用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于本体的服务发现与组合方法研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本文通过对Web服务的服务行为与用户预期的一致性、服务评价的多属性关系、Web服务之间协作上下文的研究,提出了基于本体的服务发现与组合方法,该方法能够通过服务的统一描述、发现与组合,更有效的管理和共享信息并快速构建应用。
     首先提出了服务行为模型,该模型形式化的构造了Web服务的服务行为描述,建立了Web服务的服务行为和用户预期之间的一致性计算规则,设计了服务发现原型并对服务行为的目标和任务进行了匹配。服务行为模型从用户的功能需求和主观预期两个方面能够提高服务发现的准确性。
     其次针对服务发现的结果中存在着Web服务的处理能力空闲、服务请求过载和功能失效的问题,提出了多属性关系模型的解决方案并形式化的构造了Web服务的服务评价描述,进而构建了多属性关系计算规则并且证明了多属性关系的一致性。多属性关系模型从Web服务的性能方面进一步的优化了服务发现的结果。
     最后提出了协作上下文模型,该模型依据业务流程的上下文场景,形式化的构造了Web服务的服务协作描述并构建了协作上下文的计算规则,进而通过计算业务流程中Web服务节点和节点之间关联的上下文,建立了Web服务之间的协作上下文并设计了服务组合原型。协作上下文模型提高了Web服务的可共享性和服务组合的个性化程度。
     基于本体的服务发现与组合方法能够提高用户对服务发现的准确性、服务的可用性、服务的共享性及服务组合的个性化选择的满意度。在MSIDP和KaM平台的实验结果表明,该方法能够满足用户的服务需求。
Because of increasing users and individuation of requirements, there are some newchallenges that how to utilize the Internet resources just as information, business, andknowledge and so on effectively, build applications rapidly with a uniform way of servicedescription, discovery and composition, and find a new way of service providing instead ofprogramming again and again. We call it "one-time implementation and multi-times usage",which has become one of the research hotspots in the area of service computing. In this thesis,we proposed an approach of ontology-based service discovery and composition, which isbased on our works on aspects of behavior, evaluation and collaboration of the web services.On the basis of formalized ontology representation, we built three models named ServiceBehavior, Multi-Attribute Relationship and Collaboration Context, to provide a uniformconstruction of service description. We use the Service Behavior model and Multi-AttributeRelationship model to discover web services with a matching and selection between user'sexpectation and performance evaluation, and then use the Collaboration Context model tocompose web services as a service composition for a business process.
     Firstly, we designed Service Description Ontology to describe and build web serviceuniformly. The descriptions of service behavior, service evaluation and service collaborationof a web service have been constructed in the Service Description Ontology with a formalizedontology representation. We defined a concept model and a relationship model betweendifferent concepts of the service behavior, service evaluation and service collaboration, andbuilt a conceptual description of the relationships between business function and functionalrequirement, between the actual service behavior and the expected service behavior, and therelationships of an interactive collaboration among different web services. Then we designedan attribute model of these concepts and relationships, and defined an attributes’ computingmodels as executive computing rules for service discovery on demand, service selection onevaluation and service composition on context. We built the ontology axioms of servicebehavior, service evaluation and service collaboration in the construction of ServiceDescription Ontology with the computing model, and designed a service generation prototypewhich creates an OWL-S instance of Service Description Ontology to publish a web service.We do some experiments on the platform named MSIDP (Model Driven based ServiceOriented Integration and Development Platform). We built MSIDP Service Registration andSearch Tool for business objects with this service generation prototype. The result shows thatthe service generation prototype help MSIDP users to create instances of Service DescriptionOntology for describing the services provided by different types of application resources, thenit generated web services of MSIDP business objects, and offered service units for users to share. The Service Description Ontology is on the basis of building the Service Behaviormodel, the Multi-Attribute Relationship model and the Collaboration Context model, andprovides machine-accessed service description uniformly for service discovery andcomposition further.
