面向体系贡献率的装备体系评估方法研究综述
|
摘要
面向体系贡献率,总结了武器装备体系贡献率评估的研究现状并分析了研究的技术难点,对基于作战环、复杂网络、证据推理、灰靶理论、贝叶斯网络、结构方程模型、探索性分析等目前用于评估武器装备体系贡献率的方法进行了综述,对比分析了不同评估方法的优缺点。从装备体系构成及贡献率评估特点出发,采用基于作战环和复杂网络的武器装备体系评估方法,能够全面反映装备在体系作战中的各类关系,支持从体系的角度对武器装备的贡献率进行多维度评估,更能贴近评估装备对于体系贡献的衡量。
From the perspective of the evaluation on the contribution rate of weapon system of systems,this article summarizes the current research status and the technical difficulties in this research field.More specifically,the methods based on the combat loop,complex network,evidence reasoning,gray target theory,Bayes network,the structural equation model,exploratory analysis etc.are used to evaluate the contribution rate of weapon equipment system of systems.Furthermore,their advantages and disadvantages are compared and analyzed.Base on the comparisons,the method based on operation loops and complex networks which takes into consideration the relations between different weapons is able to assess the contribution of the weapon equipment in multiple dimensions.Hence,this method can provide more scientific and reasonable results to decision makers.
From the perspective of the evaluation on the contribution rate of weapon system of systems,this article summarizes the current research status and the technical difficulties in this research field.More specifically,the methods based on the combat loop,complex network,evidence reasoning,gray target theory,Bayes network,the structural equation model,exploratory analysis etc.are used to evaluate the contribution rate of weapon equipment system of systems.Furthermore,their advantages and disadvantages are compared and analyzed.Base on the comparisons,the method based on operation loops and complex networks which takes into consideration the relations between different weapons is able to assess the contribution of the weapon equipment in multiple dimensions.Hence,this method can provide more scientific and reasonable results to decision makers.
引文
[1]刘新亮.技术引入对武器装备体系能力影响的评估方法研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2009.LIU X L.Research on assessment method of the impact of technology introduction on weapon equipment system capability[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2009.
[2]李际超,杨克巍,张小可,等.基于武器装备体系作战网络模型的装备贡献度评估[J].复杂系统与复杂性科学,2016,13(3):1-7.LI J C,YANG K W,ZHANG X K,et al.Equipment contribution degree evaluation method based on combat network of weapon system-of-systems[J].Complex Systems and Complexity Science,2016,13(3):1-7.
[3]罗小明,杨娟,何榕,等.基于任务-能力-结构-演化的武器装备体系贡献度评估与示例分析[J].装备学院学报,2016,27(3):7LUO X,YANG J,HE R,et al.Research and demonstration on contribution evaluation of weapon equipment system based on task-capability-structare-evolution[J].Journal of Equipment Academy,2016,27(3):7-13.
[4]李炜,张恒,王玮.评价舰船装备体系贡献度的一种方法[J].舰船科学技术,2015,37(10):1-5.LI W,ZHANG H,WANG W.An evaluation method for the contribution margin of a ship in the combat system of systems[J].Ship Science and Technology,2015,37(10):1-5.
[5]李怡勇,李智,管清波,等.武器装备体系贡献度评估刍议与示例[J].装备学院学报,2015,26(4):5-10.LI Y Y,LI Z,GUAN Q B,et al.Discussion and demonstration on contribution evaiuation of weapon equipment system[J].Journal of Equipment Academy,2015,26(4):5-10.
[6]韩智国.舰船评估指标体系及评估方法研究[D].大连:大连理工大学,2008.HAN Z G.Research on ship assessment index system and evaluation method[D].Dalian:Dalian University of Technology,2008.
[7]罗鹏程,傅攀峰,周经伦.武器装备体系能力评估框架[J].系统工程与电子技术,2005,27(1):72-75.LOU P C,FU P F,ZHOU J L.Framework to evaluate the combat capability of weapons SoS[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2005,27(1):72-75.
[8]鲁延京.基于体系结构关系分析的武器装备体系作战能力评估方法及应用[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2012.LU Y J.Evaluation method and application of weapon equipment system operational capability based on architectural relation analysis[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2012.
[9]赵相安.基于多视图的武器装备体系需求开发方法研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2010:42-47.ZHAO X A.Research on requirement development method of weapon equipment system based on multi-view[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2010:42-47.
[10]朱枫,韩晓明,南海阳.防空导弹反临近空间武器作战能力评估[J].火力与指挥控制,2017,42(3):8-12.ZHU F,HAN X M,NAN H Y.Combat capability evaluation of air defense missile anti-near space weapon[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2017,42(3):8-12.
[11]曹加勇,张占月.基于TOPSIS的同步轨道通信卫星综合能力评估[J].指挥控制与仿真,2011,33(1):61-63.CAO J Y,ZHANG Z Y.Synthesis capability evaluation of geostationary communication satellite based on TOPSIS method[J].Command Control&Simulation,2011,33(1):61-63.
[12]蔺美青,杨峰,李群,等.基于TOPSIS评估算子的装甲装备作战能力评估[J].指挥控制与仿真,2006,28(2):56-59.LIN M Q,YANG F,LI Q,et al.Armored equipment operational capability evaluation based on TOPSIS evaluation operators[J].Command Control&Simulation,2006,28(2):56-59.
