用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于自组织理论的电信产业系统演化发展研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
电信业是国民经济发展和信息化建设的基础性产业,技术的进步和经济全球一体化使我国电信业面临激烈的竞争挑战。目前中国电信业取得了巨大成就,但其发展现状仍然不能适应国民经济发展的要求,还存在对外开放程度低、产业协调性差、自主创新能力弱、国际竞争力不强等诸多问题。我国电信业正面临调整和转型。振兴电信业将是我国当前和今后相当长时期内的一项重大任务。由于传统产业经济理论在研究电信产业经济具有一定的局限性,因此需要我们以新的视角来加深对电信业的研究。系统研究电信产业演化问题具有重要理论价值和现实意义。
     本文把电信产业看作一个复杂的系统。从演化的角度,综合运用自组织理论、灰色系统理论、复杂适应系统理论等多学科知识,结合电信业的行业特色和实际存在的问题,采用定量和定性分析相结合、类比和移植、多主体建模等方法对电信业系统自组织演化发展的耗散结构特性、基本动力、实现途径和演化内外部表现形势等几个方面进行了应用研究。具体研究内容如下:
     (1)分析了电信产业系统内部构成主体要素、结构、特性和电信产业的外部环境,并定量分析了电信产业系统的复杂性。本文采用Takens嵌入定理和时间延迟的相空间重构思想,构造出电信业经济指标的时间序列吸引子。通过计算关联维对电信业经济指标时间序列的复杂性进行了判定,证实了我国电信产业系统是一个复杂系统。
     (2)从系统的角度界定了电信产业演化发展的内涵。对电信产业演化机制进行了分析,本文认为电信产业的演化发展是自组织和他组织的复合作用。基于自组织研究的可行性,对电信产业系统进行耗散条件的判据和熵分析,运用布鲁塞尔器分析了电信产业系统形成耗散结构的机制和条件。
     (3)综合运用协同学及灰色系统建模方法建立电信产业系统协同演化模型,求出系统演化的序参量,即用户需求、电信投资和业务创新这三个序参量决定了电信产业演化的方向。从演化模型中可以看出我国电信产业正在由投资驱动转向创新驱动和市场需求驱动。本文还从企业内部、产业链内部,产业链之间等三个层次出发分析了电信产业系统中的协同与竞争机制。运用复杂适应系统理论和多主体建模方法对运营商和SP协同机制做了经济仿真分析,进一步揭示市场的自组织行为。
     (4)从超循环和突变的角度对电信产业系统演化发展的实现途径进行分析。本文指出电信产业系统子系统的内部和子系统之间都存在着超循环。这些超循环有助于产业系统的各主体要素和子系统的竞争与协同。通过不断扩大的超循环链条,电信产业系统内部涨落现象带来的局部渐变得到积累,使得涨落突破一定的阈值,最终导致电信产业系统的整体突变现象的出现。而电信产业系统外部演化途径是电信产业系统演化的渐变和突变的两种形式。通过系统的外在渐变和突变的表现形式,电信产业系统表现出从无序到有序的演化发展途径。电信产业系统的突变与通信技术的发展有着紧密联系。
     (5)本文在实证分析中验证了我国电信产业系统演化过程遵循Logstic方程曲线,并得出电信业、移动通信业、固定通信业和电信设备制造业的演化轨迹。同时,本文还运用自组织理论分析了我国电信产业演化发展中存在的问题。针对这项问题,提出了我国发展3G产业的对策。
Telecommunication industry is fundamental to the development of national economy and informationization of other industries. Because of technological progress and the globalization of world economy, Chinese telecom industry is facing intensive competitive challenges. At present, China's telecom industry has made great achievements, but it still can not meet the requirements of the national economy development. There are many problems, such as a low level of opening to the outside, the poor coordination of sub-systems, the poor capability of independent innovation, the weakness of international competitiveness, and so on. China's telecom industry is facing the adjustment and transformation. The revitalization of China's telecommunications industry will be a major mission at present and in the future. The limitations of the traditional industry economy theory are gradually revealed in the study of the telecom industrial economy. A new perspective is needed, from which the telecom industry can be studied deeply. A systematic research on the evolution of the telecom industry has an important theoretical value and practical significance.
