基于Web of Science的国际海草研究文献计量评价
|
摘要
海草及其与周围环境形成的海草场是近海海洋生态系统的重要组成部分,具有多种重要的生态服务功能。相较于红树林和珊瑚礁,国内外学者和公众对海草的关注度偏低,至今对国际海草研究的现状、趋势和热点等的认识还较为有限。检索了1983—2017年Web of Science的SCI-E数据库中收录的海草研究相关文献,借助文献计量信息可视化分析方法,从年度发文量、研究力量和研究热点与主题等方面进行了较为系统的文献计量评价,以期阐明国内外海草研究的态势与热点。结果表明:1983—2017年间国际海草研究的文献数量总体呈明显上升趋势,该领域发文量排前3位的国家是美国、澳大利亚和西班牙;全球发文量最多的机构是佛罗里达州立大学,其次是西班牙高等科学研究理事会与美国国家海洋和大气管理局;发文总量较多的作者是Duarte CM、Marba N和Fourqurean JW,近3年发文量最高的是学者Santos R;刊文量最多的期刊分别是《Marine Ecology Progress Series》、《Aquatic Botany》和《Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science》,刊文量前15期刊中影响因子最高的是《Limnology and Oceanography》(3.969)。在国家、机构与作者合作方面,西班牙、丹麦、荷兰、墨西哥4个国家形成了关系密切的合作网络,西班牙高等科学研究理事会和美国国家海洋和大气管理局是海草研究机构合作网络中的两个中心,Duarte CM、Marba N等较多学者间有紧密的学术合作关系。通过高频关键词的关联关系分析,表明该领域的3个热点研究主题,即环境(污染)胁迫对海草场的影响、海草的生长与生理生态和海草及其相关生态系统的结构与功能。中国科学院、中国海洋大学等机构为我国海草研究做出了重要贡献,但由于研究起步较晚,我国学者的发文量、篇均被引频次等与欧美国家学者存在一定差距,但近几年的发文量增长迅速,预计未来的发展趋势良好。
引文
[1] 林鹏.海洋高等植物生态学.北京:科学出版社,2006:85.
[2] 王锁民,崔彦农,刘金祥,夏曾润.海草及海草场生态系统研究进展.草业学报,2016,25(11):149- 159.
[3] Hemminga M A,Duarte C M.Seagrass Ecology.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2000:2- 23.
[4] 韩秋影,施平.海草生态学研究进展.生态学报,2008,28(11):5561- 5570.
[5] Charpy R C,Sournia A.The comparative estimation of phytoplanktonic,microphytobenthic and macrophytobenthic primary production in the oceans.Marine Microbial Food Webs,1990,4(1):31- 57.
[6] Short F T,Polidoro B,Livingstone S R,Carpenter K E,Bandeira S,Bujang J S,Calumpong H P,Carruthers T J B,Coles R G,Dennison W C,Erftemeijer P L A,Fortes M D,Freeman A S,Jagtap T G,Kamal A H M,Kendrick G A,Kenworthy W J,La Nafie Y A,Nasution I M,Orth R J,Prathep A,Sanciangco J C,van Tussenbroek B,Vergara S G,Waycott M,Zieman J C.Extinction risk assessment of the world′s seagrass species.Biological Conservation,2011,144(7):1961- 1971.
[7] 郑凤英,邱广龙,范航清,张伟.中国海草的多样性、分布及保护.生物多样性,2013,21(5):517- 526.
[8] 黄小平,江志坚,范航清,陈小勇,周毅,张景平,李文涛,张沛东,郑凤英,韩秋影,邱广龙,方静威,林幸助,孙涛,于硕,刘松林,吴云超,张晓梅,赵鹏,林海英.中国海草的“藻”名更改.海洋与湖沼,2016,47(1):290- 294.
[9] 邱广龙,范航清,李雷鲜,李森.潮间带海草床的生态恢复.北京:中国林业出版社,2014.
[10] Nederhof A J.Bibliometric monitoring of research performance in the social sciences and the humanities:a review.Scientometrics,2006,66(1):81- 100.
[11] Liu X J,Zhang L,Hong S.Global biodiversity research during 1900- 2009:a bibliometric analysis.Biodiversity and Conservation,2011,20(4):807- 826.
[12] 陈宝明,彭少麟,吴秀平,王鹏龙,马建霞.近20年外来生物入侵危害与风险评估文献计量分析.生态学报,2016,36(20):6677- 6685.
