用户名: 密码: 验证码:
晚清民国留学运动与中国比较文学的生成
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:The Study Abroad in Late Qing and the Formation of Chinese Comparative Literature
  • 作者:管新福
  • 英文作者:Guan Xinfu;
  • 关键词:晚清民国 ; 留学运动 ; 比较视域 ; 学科建构
  • 英文关键词:late Qing Dynasty and the Republic of China;;study abroad;;the perspective of comparison;;subject construction
  • 中文刊名:ZBJW
  • 英文刊名:Comparative Literature in China
  • 机构:贵州师范大学文学院;
  • 出版日期:2019-01-20
  • 出版单位:中国比较文学
  • 年:2019
  • 期:No.114
  • 基金:国家社科项目“近现代报刊翻译理论资料整理与研究”(编号:18BZW112)的阶段性成果之一
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:ZBJW201901011
  • 页数:17
  • CN:01
  • ISSN:31-1694/I
  • 分类号:121-137
摘要
晚清民国时段的留学运动对中国文化和文学均产生了深远影响。学成归国的留学人员,如严复、王国维、鲁迅、陈寅恪、胡适、吴宓、林语堂、朱光潜、钱钟书、傅雷、季羡林等几代学人,在诠释中国文学时能够援西入中,汇通开新,形成了文学研究的世界性眼光和比较视域,且利用域外新知为中国比较文学的学科建构做出了切实贡献,并以卓有见地的研究成果为后继者提供了可供借鉴的研究范例和方法路径,有效地推动中国文学研究的现代转型,今天仍然值得学界去认真梳理和挖掘。
        The wave of studying abroad in late Qing Dynasty and the Republic of China had a profound influence on Chinese culture and literature. The returnees,such as Yan Fu,Wang Guowei,Lu Xun,Chen Yinke,Hu Shi,Wu Mi,Lin Yutang,Zhu Guangqian,Qian Zhongshu,Fu Lei and Ji Xianlin,etc.,introduced the West into China and integrated them and made innovations when interpreting the Chinese literature. They created the literary worldview and comparative perspective. With the new knowledge from abroad,they made substantial contributions to the subject construction of Chinese Comparative Literature.With the outstanding research results,they provided study paradigms and method paths to the successors. They effectively promoted the modern transformation of Chinese literature research. The Comparative Literature research from the returnees is still worth careful study for the present academia.
引文
巴赫金:“巴赫金文论两篇”,刘宁译。《世界文学》5(1995):210-236。[Bakhtin.“Two Literary Articles of Bakhtin”(ba he jin wen lun liang pian). Trans. Liu Ning.World Literature 5(1995):210-236.]
    布吕奈尔等:《什么是比较文学》,葛雷等译。北京:北京大学出版社, 1989。[Brunel,et al. What is Comparative Literature(shen me shi bi jiao wen xue). Trans. Ge Lei et al. Beijing:Peking University Press,1989.]
    Brunetiere. European Literature, Comparative Literature in the Early Years:An Anthology of Assays.Eds. Hasn-Joachim Schulz&Phillip H.Rhein. The University of North Carolina Press,1973. 153-182.
    陈惇、孙景尧、谢天振主编:《比较文学》。高等教育出版社,1997。[Chen,Dun,Sun Jingyao and Xie Tianzhen. eds. Comparative Literature(bi jiao wen xue). Beijing:China Higher Education Press,1997.]
    陈寅恪:《金明馆丛稿二编》。北京:三联书店,2001。[Chen,Yinke. Series Manuscript of Jin Ming GuanⅡ(jin ming guan cong gao er bian)Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company,2001.]
    方孝岳:《中国文学批评》。北京:三联书店,1986。[Fang,Xiaoyue. Chinese Literary Criticism(zhong guo wen xue pi ping). Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company,1986.]
    费正清主编:《剑桥中国晚清史》。北京:中国社会科学出版社, 2011a。[Fairbank John K. ed. The Cambridge History of China Volume 10(jian qiao zhong guo wan qing shi). Beijing:China Social Sciences Publishing House,2011a.]
    ——:《剑桥中华民国史》。北京:中国社会科学出版社,2011 b。[---. The Cambridge History of China Volume 11(jian qiao zhong hua min guo shi).Beijing:China Social Sciences Publishing House,2011b.]