[13]刘洪引,李体方,亓尧,等.基于熵权TOPSIS的防空导弹生存能力评价[J].弹箭与制导学报,2015(2):50-53.LIU H Y,LI T F,QI Y,et al.Entropy weight and TOPSIS based air defense missile survivability evaluation[J].Journal of Projectiles,Rockets,Missiles and Guidance,2015(2):50-53.
[14]师俊朋,胡国平,李涛.基于改进灰色关联算法的雷达反隐身能力评估[J].哈尔滨工业大学学报,2015,47(3):116-121.SHI J P,HU G P,LI T.Evaluation of anti-stealth ability of radar on improved grey correlation algorithm[J].Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology,2015,47(3):116-121.
[15]黄勇,纪永清,纪军,等.海军水面舰艇作战指数计算[J].火力与指挥控制,2004,29(1):91-94.HUANG Y,JI Y Q,JI J,et al.The research on calculating the battle index of naval ground warship[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2004,29(1):91-94.
[16]郑瑶,席泽敏,许杰.基于灰色关联分析的备件保障能力评估方法[J].兵器装备工程学报,2014,35(3):62-64.ZHENG Y,XI Z M,XU J.Spares support capability evaluation based on the grey correlation analysis[J].Journal of Sichuan Ordnance,2014,35(3):62-64.
[17]邵杰.基于AHP与改进DEA方法的装甲兵部队信息化作战能力评估[J].兵工自动化,2017,36(9):78-80.SHAO J.Evaluation method of informationi-zation operation capability of armored forces based on AHP and modified DEA[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2017,36(9):78-80.
[18]王涛,端木京顺,王晓钧.基于模糊综合评价DEA方法的信息化部队作战能力评估[J].军事运筹与系统工程,2006,20(3):69-72.WANG T,DUANMU J S,WANG X J.Based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation and data envelopment analysis in evaluating the capability of information army[J].Military Operations Research and Systems Engineering,2006,20(3):69-72.
[19]安静,孟祥劝,李国友.数据包络分析在防空兵作战方案优选中的应用[J].兵工自动化,2006,25(9):9-10.AN J,MENG X Q,LI G Y.Application of data envelopment analysis in choosing optimal operation plan for air defense forces[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2006,25(9):9-10.
[20]JIANG J,LI X,ZHOU Z J,et al.Weapon system capability assessment under uncertainty based on the evidential reasoning approach[J].Expert Systems with Applications,2011,38(11):13773-13784.
[21]程贲,姜江,谭跃进,等.基于证据推理的武器装备体系能力需求满足度评估方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,2011,31(11):2210-2216.CHENG B,JIANG J,TAN Y J,et al.A novel approach for WSoS capability requirement satisfactory degree evaluation using evidential reasoning[J].Systems Engineering-Theory&Practice,2011,31(11):2210-2216.
[22]和钰.基于RIMER方法的反导武器装备体系作战能力贡献率研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2017.HE Y.Research on contribution rate of operational capability of anti-ballistic weapon system based on RIMER method[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2017.
[23]MUSHARRAF M,SMITH J,KHAN F,et al.Assessing offshore emergency evacuation behavior in a virtual environment using a Bayesian network approach[J].Reliability Engineering&System Safety,2016,152:28-37.
[24]鲁延京,程贲,陈英武,等.基于BN的武器装备体系能力重要度分析[J].系统工程与电子技术,2012,34(8):1605-1612.LU Y J,CHENG B,CHEN Y W,et al.Capability weightiness degree analysis of weaponry system-of-systems based on BN theory[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2012,34(8):1605-1612.
[25]彭征明,李云芝,罗小明.基于贝叶斯网的作战效能评估方法研究[J].装备学院学报,2007,18(2):105-109.PENG Z M,LI Y Z,LUO X M.Research on method of force effectiveness evaluation based on Bayesian belief net[J].Journal of Equipment Academy,2007,18(2):105-109.
[26]LEE B,SEO Y.A Design of operational test&evaluation system for weapon systems thru process-based modeling[J].Journal of the Korea Society for Simulation,2014,23(4):211-218.
[27]许秉军,李孟军,李兴兵,等.装甲装备体系对抗仿真评估系统研究[C]∥系统仿真技术及其应用学术会议论文集,2007.XU B J,LI M J,LI X B,et al.Research on simulation and evaluation system of armored equipment system-of-systems combat[C]∥Proc.of the System Simulation Technology and its Application,2007:687-692.
[28]李兴兵,谭跃进,杨克巍,等.基于体系对抗仿真的装甲装备体系效能评估[J].指挥控制与仿真,2008,30(6):59-62.LI X B,TAN Y J,YANG K W,et al.Evaluation on armor weapon system-of-system effectiveness based on system-ofsystem combat simulation[J].Command Control&Simulation,2008,30(6):59-62.
[29]雷永林,李群,杨峰,等.武器装备效能仿真的可组合建模框架研究[J].系统工程理论与实践,2013,33(11):2954-2966.LEI Y L,LI Q,YANG Q,et al.A composable modeling framework for weapon systems effectiveness simulation[J].Systems Engineering-Theory&Practice,2013,33(11):2954-2966.
[30]黄炎焱,杨峰,刘晨,等.支持追溯分析的武器装备仿真评估框架及应用[J].系统仿真学报,2006,18(5):1360-1365.HUANG Y Y,YANG F,LIU C,et al.Simulation based evaluation framework of weapon equipment supporting traceability and its application[J].Journal of System Simulation,2006,18(5):1360-1365.