[13] 杨红玉,王明元,游晓朝,刘建福.植物共生信号的文献计量分析.生态学报,2017,37(14):4913- 4918.
[14] 吕明权,吴胜军,陈春娣,姜毅,温兆飞,陈吉龙,王雨,王小晓,黄平.三峡消落带生态系统研究文献计量分析.生态学报,2015,35(11):3504- 3518.
[15] 干文芝,任永宽,干友民.基于Web of Science草地退化研究态势计量分析.草业科学,2013,30(5):805- 811.
[16] 刘爱原,林荣澄,郭玉清.全球北极底栖生物研究文献计量分析.生态学报,2015,35(9):2789- 2799.
[17] 曹永强,郭明,刘思然,杨俊.基于文献计量分析的生态修复现状研究.生态学报,2016,36(8):2442- 2450.
[18] Kumaresan R,Vinitha K,Kannan K.Bibliometric analysis of aquatic microbial ecology from 2000- 2014.International Journal of Research in Library Science,2017,3(2):1- 14.
[19] 周晓艳,张文妍,叶信岳,甘甜,韩项.1992- 2012年国际生态足迹研究文献计量分析.地理科学进展,2014,33(3):336- 346.
[20] 张炯森.基于文献计量分析的中国红树林保护研究现状.热带农业科学,2017,37(4):102- 106.
[21] 李威威,何东进,游巍斌,洪伟,肖石红,侯栋梁,严思晓.中国1957- 2015年沿海湿地研究文献计量分析.湿地科学与管理,2016,12(3):50- 55.
[22] Duarte C M.Seagrass ecology at the turn of the millennium:challenges for the new century.Aquatic Botany,1999,65(1/4):7- 20.
[23] Borgatti S P,Everett M G,Freeman L C.Ucinet for Windows:Software for Social Network Analysis.Harvard,MA:Analytic Technologies,2002.
[24] Borgatti S P.NetDraw Software for Network Visualization.Analytic Technologies.Lexington,KY:Analytic Technologies,2002.
[25] Chen C M.CiteSpace II:detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):359- 377.
[26] 刘伟妍,韩秋影,唐玉琴,孙西艳.营养盐富集和全球温度升高对海草的影响.生态学杂志,2017,36(4):1087- 1096.
[27] Duarte C M.Seagrass nutrient content.Marine Ecology Progress Series,1990,67:201- 207.
[28] Dennison W C.Effects of light on seagrass photosynthesis,growth and depth distribution.Aquatic Botany,1987,27(1):15- 26.
[29] Short F T.Effects of sediment nutrients on seagrasses:literature review and mesocosm experiment.Aquatic Botany,1987,27(1):41- 57.
[30] Orth R J,Carruthers T J B,Dennison W C,Duarte C M,Fourqurean J W,Heck K L,Hughes A R,Kendrick G A,Kenworthy W J,Olyarnik S,Short F T,Waycott M,Williams S L.A global crisis for seagrass ecosystems.BioScience,2006,56(12):987- 996.
[31] Heck Jr K L,Hays G,Orth R J.Critical evaluation of the nursery role hypothesis for seagrass meadows.Marine Ecology Progress Series,2003,253:123- 136.
[32] Duarte C M,Chiscano C L.Seagrass biomass and production:a reassessment.Aquatic Botany,1999,65(1/4):159- 174.
[33] Hughes AR,Stachowicz J J.Genetic diversity enhances the resistance of a seagrass ecosystem to disturbance.Proceedings of National Academy of Science of the United States of America,2004,101(24):8998- 9002.
[34] Short F T,Neckles H A.The effects of global climate change on seagrasses.Aquatic Botany,1999,63(3/4):169- 196.
[35] Burkholder J M,Tomasko D A,Touchette B W.Seagrasses and eutrophication.Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology,2007,350(1/2):46- 72.
[36] Fourqurean J W,Duarte C M,Kennedy H,Marbà N,Holmer M,Mateo M A,Apostolaki E T,Kendrick G A,Krause-Jensen D,McGlathery K J,Serrano O.Seagrass ecosystems as a globally significant carbon stock.Nature Geoscience,2012,5(7):505- 509.
[37] Olsen J L,Rouzé P,Verhelst B,Lin Y C,Bayer T,Collen J,Dattolo E,De Paoli E,Dittami S,Maumus F,Michel G,Kersting A,Lauritano C,Lohaus R,T?pel M,Tonon T,Vanneste K,Amirebrahimi M,Brakel J,Bostr?m C,Chovatia M,Grimwood J,Jenkins J W,Jueterbock A,Mraz A,Stam W T,Tice H,Bornberg-Bauer E,Green P J,Pearson G A,Procaccini G,Duarte C M,Schmutz J,Reusch T B H,van de Peer Y.The genome of the seagrass Zostera marina reveals angiosperm adaptation to the sea.Nature,2016,530(7590):331- 335.