     Secondly, on the basis of the description and generation of a web service, we proposed abehavior centric model named Service Behavior model to build service discovery andmatching. We designed an interactive process among web services, service discoveryprototype and users with the Service Behavior model, built a service discovery process whichis from requirement analysis to result evaluation. The requirement analysis is extracted fromthe service request of a user to present his intention and task. The result evaluation is ameasurement that whether user is satisfied with the service discovery. We designed a servicediscovery prototype based on the Service Behavior model. The users’ intentions and tasks areextracted with an existing Key-phrases Extraction Algorithm and matched with the concept’sattribute of the actual service behavior that has been constructed in the Service DescriptionOntology. We defined the computing rules to prove consistency between the axioms of servicebehavior and service evaluation in the Service Description Ontology. According to thecomputing rules, we designed a service discovery and matching process for the servicediscovery prototype, and experimented on the platform of Knowledge advantage Machine(KaM). We built a discovery Agent for KaM by using the service discovery prototype. Weused the Service Behavior Model to build a service discovery process among the KaM users,KaM Knowledge Objects (named JANs) and KaM discovery Agent. The experimental resultshows that the Service Behavior model promotes the accuracy of the service discovery result,provides a solution of service discovery on demand.
     Thirdly, to solve the service evaluation problem of capability idle, request overload andfunctional invalidation of a web service on the runtime, we proposed a Multi-AttributeRelationship model, which is used to analyze and evaluate the actual service behaviorprovided by the web service in the service discovery result, and optimize the result to filterunqualified web services. On the basis of the description of service evaluation, which isconstructed in the Service Description Ontology, we designed an attribute’s computing modelfor each service evaluation concept, made analysis on the scenes of capability idle, requestoverload and functional invalidation and explored the relationships among different serviceevaluation concepts. We defined the computing rules for these concepts’ attributes in theMulti-Attribute Relationship model, computed the consistency of these attributes, and provedthe relationships between consistency and inconsistency of these attributes. We designed aservice evaluation and selection process in the service discovery prototpye based on theMulti-Attribute Relationship model, built service evaluation to optimize the service discoveryresults on the platform of MSIDP and KaM. The exprimental result shows that theMulti-Attribute Relationship model promotes the user’s satification to service discovery resultobviously, so it provides a new way of service selection in accordance with evaluation.
     Fourthly, on the basis of description, discovery and evaluation of web services, weproposed a Collaboration Context model, which is used to build a context among differentfunction nodes in a business process through scenario analysis on a special applicationdomain or on different domains across, and then we defined an interactive process betweendifferent web services for service composition on the basis of the description of servicecollaboration in the Service Description Ontology and the collaboration scenario in a businessprocess. We built executive computing rules of service composition using the axioms ofservice collaboration in the Service Description Ontology, and designed a service compositionprototype to execute service composition on the collaboration context which was associatedon different web services in a business process. This proposed Collaboration Context modeland service composition prototype can be used to provide a theoretical model for modelingbusiness processes on the platform of MSIDP for different domains such as electronic power,telecom and government affairs. We built a linking Agent on the platform of KaM by usingthe service composition prototype. The linking Agent executes to link the discovered JANsinto a personal knowledge network or a group knowledge network according to theircollaboration contexts, which were constructed for the scenario of knowledge managementand sharing. It provides a more effective way of personal knowledge management andpromotes knowledge sharing and reusing for knowledge workers. The experimental resultshows that the Collaboration Context model promotes the sharing and reusing ability of webservices, and enhances individuality for service composition.
     Our works is on the basis of the models and methods of ontology, web service in the areaof service computing. We used our proposed methods and prototypes to provide a solution forservice description, service discovery and service composition in a uniform way. The methodhas been experimented and tested on the platform of MSIDP and KaM. The results show thatthe Service Description Ontology can provide a useful way to describe service behavior,service evaluation and service collaboration for web services, and then our proposed modelsof Service Behavior, Multi-Attribute Relationship and Collaboration Context can be designedfor building the prototypes, which provide a solution of service discovery and composition forusers to manage and share information more effective and building applications rapidly. Theexperimental results and examples demonstrate the rationality and validity of our proposedmodel and method.