    傅雷“《高老头》重译本序”,罗新璋编:《翻译论集》。北京:商务印书馆, 1984。558-559。[Fu,Lei.“Preface to the Retranslation of Le Pere Goriot”(gao lao tou chong yi ben xu). Ed.Luo Xinzhang. Anthology of Translation. Beijing:The Commercial Press,1984. 558-559.]
    基亚《比较文学》,颜保译。北京:北京大学出版社, 1983。[Guyard,Marius-Francois. Comparative Literature(bi jiao wen xue). Trans. Yan Bao. Bejing:Peking University Press, 1983.]
    黑格尔:《精神现象学(上卷)》,贺麟、王玖兴译。北京:商务印书馆, 1987。[Hegel. Phenomenology of Spirit(jing shen xian xiang xue).Trans. He Lin and Wang Jiuxing.Beijing:The Commercial Press,1987.]
    胡适“建设理论集·导言”,《中国新文学大系》。上海:上海文艺出版社, 2003。1-32。[Hu,Shi.“Preface to The Theory Collection,Great Series of the Chinese New Literature”(zhong guo xin wen xue da xi jian she li lun ji dao yan). Shanghai:Shanghai Literature and Art Publishing House,2003. 1-32.]
    黄霖、黄念然:“中国文学批评近现代转型研究论纲”,《华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版)》5(2007):103-107。[Huang,Lin and Huang Nianran.“An Outline of the Study on the Modern Transformation of Chinese Literary Criticism(zhong guo wen xue pi ping jin xian dai zhuan xing yan jiu lun gang). Journal of Central China Normal University(Humanities and Social Sciences)5(2007):103-107.]
    季羡林:“中印文学比较研究论文集·序”,《北京大学比较文学研究会通讯》7(1985):1-2。[Ji,Xianlin.“Preface to The Collection of Comparative Studies on Chinese and Indian Literature”(zhong yin wen xue bi jiao yan jiu lun wen ji xu). Bulletin of the Comparative Literature Society of Peking University(7)1985:1-2.]
    蒋梦麟:《西潮·新潮》。长沙:岳麓书社,2000。[Jiang,Menglin. West and Current(xi chao xin chao). Changsha:Yue Lu Book Company,2000.]
    李亚舒、黎难秋主编:《中国科学翻译史》。武汉:湖北教育出版社,2000。[Li,Yashu and Li Nanqiu. eds. A History of Chinese Scientific Translation.(zhong guo ke xue fan yi shi). Wuhan:Hubei Education Press,2000.]
    梁启超:《清代学术概论》,《饮冰室合集(第三十四集)》。北京中华书局,1989。[Liang,Qichao. An Introduction to the Qing Dynasty Academia(qing dai xue shu gai lun). Complete Works of Yinbingshi. vol. 34. Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1989.]
    柳亚子编:《苏曼殊全集(第一册)》。北京:中国书店, 1985。[Liu,Yazi. ed. Complete Works of Su Manshu(su man shu quan ji di yi ce). vol.1. Beijing:China Book Company,1985.]
    鲁迅“摩罗诗力说”,《鲁迅全集(第一卷)》。北京:人民文学出版社,2005 a。[Lu,Xun.“On the Power of Romantic Poetry”(mo luo shi 1i shuo). Complete Works of Lu Xun. vol.1. Beijing:People's Literature Press,2005a.]
    ——:《且介亭杂文二集》,《鲁迅全集(第六卷)》。北京:人民文学出版社,2005 b。65-120。[---. Essay of Shanghai ConcessionⅡ(qie jie ting za wen er ji). Complete Works of Lu Xun. Vol.6 . Beijing:People's Literature Press,2005b. 65-120.]
    钱钟书:“林纾的翻译”,《中国翻译》11(1985):2-10。[Qian,Zhongshu.“Lin Shu's Translation”(lin shu de fan yi). Chinese Translators Journal 11(1985):2-10].
    ——:《谈艺录》。北京:中华书局, 1996。[---. On the Art of Poetry(tan yi lu). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1996.]
    秋瑾《秋瑾集》。北京:中华书局, 1962。[Qiu,in. Qiu Jin Anthology(qiu jin ji). Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1962.]
    容闳《西学东渐记·大学时代》。长沙:湖南人民出版社,1991。[Rong,Hong. Western Learning Spreads to the East·College Days(xi xue dong jian ji·da xue shi dai). Changsha:Hunan Renmin Press,1991.]
