摘要
采用模糊层次评价法对陈家冲4种不同渗沥液处理工艺的稳定性进行综合评价,选用处理效率、控制参数、运行管理3个方面作为评价层,构建COD处理效率、氨氮处理效率、回收率、食微比(F/M)、吨药剂投加量等16个指标层参数。评价结果表明:处理效率、控制参数、运行管理稳定性等方面各工艺均有优劣,其中MBR-NF-RO-蒸发工艺综合评价最为稳定,BBR+两级Fenton-BAF次之,但具有无浓缩液产生、低碳氮比要求、抗高温等特点。
The stability of four different leachate treatment processes in Wuhan Chenjiachong was evaluated comprehensively by using FCE-AHP method. Processing efficiency,control parameters and operation management were selected as evaluation layer,and sixteen index layer parameters including COD treatment efficiency,ammonia nitrogen treatment efficiency,recovery rate,F/M,dosage per ton of agent were constructed. The result showed that each process had advantages and disadvantages in terms of efficiency,control parameters and operation management stability,and MBR-NF-RO-evaporation process was the most stable,followed by BBR-two-stage Fenton-BAF process,but it had the characteristics of no concentrated liquid production,low carbon and nitrogen ratio requirements,and resistance to high temperature.
引文
[1]Hu L,Zeng G,Chen G,et al. Treatment of landfill leachate using immobilized Phanerochaete chrysosporium loaded with nitrogen-doped TiO2nanoparticles[J]. J Hazard Mater,2016,301:106-118.
[2]马丽丽,刘晓超.垃圾填埋场渗沥液处理技术综述[J].环境卫生工程,2006,14(1):32-35.
[3]Xu P,Valette F,Brissaud F,et al. Technical-economic modelling of integrated water management:Wastewater reuse in a French island[J]. Water Sci Technol,2001,43(10):67-74.
[4]Saaty T L. Multi-criteria descision making[M]. Pittsburgh:RWS Publications,1996.
[5]Chen M S,Wang S W. Fuzzy sets and fuzzy logic[M]. New Jersey:Prentice Hall,1995.
[6]Simon D. Sum normal optimization of fuzzy membership functions[J]. Int J Uncertain,Fuzz,2002,10(4):363-384.
[7]李佑智,檀炎,孙志涛,等.垃圾填埋场稳定化评价理论方法研究[J].环境卫生工程,2013,21(4):62-64.