期刊红点指标与期刊评价指标的相关性研究——以医学综合类期刊为例
|
摘要
【目的】分析医学综合类期刊红点指标与其他21项期刊评价指标的相关性,探讨提高期刊红点指标的有效途径。【方法】选取2018年版《中国科技期刊引证报告(核心版)》的医学综合类期刊(共41种)为研究样本,将红点指标与其他21项期刊评价指标作为研究对象,进行Spearman相关分析。【结果】红点指标与11项评价指标呈正相关,即总被引频次、引用刊数、权威因子、来源文献量、文献选出率、AR论文量、地区分布数、机构分布数、学科扩散指标、学科影响指标、总被引频次的离均差率;与3项评价指标呈负相关,即扩散因子、被引半衰期、引用半衰期;与7项评价指标无相关性,即影响因子、即年指标、他引率、开放因子、基金论文比、综合评价总分、影响因子的离均差率。【结论】红点指标作为期刊评价指标是科学合理的,它对提高论文显示度、期刊学术传播能力和学术权威性具有重要意义;通过控制载文量、注重引文时效性、谨慎选择文章关键词等途径可有效提高红点指标。
[Purposes]This paper aims to investigate the correlation between red point factor and other 21 evaluation indicators in medical comprehensive journals and discuss the effective ways to improve the red point factor. [Methods]Medical comprehensive journals in Chinese S&T Journal Citation Reports( 2018 Edition) were selected as the study samples,and the correlation between red point factor and other evaluation indicators were did by Spearman correlation analysis. [Findings]Red point factor is positively correlated to total citation,number of citing journals,authority factor,literature quantity,literature selection rate,quantity of AR papers,area distributing number,organization distributing number,discipline diffusion index,discipline influence index,and centrifugal rate of total citation,but it is negatively correlated to diffusion factor,cited half-life,and citing half-life. There is no correlation between red point factor and impact factor,immediacy index,non-self-cited rate,open factor,ratio of fund article,comprehensive evaluation score,and centrifugal rate of impact factor. [Conclusions]Red point factor is suitable as an important indicator for the journal evaluation. It is important for improving the visibility of papers and enhancing academic communication ability and academic authority. It can be improved by controlling the number of published papers,focusing on the timeliness of references,carefully selecting keywords of papers,and so.
[Purposes]This paper aims to investigate the correlation between red point factor and other 21 evaluation indicators in medical comprehensive journals and discuss the effective ways to improve the red point factor. [Methods]Medical comprehensive journals in Chinese S&T Journal Citation Reports( 2018 Edition) were selected as the study samples,and the correlation between red point factor and other evaluation indicators were did by Spearman correlation analysis. [Findings]Red point factor is positively correlated to total citation,number of citing journals,authority factor,literature quantity,literature selection rate,quantity of AR papers,area distributing number,organization distributing number,discipline diffusion index,discipline influence index,and centrifugal rate of total citation,but it is negatively correlated to diffusion factor,cited half-life,and citing half-life. There is no correlation between red point factor and impact factor,immediacy index,non-self-cited rate,open factor,ratio of fund article,comprehensive evaluation score,and centrifugal rate of impact factor. [Conclusions]Red point factor is suitable as an important indicator for the journal evaluation. It is important for improving the visibility of papers and enhancing academic communication ability and academic authority. It can be improved by controlling the number of published papers,focusing on the timeliness of references,carefully selecting keywords of papers,and so.
引文
[1]中国科学技术信息研究所. 2017年版中国科技期刊引证报告(核心版):自然科学卷[M].北京:科学技术文献出版社,2017:9.
[2]马峥,俞征鹿.学术期刊“红点指标”的定义与应用[J].编辑学报,2018,30(1):102-104.
[3]吕小红,杨开英,张蕾.大数据时代精细加工提高科技论文显示度[J].编辑学报,2018,30(4):373-375.
[4]廖薇薇,周晓凤,陈秋莲,等.医学科技期刊青年编辑的素质提升[J].天津科技,2018,45(8):94-97.
[5]周立波,卜丽娟.从文献计量学角度提升医学期刊水平之我见[J].新闻研究导刊,2018,9(17):200-202.
[6]孙婧,周康.期刊零被引率与期刊评价指标的相关性研究——以神经病学核心期刊为例[J].中国科技期刊研究,2018,29(7):733-738.
[7]王燕.开放因子与期刊其他评价指标的相关性研究——以我国医药大学学报类期刊为例[J].情报探索,2018(9):65-68.
[8]邵作运,李秀霞. f(x)指数:期刊学术影响力评价新指标[J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(11):1194-1199.
[9]王谦,林萍,孙昌朋,等.医学期刊基金论文比与影响因子等指标的关系及影响因素[J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(6):634-638.
