用户名: 密码: 验证码:
CVD金刚石涂层拉拔模具参数优化仿真及试验研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着国内大型装备制造业及空调制冷业的迅猛发展,我国在对铜线及铜管需求量增多的同时对其质量的要求也越来越高。它们不仅要保证足够的力学强度及刚度,还要有较高的表面光洁度和尺寸精度。在我国传统拉拔行业中,硬质合金模具应用最为广泛,但由于其自身材料性质使得模具在应用过程中磨损非常严重、精度难以保证、拉制质量差、模具消耗大、铜等原材料浪费严重,造成生产效率低,工人劳动强度大,严重制约了铜材拉拔行业效益和产品质量的提高。此外,大量模具硬质合金材料的消耗,直接导致国家战略物质钨资源的浪费。因此采用金刚石涂层技术,研究开发的具有优异性能(CVD金刚石薄膜具有十分接近天然金刚石的硬度、高的弹性模量、极高的热导率、良好的自润滑性和化学稳定性等优异性能)的新型CVD金刚石涂层拉拔模具,不仅能大幅度提高模具的使用寿命,显著提高生产效率和产品质量,减少原材料消耗,降低成本,给应用行业带来巨大的经济效益,而且对于有效减少钨资源的消耗,促进经济可持续发展,也具有重要意义。
     本文通过弹塑性有限元法,利用非线性有限元分析软件分别对铜线材单、多道次及铜管空拉、固定短芯头拉拔和游动芯头拉拔过程进行有限元模拟,得到了各种拉拔条件下铜材及模具的轴向和径向应力分布,并通过不断改变模拟拉拔参数,及分析仿真结果得到各种拉拔条件下最佳的拉拔模具参数,最后对最佳的拉拔模具参数进行实际的拉拔试验研究,这对延长模具寿命、提高拉拔铜材的表面质量和尺寸精度及CVD金刚石涂层拉拔模具的推广应用有重要意义。
     论文的具体研究内容如下:
     1.采用非线性有限元分析软件对铜线材单道次拉拔过程进行有限元仿真,得到了拉拔过程中铜线及模具的轴向及径向应力分布规律,然后通过正交实验法研究了铜线不同压缩率时金刚石涂层拉拔模具参数(工作锥半角α,过渡圆弧半径R,定径带长度L)对铜材拉拔过程的影响,得到了最佳的拉拔模具孔型参数,及不同压缩率时各影响因素对铜材表面轴向残余应力和涂层模具最大等效应力的影响规律。最后实际拉拔试验表明,孔型参数优化后的金刚石涂层拉拔模具的工作寿命是硬质合金模具的10倍。
     2.对铜线材多道次拉拔过程进行有限元仿真,得到了铜线及模具在各个道次的轴向及径向应力分布规律,并对比分析了生产用铜线多道次拉拔和双递减法所得铜材多道次拉拔对铜材等效应变、等效应力及残余应力的影响。这对实际生产中铜线多道次拉拔的道次优化有重要指导作用。
     3.利用弹塑性有限元法对铜管的空拔过程进行有限元模拟,分析了空拔过程中铜管与模具的轴向及径向应力分布规律,并以此阐述了空拔铜管的缩径缺陷。然后采用正交实验法模拟研究了拉拔参数(工作锥半角α、过渡圆弧半径R、定径带长度L、摩擦系数μ、拉拔速度v)对铜管空拔的影响,并得到铜管一定减面率条件下的最佳拉拔参数及各因素对分析指标的影响。实际拉拔试验验证了铜管空拔有限元分析的正确。
     4.借助有限元分析软件研究了金刚石涂层模具铜管短芯头的拉拔过程,得到了拉拔过程中铜管及模具的轴向、径向应力分布,并阐述了固定短芯头拉拔铜管的缩径缺陷,根据对模拟结果的分析,得到一定拉拔条件下最佳的模具配合参数,并比较分析了摩擦系数及金刚石涂层对拉拔后铜管尺寸精度的影响。应用试验表明,与硬质合金模具相比,模具配合参数优化后的金刚石涂层模具不仅可以大幅提高模具寿命,而且可保证拉拔后铜管的尺寸精度及表面光洁度。
     5.通过有限元模拟研究了金刚石涂层模具铜管游动芯头的拉拔过程,分析了铜管及模具的轴向和径向应力分布,并通过正交实验法分析研究了外模参数(工作锥半角α、过渡圆弧半径R、定径带长度L)对铜材及涂层模具轴向应力的影响,并得到一定拉拔条件下最佳的外模参数。最后,对具有最佳孔型参数的外模进行实际的拉拔试验,与硬质合金模具相比,其产量和寿命都可至少提高8倍以上。
With the rapid development of large-scale equipment manufacturing industry and air-conditioning refrigeration, Chinese demand for copper tubes and wires with much higher qualities increases rapidly. It must not only guarantee adequate mechanical strength and stiffness, but also have a high surface finish and dimensional accuracy. In Chinese traditional drawing area, the cemented carbide drawing dies are widely used for their low manufacturing cost. But because of the material characteristic itself, it becomes abrade easily, so it is difficult to ensure the accuracy, the quality of drawn tubes, and it may also lead the more consuming of drawing dies and the wasting of copper, accordingly restricts the improvement of the productivity and the quality of drawn products. Meanwhile, the large quantities of consumption of cemented carbide drawing dies may directly result of the wasting of the national strategy of tungsten material. Therefore, the use of diamond coating technology to research and develop the new type of CVD diamond-coated drawing dies with excellent performance( CVD diamond films have the very similar hardness with the natural diamond, the high elastic modulus, the high thermal conductivity, the good self-lubricating and chemical stability and so on) can not only substantially increases the working lifetime of drawing dies, the productivity and quality of drawn products, reduce raw material consumption and costs, but also effectively decrease the consumption of tungsten resources and promote sustainable economic development.