     In this dissertation, the telecom industry is regarded as a complex system whose dissipative structure character, basic driving force, ways of realization and evolutionary internal and external manifestations are studied from the view of self-organization evolution. And some multidisciplinary knowledge is comprehensively used, including self-organization theory, the gray system theory and complex adaptive systems theory. Through the whole process of research, the characteristics and practical problems of telecom industry are taken into account carefully. The methods of the quantitative and qualitative analysis, analog and transplantation analysis, and multi-agent system modeling are adopted to research the evolopment of telecom industry. Specific studies are as follows:
     (1) The main elements of system which constitute the telecom industry, together with their functions and the external environment, are firstly analyzed. Then the complexity characteristics of the telecom industry system are also analyzed. In this paper, Taken's embedding theorem and the time delay phase space reconstruction ideology are used to construct the time series of economic indicators (that is, the total amount of telecommunication services of the telecom industry). By calculating the fractal dimension of the time series, the telecom industry is proved to be a complex system.
     (2) The self-organization mechanism of the telecom industry is analyzed from the point of system. We think that the evolution developmentof the telecom industry is a complicated result of self-organization and hetero-organization. Based on the feasibility of self-organization, the dissipative structure criterion of the telecom industry and the entropy are analyzed. By using Brusselator, the instability condition and mechanism, which result in that telecom industry becomes a dissipative system, are quantitatively analyzed.
     (3) The synergetic evolution model of telecom industry is established by synergy and gray system modeling method, and synergetic order parameter of telecom industry system is drawn. The order parameter is the user demand, telecommunications investment and innovation of telecom services. These three order parameters simultaneously decided the the evolutionary direction of telecom industry. From the synergy model it concludes that the driving force of China's telecom industry evolution is shifting from investment-driven mode to innovation-driven and demand-driven mode. Meanwhile, the telecom industry collaboration and competition mechanism is analyzed from the different levels including the enterprise level, industry chain analysis level. Finally, based on complex adaptive system theory and multi-agent modeling method, the coordination mechanism between telecom operators and SP is analyzed by computer simulation.
     (4) The evolution development path of telecom industry is analyzed by means of the hypercycle and catastrophe theory. There exits hypercycles among the internal elements of each subsystem and among subsystems of telecom industry system. These hypercycles induced the competition and collaboration among the main elements of subsystems and among subsystems of telecom industrial systems. Through these expanding hypercycle chains, fluctuation phenomena of the system will bring the accumulation of local changes. When the accumulation exceeds a certain threshold, it eventually leads to catastrophe phenomenon of the telecom industry. The external evolution way of the telecom industry system shows two forms, that is gradual evolution and calamity. Through the external gradual change and calamity forms of the system, the telecom industry system follows the evolutionary approaches from disorder to order development. Telecom industry system calamity is closely linked with the development of communication technology. Telecom industry value chain's structural change is caused usually by the development of communication technology.
     (5) Based on demonstration analysis, it is validated that the evolutionary process of China's telecom industry follows Logistic curve. At the same time, the problems in the China's telecom industry development are analyzed by using self-organization theory. And the correspondent strategies of the 3G telecom industry development are put forward.
引文
[1]吴洪,黄秀清,苑春绘,通信经济学[M],北京邮电大学出版社,2007.
    [2]中国通信企业协会,中国通信统计年度报告2007年[C],人民邮电出版社,2007.
    [3]http://www.miit.gov.cn/
    [4]拉丰J.J.,泰勒尔J.,电信竞争[M],人民邮电出版社,2001.
    [5]Olivier B.,Giuseppe N.,Regulation Market Structure and Performance In Telecommuncations[C],OECD Economics Department Working Paper,No.237,2000.
    [6]Michalis M.,Local competition and the role of regulation:the EU debate and Britain's experience[J],Telecommunications Policy,Vol.25,No.11.2001,759-776.
    [7]Koski H.A.,Majumdar S.K.,Paragons of virtue? Competitor entry and the strategies of incumbents in the US local telecommunications industry[J],Information Economics and Policy,No.14,2002,453-480.
    [8]Knittel Christopher R.,Regulatory Restructuring and Incumbent Price Dynamics:The Case of U.S.Local Telephone Markets[J],The Review of Economics and Statistics,Vol.86,No.2,2004,614-625.
    [9]Fox Eleanor M.The WTO's First Antitrust Case-Mexican Telecom:A Sleeping Victory for Trade and Competition[J],Journal of International Economic Law,Vol.9,No.2,2006,271-292.