[10]曾玲,舒安琴,徐川平,等.医学综合类期刊载文量与影响因子关系研究[J].重庆广播电视大学学报,2016,28(5):77-80.
[11]刘雪立,方红玲,周志新,等.我国自引率不同的科技期刊文献计量学特征的对照研究[J].编辑学报,2011,23(1):8-11.
[12] Liu X L,Wang M Y. Self-citation in Chinese biomedical journals[J]. Learned Publishing,2010,23(2):93-100.
[13]汪艺桦.跟踪报道热点课题保持期刊与学科同步发展[J].中国科技期刊研究,1997,8(S1):91-92.
[14]耿艳辉.影响因子的局限性研究综述[J].中国科技期刊研究,2014,25(8):1052-1057.
[15]苏成,潘云涛,马峥,等.权威因子:一个新的期刊评价指标[J].编辑学报,2010,22(4):369-373.
[16]刘雪立,魏雅慧,盛丽娜,等.科技期刊总被引频次和影响因子构成中的自引率比较——兼谈影响因子的人为操纵倾向[J].编辑学报,2017,29(6):602-606.
[17]方红玲,董建军,盛丽娜,等.我国眼科学科技核心期刊2010—2014年主要学术指标对比研究[J].眼科,2016,25(6):413-417.
[18]许花桃. 8种出版事业类核心期刊的学术影响力分析[J].编辑之友,2012(9):59-62.
[19]黄明睿.载文量对科技期刊影响力评价的影响[J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(7):749-757.
[20]陈霄,江金戈,何志辉. 2016—2015年《华南预防医学》学术影响力动态评估[J].预防医学情报杂志,2018,34(7):1003-1006.
[21]朱清.我国外国文学期刊引用半衰期研究[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),2016,37(3):237-240.
[2]马峥,俞征鹿.学术期刊“红点指标”的定义与应用[J].编辑学报,2018,30(1):102-104.
[3]吕小红,杨开英,张蕾.大数据时代精细加工提高科技论文显示度[J].编辑学报,2018,30(4):373-375.
[4]廖薇薇,周晓凤,陈秋莲,等.医学科技期刊青年编辑的素质提升[J].天津科技,2018,45(8):94-97.
[5]周立波,卜丽娟.从文献计量学角度提升医学期刊水平之我见[J].新闻研究导刊,2018,9(17):200-202.
[6]孙婧,周康.期刊零被引率与期刊评价指标的相关性研究——以神经病学核心期刊为例[J].中国科技期刊研究,2018,29(7):733-738.
[7]王燕.开放因子与期刊其他评价指标的相关性研究——以我国医药大学学报类期刊为例[J].情报探索,2018(9):65-68.
[8]邵作运,李秀霞. f(x)指数:期刊学术影响力评价新指标[J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(11):1194-1199.
[9]王谦,林萍,孙昌朋,等.医学期刊基金论文比与影响因子等指标的关系及影响因素[J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(6):634-638.
[10]曾玲,舒安琴,徐川平,等.医学综合类期刊载文量与影响因子关系研究[J].重庆广播电视大学学报,2016,28(5):77-80.
[11]刘雪立,方红玲,周志新,等.我国自引率不同的科技期刊文献计量学特征的对照研究[J].编辑学报,2011,23(1):8-11.
[12] Liu X L,Wang M Y. Self-citation in Chinese biomedical journals[J]. Learned Publishing,2010,23(2):93-100.
[13]汪艺桦.跟踪报道热点课题保持期刊与学科同步发展[J].中国科技期刊研究,1997,8(S1):91-92.
[14]耿艳辉.影响因子的局限性研究综述[J].中国科技期刊研究,2014,25(8):1052-1057.
[15]苏成,潘云涛,马峥,等.权威因子:一个新的期刊评价指标[J].编辑学报,2010,22(4):369-373.
[16]刘雪立,魏雅慧,盛丽娜,等.科技期刊总被引频次和影响因子构成中的自引率比较——兼谈影响因子的人为操纵倾向[J].编辑学报,2017,29(6):602-606.
[17]方红玲,董建军,盛丽娜,等.我国眼科学科技核心期刊2010—2014年主要学术指标对比研究[J].眼科,2016,25(6):413-417.
[18]许花桃. 8种出版事业类核心期刊的学术影响力分析[J].编辑之友,2012(9):59-62.
[19]黄明睿.载文量对科技期刊影响力评价的影响[J].中国科技期刊研究,2015,26(7):749-757.
[20]陈霄,江金戈,何志辉. 2016—2015年《华南预防医学》学术影响力动态评估[J].预防医学情报杂志,2018,34(7):1003-1006.
[21]朱清.我国外国文学期刊引用半衰期研究[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),2016,37(3):237-240.
© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号 地址：北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编：100083 电话：办公室：(+86 10)66554848；文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新：66554700 |