     In this paper, non-linear finite element analysis software was used to simulate copper wires with single-pass and multi-pass drawing, copper tubes with hollow sinking, fixed plug drawing and floating plug drawing. Based on the simulation results, we obtained the distribution of axial and radial stresses of drawing products and drawing dies with every drawing conditions. The optimal drawing die parameters were gained by changing the drawing parameters and analyzing the simulation results. Finally, the real drawing experiments were perform with these optimal drawing dies. It has a great significant for prolonging the working lifetime of drawing dies, improving the quality and accuracy of drawn products.
     The main contents of the paper are as follows:
     1. Using non-linear finite element analysis software analyzed the single-pass drawing process of copper wires, and obtained the distributions of axial stress and radial stress on wires and drawing dies; Then the orthogonal experiment was used to investigate the influence of parameters (the semi-angle of drawing diesα, the radius of transition arc R , the length of bearing part L)of diamond-coated drawing dies upon the copper wires drawing process with different compressibility. Based on the range analysis and variance analysis of the simulation results, the optimal parameters of diamond-coated drawing dies were gained, as well as the influence of experiment factors upon the axial residual stress of copper wires and the maximum equivalent stress of diamond-coated drawing dies. Finally the results of application experiments showed that the working lifetime of optimal diamond-coated drawing dies could be increased by a factor of 10 compared with the cemented carbide drawing dies.
     2. In order to deeply investigate the influence of drawing passes on copper wires drawing process, the nonlinear FEM software was used to simulate the whole copper wires multi-pass drawing process, and analyzed the influence of the equivalent stress, equivalent strain and residual stress of copper wires multi-pass drawing for production and multi-pass drawing by double degressive method. The simulation results showed that with the same total elongation factor, the optimization of copper wires drawing passes can reduce the wire asymmetry deformation and the residual stress, improve the quality of drawn copper wires and promote the drawing productivity. It is of great significance for the real copper wires multi-pass drawing.
     3. We used the nonlinear finite element software to simulate the whole copper tube hollow sinking process, and then analyzed distributions of the axial stress and radial stress, and explained the mechanism of drawn copper tubes diameter shrinking. The influence of drawing parameters (the semi-angle of drawing diesα, the transition arc radius R, the length of bearing part L, friction coefficientμ, drawing velocity v)on copper tubes hollow sinking was investigated by using orthogonal experiment. The optimal drawing parameters under certain reduction of area and the influence of factors on analysis indexes were obtained according to simulation results by range analysis and variance analysis. Furthermore, the optimal drawing parameters were simulated by FEM, and the simulation results confirmed the effectiveness of the orthogonal experiment in optimizing tubes drawing in hollow sinking.
     4. In order to investigate the drawing process of diamond-coated drawing dies for copper tubes with fixed plug, the nonlinear finite element method was used to simulate the whole drawing process , the distributions of axial stress and radial stress were obtained, and the mechanism of the drawn copper tube diameter shrinking was explained. Based on the simulation results, the optimal matching parameters of diamond-coated drawing dies and fixed plugs were obtained under certain drawing conditions, and the influence of friction coefficients and diamond coating upon the diameter precision of drawn tubes were analyzed. Compared with cemented carbide drawing dies, the results of application experiments showed that diamond-coated drawing dies not only could prolong the working lifetime of drawing dies, but could improve the diameter precision and smoothness of drawn tubes.