    [10]Sissel Jensen,Implementation of competitive nonlinear pricing:tariffs with inclusive consumption[J],Review of Economic Design,Vol.10,No.1,2006,9-29.
    [11]张维迎,盛洪,从电信产业看中国的反垄断问题[J],改革,No.2,1998,66-75.
    [12]陈小洪,中国电信产业:政策、产业组织的变化及若干建议[J],管理世界,No.1,1999,126-138.
    [13]唐守廉,电信管制[M],北京邮电大学出版社,2001.
    [14]陈宏平,市场结构与政府管制的对称与动态均衡--关于中国电信产业管制改革的实证分析[J],经济评论,No.3,2002,91-94.
    [15]杨宏伟,中国电信产业的产业组织与变迁[D],博士学位论文,上海,复旦大学,2005.
    [16]Hardy A.,The role of the telephone in Economics development[J],Telecommunication Policy,.Vol.4,1980,278-286.
    [17]Carr.G.W.,Telecommunications,contribution to economic development,Conference record "World Prosperity Through Communication"[C],IEEE International Conference,Vol.1,1989,319-323.
    [18]Norton.S.W.,Transaction costs,telecommunication,and the mioroeconomics,of maoroeconomics growth[J],Economic Development and Cultural Change,No.90,1992,175-196.
    [19]Cneenstein S.,Pablo T.S.,Estimating the welfare effects of digital infrastructure[C],NBER working paper,September,1996,5770.
    [20]Madden Gray,Savage Scott J.,CEE telecommunication investment and economic growth.Information[J],Economics and Policy,No.10,1998,173-195.
    [21]Roller L.H.,Waverman L.,Telecommunications infrastructure and economic development:a simultaneous approach[C],CERP discussion paper,March,2000,2399.
    [22]刘国亮,赵英才,区域电信技术进步与创新的贡献率测算[J],长春邮电学院学,Vol.18,No.3,2000,12-17.
    [23]信息产业部电信研究院通信政策与管理研究所,电信产业对国民经济和社会贡献的定量研究[C],北京,信息产业部电信研究院通信政策与管理研究所,2006.
    [24]刘宇,中国电信产业对国民经济影响的量化分析[D],北京,中国社会科学院数量经济与技术经济研究所.2005.
    [25]Rouse W.B.,A Theory of Enterprise Transformation,Systems,Man and Cybernetics[J],IEEE International Conference on 2005,Vol.1,No.10,2005,2233-2245.
    [26]Rouse W.B.,Enterprises as Systems:Essential Challenges and Approaches to Transformation[J],Engineering Management Review,IEEE 2005,Vol.33,No.3,2005,138-150.
    [27]Rouse W.B.,Cannon B.,Salas E.,The role of mental models in team performance in complex systems,Systems,Man and Cybernetics[J],IEEE Transactions on1992,Vol.22,No.6,1992,1296-1308.
    [28]David P.,Development and Initial Testing of a Theoretical Model of transformation[J],Proceedings of the 33rd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences-2000.
    [29]Raymond J.Adensamer,A Process-Centric Approach to Enterprise Transformation[J],Network Operations and Management Symposium,IEEE 1996,Vol.3,1996,15-19.
    [30]刘钢庭,转型经济条件下中国自然垄断产业演变及企业行为研究[D],博士学位论文,广州,华南理工大学,2004.
    [31]朱金周,电信转型:通信信息服务业的产业政策[M],北京邮电大学出版社,2007.
    [32]曾勇,我国电信企业向现代综合信息服务提供商转型的思考[J],电信网技术,No.8,2005,24-27.
    [33]王育民,电信业的转型与运营商的策略[J],当代通信,No.22,2005,14-15.
    [34]张耀寰,梁雄健,付亮,电信运营的转型及实施[J],电信科学,No.1,2006,34-36.
    [35]马慧,基于系统科学的电信运营企业转型研究[D],博士学位论文,北京,北京邮电大学,2006.
    [36]岳欣,固定网络运营商转型研究[D],博士学位论文,北京,北京邮电大学,2007.
    [37]孔文,移动通信生态系统的演化[J],世界电信,No.1,2002,25-29.
    [38]王育民,从电信价值链到产业生态系统[J],通信企业管理,No.3,2004,28-30.