[31]蔺美青,杨峰,李群,等.基于仿真的装甲装备作战效能影响因素分析[J].计算机仿真,2006,23(8):9-11.LIN M Q,YANG F,LI Q,et al.Analysis of the factors affecting armor weapon system operational effectiveness based on simulation[J].Computer Simulation,2006,23(8):9-11.
[32]雷永林,姚剑,朱宁,等.武器装备效能仿真系统WESS[J].系统仿真学报,2017,29(6):1244-1252.LIU Y L,YAO J,ZHU N,et al.Weapon effectiveness simulation system(WESS)[J].Journal of System Simulation,2017,29(6):1244-1252.
[33]DAVIS P K.Exploratory analysis enabled by multi-resolution,multi-perspective modeling[C]∥Proc.of the Winter Simulation Conference,2000.
[34]YAU P E.An exploratory analysis on the effects of information superiority on battle outcomes[R].Monterey:Naval Postgraduate School,2002.
[35]JOHNSON S E,LIBICKI M C,TREVERTON G F.New challenges,new tools for defense decision-making[M].Santa Monica:RAND Corporation,2003.
[36]曾宪钊,蔡游飞,黄谦,等.基于作战仿真和探索性分析的海战效能评估[J].系统仿真学报,2005,17(3):763-766.ZENG X Z,CAI Y F,HUANG Q,et al.Simulation and exploratory analysis based navy-battle effectiveness evaluation[J].Journal of System Simulation,2005,17(3):763-766.
[37]李兴兵.武器装备体系作战效能探索性评估与分析方法及应用研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2010.LI X B.Exploratory evaluation and analysis method of weapon equipment system operational effectiveness and its application[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2010.
[38]李志猛,谈群,汪彦明,等.基于探索性分析的信息系统效能评估方法[J].科学技术与工程,2009,22(9):6702-6707.LI Z M,TAN Q,WANG Y M,et al.Effectiveness evaluation method for information systems based on exploratory analysis[J].Science Technology and Engineering,2009,22(9):6702-6707.
[39]刘明辉,杨峰,王磊,等.基于SVR的反舰导弹作战效能探索性评估方法[J].计算机仿真,2009,26(8):9-12.LIU M H,YANG F,WANG L,et al.An operational effectiveness exploratory evaluation method of anti-ship missile based on support vector regression[J].Computer Simulation,2009,26(8):9-12.
[40]刘德生,郭静.基于探索性分析方法的导弹对抗作战效能评估[J].微计算机信息,2010,26(25):30-32.LIU D S,GUO J.Missile countermeasure effectiveness evaluation based on exploratory analysis method[J].Control&Automation,2010,26(25):30-32.
[41]XIA W,LIU X,MENG S,et al.Efficiency evaluation research of missile weapon system based on the ADC-model[C]∥Proc.of the International Conference on Machinery,Materials,Environment,Biotechnology and Computer,2016.
[42]陈健,滕克难,杨春周.基于ADC法的反卫装备体系打击效能评估模型研究[J].舰船电子工程,2014,34(3):116-119.CHEN J,TENG K N,YANG C Z.Effectiveness evaluation model of anti-satellite equipment SoS based on ADC method[J].Ship Electronic Engineering,2014,34(3):116-119.
[43]栾孝丰,温瑞.基于UML和ADC法的舰载反舰导弹武器系统效能评估[J].计算机与数字工程,2010,38(8):135-137,149.LUAN X F,WEN R.Evaluation for ship-to-ship missile weapon system effectiveness based on UML and ADC method[J].Computer and Digital Engineering,2010,38(8):135-137,149.
[44]刘花云,张贤椿.基于ADC的导弹武器系统效能评估方法[J].兵工自动化,2015,34(8):11-14.LIU H Y,ZHANG X C.Effectiveness evaluation method of missile weapon system based on ADC[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2015,34(8):11-14.
[45]CHENG E W L,LI H.Analytic hierarchy process:an approach to determine measures for business performance[J].Measuring Business Excellence,2001,5(3):30-37.
[46]郑孝勇,姚景顺.基于模糊层次分析法的雷达效能评估方法[J].现代雷达,2002,24(2):7-9.ZHENG X Y,YAO J S.A method to evaluate the effectiveness of a radar based on FAHP[J].Modern Radar,2002,24(2):7-9.
[47]吴智辉,张多林,谢磊峰.基于层次分析法的防空信息战效能评估[J].系统工程与电子技术,2004,26(2):209-211.WU Z H,ZHANG D L,XIE L F.Evaluation of the operational effectiveness of the information warfare of air defense[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2004,26(2):209-211.
[48]段绍展.层次分析法在电子武器效能评估中的应用[J].电子信息对抗技术,2006,21(1):38-40.DUAN S Z.AHP application in EW weapon efficiency evaluation[J].Electronic Information Warfare Technology,2006,21(1):38-40.
[49]董超,倪明放,杨盘隆,等.层次分析法在战术互联网效能评估中的应用[J].运筹与管理,2006,15(3):119-124.DONG C,NI M F,YANG P L,et al.Effectiveness evaluation of TI based on AHP[J].Operations Research and Management Science,2006,15(3):119-124.