     5. We used the FEM simulaiton to investigate the influence of parameters(the semi-angle of conical dieα, the radius of transition arc R, the length of bearing part L ) of diamond-coated conical dies upon the deformation of copper tubes with floating plug drawing. Based on the simulation results, the distributions of the axial stress and radial stress of drawing tubes and dies are obtained. The relative influence of parameters of diamond-coated conical dies are systematically examined using the orthogonal experiment. The influence of conical die parameters and the optimal parameters of the diamond-coated conical die are obtained by range analysis and variance analysis under the compressibility of 26%. The drawing experiment confirms the effectiveness of the orthogonal experiment in optimizing tubes drawing conical dies. As compared with cemented carbide drwing dies, the working lifetime of the optimal diamond-coated drawing dies can be increased by a factor of 8.
引文
[1]戴达煌,周克崧等,金刚石薄膜沉积制备工艺与应用[M],冶金工业出版社,2001.
    [2] Spitsyn B V, Bouilov L L, Derjaguin B V. Crystal Growth [J], 1981; 52:219.
    [3] Chen Ming, Sun Fanghong et al. CVD diamond Coating technologies and application in cutting abrasive materials[J]. Key Engineering Materials,2000.10:193-198
    [4] Friederike Deuerler, Hekio Gruner et al. Wear mechanisms of diamond-coated tools, Surface and Coatings Technology,2001,142-144:674-680.
    [5] Matsumoto S et al. J.Mater. Sci. , 1982;21: 1183.
    [6] Matsumoto S et al.Jpn. Appl. Phys. , 1982;21: 29.
    [7]蒋翔六,金刚石薄膜研究进展[M],北京:化学工业出版社, 1991:10
    [8] A. J. Miller, D. M. Reece, M. D. Hudson, etc., Diamond coatings for IR window applications, Diamond and Related Materials, 1997, 6(2-4): 386-389
    [9] Yin Z, Akkerman Z, Yang B X, etc., Optical properties and microstructure of CVD diamond films, Diamond and related materials, 1997, 6(1):153-158
    [10]顾毓沁,余立新,朱德贵,金刚石薄膜的导热性质研究,中国科学(E辑), 1996, 26(1):103-108
    [11] M Werner, R Locher, Growth and application of undoped and doped diamond films, Journal of report process of physics, 1998, 61:1665-1710
    [12]殷声,现代陶瓷及其应用[M],北京科学技术出版社, 1990:10
    [13] Bakon A, Szymanski A, Practical uses of diamond, PWN-polish scientific publishers, 1993:29
    [14] Marka Prelas, Galina Popovic, Louis K Bigelow, Handbook of industrial diamonds and diamond films, MARCEL. Dekker. Inc., 1997
    [15]田民波,刘德令,薄膜科学与技术手册(下册) [M],北京:机械工业出版社, 1991: 855
    [16] Matsumoto S, Sato Y, Kamo M, etc., Vapor deposition of diamond particles from methane, Japanese Journal of applied physics, 1982, 21(4):183-185
    [17] Jubber M G, Wilon J I, Drummond I, etc., Microwave plasma CVD of high purity diamond films, Diamond and related materials, 1993, 2:402-406
    [18]李惠琪,钟国仿,吕反修, DC PJ-CVD等离子体炬通道中的电弧行为,北京科技大学学报, 1994, 16(12):547-550
    [19] Y Hirose, S Amanuma, K Komaki, The synthesis of high-quality diamond in combustion flames, Journal of applied physics, 1990, 68(25):6401-6405
    [20] F.H. Sun, Z.M. Zhang, M.Chen, H.S. Shen, Fabrication and Application of High Quality Diamond-Coated Tools, Journal of Materials Proceedings Technology,2002, 129:435-440
    [21] S.Schwarz, C.Rottmair, J.Hirmke and S.Rosiwal. CVD-diamond single-crystal growth. Journal of Crystal Growth, 2004.271: 425-434
    [22]吕反修,唐伟忠等,金刚石膜涂层硬质合金工具研究进展(上),机械工人(热加工),2004(5) 63-64。
    [23]吕反修,唐伟忠等,金刚石膜涂层硬质合金工具研究进展(下),机械工人(热加工),2004(6) 18-20。
    [24]张志明,沈荷生等,CVD金刚石涂层拉丝模的研制与应用[J],工具技术,2000,34:13-16。
    [25] Y.F.Zhang, F.Zhang, et al, The roles of argon addition in the hot filament chemical vapor deposition system, Diamond and Related Materials, 2001, 10:1523-1527
    [26] W.Tang, C.Zhu, et al. Nanocrystalline diamond films produced by direct current arc plasma jet process, Thin Solid Films, 2003:429:63-70
    [27] M.Y.Liao, X.M.Meng, et al. Nanodiamond formation by hot-filament chemical vapor deposition on carbon ions bombarded Si, Journal of Crystal Growth, 2002,236:85-89
    [28]张志明,莘海维,孙方宏等,热丝CVD法生长纳米金刚石薄膜的研究[J],微细加工技术,2003,1:27-33
    [29] W.Tang, C.Zhu, et al. Nanocrystalline diamond films produced by direct current arc plasma jet process[J], Thin Solid Films, 2003:429:63-70
    [30] Hironmichi Yoshikawa, Cedric Moral, et al. Synthesis of nanocrystalline diamond films using microwave plasma CVD, Diamond and Related Materials, 2001,10:1588-1591
    [31] T. Sharda, T. Soga, et al. Growth of nanocrystalline diamond films by biased enhanced microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition, Diamond and Related Materials, 2001,10:1592-1596
    [32]于仁伟,谢铁桥编著.拉丝模与润滑剂[M],中国轻工业出版社,1991,134~143.
