant box of sharpened knives.The Guardian,International Edition,15 July 2004.
    Fuller,G.(1995).Engaging cultures:Negotiating discourse in popular science.Unpublished Ph.D.thesis.University of Sydney.
    Fuller,G.(1998).Cultivating science:Negotiating discourse in the popular texts of Stephen Jay Gould.In J.R.Martin,& Veel(Eds.),Reading science:Critical and functional perspectives on discourses of science(pp.35-62).London:Routledge.
    Galtung,J.,& Ruge,M.(1965).The structure of foreign news.Journal of Peace Research,2/1,64-91.
    Geis,M.(1987).The language of politics.New York:Springer.
    Girth,L.(1989).Las formas del discurso referido en el 'Cantar de Mio Cid'.Madrid:Anejos del Boletin de la Real Academia Espanola,Anejo XLIV.
    Goffmart,E.(1959).The presentation of self in everyday life.New York:Doubleday.
    Goossens,L.(1982).Say:Focus on the message.In R.Dirven,L.Goossens,Y.Putseys,& E.Vodat(Eds.),The scene of linguistic action and its perspectivization by speak,talk,say and tell(pp.45-61).Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
    Gregory,M.(1988).Generic situation and register:A functional view of communication.In J.D.Benson,M.J.Cummings,& W.S.Greaves(Eds.),Linguistics in a systemic perspective(pp.301-329).Philadelphia/Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
    Gregory,M.,& Malcolm,K.(1981).Generic situation and discourse phase:An approach to the analysis of children's talk.Applied Linguistic Papers.Applied Linguistics Research Working Group.Tloronto:Glendon Collge of York University(mimeo).
    Groom,N.(2000).Attribution and averral revisited:Three perspectives on manifest intertextuality in academic writing.In P.Thompson(Ed.),Patterns and Perspectives:Insights into EAP writing practice(pp.14-25).UK:Centre for Applied Language Studies,University of Reading.
    Gruber,H.(1991).Antisemitismus im Mediendiskurs.Die A & e 'Waldheim' in der Tages-presse.Wiesbaden:Deutscher Universitatsverlag.
    Gruber,H.(1993).Evaluation devices in newspaper reports.Journal of Pragmatics,19,469-486.
    Habermas,J.(1971).Knowledge and Human Interests.Boston:Beacon Press.
    Hall,S.(1989).Die strukturierte vermittlung yon Ereignissen.In S.Hall(Ed.),Ausgewlhlte Schriften.Ideologie,Kultur,Medien,neue Rechte(pp.126-150).Bern:Argument-Verlag.
    Halliday,M.A.K.(1978).Language as social semiotic:The social interpretation of language and meaning.U.K.:Edward Arnold.
    Halliday,M.A.K.(1981).Text semantics and clause grammar:Some patterns of realization.In J.E.Coupeland,& P.W.Davis(Eds.),The Seventh LACUS Forum(pp.31-59).
    Halliday,M.A.K.(1985).Spoken and written language.Oxford.:Oxford University Press.
    Halliday,M.A.K.(1994).An introduction to functional grammar.London:Edward Arnold.
    Halliday,M.A.K.,& Matthiesson,C.M.I.M.(1999).Construing experience through meaning:A language based approach to cognition.London,U.K.:Cassell.
    Hallin,K.,& Mancini,C.(2004).Comparing media systems.Cambridge:CUP.
    Hartley,J.(1982).Understanding news.London:Methuen & Co.Ltd.
    Herman,E.S.,& Chomsky,N.(1988).Manufacturing consent:The political economy of the mass media.New York:Pantheon Books.
    Herwig,R.(1999).Changing language in changing times.London:Edward Arnold.
    Hill,J.H.,& Irvine,J.T.(Eds.),(1993).Responsibility and evidence in oral discourse.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Hodge,B.(1979).Newspapers and communities.In Fowler et al.(Eds.),Language and control(pp.34-52).London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
    Hodge,R.,& Kress,G.(1993).Language as ideology(2nd edition).London:Routledge.