引文
[1]韩燕波,徐晓飞,何克清.互联网环境下的服务计算[J].中国计算机学会通讯,2009,6(9):10-11.
    [2] Jim Spohrer, Laura C. Anderson, Norman J. Pass, Tryg Ager, Daniel Gruhl. ServiceScience [J]. Journal of Grid Computing,2008,6(3):313-324.
    [3] Sheila A. McIlraith, David L. Martin. Bringing semantics to web services [J]. IEEEINTELLIGENT SYSTEMS,2003,18(1):90-93.
    [4] Ian Foster. Service-Oriented Science [J]. Science,2005, DOI:10.1126/science.1110411308:814-817.
    [5] Luyi Wang, Ramana Reddy, Sumitra Reddy, Asesh Das. A Context Centric Model forBuilding a Knowledge Advantage Machine Based on Personal Ontology Patterns [C].PROCEEDINGS OF THE2011INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON SEMANTICWEB&WEB SERVICES,2011:99-105.
    [6]杨鑫,陈俊亮. WSC/ADL: Web Services组合系统体系结构描述语言[J].软件学报,2006,17(5):1128-1194.
    [7] Tsur S. Are Web Services the next revolution in E-Commerce [C]. The proceedings of the27th International Conference on Very large Data Bases, Roma: Morgan KaufmannPublishers,2001:614-617.
    [8] Cambronero ME, Diaz G, Martinez E. A comparative study between WSCI, WS-CDL, andOWL-S [C]. The proceedings of IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ONE-BUSINESS ENGINEERING,2009:377-382.
    [9] DANIEL J. WEITZNER, HAROLD ABELSON, TIM BERNERS-LEE, JOANFEIGENBAUM, JAMES HENDLER, GERALD JAY SUSSMAN. Informationaccountability [J]. COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ACM,2008,51(6):82-87.
    [10] Surya Nepal, John Zic, Shiping Chen. WS-CCDL: A Framework for Web ServiceCollaborative Context Definition Language for Dynamic Collaborations [C].2008IEEEInternational Conference on Web Services,2008:781-784.
    [11] Zhao JL, Tanniru M, Zhang JL. Services computing as the foundation of enterpriseagility: Overview of recent advances and introduction to the special issue [J].Information System Frontiers,2007,9(1):1-8.
    [12] Maglio PP, Srinivasan S, Kreulen JT. Service systems, service scientists, SSME, andinnovation [J]. COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ACM,2006,49(7):81-85.
    [13] T Berners-Lee, J Hendler, O Lassila. The semantic Web [J]. Scientific American,2001,284(5):34-43.
    [14] James Hendler, Nigel Shadbolt, Wendy Hall, Tim Berners-Lee, Daniel Weitzner. Webscience: An interdisciplinary approach to understanding the web [J].COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ACM,2008,51(7):60-69.
    [15] Jim Hendler, Tim Berners-Lee. From the Semantic Web to social machines: A researchchallenge for AI on the World Wide Web [J]. Artificial Intelligence,2010,174(2):156-161.
    [16] Xiao Ruliang, Tang Shengqun, Li Ling, Fang Lina, Xu Yang, Xu Youwei, Deng Xingguo.Extend OWL: toward a clustering integration of collaborative ontologies and agents [J].Journal of Southeast University (English Edition),2008,22(No.3):375-388.
    [17] Mick Kerrigan, Adrian Mocan, Elena Simperl, Dieter Fensel. Modeling Semantic WebServices with the Web Service Modeling Toolkit [J]. JOURNAL OF NETWORK ANDSYSTEMS MANAGEMENT,2009,17(3):326-342.
    [18]赵文峰.信息提供类Web服务的自动发现和自动组合[D].北京:北京邮电大学,2010.
    [19]任开军.基于QSQL的高效语义Web服务发现及合成关键技术研究[D].长沙:国防科学技术大学,2008.