[38] Lamb J B,van de Water J A J M,Bourne D G,Altier G,Hein M Y,Fiorenza E A,Abu N,Jompa J,Harvell C D.Seagrass ecosystems reduce exposure to bacterial pathogens of humans,fishes,and invertebrates.Science,2017,355(6326):731- 733.
[39] van Katwijk M M,Thorhaug A,Marbà N,Orth R J,Duarte C M,Kendrick G A,Althuizen I H J,Balestri E,Bernard G,Cambridge M L,Cunha A,Durance C,Giesen W,Han Q Y,Hosokawa S,Kiswara W,Komatsu T,Lardicci C,Lee K S,Meinesz A,Nakaoka M,O′Brien K R,Paling E I,Pickerell C,Ransijn A M A,Verduin J J.Global analysis of seagrass restoration:the importance of large-scale planting.Journal of Applied Ecology,2016,53(2):567- 578.
[40] Shi Y J,Fan H Q,Cui X J,Pan L H,Li S,Song S K.Overview on seagrasses and related research in China.Chinese Journal of Oceanology and Limnology,2010,28(2):329- 339.
[41] Lee S Y,Fong C W,Wu R S S.The effects of seagrass (Zostera japonica) canopy structure on associated fauna:a study using artificial seagrass units and sampling of natural beds.Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology,2001,259(1):23- 50.
[42] Yang S L.The role of Scirpus marsh in attenuation of hydrodynamics and retention of fine sediment in the Yangtze Estuary.Estuarine,Coastal and Shelf Science,1998,47(2):227- 233.
[43] Xu S C,Zhou Y,Wang P M,Wang F,Zhang X M,Gu R T.Salinity and temperature significantly influence seed germination,seedling establishment,and seedling growth of eelgrass Zostera marina L.PeerJ,2014,4:e2697.
[44] Liu S L,Jiang Z J,Deng Y Q,Wu Y C,Zhao C Y,Zhang J P,Shen Y,Huang X P.Effects of seagrass leaf litter decomposition on sediment organic carbon composition and the key transformation processes.Science China Earth Sciences,2017,60(12):2108- 2117.
[45] Liu S L,Jiang Z J,Zhang J P,Wu Y C,Huang X P,Macreadie P I.Sediment microbes mediate the impact of nutrient loading on blue carbon sequestration by mixed seagrass meadows.Science of the Total Environment,2017,599- 600:1479- 1484.
[46] Jiang Z J,Liu S L,Zhang J P,Zhao C Y,Wu Y C,Yu S,Zhang X,Huang C,Huang X P,Kumar M.Newly discovered seagrass beds and their potential for blue carbon in the coastal seas of Hainan Island,South China Sea.Marine Pollution Bulletin,2017,125(1/2):513- 521.
[47] Soong K,Chiu S T,Chen C N N.Novel seed adaptations of a monocotyledon seagrass in the wavy sea.PLoS One,2013,8(9):e74143.
[2] 王锁民,崔彦农,刘金祥,夏曾润.海草及海草场生态系统研究进展.草业学报,2016,25(11):149- 159.
[3] Hemminga M A,Duarte C M.Seagrass Ecology.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2000:2- 23.
[4] 韩秋影,施平.海草生态学研究进展.生态学报,2008,28(11):5561- 5570.
[5] Charpy R C,Sournia A.The comparative estimation of phytoplanktonic,microphytobenthic and macrophytobenthic primary production in the oceans.Marine Microbial Food Webs,1990,4(1):31- 57.
[6] Short F T,Polidoro B,Livingstone S R,Carpenter K E,Bandeira S,Bujang J S,Calumpong H P,Carruthers T J B,Coles R G,Dennison W C,Erftemeijer P L A,Fortes M D,Freeman A S,Jagtap T G,Kamal A H M,Kendrick G A,Kenworthy W J,La Nafie Y A,Nasution I M,Orth R J,Prathep A,Sanciangco J C,van Tussenbroek B,Vergara S G,Waycott M,Zieman J C.Extinction risk assessment of the world′s seagrass species.Biological Conservation,2011,144(7):1961- 1971.