    Hoey,M.(1983).On the surface of discourse.London:Allen & Unwin.
    Hoey,M.(2000).Persuasive rhetoric in linguistics:A stylistic study of some features of the language of Noam Chomsky.In S.Hunston,& G.Thompson(Eds.),Evaluation in text:Authorial stance and the construction of discourse(pp. 28-37).Oxford:OUP.
    Hood,S.(2004).Appraising research:Taking a stance in academic writing.Unpublished Ph.D.Dissertation.University of Technology in Sydney.
    Hoye,L.(1997).Adverbs and modality in English.London/New York:Longman.
    House,J.,& Kasper,G.(1981).Politeness markers in English and in German.In F.Coulmas(Ed.),Conversational routines(pp.157-185).The Hague:Mouton de Gruyter.
    Humphrey,S.(2006)."Getting the reader on side":Exploring adolescent online political discourse.E-Learning,3/2,143-157.
    Hunston,S.(1989).Evaluation in experimental research articles.Unpublished Ph.D.thesis.University of Birmingham.
    Hunston,S.(1993a).Evaluation and ideology in scientific writing.In M.Gahadessy (Ed.),Register analysis:Theory and practice(pp.98-107).London:Pinter.
    Hunston,S.(1993b).Professional conflict disagreement in academic discourse.In M.Baker,G.Francis,& E.Tognini-Bonelli(Eds.),Text and technology(pp.115-134).Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
    Hunston,S.(1994).Evaluation and organization in a sample of written academic discourse.In M.Coulthard(Ed.),Advances in written text analysis(pp.191-218).London:Roufledge.
    Hunston,S.(1995).A corpus study of some English verbs of attribution.Functions of Language,2/2,133-158.
    Hunston,S.(2000).Evaluation and the planes of discourse:Status and value in persuasive texts.In S.Hunston,& G.Thompson(Eds.),Evaluation in text:Authorial stance and the construction of discourse.Oxford:OUP.
    Hunston,S.,& Thompson,G.(Eds.),(2000).Evaluation in text:Authorial stance and the construction of discourse.Oxford:OUP.
    Hyland,K.(1994).Hedging in academic writing and EAP textbooks.English for Specific Purposes,Vol.13,239-256.
    Hyland,K.(1998).Hedging in scientific research articles.Amsterdam:Benjamins.
    Hyland,K.(1996).Writing without conviction:Hedging in science research articles. Applied Linguistics,17(4),433-454.
    Hyland,K.(1999).Disciplinary discourses:Writer stance in research articles.In N.Candlin,& K.Hyland(Eds.),Writing:Texts,processes and practices(pp.99-121).London/New York:Longman.
    Hyland,K.(2000).Disciplinary discourses:Social interactions in academic writing.London:Longman.
    Iedema,R.,Feez,S.,& White,P.R.R.(1994).Media literacy.Sydney:Disadvantaged Schools Program,NSW Department of School Education.(extracts available to download from http://www.grammatics.com/appraisal).
    Ifantidou,E.(2001).Evidentials and relevance.Amsterdam:John Benjamins Publishing Company.
    Jakobson,R.(1960).Closing statement:Linguistics and poetics.In T.Sebeok(Ed.),Style in language(pp.350-77).Cambridge:MIT press.
    Johnson-Cartee,K.S.(2005).News narrative and' news framing:Constructing political reality.New York:Rowman & Littlefield Publishers,Inc.
    Jucker,A.H.(1992).Social stylistics.Syntactic variation in British newspapers.Berlin/New York:Mouton de Gruyter.
    Kress,G.(1985/1989).Linguistic process in sociocultural practice.London:Oxford University Press.
    Kress,G.(1986).Language in the media:The construction of the domains of public and private.Media,Culture and Society,8,395-419.
    Kress,G.(1990).Critical discourse analysis.Annual review of applied linguistics,11,84-99.