    [39]郭晓岩,移动生态体系发展规律探寻[J],通信企业管理,No.9,2004,60-62.
    [40]金吾伦,郭元林,国外复杂性科学的研究进展[J],国外社会科学,No 6,2003,2-5.
    [4l]贝塔朗菲著,一般系统论:基础、发展和应用[M],清华大学出版社,1987.
    [42]维纳著,郝季仁译,控制论[M],科学出版社,1963.
    [43]Nicolis G.,Prigogine I.,Self-organization in Nonequilibrium System[M],Wiley,New York,1977.
    [44]Haken H.,Synergetics:An Introduction[M],Spring-Verlog,1997.
    [45]Eigen M.,Schuster P.,The Hypercycle:A Principle of Natural Self-organization[M],Springer-Verlag,Berlin,1979.
    [46]Thom R.,Structure stability and morphogenesis[M],Reading Mass,Benjamin,1975.
    [47]郝柏林,混沌与分形[M],上海科学出版社,2004.
    [48]Manddbrot,B.B.Stochastic models for the earth's relif,the shape and fractal dimension of the coastlines and the number-area rule for islands[C],Proc.Nat.Acad.Sci.USA,1975,72.
    [49]Zhou T,Zhou P I,Wang B H,et al.Modeling Stock Market Based on Genetic Celluar Automata[J],Int J Mod Phys B,No.18,2004,2697-2703.
    [50]Wolfran S.,Theory and Application of Cellular Automata[M],Singapore World Scientific,1986.
    [51]Holland J.H,Hidden Order:How adaptation builds complexity[M],Addison-Wesley,1996
    [52]约翰.霍兰著,陈禹译,涌现-从混沌到有序[M],上海科学技术出版社,2001.
    [53]Christof Koch,Gilles Laurent.Complexity and the Nervous System[J],Science,Vol.284,No.2,1999,96-98.
    [54]Arthur W.,Complexity and the Economy[J],Science,Vol.284,No.2,1999,107-109.
    [55]Heylighen Francis;Bollen Johan,Riegler Alexander,The Evolution of Complexity[M],Dordrecht:Kluwer Academic Publishers,1999.
    [56]The NPCV England Complex Systems Institute,Emergence[J],A Journal of Complexity Issues in Organizations and Management,Vol.1,No.1,1999.
    [57]Day R.,The emergence of chaos from classical economic growth[J],The Quarterly Journal of Economic.May,1983,201-203.
    [58]Boldrin M.,and Woodford M.Equilibrium models displaying endogenous fiuctuations and chaos[J],Journal of monetary economics,No.25,1990,182-222.
    [59]Smale S.,Dynamics retrospective:great problems,attempts that failed[J],Physica D,Vol.51,1991,267-273.
    [60]Arrow,K.J.,Behavior Under Uncertainty and Its Implications for Policy[C],In D.E.Bell,H.Raiffa&A.Tversky(eds.).Decision Making.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.1988,497-507.
    [61]Arthur W.,Competing technologies,increasing returns and lock-in by historical events[J],Economic Journal,Vol.99,1989,116-131.
    [62]Arthur W.,Positive Feedback in the Economy[J],Scientific American,Vol.2,1990,92-99.
    [63]Peters Edgar E.,Fractal Market Analysis:Applying Chaos Theory to Investment and Economics[M],John Wiley & Sons,Inc.,1994.
    [64]Peters Edgar E.,Chaos and Order in Capital Markets:A New View of Cycles,Prices and Market Volatility[M],John Wiley & Sons,Inc.,1996.
    [65]Arthur W B,Holland J,Lebaron B,et al.Asset Pricing under Endogenous Expectations in an Artificial Stock Market in Arthur W B,Durlauf S,Lane D.The Economy as an Evolving Complex System Ⅱ[C].Boston:Addison-Wesley,1997,15-44.
    [66]Cilliers P.,Complexity and postmodemism:understanding complex systems[M],Routledge,1998.
    [67]Takadama K.,Terano T.,Shimohara K.,Nongovemance Rather Than Governance in a Multiagent Economic Society[J],IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation.Vol.5,No.5,2001,535 -545.
    [68]Lin Fu-ren,Huang Sheng-hsiu,Lin Sheng-cheng.Effects of Information Sharing on Supply Chain Performance in Electronic Commerce[J],IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,Vol.49,No.3,2002,223-233.