[50]史睿冰,姚兴太,史圣兵,等.基于层次分析法的通信系统效能评估[J].计算机工程与设计,2013,34(12):4131-4136.SHI R B,YAO X T,SHI S B,et al.Effectiveness evaluation of communication system based on AHP[J].Computer Engineering and Design,2013,34(12):4131-4136.
[51]卜广志.武器装备体系的体系结构与体系效能[J].系统工程与电子技术,2006,28(10):1544-1548.BU G Z.Study on the architecture and effectiveness for armament systems[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2006,28(10):1544-1548.
[52]CARES J R.An information age combat model[M].Newport:Alidade Incorporated,2004:85-90.
[53]DELLER S,BELL M I,BOWLING S R,et al.Applying the information age combat model:quantitative analysis of network centric operations[J].The International C2Journal,2009(1):24-26.
[54]田旭光,朱元昌,邱彦强.指挥与控制系统复杂网络形式化建模分析[J].电光与控制,2012,19(7):23-27.TIAN X G,ZHU Y C,QIU Y Q.Formalized modeling and analysis for C2based on complex networks[J].Electronics Optics&Control,2012,19(7):23-27.
[55]金伟新.体系对抗复杂网络建模与仿真[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2010.JIN W X.SoS-Ops M&S based on the complex network[M].Beijing:Electronic Industry Press,2010.
[56]谭跃进,张小可,杨克巍.武器装备体系网络化描述与建模方法研究[J].系统管理杂志,2012,21(6):781-786.TAN Y J,ZHANG X K,YANG K W.Research on networked description and modeling methods of armament system-ofsystems[J].Journal of Systems&Management,2012,21(6):781-786.
[57]孙建彬.基于作战环的反导装备体系形式化建模与能力评估方法[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2015.SUN J B.Formal modeling and capability assessment method of anti-missile equipment system based on combat ring[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2015.
[58]LI J,FU C,CHEN Y,et al.An operational efficiency evaluationmethod for weapon system-of-systems combat networks based on operation loop[C]∥Proc.of the IEEE International Conference on System of Systems Engineering,2014:219-223.
[59]CHI Y,LI J C,YANG K W,et al.An equipment offering degree evaluation method for weapon system-of-systems combat network based on operation loop[C]∥Proc.of the 22nd International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management,2015:477-488.
[60]商慧琳.武器装备体系作战网络建模及能力评估方法研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2013:72-73.SHANG H L.Research on modeling and capability assessment of weapon and equipment systems operational network[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2013:72-73.
[61]WU J,TAN S Y,TAN Y J,et al.Analysis of invulnerability in complex networks based on natural connectivity[J].Complex Systems&Complexity Science,2014,11(1):77-86.
[62]LI J,TAN Y,YANG K,et al.Structural robustness of combat networks of weapon system-of-systems based on the operation loop[J].International Journal of Systems Science,2016,48(3):659-674.
[63]张会.武器装备体系连通性评估方法研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2008.ZHANG H.Research on connectivity assessment method of weapon equipment system[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2008.
[64]王宏宇,吴纬,魏艳艳.基于超网络模型武器装备体系抗毁性分析[J].系统工程与电子技术,2017,39(8):1782-1787.WANG H,WU W,WEI Y Y.Weapon system-of-systems invulnerability analysis based on super network model[J].Systems Engineering&Electronics,2017,39(8):1782-1787.
[65]NEALE M C,HUNTER M D,PRITIKIN J N,et al.OpenMx2.0:extended structural equation and statistical modeling[J].Psychometrika,2016,81(2):535.
[66]罗小明,朱延雷,何栊.武器装备体系结构贡献度评估[J].装甲兵工程学报,2016,30(4):1-5.LUO X M,HE R,ZHU Y L.Research on evaluation of contribution to weapon equipment system architecture[J].Journal of Academy of Armored Force Engineering,2016,30(4):1-5.
[67]DENG J.Application of grey system theory in China[C]∥Proc.of the International Symposium on Uncertainty Modeling and Analysis,1990:285-291.
[68]常雷雷,张小可,李孟军.基于灰靶理论的武器装备体系技术贡献度评估[J].兵工自动化,2010,29(10):13-19.CHANG L L,ZHANG X K,LI M J.Weapon system of system technology contribution evaluation based on Grey target theory[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2010,29(10):13-19.
[69]吕惠文,武庆春,张炜.基于灰色证据理论的装备体系贡献率评估[J].军事交通学院学报,2017,19(5):22-27.LH W,WU Q C,ZHANG W,et al.Equipment system contribution evaluation based on gray evidence theory[J].Journal of Academy of Military Transportation,2017,19(5):22-27.
[70]HUANG G,SU L.Effectiveness evaluation analysis of weapon equipment system based on weighted gray relational degree[J].Information Engineering,2015,4:33-37.
[71]ERDOS P,RENYI A.On the evolution of random graphs.Publicationes Mathematicae,1959,6:290-297.
[72]刘磊,荆涛,吴小勇.武器装备体系演化的评估方法研究[J].系统仿真学报,2006,18(2):621-622.LIU L,JING T,WU X Y.Research on evaluation of armament system of systems evolution[J].Journal of System Simulation,2006,18(2):621-622.
[73]张婷婷,王智学.C4ISR体系演化过程中可靠性分析与评估[J].指挥与控制学报,2015,1(4):439-440.ZHANG T T,WANG Z X.Reliability of system of systems evolution processes analysis and valuation[J].Journal of Command and Control,2015,1(4):439-440.