    [20] Kopecky J, Vitvar T, Bournez C. SAWSDL: Semantic annotations for WSDL and XMLschema [J]. IEEE INTERNET COMPUTING,2009,11(6):60-67.
    [21] Alexander Mintchev. Interoperability among Service Registry Implementation: Is UDDIstandard enough[C].2008IEEE International Conference on Web Services,2008:724-731.
    [22]杜宗霞,怀进鹏.主动分布式Web服务注册机制研究与实现[J].软件学报,2006,17(3):454-462.
    [23] Anupriya Ankolekar, Massimao Paolucci, Katia Sycara. Towards a Formal Verification ofOWL-S Process Models [J]. Springer The Semantic Web-ICWC2005,2005,3729:1-25.
    [24] Xinxin Bai, Yushun Fan. TOWARDS FORMAL VERIFICATION OF WEB SERVICECOMPOSITION [J], Springer Business Process Management,2006,4102:1-5.
    [25] Massimo P, Kawamura T. Importing the Semantic Web in UDDI [C]. The Proceedings ofWeb Service, E-business and Semantic Web Workshop, Toronto: Canada,2002:225-236.
    [26]杨胜文,史美林.一种支持QoS约束的Web服务发现模型[J].计算机学报,2005,28(4):1-6.
    [27]龚晓勇,朱庆生.支持QoS的Web服务选择模型的研究与实现[J].计算机工程,2008,34(24):1-3.
    [28]倪晚成,刘连臣,吴澄. Web服务组合方法综述[J].计算机工程,2008,34(4):1-3.
    [29]周长寿,江水,顾华江,邵培南. Web服务合成平台研究[J].计算机工程,2006,32(5):1-3.
    [30]李善平,胡玉杰,郭鸣,付相君.本体论研究综述[J].计算机研究与发展,2004,47(7):1-12.
    [31]王晓玲,郭志懋,周傲英. Web服务组合基于文法的消息处理[J].计算机学报,2005,28(4):1-8.
    [32]钱柱中,陆桑璐,谢立.基于Petri网的Web服务自动组合研究[J].计算机学报,2006,29(7):1057-1066.
    [33]张艳梅,余镇危,曹怀虎,金鑫.基于服务质量的组合服务路由算法[J].计算机工程,2008,34(1):1-3.
    [34]任志宏,李京,金蓓弘.基于Internet工作流的复合Web服务框架[J].计算机研究与发展,2003,40(7):1-7.
    [35]吴晓东,卜佳俊,陈纯.基于工作流的ASP服务组合模型研究[J].通信学报,2007,28(11):1-7.
    [36]廖军,谭浩,刘锦德.基于Pi-演算的Web服务组合的描述和验证[J].计算机学报,2005,28(4):1-4.
    [37]刘方方,史玉良,张亮,施伯乐.基于进程代数的Web服务合成的替换分析[J].计算机学报,2007,30(11):1-7.
    [38]刘静,何积丰, Zhiming Liu.面向服务架构中服务实现的策略[J].中国科学E辑,2006,36(10):1220-1239.
    [39]侯丽珊,金芝,吴步丹.需求驱动的Web服务建模及其验证:一个基于本体的方法[J].中国科学E辑,2006,36(10):1189-1219.
    [40]岳昆,王晓玲,周傲英. Web服务核心支撑技术:研究综述[J].软件学报,2004,15(3):1-15.
    [41]梅宏,申峻嵘.软件体系结构研究进展[J].软件学报,2006,17(6):1259-1265.
    [42]张宇,陈华钧,姜晓红,盛浩,于彤,周林华.电子商务系统信任管理研究综述[J].2008,36(10):2011-2020.
    [43]何克清,何非,李兵,何扬帆,刘进,梁鹏,王翀.面向服务的本体元建模理论与方法研究[J].计算机学报,2005,28(4):1-10.
    [44] Anupriya Ankolekar, Frank Huch, Katia Sycara. Concurrent Semantics for the WebServices Specification Language DAML-S [J]. Springer Lecture Notes in ComputerScience,2002,22:1-8.