    Kress,G.,& Hodge,R.(1979).Language as ideology.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
    Kress,G.,& van Leeuwen,T.(1996).Reading images.London:Routledge.
    Kristeva,J.(1986).Word,dialogue and novel.In T.Moi(Ed.),The Kristeva reader (pp.34-61).Oxford:Blackwell.
    Labov,W.(1972).Language in the inner city:Studies in Black English vernacular.Philadelphia:University of Pennsyvania Press.
    Labov,W.,& Fanshel,D.(1977).Therapeutic discourse.New York:Academic Press.
    Lakoff,G.(1972).Hedges:A study in meaning criteria and the logic of fuzzy concepts.Proceedings of the Chicago Linguistic Society 8,183-228.
    Lauerbaeh,G.(2006).Discourse representation in political interviews:The construction of identities and relations through voicing and ventriloquizing.Journal of Pragmatics,38,196-215.
    Latour,B.,& Woolgar,S.(1979).Laboratory life:The social construction of scientific facts.Beverley Hills:Sage.
    Lassen,I.(2006).De-naturalizing ideology:Presupposition and appraisal in biotechnology press releases.In:I.Lassen,J.Strunck,& T.Vestergaard(Eds.),Mediating ideology in text and image:Ten critical studies(pp.97-118).Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
    Lemke,J.L.(1989).Semantics and social values.Word,40,1-2.
    Lemke,J.L.(1992).Interpersonal meaning in discourse:Value orientations.In M.Davies & L.Ravelli(Eds.),Advances in systemic linguistics:Recent theory and practice(pp.82-194).London:Pinter.
    Lemke,J.L.(1998).Resources for attitudinal meaning:evaluative orientations in text semantics.Functions of Language,5/1,33-56.
    Levinson,S.(1984).Pragmatics.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Linde,C.(1997).Evaluation as linguistic structure and social practice.In B.Gunnarson,P.Linell,& B.Nordberg(Eds.),The construction of professional discourse(pp.151-72).London:Longman.
    Li,Shuguang.(2007).A recontextualization of Bakhtin's Translinguistics and its application to print news analysis.Unpublished Ph.D.thesis.Nanjing Normal University.
    Liu,Shizhu.(2006).Structural potential of attitude.Unpublished Ph.D.thesis.Shandong University.
    Ljung,M.(1997).The English of British tabloids and heavies:Differences and similarities.Studies in Modern Philology,11,133-148.
    Ljung,M.(2002).What vocabulary tells us about genre differences:A study of lexis in five newspaper genres.In L.E.Breivik,& A.Hasselgren(Eds.),From the COLT's Mouth...and Others':Language corpora studies in honour of Anna-Brita Stenstrom(pp.354-367).Amsterdam/New York:Rodopi.
    Locher,M.,& Wortham,S.(1994).The cast of news.Pragmatics,4,517-534.
    Louw,W.E.(1993).Irony in the text or insincerity in the walter? In M.Baker,G.Francis,& E.Tognini-Bonelli(Eds.),Text and technology.In honour of John M.Sinclair(pp.120-131).Amsterdam:Benjamins.
    Lyons,J.(1977).Semantics.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Macken-Horarik,M.(2003a).APPRAISAL and the special instructiveness of narrative.Text,23,285-312.
    Maeken-Horarik,M.(2003b).Envoi:Intractable issues in appraisal analysis? Text,23,313-319.
    Maeken-Horarik,M.,& Martin J.R.(Eds.).(2003).Special issue of Text 23/2 on 'Appraisal'.
    Maingueneau,D.(1987).L'heterogeneite.In D.Maingueneau(Ed.),Nouvelles tendances en analyse du discourse(pp.53-93).Paris:Hachette.
    Manning,P.(2004).Dog whistle politics and journalism.Sydney:Australian Centre for Independent Journalists.