[74]温睿,陈小青,马亚平,等.基于边权拓补的作战体系演化生长模型[J].系统工程学报,2011,26(2):282-285.WEN R,CHEN X Q,MA Y P,et al.Evolutionary model for military forces system of systems based on topological weighed networks[J].Journal of Systems Engineering,2011,26(2):282-285.
[75]王寿彪,李新明,杨凡德,等.武器装备体系演化研究[J].火力与指挥控制,2017,42(3):1-3.WANG S B,LI X M,YANG F D,et al.Research progress on evolution of weapon equipment system of systems[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2017,42(3):1-3.
[76]贾子英,闫飞龙,唐岩辉.系统演化的作战体系对抗结构模型[J].火力与指挥控制,2013,38(9):91-92.JIA Z Y,YAN F L,TANG Y H.Structure model for SoS combat base on system evolution[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2013,38(9):91-92.
[2]李际超,杨克巍,张小可,等.基于武器装备体系作战网络模型的装备贡献度评估[J].复杂系统与复杂性科学,2016,13(3):1-7.LI J C,YANG K W,ZHANG X K,et al.Equipment contribution degree evaluation method based on combat network of weapon system-of-systems[J].Complex Systems and Complexity Science,2016,13(3):1-7.
[3]罗小明,杨娟,何榕,等.基于任务-能力-结构-演化的武器装备体系贡献度评估与示例分析[J].装备学院学报,2016,27(3):7LUO X,YANG J,HE R,et al.Research and demonstration on contribution evaluation of weapon equipment system based on task-capability-structare-evolution[J].Journal of Equipment Academy,2016,27(3):7-13.
[4]李炜,张恒,王玮.评价舰船装备体系贡献度的一种方法[J].舰船科学技术,2015,37(10):1-5.LI W,ZHANG H,WANG W.An evaluation method for the contribution margin of a ship in the combat system of systems[J].Ship Science and Technology,2015,37(10):1-5.
[5]李怡勇,李智,管清波,等.武器装备体系贡献度评估刍议与示例[J].装备学院学报,2015,26(4):5-10.LI Y Y,LI Z,GUAN Q B,et al.Discussion and demonstration on contribution evaiuation of weapon equipment system[J].Journal of Equipment Academy,2015,26(4):5-10.
[6]韩智国.舰船评估指标体系及评估方法研究[D].大连:大连理工大学,2008.HAN Z G.Research on ship assessment index system and evaluation method[D].Dalian:Dalian University of Technology,2008.
[7]罗鹏程,傅攀峰,周经伦.武器装备体系能力评估框架[J].系统工程与电子技术,2005,27(1):72-75.LOU P C,FU P F,ZHOU J L.Framework to evaluate the combat capability of weapons SoS[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2005,27(1):72-75.
[8]鲁延京.基于体系结构关系分析的武器装备体系作战能力评估方法及应用[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2012.LU Y J.Evaluation method and application of weapon equipment system operational capability based on architectural relation analysis[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2012.
[9]赵相安.基于多视图的武器装备体系需求开发方法研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2010:42-47.ZHAO X A.Research on requirement development method of weapon equipment system based on multi-view[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2010:42-47.
[10]朱枫,韩晓明,南海阳.防空导弹反临近空间武器作战能力评估[J].火力与指挥控制,2017,42(3):8-12.ZHU F,HAN X M,NAN H Y.Combat capability evaluation of air defense missile anti-near space weapon[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2017,42(3):8-12.
[11]曹加勇,张占月.基于TOPSIS的同步轨道通信卫星综合能力评估[J].指挥控制与仿真,2011,33(1):61-63.CAO J Y,ZHANG Z Y.Synthesis capability evaluation of geostationary communication satellite based on TOPSIS method[J].Command Control&Simulation,2011,33(1):61-63.
[12]蔺美青,杨峰,李群,等.基于TOPSIS评估算子的装甲装备作战能力评估[J].指挥控制与仿真,2006,28(2):56-59.LIN M Q,YANG F,LI Q,et al.Armored equipment operational capability evaluation based on TOPSIS evaluation operators[J].Command Control&Simulation,2006,28(2):56-59.
[13]刘洪引,李体方,亓尧,等.基于熵权TOPSIS的防空导弹生存能力评价[J].弹箭与制导学报,2015(2):50-53.LIU H Y,LI T F,QI Y,et al.Entropy weight and TOPSIS based air defense missile survivability evaluation[J].Journal of Projectiles,Rockets,Missiles and Guidance,2015(2):50-53.
[14]师俊朋,胡国平,李涛.基于改进灰色关联算法的雷达反隐身能力评估[J].哈尔滨工业大学学报,2015,47(3):116-121.SHI J P,HU G P,LI T.Evaluation of anti-stealth ability of radar on improved grey correlation algorithm[J].Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology,2015,47(3):116-121.
[15]黄勇,纪永清,纪军,等.海军水面舰艇作战指数计算[J].火力与指挥控制,2004,29(1):91-94.HUANG Y,JI Y Q,JI J,et al.The research on calculating the battle index of naval ground warship[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2004,29(1):91-94.
[16]郑瑶,席泽敏,许杰.基于灰色关联分析的备件保障能力评估方法[J].兵器装备工程学报,2014,35(3):62-64.ZHENG Y,XI Z M,XU J.Spares support capability evaluation based on the grey correlation analysis[J].Journal of Sichuan Ordnance,2014,35(3):62-64.