    [69]吴彤,自组织方法论研究[M],清华大学出版社,2001.
    [70]赫尔曼.哈肯,协同学:大自然构成的奥秘[M],上海译文出版社,1995.
    [71]Mandelbrot B.B.,The Fractal Geometry of Nature[M],Freeman,1982.
    [72]方兆煃,维数:从纯粹几何学走入经验科学[J],自然杂志,Vol.15,No.1,1998,30-34.
    [73]Pierre M.Auger,Self-Organization in Hierarchically Organized Systems[J],Systems Research,No.4,1990,221-236.
    [74]Schieve William G.,Allen Peter M.,Self-Organization and Dissipative Structures:Applications in the Physical and Social Sciences[M],Austin,TX:University of Texas Press,1982,132-158.
    [75]Krugman P.R.,The self-Organization Economy[J],Blackwell Publishers Cambridge MA.,1996.
    [76]Scheinkman J.A.,WoodFood M.,Self-Organized criticality and economic fluctuations[J],AEA Papers and Proceedings,Vol.5,1994,417- 421.
    [77]Jacques Lesourne,Richard H.Day,Chen Ping eds.Nonlinear Dynamics and Evolutionary Economics.[M]New York,Oxford University Press,1993,150-166.
    [78]Martin Rinne,Technology Roadmaps:Infrastructure for innovation[J],Technological Forecasting & Social Change,Vol.71,No.8,2004,67-80.
    [79]Kostoff R.,Schaller R.,Science technology roadmaps[J],IEEE Trans.Eng.Manage,Vol.48,No.3,2001,132-143.
    [80]Witt Ulrich,Self-organization and economics--what is new?[J],Structural Change and Economics Dynamics,No.8,1997,489-507.
    [81]Foster John,Economics and the Self-Organization Approach:Alfred Marshall Revisited[J],Economic Journal,No.7,1993,975-991.
    [82]Rycroft Robert W.,Don E.Kash.,Self-Organization Innovation Networks:Implications for Globalization[J],Technovation,Vol.24,No.7,2004,187-197.
    [83]Silverberg G.,Dosi Orsenigol,Innovation,Diversity,and Diffusion:A Self Organizing Model[J],Economic Journal,Vol.98,No.393,1988,1032-1054.
    [84]叶金国,张世英,企业技术创新过程的自组织与演化模型[J],科学学与科学技术管理,No.12,2002,74-77.
    [85]Andrew C.Inkpen,"Creating Knowledge Through Collaboration," California Management Review,Fall 1996,124.
    [86]Sergio Focardi,Silvano Cincotti,Michele Marchesi,Self-organization and market crashes[J],Journal of Economics Behavior & Organization,Vol.49,No.1,2002,241-267.
    [87]Johnson N.F.,Jarvis S.,Volatility and agent adaptability in a self-organizaition market[J],Physica A,Vol.258,No.5,1998,230-236.
    [88]王红霞,基于自组织理论的住宅房地产市场系统演化研究[D],硕士学位论文,南京,东南大学,2006.
    [89]Nelson R R.,Recent evolutionary theorizing about economic change[J].Journal of Economic Literature,Vol.18,No.3,1995,48-90
    [90]邓英淘,何维凌,动态经济系统的调节与演化[M],四川人民出版社,1985.
    [91]胡传机,周豹荣,非平衡系统经济学[M],吉林人民出版社,1987.
    [92]沈华嵩,经济系统的自组织理论[M],中国社会科学出版社,1991.
    [93]王述英,白雪洁,杜传忠,产业经济学[M],经济科学出版社,2006.
    [94]颜泽贤,复杂系统演化论[M],人民出版社,1999.
    [95]马丰,杨玉凤,电信市场-建立共赢的价值链竞争模式[J],电信,No.7,2003,99-101.
    [96]黄逸珺,电信运营产业供应链的系统动力学模型[D],博士学位论文,北京,北京邮电大学,2005.
    [97]Takens F.Detecting strange attractors in turbulence[J].Lecture Notes in Mathematics,Vol.898,1981,366-381.
    [98]吕金虎,陆君安,陈士华,混沌时间序列分析及其应用[M],武汉大学出版社,2005.