    Martin,J.R.(1991).Intrinsic functionality:Implications for contextual theory.Social Semiotics,1,99-162.
    Martin,J.R.(1995).Reading positions/positioning readers:Judgement in English.prospect.Journal of Australian TESOL,10,27-37.
    Martin,J.R.(1996).Evaluating disruption:Symbolising theme in junior secondary narrative.In R.Hasan,& G.Williams(Eds.),Literacy in society(pp.124-171).London:Longman.
    Martin,J.R.(1997).Analysing genre:Functional parameters.In F.Christie & J.Martin(Eds.),Genres and institutions:Social processes in the workplace and school(pp.3-39).London:Cassell.
    Martin,J.R.(2000).Beyond exchange:Appraisal systems in English.In S.Hunston,& G.Thompson(Eds.),Evaluation in text:Authorial stance and the construction of discourse(pp.142-175).Oxford:OUP.
    Martin,J.R.(2001).Giving the game away:Explicitness,diversity and genre-based literacy in Australia.In R.Wodak et al.(eds.),Functional il/literacy(pp.155-74).Vienna:Vedag der Osterreichischen Akadamie der Wissenschaften.
    Martin,J.R.(2002).Meaning beyond the clause:SFL perspectives.Annual Review of Applied Linguistics,Vol.22,52-74.
    Martin,J.R.(2003).Introduction.Text,23,171-181.
    Martin,J.R.,& Rose,D.(2003).Working with discourse:Meaning beyond the clause.London:Continuum.
    Martin,J.R.(2004a).Sense and sensibility:Texturing evaluation.In J.Foley(Ed.),New perspectives on education and discourse(pp.129-140).London:Continuum.
    Martin,J.R.(2004b).Mourning:How we get aligned.Discourse & Society,15/2-3,321-344.
    Martin,J.R.,& Plum,G.(1997).Construing experience:Some story genres.Journal of Narrative and Life History,7,1-4.
    Martin,J.R.,& White,P.R.R.(2005).The language of evaluation:Appraisal in English.London/New York:Palgrave/Macmillan.
    Matloek,T.(1989).Metaphor and the grammatiealization of evidentials.Proceedings of the 15~(th)Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistic Society,15,215-225.
    Matthiessen,C.M.I.M.(1995).Lexicogrammatical cartography:English systems.Tokyo:International Language Sciences.
    Mayes,P.(1990).Quotation in spoken English.Studies in Language,14,124-140.
    Maynard,S.K.(1997).Textual ventriloquism:Quotation and the assumed community voice in Japanese newspaper columns.Poetics,(24),379-392.
    MeGill,S.(2004).The fading mystique of an objective press.Online news.
    McOlone,M.S.(2005a).Quoted out of context:Contextomy and its consequences.Journal of Communication,Vol.55(2),330-346.
    MeGlone,M.S.(2005b).Contextomy:The art of quoting out of context.Media,Culture & Society,Vol.27(24),511-522.
    McQuail,D.(1988).Mass communication theory:An introduction.London:Sage.
    Mendez Garcia de Paredes,E.(1999a).La literalidad de la cita en los textos pefiodisticos.Revista Espanola de Linguistica,30(1),147-67.
    Mendez Garcia de Paredes,E.(1999b).Analisis de la reproducci6n del discurso ajeno en los textos pefiodisticos.Pragmalinguistica,7,99-128.
    Miller,D.M.(2002a).Ways of meaning "yea" and "nay" in parliamentary debate as register:A cost-benefit analysis.In M.Bignami,G.Iamartino,& C.Pagetti (Eds.),The economy principle in English:Linguistic,literary,and cultural Perspectives(pp.220-233).Milano:Edizioni Unicopli.
    Miller,D.M.(2002b).Multiple judicial opinions as specialized sites of engagement:Conflicting paradigms of valuation and legitimation in Bush v.Gore 2000.In M.Gotti,D.Heller,& M.Dossena(Eds.),Conflict and negotiation in specialized texts(pp.119-41).Bern:Peter Lang,Linguistic Insights Series.