[17]邵杰.基于AHP与改进DEA方法的装甲兵部队信息化作战能力评估[J].兵工自动化,2017,36(9):78-80.SHAO J.Evaluation method of informationi-zation operation capability of armored forces based on AHP and modified DEA[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2017,36(9):78-80.
[18]王涛,端木京顺,王晓钧.基于模糊综合评价DEA方法的信息化部队作战能力评估[J].军事运筹与系统工程,2006,20(3):69-72.WANG T,DUANMU J S,WANG X J.Based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation and data envelopment analysis in evaluating the capability of information army[J].Military Operations Research and Systems Engineering,2006,20(3):69-72.
[19]安静,孟祥劝,李国友.数据包络分析在防空兵作战方案优选中的应用[J].兵工自动化,2006,25(9):9-10.AN J,MENG X Q,LI G Y.Application of data envelopment analysis in choosing optimal operation plan for air defense forces[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2006,25(9):9-10.
[20]JIANG J,LI X,ZHOU Z J,et al.Weapon system capability assessment under uncertainty based on the evidential reasoning approach[J].Expert Systems with Applications,2011,38(11):13773-13784.
[21]程贲,姜江,谭跃进,等.基于证据推理的武器装备体系能力需求满足度评估方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,2011,31(11):2210-2216.CHENG B,JIANG J,TAN Y J,et al.A novel approach for WSoS capability requirement satisfactory degree evaluation using evidential reasoning[J].Systems Engineering-Theory&Practice,2011,31(11):2210-2216.
[22]和钰.基于RIMER方法的反导武器装备体系作战能力贡献率研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2017.HE Y.Research on contribution rate of operational capability of anti-ballistic weapon system based on RIMER method[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2017.
[23]MUSHARRAF M,SMITH J,KHAN F,et al.Assessing offshore emergency evacuation behavior in a virtual environment using a Bayesian network approach[J].Reliability Engineering&System Safety,2016,152:28-37.
[24]鲁延京,程贲,陈英武,等.基于BN的武器装备体系能力重要度分析[J].系统工程与电子技术,2012,34(8):1605-1612.LU Y J,CHENG B,CHEN Y W,et al.Capability weightiness degree analysis of weaponry system-of-systems based on BN theory[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2012,34(8):1605-1612.
[25]彭征明,李云芝,罗小明.基于贝叶斯网的作战效能评估方法研究[J].装备学院学报,2007,18(2):105-109.PENG Z M,LI Y Z,LUO X M.Research on method of force effectiveness evaluation based on Bayesian belief net[J].Journal of Equipment Academy,2007,18(2):105-109.
[26]LEE B,SEO Y.A Design of operational test&evaluation system for weapon systems thru process-based modeling[J].Journal of the Korea Society for Simulation,2014,23(4):211-218.
[27]许秉军,李孟军,李兴兵,等.装甲装备体系对抗仿真评估系统研究[C]∥系统仿真技术及其应用学术会议论文集,2007.XU B J,LI M J,LI X B,et al.Research on simulation and evaluation system of armored equipment system-of-systems combat[C]∥Proc.of the System Simulation Technology and its Application,2007:687-692.
[28]李兴兵,谭跃进,杨克巍,等.基于体系对抗仿真的装甲装备体系效能评估[J].指挥控制与仿真,2008,30(6):59-62.LI X B,TAN Y J,YANG K W,et al.Evaluation on armor weapon system-of-system effectiveness based on system-ofsystem combat simulation[J].Command Control&Simulation,2008,30(6):59-62.
[29]雷永林,李群,杨峰,等.武器装备效能仿真的可组合建模框架研究[J].系统工程理论与实践,2013,33(11):2954-2966.LEI Y L,LI Q,YANG Q,et al.A composable modeling framework for weapon systems effectiveness simulation[J].Systems Engineering-Theory&Practice,2013,33(11):2954-2966.
[30]黄炎焱,杨峰,刘晨,等.支持追溯分析的武器装备仿真评估框架及应用[J].系统仿真学报,2006,18(5):1360-1365.HUANG Y Y,YANG F,LIU C,et al.Simulation based evaluation framework of weapon equipment supporting traceability and its application[J].Journal of System Simulation,2006,18(5):1360-1365.
[31]蔺美青,杨峰,李群,等.基于仿真的装甲装备作战效能影响因素分析[J].计算机仿真,2006,23(8):9-11.LIN M Q,YANG F,LI Q,et al.Analysis of the factors affecting armor weapon system operational effectiveness based on simulation[J].Computer Simulation,2006,23(8):9-11.
[32]雷永林,姚剑,朱宁,等.武器装备效能仿真系统WESS[J].系统仿真学报,2017,29(6):1244-1252.LIU Y L,YAO J,ZHU N,et al.Weapon effectiveness simulation system(WESS)[J].Journal of System Simulation,2017,29(6):1244-1252.
[33]DAVIS P K.Exploratory analysis enabled by multi-resolution,multi-perspective modeling[C]∥Proc.of the Winter Simulation Conference,2000.
[34]YAU P E.An exploratory analysis on the effects of information superiority on battle outcomes[R].Monterey:Naval Postgraduate School,2002.
[35]JOHNSON S E,LIBICKI M C,TREVERTON G F.New challenges,new tools for defense decision-making[M].Santa Monica:RAND Corporation,2003.