    [33]温景林等.金属挤压与拉拔工艺[M],东北大学出版社,1996,151~152.
    [34]王德广,邓小民.芯棒位置对管材内径尺寸精度影响的有限元模拟[J].重型机械,2005,(1): 51-57.
    [35] Okuzumi Ayanori, Matsuda Junichi, Diamond coated die for wire drawing, JP01062213
    [36] M. Murakawa, S, Takeuchi, K.Yoshida, Fabrication of a diamond-coated drawing die and performance test[J], The 2th International Conference on Application of Diamond Films and Related Materials, 1993:589-594
    [37] M Murakawa, S Takeuchi, Wire drawing die for thin wire using polycrystalline diamond synthesized by vapor deposition method, JP09220610, 1997
    [38] Dieguez Ivan, Bsuer Grosse Elizabeth, Reactor for diamond synthesis assisted by microware plasma has system for forcing and depositing diamond germination species on inner walls of holes in wire, FR2850116, 2004
    [39]苟立,安晓明,冉均国, CVD金刚石涂层拉拔模的制备[J],工具技术, 2007, 41(6):62-64
    [40]张志明,沈菏生,孙方宏等,大孔径金刚石涂层拉拔模的制备方法, CN1401818A, 2003
    [41]张志明,沈菏生,孙方宏等,纳米金刚石复合涂层紧压模的制备及应用[J],电线电缆, 2003, 4:9-12
    [42] Z M Zhang, H S Shen, F H Sun, etc., Fabrication and application of chemical vapor deposition diamond-coated drawing dies[J], Diamond and Related Materials, 2001, 10:33-38
    [43]郭松寿,张志明,沈荷生等,纳米金刚石复合涂层焊接套及拉拔套的特性与应用[J],光线与电缆及其应用技术, 2007, 1:9-12
    [44]张志明,沈菏生,孙方宏等, CVD金刚石涂层拉丝模的研制与应用[J],工具技术, 2000,34(4):13-15
    [45]李尚健.金属塑性成形过程模拟[M],机械工业出版社,1999.
    [46]刘才.金属成型非线性有限元模拟技术[J].燕山大学学报,1998,22 (1): 23-26.
    [47]申卫华.铜及铜合金管材拉拔工艺的计算机模拟[D].沈阳:中国科学院金属研究所, 2005: 7-8.
    [48]应富强,张更超,潘孝勇.金属塑性成形中的三维有限元模拟技术探讨[J].锻压技术, 2004,2:1-4.
    [49]张林荣,张福林,么茂秀等, CVD涂层在硬质合金拉丝模上的应用[J],稀有金属, 1995, 19(2):94-97
    [50]胡三媛, YG6拉丝模渗硼的试验研究[J],中国农业大学学报, 2000, 5(4):81-83
    [51]Dyi-Cheng Chen , Jheng-Yu Huang. Design of brass alloy drawing process using Taguchi method [J]. Materials Science and Engineering A 464(2007)135-140.
    [52]S.M.Weygand, H.Riedel , B.Eberhard, ect. Numerical simulation of the drawing process of tungsten wires[J] . International Journal of Refractory Metals & Hard Materials 24(2006)338-342.
    [53]S.He, A.Van Bael, S.Y.Li, ect. Residual stress determination in cold drawn steel wire by FEM simulation and X-ray diffraction[J]. Materials Sciences and Engineering, A346(2003):101-107.