    Mills,S.(1995).Feminist stylistics.London:Routledge.
    Minugh,D.(2000).You people use such weird expressions:The frequency of idioms in newspaper CDs as corpora.In J.Kirk(Ed.),Corpora galore:Analyses and techniques in describing English(pp.92-108).Amsterdam/Atlanta.
    Moirand,S.(2000).Variations discursives darts deux situations productrices d'un discourse sur la science de la presse ordinaire.Carnets du Cediscor,6,45-62.
    Myers,G.(1989).The pragmatics of politeness in scientific articles.Applied Linguistics,10,1-35.
    O'Halloran,K.A.(2003).Critical discourse analysis and language cognition.Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press.
    Ochs,E.,& Schieffelin,B.(1989).Language has a heart.Text,9(1),7-25.
    Ochs,E.(1990).Indexicality and socialization.In:J.Stigler,R.Shweder,& G.Herdt (Eds.),Cultural psychology:Essays on comparative human development(pp.287-308).Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Page,R.E.(2003).An analysis of APPRAISAL in childbirth narratives with special consideration of gender and storytelling style.Text,23,211-237.
    Palmer,F.R.(1979/1995).Modality and the English modals.London:Longman.
    Palmer,F.R.(1986).Mood and modality.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Papafragou,A.(2000).Modality:Issues in the semantics-pragmatics interface.Amsterdam:Elsevier.
    Perkins,M.R.(1983).Modal expression in English.Norwood,NJ:Ablex.
    Piazza,Z.(2005).http://www.investireoggi.it/forum/15-maggio-titoli-da- seguire-ed-elenco-riunioni-cda-vt 28146.html
    Preeht,K.(2003).Stance moods in spoken English:Evidentiality and affect in British and American conversation.Text,23(2),239-257
    Prince,E.,Bosk,C.,& Frader,J.(1982).On hedging in physician-phasieian discourse.In J.di Pietro(Ed.),Linguistics and the professions(pp.83-97).Norwood:N.J.Ablex.
    Pynehon,T.(1959).Modality and mercy in Vienna.Epoch,9,195-213.
    Ramge,H.1994.Auf der Suche nach der Evaluation in Zeitungskommentaren.In M.Moilanen,& L.Tiittula(Eds.),Oberredung in der Presse.Texte,Strategien,Analysen(pp.101-120).Berlin/New York:Walter de Gruyter.
    Reyes,G.(1993).Los procedimientos de cita:estilo directo y estilo indirecto.Madrid:Arco Libros.
    Reyes,G.(1994).Los procedimientos de cita:Citas encubiertas y ecos.Madrid:Arco Libros.
    Rojo,L.M.(1995).Division and rejection:From the personification of the Gulf conflict to the demonization of Saddam Hussein.Discourse & Society,6(1),49-80.
    Rothery,J.,& Stenglin,M.(2000).Interpreting literature:The role of APPRAISAL.In L.Unsworth(Ed.),Researching language in schools and functional Linguistic perspectives(pp.222-244).London:Cassell.
    Salager-Meyer,F.(1994).Hedges and textual communicative function in medical English written discourse.English for Specific Purposes,13(2),149-170.
    Scannell,P.(1998).Media - language - world.In A.Bell,& P.Garrett(Eds.),Approaches to media discourse(pp.94-101).Oxford/Malden,MA:Blackwell.
    Schiller,D.(1981).Objectivity and the news:The public and the rise of commercial journalism.Philadelphia:University of Pennsylvania Press.
    Schneider,D.(1999)."Euro-this,Euro-that and now Euro-money"(The Guardian 1996):Computer-assisted studies of British newspaper language.In U.Carls,&P.Lucko(Eds.),Form,function and variation in English:Studies in honour of Klaus Hansen(pp.89-99).Frankfurt:Peter Lang.