    [45]杜小勇,李曼,王珊.本体学习研究综述[J].软件学报,2006,17(9):1837-1847.
    [46]吕鲲,曾庆良,万丽荣,曾庆田,刘志海.服务于本体理论的本体定义[J].计算机工程,2008,34(9):52-54.
    [47] McIlraith SA, Son TC, Zeng HL. Semantic Web services [J]. IEEE INTELLIGENTSYSTEMS,2001,16(2):46-53.
    [48] Wil M. P. van der Aalst, Marlon Dumas, Chun Ouyang, Anne Rozinat, Eric Verbeek.Conformance Checking of Service Behavior [J]. ACM Transactions on InternetTechnology,2008,8(3):1-30.
    [49] Z. Zhou, L.T.Yang, S.Bhiri, L.Shu, N.Xiong, M.Hauswirth. Verifying mediated serviceinteractions considering expected behaviours [J]. Journal of Network and ComputerApplications,2011,34:1043-1053.
    [50] Antonio Brogi. On the potential advantages of exploiting behavioural information forcontract-based service discovery and composition [J]. The Journal of Logic andAlgebraic Programming,2011,(80):3-12.
    [51] Antonio Brogi, Sara Corfini. Behaviour-aware discovery of Web service compositions [J].International Journal of Web Services Research,2007,4(3):1-25.
    [52] Antonio Brogi, Sara Corfini, Razvan Popescu. Composition-oriented Service Discovery[C].4th International Workshop Software Composition, Edinburgh,2005:15-30.
    [53] Antonio Brogi, Sara Corfini. SAM: A Semantic Web service discovery system [C].11thInternational Conference on Knowledge-Based Intelligent Informational and EngineeringSystems/17th Italian Workshop on Neural Networks, Italy,2007:703-710.
    [54] Antonio Brogi, Sara Corfini, Razvan Popescu. Semantics-Based Composition-OrientedDiscovery of Web Services [J]. ACM Transactions on Internet Technology,2008,8(4):1-39.
    [55] Brogi A, Popescu R, Tanca M. Design and Implementation of SATOR: A Web ServiceAggregator [J]. ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology,2010,19(3):1-21.
    [56] Antonio Brogi, Sara Corfini, Stefano Iardella. From OWL-S Descriptions to Petri Nets
    [C].5th International Conference on Service-Oriented Computing (ICSOC2007),Austria,2007:427-438.
    [57] Fabrizio Benigni, Antonio Brogi, Sara Corfini. Discovering service compositions thatfeature a desired behaviour [C].5th International Conference on Service-OrientedComputing (ICSOC2007), Vienna: Austria,2007:56-68.
    [58] Francisco G, Rafael V, Rodrigo M, Jesualdo T. F.. An ontology, intelligent agent-basedframework for the provision of semantic web services [J]. Expert Systems withApplications,2009(36):3167-187.
    [59] Joanna J. Bryson, David L. Martin, Sheila A. McIlraith, Lynn Andrea Stein. Towardbehavioral intelligence in the semantic Web [J]. COMPUTER,2002,22(11):54-60.
    [60] Alan Dix, Giorgos Lepouras, Akrivi Katifori, Costas Vassilakis, Tiziana Catarci,Antonella Poggi, Yannis Ioannidis, Miguel Mora, Ilias Daradimos, Nazihah Md.Akim,Shah Rukh Humayoun, Fabio Terella. From the web of data to a world of action [J].Journal of Web Semantics,2010,8(4):394-408.
    [61] Silvia Calegari, Gabriella Pasi. Ontology-Based Information Behaviour to Improve WebSearch [J]. Future Internet,2010,2(4):533-558.
    [62] Dong-Hoon Shin, Kyong-Ho Lee, Tatsuya Suda. Automated generation of compositeweb services based on functional semantics [J]. Journal of Web Semantics,2009,7(4):332-343.