[7] 郑凤英,邱广龙,范航清,张伟.中国海草的多样性、分布及保护.生物多样性,2013,21(5):517- 526.
[8] 黄小平,江志坚,范航清,陈小勇,周毅,张景平,李文涛,张沛东,郑凤英,韩秋影,邱广龙,方静威,林幸助,孙涛,于硕,刘松林,吴云超,张晓梅,赵鹏,林海英.中国海草的“藻”名更改.海洋与湖沼,2016,47(1):290- 294.
[9] 邱广龙,范航清,李雷鲜,李森.潮间带海草床的生态恢复.北京:中国林业出版社,2014.
[10] Nederhof A J.Bibliometric monitoring of research performance in the social sciences and the humanities:a review.Scientometrics,2006,66(1):81- 100.
[11] Liu X J,Zhang L,Hong S.Global biodiversity research during 1900- 2009:a bibliometric analysis.Biodiversity and Conservation,2011,20(4):807- 826.
[12] 陈宝明,彭少麟,吴秀平,王鹏龙,马建霞.近20年外来生物入侵危害与风险评估文献计量分析.生态学报,2016,36(20):6677- 6685.
[13] 杨红玉,王明元,游晓朝,刘建福.植物共生信号的文献计量分析.生态学报,2017,37(14):4913- 4918.
[14] 吕明权,吴胜军,陈春娣,姜毅,温兆飞,陈吉龙,王雨,王小晓,黄平.三峡消落带生态系统研究文献计量分析.生态学报,2015,35(11):3504- 3518.
[15] 干文芝,任永宽,干友民.基于Web of Science草地退化研究态势计量分析.草业科学,2013,30(5):805- 811.
[16] 刘爱原,林荣澄,郭玉清.全球北极底栖生物研究文献计量分析.生态学报,2015,35(9):2789- 2799.
[17] 曹永强,郭明,刘思然,杨俊.基于文献计量分析的生态修复现状研究.生态学报,2016,36(8):2442- 2450.
[18] Kumaresan R,Vinitha K,Kannan K.Bibliometric analysis of aquatic microbial ecology from 2000- 2014.International Journal of Research in Library Science,2017,3(2):1- 14.
[19] 周晓艳,张文妍,叶信岳,甘甜,韩项.1992- 2012年国际生态足迹研究文献计量分析.地理科学进展,2014,33(3):336- 346.
[20] 张炯森.基于文献计量分析的中国红树林保护研究现状.热带农业科学,2017,37(4):102- 106.
[21] 李威威,何东进,游巍斌,洪伟,肖石红,侯栋梁,严思晓.中国1957- 2015年沿海湿地研究文献计量分析.湿地科学与管理,2016,12(3):50- 55.
[22] Duarte C M.Seagrass ecology at the turn of the millennium:challenges for the new century.Aquatic Botany,1999,65(1/4):7- 20.
[23] Borgatti S P,Everett M G,Freeman L C.Ucinet for Windows:Software for Social Network Analysis.Harvard,MA:Analytic Technologies,2002.
[24] Borgatti S P.NetDraw Software for Network Visualization.Analytic Technologies.Lexington,KY:Analytic Technologies,2002.
[25] Chen C M.CiteSpace II:detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):359- 377.
[26] 刘伟妍,韩秋影,唐玉琴,孙西艳.营养盐富集和全球温度升高对海草的影响.生态学杂志,2017,36(4):1087- 1096.
[27] Duarte C M.Seagrass nutrient content.Marine Ecology Progress Series,1990,67:201- 207.
[28] Dennison W C.Effects of light on seagrass photosynthesis,growth and depth distribution.Aquatic Botany,1987,27(1):15- 26.
[29] Short F T.Effects of sediment nutrients on seagrasses:literature review and mesocosm experiment.Aquatic Botany,1987,27(1):41- 57.
[30] Orth R J,Carruthers T J B,Dennison W C,Duarte C M,Fourqurean J W,Heck K L,Hughes A R,Kendrick G A,Kenworthy W J,Olyarnik S,Short F T,Waycott M,Williams S L.A global crisis for seagrass ecosystems.BioScience,2006,56(12):987- 996.
[31] Heck Jr K L,Hays G,Orth R J.Critical evaluation of the nursery role hypothesis for seagrass meadows.Marine Ecology Progress Series,2003,253:123- 136.
[32] Duarte C M,Chiscano C L.Seagrass biomass and production:a reassessment.Aquatic Botany,1999,65(1/4):159- 174.