    Schneider;K.(1999).Exploring the roots of popular English news writing:A preliminary report on a corpus-based project.In Diller et al.(Eds.),English via various media(pp.231-249).Heidelberg:Winter.
    Schneider,K.(2000).Popular and quality papers in the Rostock historical newspaper corpus.In C.Mair,& M.Hundt(Eds.),Corpus linguistics and linguistic theory (pp.46-61).Amsterdam/Atlanta.
    Sehudson,M.(1978).Discovering the news:A social history of American newspapers.New York:Basic Books.
    Seollon,R.(1998).Mediated discourse as social interaction:A study of news discourse.London and New York:Longman.
    Short,M.(1988).Speech presentation,the novel and the press.In W.van Peer(Ed.),The taming of the text(pp.61-81).London and New York:Routledge.
    Short,M.,Wynne,M.,& Semino,E.(1999).Reading reports:Discourse presentation in a corpus of narratives,with special reference to news reports.In Diller et al.(Eds.),English via various media(pp.44-60).Heidelberg:Winter.
    Silverstein,J.(1988).Devoice of authority.Paper read at 87~(th)Annual Meeting of the American Anthropological Association.Phoenix:Arizona.
    Simpson,P.(1993).Language,ideology and point of view.London:Roufledge.
    Sinclair,J.M.(1986).Fictional worlds.In M.Coulthard(Ed.),Talking about text(pp.43-60).Birmingham:Birmingham University,ULR.
    Sparks,C.,& Tulloch,J.(Eds.),(2000).Tabloid tales:Global debates over media standards.Lanham:Rowman & Littlefield.
    Stenglin,M.(2002).Comfort and security:A challenge for exhibition design.In L.Kelly,& J.Barratt(Eds.),Graduate research in the museum sector conference,Australian Museum,Sydney.Vol 1 of the Proceedings of the UNCOVER,23-30. Sydney:Australian Museum/University of Sydney.
    Stephens,M.(1988).A history of news:From the drum to the satellite.New York:Vildng.
    Sternberg,M.(1982).Proteus in quotation-land:Mimesis and the forms of reported discourse.Poetics,3,107-156.
    Stubbs,M.(1986).A matter of prolonged fieldwork:Notes towards a modal grammar of English.Applied Linguistics,7,1-25.
    Stubbs,M.(1996).Text and corpus analysis.Oxford:Blackwell.
    Tadros,A.(1993).The pragmaties of text averral and attribution in academic texts.In M.Hoey(Ed.),Data,description,discourse.Papers on the English Language in Honour of John McH Sinclair on his Sixtieth Birthday(pp.98-114).London:HarperCollins.
    Talbot,M.(1995).Randy fish boss branded a stinker:Coherence and the construction of masculinities in a British tabloid.Working Papers on Language and Linguistics,23,259-70.
    Tannen,D.(1989).Talking voices:Repetition,dialogue,and imagery in conversational discourse.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Thetela,P.(1997).Evaluated entities and parameters of value in academic research articles.English for specific purposes,16,101-118.
    Thetela,P.(2001).Critique discourses and ideology in newspaper reports:A discourse analysis of the South African press reports on the 1998 SADC's military intervention in Lesotho.Discourse & Society,12(3),89-102.
    Thomas,S.,& Hawes,T.(1994).Reporting verbs in medical journal articles.English for Specific Purposes,15(2),129-148.
    Thompson,G.(1996).Voices in the text:Discourse perspectives on language reports.Applied Linguistics,17,501-530.
    Thompson,G.(1998).Resonance in text.In A.Sanchez-Macarro,& R.Carter(Eds.),Linguistic choice across genres:.Variation in spoken and written English(pp.22-63).Philadelphia/Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
    Thompson,G.(2000).Reporting.Beijing:Foreign Language Press.
    Thompson,G,& Hunston,S.(2000).Evaluation:An introduction.In S.Hunston,& G.Thompson(Eds.),Evaluation in text:Authorial stance and the construction of discourse(pp.1-27).Oxford:OUP.