    [63] Nicholas Gibbins, Stephen Harris, Nigel Shadbolt. Agent-based Semantic Web Services[J]. Journal of Web Semantics,2004,2(1):141-154.
    [64] Sara Bouchenak, Fabienne Boyer, Benoit Claudel, Noel De Palma, Olivier Gruber,Sylvain Sicard. From Autonomic to Self-Self Behaviors: The JADE Experience [J].ACM Transactions on Autonomous and Adaptive Systems,2011,6(4):1-22.
    [65] R. Reddy, L. Wang, S. Reddy, S. Devalapalli, G. Sasanka, S.Macha, S. Teja, R.Doppalapudi, J. Yu. Vijjana: A Pragmatic Model for Collaborative, Self-organizing,Domain Centric Knowledge Networks [C]. Proceedings of the2008InternationalConference on Information&Knowledge Engineering,2008:116-121.
    [66] S. Devalapalli, R. Reddy, L. Wang, S. Reddy. MARKUP and Validation Agents in Vijjana:A Pragmatic Model for Collaborative, Self-organizing, Domain Centric KnowledgeNetworks [C]. WEBIST2009: PROCEEDINGS OF THE FIFTH INTERNATIONALCONFERENCE ON WEB INFORMATION SYSTEMS AND TECHNOLOGIES,2009:263-269.
    [67] WANG Shu-chao, SONG Jing-yu, ZHONG Hua, LI Jing. A selection model forinteractive web services and its implementation in portal [J]. CHINESE JOURNAL OFELECTRONICS,2008,17(1):115-122.
    [68] LI Zhen, Yang Fang-chun, SU Sen. QoS-Aware Semantic Web Service Composition withUncertainties [J]. CHINESE JOURNAL OF ELECTRONICS,2008,17(4):703-709.
    [69]殷昱煜,李莹,邓水光,尹建伟. Web服务行为一致性和相容性判定[J].电子学报,2009,37(3):433-437.
    [70]邓水光,李莹,吴健,邝砾,吴朝晖. Web服务行为兼容性的判定与计算[J],软件学报,2007,18(2):3001-3014.
    [71]刘莹,张一川,张斌,张明卫,朱志良.基于行为效果的服务可替换性分析[J].计算机研究与发展,2010,47(8):1442-1449.
    [72]李研,周明辉,李瑞超,曹东刚,梅宏.一种考虑QoS数据可信性的服务选择方法[J].软件学报,2008,19(10):2620-2627.
    [73]吴国全,魏峻,黄涛.基于非确定性的网构软件服务质量动态评估方法[J].软件学报,2008,19(5):1173-1185.
    [74] Galizia S, Gugliotta A. A Framework for Selecting Trusted Semantic Web Services [J].LECTURE NOTES IN COMPUTER SCIENCE,2009,5468:130-140.
    [75] E.G. da Silva, L.F. Pires, M. van Sinderen. Towards runtime discovery, selection andcomposition of semantic services [J]. Computer Communications,2010,doi:10.1016/j.comcom.2010.04.003.34:159-168.
    [76] Hassina Nacer Talantikite, Djamil Aissani, Nacer Boudjlida. Semantic annotations forweb services discovery and composition [J]. Computer Standards&Interfaces,2009,31(6):1108-1117.
    [77] Matthias Klusch, Benedikt Fries, Katia Sycara. OWLS-MX: A hybrid Semantic Webservice matchmaker for OWL-S services [J]. Journal of Web Semantics,2009,7(2):121-133.
    [78]周宁,谢俊元.基于定性多用户偏好的Web服务选择[J].电子学报,2011,39(4):1-8.
    [79] Ping Wang. QoS-aware web services selection with intuitionistic fuzzy set underconsumer's vague perception [J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2009,36(3):4460-4466.
    [80]潘静,徐锋,吕建.面向可信服务选取的基于声誉的推荐者发现方法[J].软件学报,2010,21(2):388-400.
    [81]胡昊,殷琴,吕建.虚拟计算环境中服务行为与质量的一致性[J].软件学报,2007,18(8):1943-1957.