[36]曾宪钊,蔡游飞,黄谦,等.基于作战仿真和探索性分析的海战效能评估[J].系统仿真学报,2005,17(3):763-766.ZENG X Z,CAI Y F,HUANG Q,et al.Simulation and exploratory analysis based navy-battle effectiveness evaluation[J].Journal of System Simulation,2005,17(3):763-766.
[37]李兴兵.武器装备体系作战效能探索性评估与分析方法及应用研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2010.LI X B.Exploratory evaluation and analysis method of weapon equipment system operational effectiveness and its application[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2010.
[38]李志猛,谈群,汪彦明,等.基于探索性分析的信息系统效能评估方法[J].科学技术与工程,2009,22(9):6702-6707.LI Z M,TAN Q,WANG Y M,et al.Effectiveness evaluation method for information systems based on exploratory analysis[J].Science Technology and Engineering,2009,22(9):6702-6707.
[39]刘明辉,杨峰,王磊,等.基于SVR的反舰导弹作战效能探索性评估方法[J].计算机仿真,2009,26(8):9-12.LIU M H,YANG F,WANG L,et al.An operational effectiveness exploratory evaluation method of anti-ship missile based on support vector regression[J].Computer Simulation,2009,26(8):9-12.
[40]刘德生,郭静.基于探索性分析方法的导弹对抗作战效能评估[J].微计算机信息,2010,26(25):30-32.LIU D S,GUO J.Missile countermeasure effectiveness evaluation based on exploratory analysis method[J].Control&Automation,2010,26(25):30-32.
[41]XIA W,LIU X,MENG S,et al.Efficiency evaluation research of missile weapon system based on the ADC-model[C]∥Proc.of the International Conference on Machinery,Materials,Environment,Biotechnology and Computer,2016.
[42]陈健,滕克难,杨春周.基于ADC法的反卫装备体系打击效能评估模型研究[J].舰船电子工程,2014,34(3):116-119.CHEN J,TENG K N,YANG C Z.Effectiveness evaluation model of anti-satellite equipment SoS based on ADC method[J].Ship Electronic Engineering,2014,34(3):116-119.
[43]栾孝丰,温瑞.基于UML和ADC法的舰载反舰导弹武器系统效能评估[J].计算机与数字工程,2010,38(8):135-137,149.LUAN X F,WEN R.Evaluation for ship-to-ship missile weapon system effectiveness based on UML and ADC method[J].Computer and Digital Engineering,2010,38(8):135-137,149.
[44]刘花云,张贤椿.基于ADC的导弹武器系统效能评估方法[J].兵工自动化,2015,34(8):11-14.LIU H Y,ZHANG X C.Effectiveness evaluation method of missile weapon system based on ADC[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2015,34(8):11-14.
[45]CHENG E W L,LI H.Analytic hierarchy process:an approach to determine measures for business performance[J].Measuring Business Excellence,2001,5(3):30-37.
[46]郑孝勇,姚景顺.基于模糊层次分析法的雷达效能评估方法[J].现代雷达,2002,24(2):7-9.ZHENG X Y,YAO J S.A method to evaluate the effectiveness of a radar based on FAHP[J].Modern Radar,2002,24(2):7-9.
[47]吴智辉,张多林,谢磊峰.基于层次分析法的防空信息战效能评估[J].系统工程与电子技术,2004,26(2):209-211.WU Z H,ZHANG D L,XIE L F.Evaluation of the operational effectiveness of the information warfare of air defense[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2004,26(2):209-211.
[48]段绍展.层次分析法在电子武器效能评估中的应用[J].电子信息对抗技术,2006,21(1):38-40.DUAN S Z.AHP application in EW weapon efficiency evaluation[J].Electronic Information Warfare Technology,2006,21(1):38-40.
[49]董超,倪明放,杨盘隆,等.层次分析法在战术互联网效能评估中的应用[J].运筹与管理,2006,15(3):119-124.DONG C,NI M F,YANG P L,et al.Effectiveness evaluation of TI based on AHP[J].Operations Research and Management Science,2006,15(3):119-124.
[50]史睿冰,姚兴太,史圣兵,等.基于层次分析法的通信系统效能评估[J].计算机工程与设计,2013,34(12):4131-4136.SHI R B,YAO X T,SHI S B,et al.Effectiveness evaluation of communication system based on AHP[J].Computer Engineering and Design,2013,34(12):4131-4136.
[51]卜广志.武器装备体系的体系结构与体系效能[J].系统工程与电子技术,2006,28(10):1544-1548.BU G Z.Study on the architecture and effectiveness for armament systems[J].Systems Engineering and Electronics,2006,28(10):1544-1548.
[52]CARES J R.An information age combat model[M].Newport:Alidade Incorporated,2004:85-90.
[53]DELLER S,BELL M I,BOWLING S R,et al.Applying the information age combat model:quantitative analysis of network centric operations[J].The International C2Journal,2009(1):24-26.
[54]田旭光,朱元昌,邱彦强.指挥与控制系统复杂网络形式化建模分析[J].电光与控制,2012,19(7):23-27.TIAN X G,ZHU Y C,QIU Y Q.Formalized modeling and analysis for C2based on complex networks[J].Electronics Optics&Control,2012,19(7):23-27.