    施蛰存:“翻译文学集·导言”,《中国近代文学大系(1840-1919)(第26卷)》。上海:上海书店出版社, 2012。1-28。[Shi,Zhecun.“Preface to Translated Literature Collection”(fan yi wen xue ji·dao yan). Great Series of the Chinese Modern Literature(1840-1919)vol. 26. Shanghai:Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House,2012. 1-28.]
    舒新城:《近代中国留学史》,《民国丛书(第一编)》。上海:上海书店,1989。[Shu,Xincheng. The History of Studying Abroad in Modern China(jin dai zhong guo liu xue shi). Series of Republic of China. vol. 1. Shanghai:Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House,1989.]
    宋炳辉:“20世纪中外文学关系研究与比较文学学术空间的拓展”,《中国比较文学》4(2000):21-37。[Song,Binghui.“The Research on the Relationship Between Chinese and Foreign Literature in20 th Century and the Development of Comparative Literature Academic Space”(20 shi ji zhong wai wen xue guan xi yu bi jiao wen xue xue shu kong jian de tuo zhan). Comparative Literature in China 4(2000):21-37.]
    梵·第根:《比较文学论》,戴望舒译。长春:吉林出版集团有限责任公司,2010。[Tieghem,P. Van. On Comparative Literature(bi jiao wen xue lun). Trans. Dai Wangshu.Changchun:Jilin Publishing Group Ltd,2010.]
    王哲甫:《中国新文学运动史》,《民国丛书》第5编。上海:上海书店出版社, 1990。[Wang,Zhefu. The History of Chinese New Literature Movement(zhong guo xin wen xue yun dong shi). Series of Republic of China. vol. 5. Shanghai:Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House,1990.]
    王国维:“哲学辨惑”,《王国维文集(第三卷)》。北京:中国文史出版社, 1997。3-5。[Wang,Guowei.“Philosophy Explanation”(zhe xue bian huo). Collected Works of Wang Guowei.vol.3. Beijing:China Literature and History Publishing House,1997. 3-5.]
    韦勒克、沃伦:《文学理论》,刘象愚等译。北京:文化艺术出版社,2010。[Wellek,Rene and Austin Warren. Theory of Literature(wen xue li lun). Trans. Liu Xiangyu et al. Beijing:Culture and Arts Press,2010.]
    韦勒克:“比较文学的名称和实质”,北京师范大学中文系比较文学研究组编:《比较文学研究资料》。北京:北京师范大学出版社,1986。[Wellek,René.“The Name and Nature of Comparative Literature”(bi jiao wen xue de ming cheng yu shi zhi). Ed. Comparative Literature Research Group of Department of Chinese Language and Literature in Beijing Normal University. Comparative Literature Research Material.Beijing:Beijing Normal University Press, 1986.]
    吴康“比较文学绪论”,《文史汇刊》. Vol.1,2(1935):31-67。[Wu,Kang.“An Introduction to Comparative Literature”(bi jiao wen xue xu lu). Literature and History Magazine. Vol. 1,2(1935):31-67.]
    吴组缃等:“总序”,《中国近代文学大系(1840-1919).(第1卷)》。上海:上海书店出版社,2012。1-24。[Wu,Zuxiang. et al. eds.“Preface”(zong xu). The Great Series of the Chinese Modern Literature(1840-1919)vol.1. Shanghai:Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House,2012. 1-24.]
    熊月之:《西学东渐与晚清社会》。上海:上海人民出版社,1994。[Xiong,Yuezhi. Western Learning Spreads to the East and Society in Late Qing Dynasty(xi xue dong jian yu wan qing she hui). Shanghai:Shanghai People Press,1994.]
    夏志清:《中国现代小说史》,刘绍铭等译。台北:台湾传记文学社,1979。[Xia,Zhiqing. The History of Chinese Modern Fiction(zhong guo xian dai xiao shuo shi). Trans.Liu Shaoming. et l. Taipei:Taiwan Biography Literary Press.1979.]
    徐中玉:《中国近代文学大系(1840-1919)·文学理论集·导言(第一卷)》。上海:上海书店,2012。1-43。[Xu,Zhongyu. Preface. Theory of Literature Collection of Great Series of the Chinese Modern Literature(1840-1919)vol.1.(zhong guo jin dai wen xue da xi wen xue li lun ji dao yan).Shanghai:Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House,2012. 1-43.]
    杨乃乔:《比较文学概论》。北京:北京大学出版社,2006。[Yang,Naiqiao. An Introduction to Comparative Literature(bi jiao wen xue gai lun). Bejing:Peking University Press,2006.]