    [82]邱田,胡晓慧,李鹏飞,马恒太.基于OWL-S的服务发现语义匹配机制[J].电子学报,2010,38(1):43-47.
    [83]邱田,李鹏飞,林品.一个基于概念语义近似度的Web服务匹配算法[J].电子学报,2009,37(2):429-432.
    [84]徐萌,陈俊亮,彭泳,梅翔.基于服务关系本体的服务生成[J].软件学报,2008,19(3):545-556.
    [85] Riina Maigre. Survey of the Tools for Automating Service Composition [C].2010IEEE8th International Conference on Web Services (ICWS2010),2010:628-629.
    [86] Luciano Baresi, Liliana Pasquale. Adaptive Goals for Self-Adaptive ServiceCompositions [C].2010IEEE8th International Conference on Web Services (ICWS2010),2010:353-360.
    [87] Raya Fidel, Annelise Mark Pejtersen, Bryan Cleal, Harry Bruce. A multidimensionalapproach to the study of human-information interaction: A case study of collaborativeinformation retrieval [J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science andTechnology,2004,55(11):939-953.
    [88] E. Karakoc, P. Senkul. Composing semantic Web services under constraints [J]. ExpertSystems with Applications,2009,36(8):11021-11029.
    [89] Raya Fidel, Annelise Mark Pejtersen, Bryan Cleal, Harry Bruce. A multidimensionalapproach to the study of human-information interaction: A case study of collaborativeinformation retrieval [J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science andTechnology,2004,55(11):939-953.
    [90] Anna Formica. Semantic Web search based on rough sets and Fuzzy Formal ConceptAnalysis [J]. Knowledge-Based Systems,2012,26:40-47.
    [91]王守信,张莉,李鹤松.一种基于云模型的主观信任评价方法[J].软件学报,2010,21(6):1341-1352.
    [92]张润莲,武小年,周胜源,董小社.一种基于实体行为风险评估的信任模型[J].计算机学报,2009,32(4):688-698.
    [93]唐文,陈钟.基于模糊集合理论的主观信任管理模型研究[J].软件学报,2003,14(8):1401-1408.
    [94]李小勇,桂小林.动态信任预测的认知模型[J].软件学报,2010,21(1):163-176.
    [95]徐锋,吕建. Web安全中的信任管理研究与进展[J].软件学报,2002,13(11):2057-2064.
    [96] Saeedeh Shekarpour, S.D. Katebi. Modeling and evaluation of trust with an extension insemantic web [J]. Journal of Web Semantics,2010,8(1):26-36.
    [97]胡旭东,曾国荪,陈波.一种基于非功能属性决策的可信Web服务发现模型[J].计算机科学,2009,36(2):95-98.
    [98]李佳伦,谷利泽,杨义先.一种新的P2P网络的信任管理模型[J].北京邮电大学学报,2009,32(2):71-74.
    [99] Stephen J.H. Yang, Jia Zhang, Irene Y.L. Chen. A JESS-enabled context elicitationsystem for providing context-aware Web services [J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2008,34:2254-2266.
    [100] Nayat Sachez-Pi, Javier Carbo, Jose Manuel Molina. A knowledge-based systemapproach for a context-aware system [J]. Knowledge-Based Systems,2012,27:1-17.
    [101] Guido Boella, Guido Governatori, Joris Hulstijn, Regis Riveret, Antonino Rotolo,Leendert van der Torre. Time and defeasibility in FIPA ACL semantics [J]. Journal ofApplied Logic,2011,9:274-288.
    [102] Zakaria Maamar, Soraya Kouadri Mostefaoui, and Hamdi Yahyaoui. Toward anagent-based and context-oriented approach for Web services composition [J]. IEEE TransKnowl Data Engineering,2005,17(5):686-697.
    [103] Hamdi Yahyaoui. Trust Assessment for Web Services Collaboration [C].2010IEEE8thInternational Conference on Web Services (ICWS2010),2010:315-320.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700