[55]金伟新.体系对抗复杂网络建模与仿真[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2010.JIN W X.SoS-Ops M&S based on the complex network[M].Beijing:Electronic Industry Press,2010.
[56]谭跃进,张小可,杨克巍.武器装备体系网络化描述与建模方法研究[J].系统管理杂志,2012,21(6):781-786.TAN Y J,ZHANG X K,YANG K W.Research on networked description and modeling methods of armament system-ofsystems[J].Journal of Systems&Management,2012,21(6):781-786.
[57]孙建彬.基于作战环的反导装备体系形式化建模与能力评估方法[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2015.SUN J B.Formal modeling and capability assessment method of anti-missile equipment system based on combat ring[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2015.
[58]LI J,FU C,CHEN Y,et al.An operational efficiency evaluationmethod for weapon system-of-systems combat networks based on operation loop[C]∥Proc.of the IEEE International Conference on System of Systems Engineering,2014:219-223.
[59]CHI Y,LI J C,YANG K W,et al.An equipment offering degree evaluation method for weapon system-of-systems combat network based on operation loop[C]∥Proc.of the 22nd International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management,2015:477-488.
[60]商慧琳.武器装备体系作战网络建模及能力评估方法研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2013:72-73.SHANG H L.Research on modeling and capability assessment of weapon and equipment systems operational network[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2013:72-73.
[61]WU J,TAN S Y,TAN Y J,et al.Analysis of invulnerability in complex networks based on natural connectivity[J].Complex Systems&Complexity Science,2014,11(1):77-86.
[62]LI J,TAN Y,YANG K,et al.Structural robustness of combat networks of weapon system-of-systems based on the operation loop[J].International Journal of Systems Science,2016,48(3):659-674.
[63]张会.武器装备体系连通性评估方法研究[D].长沙:国防科技大学,2008.ZHANG H.Research on connectivity assessment method of weapon equipment system[D].Changsha:National University of Defense Technology,2008.
[64]王宏宇,吴纬,魏艳艳.基于超网络模型武器装备体系抗毁性分析[J].系统工程与电子技术,2017,39(8):1782-1787.WANG H,WU W,WEI Y Y.Weapon system-of-systems invulnerability analysis based on super network model[J].Systems Engineering&Electronics,2017,39(8):1782-1787.
[65]NEALE M C,HUNTER M D,PRITIKIN J N,et al.OpenMx2.0:extended structural equation and statistical modeling[J].Psychometrika,2016,81(2):535.
[66]罗小明,朱延雷,何栊.武器装备体系结构贡献度评估[J].装甲兵工程学报,2016,30(4):1-5.LUO X M,HE R,ZHU Y L.Research on evaluation of contribution to weapon equipment system architecture[J].Journal of Academy of Armored Force Engineering,2016,30(4):1-5.
[67]DENG J.Application of grey system theory in China[C]∥Proc.of the International Symposium on Uncertainty Modeling and Analysis,1990:285-291.
[68]常雷雷,张小可,李孟军.基于灰靶理论的武器装备体系技术贡献度评估[J].兵工自动化,2010,29(10):13-19.CHANG L L,ZHANG X K,LI M J.Weapon system of system technology contribution evaluation based on Grey target theory[J].Ordnance Industry Automation,2010,29(10):13-19.
[69]吕惠文,武庆春,张炜.基于灰色证据理论的装备体系贡献率评估[J].军事交通学院学报,2017,19(5):22-27.LH W,WU Q C,ZHANG W,et al.Equipment system contribution evaluation based on gray evidence theory[J].Journal of Academy of Military Transportation,2017,19(5):22-27.
[70]HUANG G,SU L.Effectiveness evaluation analysis of weapon equipment system based on weighted gray relational degree[J].Information Engineering,2015,4:33-37.
[71]ERDOS P,RENYI A.On the evolution of random graphs.Publicationes Mathematicae,1959,6:290-297.
[72]刘磊,荆涛,吴小勇.武器装备体系演化的评估方法研究[J].系统仿真学报,2006,18(2):621-622.LIU L,JING T,WU X Y.Research on evaluation of armament system of systems evolution[J].Journal of System Simulation,2006,18(2):621-622.
[73]张婷婷,王智学.C4ISR体系演化过程中可靠性分析与评估[J].指挥与控制学报,2015,1(4):439-440.ZHANG T T,WANG Z X.Reliability of system of systems evolution processes analysis and valuation[J].Journal of Command and Control,2015,1(4):439-440.
[74]温睿,陈小青,马亚平,等.基于边权拓补的作战体系演化生长模型[J].系统工程学报,2011,26(2):282-285.WEN R,CHEN X Q,MA Y P,et al.Evolutionary model for military forces system of systems based on topological weighed networks[J].Journal of Systems Engineering,2011,26(2):282-285.
[75]王寿彪,李新明,杨凡德,等.武器装备体系演化研究[J].火力与指挥控制,2017,42(3):1-3.WANG S B,LI X M,YANG F D,et al.Research progress on evolution of weapon equipment system of systems[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2017,42(3):1-3.
[76]贾子英,闫飞龙,唐岩辉.系统演化的作战体系对抗结构模型[J].火力与指挥控制,2013,38(9):91-92.JIA Z Y,YAN F L,TANG Y H.Structure model for SoS combat base on system evolution[J].Fire Control&Command Control,2013,38(9):91-92.
© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号 地址：北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编：100083 电话：办公室：(+86 10)66554848；文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新：66554700 |