[33] Hughes AR,Stachowicz J J.Genetic diversity enhances the resistance of a seagrass ecosystem to disturbance.Proceedings of National Academy of Science of the United States of America,2004,101(24):8998- 9002.
[34] Short F T,Neckles H A.The effects of global climate change on seagrasses.Aquatic Botany,1999,63(3/4):169- 196.
[35] Burkholder J M,Tomasko D A,Touchette B W.Seagrasses and eutrophication.Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology,2007,350(1/2):46- 72.
[36] Fourqurean J W,Duarte C M,Kennedy H,Marbà N,Holmer M,Mateo M A,Apostolaki E T,Kendrick G A,Krause-Jensen D,McGlathery K J,Serrano O.Seagrass ecosystems as a globally significant carbon stock.Nature Geoscience,2012,5(7):505- 509.
[37] Olsen J L,Rouzé P,Verhelst B,Lin Y C,Bayer T,Collen J,Dattolo E,De Paoli E,Dittami S,Maumus F,Michel G,Kersting A,Lauritano C,Lohaus R,T?pel M,Tonon T,Vanneste K,Amirebrahimi M,Brakel J,Bostr?m C,Chovatia M,Grimwood J,Jenkins J W,Jueterbock A,Mraz A,Stam W T,Tice H,Bornberg-Bauer E,Green P J,Pearson G A,Procaccini G,Duarte C M,Schmutz J,Reusch T B H,van de Peer Y.The genome of the seagrass Zostera marina reveals angiosperm adaptation to the sea.Nature,2016,530(7590):331- 335.
[38] Lamb J B,van de Water J A J M,Bourne D G,Altier G,Hein M Y,Fiorenza E A,Abu N,Jompa J,Harvell C D.Seagrass ecosystems reduce exposure to bacterial pathogens of humans,fishes,and invertebrates.Science,2017,355(6326):731- 733.
[39] van Katwijk M M,Thorhaug A,Marbà N,Orth R J,Duarte C M,Kendrick G A,Althuizen I H J,Balestri E,Bernard G,Cambridge M L,Cunha A,Durance C,Giesen W,Han Q Y,Hosokawa S,Kiswara W,Komatsu T,Lardicci C,Lee K S,Meinesz A,Nakaoka M,O′Brien K R,Paling E I,Pickerell C,Ransijn A M A,Verduin J J.Global analysis of seagrass restoration:the importance of large-scale planting.Journal of Applied Ecology,2016,53(2):567- 578.
[40] Shi Y J,Fan H Q,Cui X J,Pan L H,Li S,Song S K.Overview on seagrasses and related research in China.Chinese Journal of Oceanology and Limnology,2010,28(2):329- 339.
[41] Lee S Y,Fong C W,Wu R S S.The effects of seagrass (Zostera japonica) canopy structure on associated fauna:a study using artificial seagrass units and sampling of natural beds.Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology,2001,259(1):23- 50.
[42] Yang S L.The role of Scirpus marsh in attenuation of hydrodynamics and retention of fine sediment in the Yangtze Estuary.Estuarine,Coastal and Shelf Science,1998,47(2):227- 233.
[43] Xu S C,Zhou Y,Wang P M,Wang F,Zhang X M,Gu R T.Salinity and temperature significantly influence seed germination,seedling establishment,and seedling growth of eelgrass Zostera marina L.PeerJ,2014,4:e2697.
[44] Liu S L,Jiang Z J,Deng Y Q,Wu Y C,Zhao C Y,Zhang J P,Shen Y,Huang X P.Effects of seagrass leaf litter decomposition on sediment organic carbon composition and the key transformation processes.Science China Earth Sciences,2017,60(12):2108- 2117.
[45] Liu S L,Jiang Z J,Zhang J P,Wu Y C,Huang X P,Macreadie P I.Sediment microbes mediate the impact of nutrient loading on blue carbon sequestration by mixed seagrass meadows.Science of the Total Environment,2017,599- 600:1479- 1484.
[46] Jiang Z J,Liu S L,Zhang J P,Zhao C Y,Wu Y C,Yu S,Zhang X,Huang C,Huang X P,Kumar M.Newly discovered seagrass beds and their potential for blue carbon in the coastal seas of Hainan Island,South China Sea.Marine Pollution Bulletin,2017,125(1/2):513- 521.
[47] Soong K,Chiu S T,Chen C N N.Novel seed adaptations of a monocotyledon seagrass in the wavy sea.PLoS One,2013,8(9):e74143.