    [54]J. Luksza , M . Burdek .The influence of the deformation mode on the final mechanical properties of products in multi-pass drawing and flat rolling[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2002,125-126: 725-730.
    [55]J. Luksza , J. Majta, M . Burdek, M. Ruminski. Modelling and measurements of mechanical behavior in multi-pass drawing process[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology 80-81(1998)398-405.
    [56]C.Genzel, W. Reimers, R. malek, K. Pohlandt. Neutron and X-ray residual stress analysis of steel parts produced by cold forward extrusion and tube drawing[J].Materials Science and Engineering. 1996,205(1-2):79-90.
    [57]黄成江,李殿中,戎利建,李依依.多道次拉拔管的三维弹塑性有限元分析[J].钢铁研究学报. 2000.(3):27-30.
    [58]J. Luksza , J. Majta, M . Burdek, M. Ruminski. Modelling and measurements of mechanical behavior in multi-pass drawing process[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology 80-81(1998)398-405.
    [59]P. Karnezis, D.C.J.Farrugia . Study of cold tube drawing by finite-element modeling[J], Journal of Materials Processing Technology 80-81(1998) 690-694.
    [60] J. Luksza , M . Burdek .The influence of the deformation mode on the final mechanical properties of products in multi-pass drawing and flat rolling[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2002,125-126: 725-730.
    [61]钟卫佳,马可定,吴维治.铜加工技术实用手册[M].北京:冶金工业出版社,2007.
    [62]谢水生.金属塑性成形工步的有限元数值模拟[M].北京:冶金工业出版社,1997.
    [63]苏岚,王先进,唐荻,孙吉先,田荣彬.有限元法处理金属塑性成型过程的接触问题[J].塑性工程学报,2000,7(4):12-15.
    [64]刘建生,陈慧琴,郭晓霞.金属塑性加工有限元模拟技术与应用[M].冶金工业出版社, 2003,38-39.
    [65] Takashi Kuboki, Keigo Nishida, Tomohiro Sakaki. Effect of plug on leveling of residual stress in tube drawing[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology , (2007), doi:10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2007.11.029.
    [66] Yoshida Kazunari, Furuya Hiroaki. Mandrel drawing and plug drawing of shape-memory-alloy fine tubes used in catheter and stents[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology ,2004,153-154:145-150.
    [67]俞庆,张侃,何亚峰.拔制方式对冷拔钢管拔制效果影响的显式动力分析[J].塑性工程学报, 2007,14(1): 89-93.
    [68]胡建英,金铎,牛洪军.锥模与弧形模芯拔管成型过程的非线性有限元分析[J].天津理工大学学报, 2006,22(2): 23-26.
    [69]王德广,邓小民.芯棒位置对管材内径尺寸精度影响的有限元模拟[J].重型机械,2005,(1): 51-57.
    [70] Yoshida Kazunari, Watanabe MasaKi, Ishikawa Hiroshi. Drawing of Ni-Ti shape-memory-alloy fine tubes used in medical tests[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology ,2001,118: 251-255.
    [71] Kuboki Takashi, Nishida Keigo, Sakaki Tomohiro. Effect of plug on leveling of residual stress in tube drawing [J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology , (2007), doi:10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2007.11.029.
    [72] QUAN Guo-zheng ,ZHOU Jie ,WANG Meng-han ,QUAN Guo-hui, TONG Ying. Deforming mechanism of non-mandrel drawing process of circular aluminum tube by simulation[J].Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China,2006,16: s1301-s1304.
    [73]薛隆泉,何亚峰,刘荣昌,代春英,陈军涛.基于ANSYS/LS-DYNA的空拔钢管有限元分析[J].塑性工程学报, 2005, 12(5): 74-77.
    [74]俞庆,张侃,何亚峰.拔制方式对冷拔钢管拔制效果影响的显式动力分析[J].塑性工程学报, 2007,14(1): 89-93.
    [75]洛阳铜加工厂编.游动芯头拉伸铜管.北京:冶金工业出版社, 1976, 1-15.
    [76] P. Karnezis, D.C.J.Farrugia. Study of cold tube drawing by finite-element modelling[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 80-81(1998) 690-694.
    [77]申卫华,李章刚等.铜管游动芯头拉拔模具角度优化的有限元模拟[J],塑性工程学报,2005,12(2): 61-64.
    [78]牟取晗,黄东男.游动芯头拉拔模具受力和温度分布的数值模拟[J],内蒙古石油化工,2007(2): 26-28.
    [79]黄东男,张士宏,王鹏程,唐正魁.游动芯头拉拔模具锥角优化的数值模拟[J],机械工程与自动化,2006,135(2):33-35.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700