    杨周翰:《镜子与七巧板》。北京:中国社会科学出版社,1990。[Yang,Zhouhan. Mirror and the Jigsaw(jing zi yu qi qiao ban). Beijing:China Social Sciences Publishing House,1990.]
    叶嘉莹:《王国维及其文学批评》。北京:北京大学出版社,2008。[Ye,Jiaying. Wang Guowei and His Literary Criticism(wang guo wei ji qi wen xue pi ping).Beijing:Peking University Press,2008.]
    袁进《中国文学的近代变革》。桂林:广西师范大学出版社,2006。[Yuan,Jin. The Modern Evolution of Chinese Literature(zhong guo wen xue de jin dai bian ge).Guilin:Guangxi Normal University press,2006.]
    乐黛云:“帝国霸权·文化自觉·比较文学”,《中国比较文学》1(2004):47-60。[Yue,Daiyun:“Imperialist Hegemony, Cultural Self-consciousness,Comparative Literature”(di guo ba quan wen hua zi jue bi jiao wen xue). Comparative Literature in China 1(2004):47-60.]
    ——.“1900-1910:中国比较文学的发端”,《东方丛刊》4(2006):1-24。[---.“1900-1910:The Initiation of Comparative Literature in China”(1900-1910:zhong guo bi jiao wen xue de fa duan). A Multidimensional Study of Orientalism 4(2006):1-24.]
    查明建:“译介学:渊源、性质、内容与方法—兼评比较文学论著、教材中有关”译介学“的论述”,《中国比较文学》1(2005):41-62。[Zha,Mingjian.“Origin,Nature,Content and Method of Translation Studies:on Comparative Literature and the Translation Studies in Comparative Literature Works,Textbooks”(yi jie xue:yuan yuan xing zhi nei rong yu fang fa-jian ping bi jiao wen xue lun zhu jiao cai zhong you guan yi jie xue de lun shu). Comparative Literature in China 1(2005):41-62.]
    张隆溪:“钱钟书谈比较文学与‘文学比较’”,《读书》10(1981)132-139。[Zhang,Longxi.“Qian Zhongshu's Comparative Literature and Literary Comparison”(qian zhong shu tan bi jiao wen xue yu wen xue bi jiao). Reading Magazine10(1981):132-139.]
    郑春“留学背景与中国现代文学的开放”,《文学评论》4(2003):140-148。[Zheng,Chun.“Background of Studying Abroad and the Opening of Contemporary Literature”(liu xue bei jing yu zhong guo xian dai wen xue de kai fang).Literary Review 4(2003):140-148.]
    周作人:“序”,《陀螺》,黄嘉德编:《翻译论集》。上海:上海书店,1940。52-54。[Zhou,Zuoren.“Preface of Gyroscope”(xu tuo luo). Ed. Huang Jiade. Anthology of Translation.Shanghai:Shanghai Book Company,1940. 52-54.]
    ——:“文学上的俄国与中国”,《小说月报》, 1921年12月号,附录:1-6。[---.“Literature of Russia and China”(wen xue shang de e guo yu zhong guo). Fiction Monthly12(1921). 1-6.]
    朱光潜:“五四以后的翻译文学”,《朱光潜全集(第9卷)》。合肥安徽教育出版社,1993a。237。[Zhu,Guangqian.“The Translated Literature after the May 4th Movement”(wu si yi hou de fan yi wen xue). Complete Works of Zhu Guangqian. vol. 9. Hefei:Anhui Education Press,1993a. 237.]
    ——:“文学的比较研究”,《朱光潜全集(第10卷)》。合肥:安徽教育出版社, 1993b。620。[---.“A Comparative Study of Literature”(wen xue de bi jiao yan jiu). Complete Works of Zhu Guangqian. vol.10.Hefei:Anhui Education Press.1993b. 620.]
    朱自清:《朱自清古典文学论文集》。上海:上海古籍出版社,1981。[Zhu,Ziqing. Collected Essays on Classical Chinese Literature(zhu zi qing gu dian wen xue lun wen ji). Shanghai:Shanghai Classics Publishing House,1981.]
    诸宗元、顾燮光:“译书经眼录·序例”,《中国近代出版史料(近代二编)》,张静庐辑注。上海:上海书店,2003。95-101。[Zhu,Zongyuan and Gu Xieguang.“Instructation and Example of Translation Horizon”(yi shu jing yan lu xu li). Modern Publishing Historical Materials in China. vol.2. Shanghai:Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House,2003. 95-101.]

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700