    Thompson,G,& Zhou,J.(2000).Evaluation and organisation in text:The structuring role of evaluative disjuncts.In S.Hunston,& G Thompson(Eds.),Evaluation in text:AuthorialsStance and the construction of discourse(pp.121-141).Oxford:OUP.
    Toolan,M.J.(1988).Narrative:A critical linguistic introduction.London/New York:Routledge.
    Trew,T.(1979a).Theory and ideology at work.In R.Fowler,B.Hodge,G.Kress,& T.Trew(Eds.),Language and control(pp.154-172).London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
    Trew,T.(1979b).What the papers say:Linguistic variation and ideological difference.In R.Fowler,B.Hodge,G Kress,& T.Trew(Eds.),Language and control(pp.89-101).London:Roufledge & Kegan Paul.
    Tunstall,J.(1996).Newspaper power:The new national press in Britain.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
    Ungerer,F.(1997).Emotions and emotional language in English and German news stories.In S.Niemeier,& R.Dirven(Eds.),The language of emotions..(pp.87-99).Amsterdam/philadelphia:John Benjamins.
    Ungerer,F.(2004).Ads as news stories,news stories as ads.Text,24,307-28.
    van tier Auwera,J.,& Vladimir,P.(1997).On modality's semantic map.Linguistic Typology,2,79-124.
    van Dijk,T.A.(1987).Communicating racism:Ethnic prejudice in thought and talk.London:Sage.
    van Dijk,T.A.(1988a).News as discourse.Hillsdale,NJ:Erlbaum.
    van Dijk,T.A.(1988b).News analysis:Case studies of international and national news in the press.Hillsdale,NJ:Erlbaum.
    van Dijk,T.A.(1991).Racism and thepress.London:Routledge.
    van Dijk,T.A.(1995).Discourse semantics and ideology.Discourse & Society,6(2), 243-259.van Dijk,T.A.(1996).Opinions and.ideologies in editorials.URL http://www.hum.uva.nl/teun/editoria.htm.
    van Dijk,T.A.(1998).Ideologies in political discourse on immigration.URL (consulted 2,July 2000):http//hum.uva.nl/teun/ideo-rac.htm.
    van Leeuwen,T.(1996).The Representation of social actors.In C.R.Caldas-Coulthard,& M.Coulthard(Eds.),Texts and practice(pp.32-70).London:Routledge.
    Veel,R.(1998).The greening of school science:Ecogenesis in secondary classrooms.In J.R.Martin,& R.Veel(Eds.),Reading science:Critical and functional perspectives on discourse of science(pp.114-151).London:Routledge.
    Verschueren,J.(1985).International news reporting:Metapragmatic metaphors and the U2.Amsterdam:Benjamins.
    Volosilinov,V.N.(1986/1929).Marxism and the philosophy of language.Cambridge,MA:Harvard University Press.
    Warren,C.(1934).Modern news reporting.New York:Harper and Brothers.
    Waugh,L.(1995).Reported speech in journalitic discourse.Text,I5,125-141.
    Weinreich,U.(1966).On the semantic structure of English.In J.H.Crreenberg(Ed.),Universals of language(pp.142-217).Cambridge/Mass:MIT Press.
    Weiss,G.,& Wodak,R.(Eds.).(2003).Critical discourse analysis.Theory and interdisciplinarity.Houndmills:Palgrave Macmillan.
    Weizman,E.,& Marce,D.1991.On clues and cues:Strategies of text-understanding.Journal of Literary Semantics,20(1),18-30.
    Wetherell,M.,Taylor,S.,& Yates,S.J.(Eds.),(2001).Discourse as data:A guide for analysis.London:Sage.
    Weydt,H.,Harden,T.,Hentschel,E.,& Rosier,D.(1983).Kleine deutsche Partikellehre.Munchen:Klett.
    White,P.R.R.(1997).Death,disruption and the moral order:The narrative impulse in mass media 'hard news' reporting.In E Christie & J.Martin(Eds.),Genre and Institutions:Social process in the workplace and school(pp.101-132).London: Continuum.
    White,P.R.R.(1998).Telling media tales:The news story as rhetoric.Unpublished PhD thesis.From http://www.grammatics.com/appraisal/index.html.
    White,P.R.R.(2000).Dialogue and inter-subjectivity:reinterpreting the semantics of modality and hedging.In M.Coulthard,J.Cotterill and F.Rock(Eds.),Dialogue Analysis Ⅶ:Working with dialogue(pp.67-80).Tubingen:Niemeyer.
    White,P.R.R.(2001a).Appraisal outline.Manuscript(word processor version).www.grammatics.com/appraisal.
    White,P.R.R.(2001b).Attitude/Appreciation.Manuscript(word processor version).www.grammatics.com/appraisal.
    White,P.R.R.(2001c).Intertextuality.Manuscript(word processor version).www.grammatics.com/appraisal.
    White,P.R.R.(2001d).Attitude/Judgement.Manuscript(word processor version).www.grammatics.com/appralsal.
    White,P.R.R.(2001e).'Appraisal:an overview'.Manuscript(word processor version),www.grammatics.com/appraisal
    White,P.R.R.(2001f).Attitude/Affect.Manuscript(word processor version).www.grammatics.com/appraisal
    White,P.R.R.(2002).Appraisal:The language of evaluation and stance.In J.Verschueren,J.Ostman,J.Blommaert,& C.Bulcaen(Eds.),The Handbook of Pragmatics(pp.1-27).Amsterdam/Philadelphia:John Benjamins Publishing Co.
    White,P.R.R.(2003a).Appraisal and the resources of intersubjective stance.Manuscript(word version),www.grammatics.com/appraisal.
    White,P.R.R.(2003b).Beyond modality and hedging:A dialogic view of the language of intersubjective stance.Text,23,259-284.
    White,P.R.R.(2004a).Attitudinal meaning and inference:Semantic prosodies in text and inter-text.Presentation given at the University of Birmingham.17,February 2004.
    White,P.R.R.(2004b).Subjectivity,evaluation and point of view in media discourse.In C.Coffin(Ed.),Applying English grammar:Functional and corpus approaches(pp.229-246).London:Arnold.
    White,P.R.R.(2006).Evaluative semantics and ideological positioning in journalistic discourse:A new framework for analysis.In I.Lassen,J.Strunck,&T.Vestergaard(Eds.),Mediating ideology in text and image:Ten critical studies (pp.37-67).Amsterdam:John Benjamins.
    Widdowson,H.G.(1995).Discourse analysis:A critical view.Language and Literature,4,157-172.
    Widdowson,H.G.(2000).On the limitations of linguistics applied.Applied Linguistics,21,3-25.
    Winter,E.(1982).Towards a contextual grammar of English:The clause and its place in the definition of sentence.London:Allen & Unwin.
    Willett,T.(1988).A crosslinguistic survey of the grammaticalization of evidentiality.Studies in Language,12,51-97.
    Wodak,R.(1996).Orders of discourse.New York:Addison Wesley Lonman.
    Wodak,R.,& Ludwig,C.(Eds.),(1999).Challenges in a changing world:Issues in critical discourse analysis.Vienna:Passagenverlag.
    Worthara,S.,& Loeher,M.(1996).Voicing on the news:An analytic technique for studying media bias.Text,16,557-585.
    Xin,B.(2000).Intertextuality from a critical perspective.Suzhou:Suzhou University Press.
    黄旦,(2005),《作者图像:新闻专业主义的建构与消解》,上海:复旦大学出版社.
    曾庆香,(2005),《新闻叙事学》,北京:中国广播电视出版社.
    刘世铸,(2007),《态度的结构潜势》,北京:中国社会科学出版社.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700