    [99]马红光,李夕海,王国华,相空间重构中嵌入维和时间延迟的选择[J],西安交通大学学报,Vol.38,No.4,2004,335-338.
    [100]Grassberger P.and ProcacciaL.,Measuring the strangeness of strange attractors[J],Physica D,No.9,1983,189-208.
    [101]吴彤,曾国屏,自组织思想:观念演变、方法和问题[J],上海科技教育出版社,2000.
    [102]才华,基于自组织理论的黑龙江省电信产业系统演化发展研究[D],博士学位论文,哈尔滨工程大学.2006.
    [103]赫尔曼.哈肯,信息与自组织[M],四川教育出版社,1990.
    [104]钱学森,论系统工程[M],湖南科学技术出版社,1982.
    [105]蔡绍洪,彭仕政,赵行知等,耗散结构与非平衡相变原理及其应用[M],贵州出版社,1999.
    [106]沈小峰,自组织的哲学--一种新的自然观和科学观[M],中共中央党校出版社,1993.
    [107]谷超豪,非线性现象的个性和共性[J],科学,No.3,1992,10-12.
    [108]梁雄键,张静,通信服务创新[M],北京邮电大学出版社,2002.
    [109]许国志,系统科学[M],上海科技教育出版社,2000.
    [110]赫尔曼.哈肯著,凌复华译,协同学一大自然构成奥秘[M],上海译文出版社,2001.
    [111]吴彤,自组织理论与方法.内蒙古社会科学(汉文版)[J],No.6,2000,196-265.
    [112]Mainzer K.,Brain,Computer,Complexity[M],Springer,1997.
    [113]苗东升,系统科学原理[M],中国人民大学出版社,1990.
    [114]陈兵兵,协同和智能化的电子商务[J],IT经理世界,No.3,2001,76-78.
    [115]谭跃进,系统学原理[M],国协科技大学出版社,1996.
    [116]高锡荣,刘伟,中国电信市场的需求关系估计与需求效应介析[J],数量经济技术经济研究,2007,No.4,26-35
    [117]刘思耕,党耀国,方志耕等,灰色系统理论及应用[M],科学出版社,2008.
    [118]张玉轩,控制系统CAD[M],西安交通大学出版社,1991.
    [119]堪安琦,科技工程的数学模型[M],中国铁道出版社,1988.
    [120]邹辉霞,供应链协同管理理论与方法[M],北京大学出版社,2007.
    [121]陈小洪,马骏,何霞,移动通信革命.产业发展与社会经济影响[M],北京邮电大学出版社,2007.
    [122]冯小芳,周文杰,基于3G网络的中国电信CP/SP合作模式分析[J],No.2,2007,19-21.
    [123]宋军,运营商如何与SP合作的策略分析[J],移动通信,No.4,2004,45-47.
    [124]卢安文,电信市场品牌竞争中的“智猪”博弈模型构建[J],企业经济,No.11,2006,87-89.
    [125]朱洪瑞,王宏江,我国电信企业在价值网中的竞争合作[J],河北理工大学学报(社会科学版),Vol.6,No.1,2006,93-97.
    [126]乔尔.布利克,戴维.厄恩斯特,协作型竞争-全球市场的战略联营与收购[M],中国大百科全书出版社,1998.
    [127]黄登仕,经济复杂性现象研究思路[J],经济学动态,No.1,2001,54.57.
    [128]Robert A.Advancing the Art of Simulation in the Social Sciences[J].Complexity Magazine,Vol.3,No.2,1987,32-38.
    [129]廖守亿,戴金海,复杂适应系统及基于Agent的建模与仿真方法[J],系统仿真学报,Vol.16,No.1,2004,113-117.
    [130]Charlotte Bruun,Francesco Luna,Endogenous Growth in a Swarm Economy:Fighting Time,Space,and Complexity[J],Computing in Economics and Finance,No.3,1999,1354.
    [131]Mittone L.,Patelli P.,Imitative Behaviour in Tax Evasion.In Stefansson B.and Luna,F.(eds.):Economic Simulations in swarm:Agent-Based Modelling and Objected Oriented Programming[C],Boston,MA:Kluwer Academic Publishers,2000
    [132]Sapienza M.D.,An Experimental Approach to the Study of Banking Intermediation:The BankNet Simulator,In Luna,F.and Stefansson B.(eds.),Economic Simulations in swarm:Agent-Based Modelling and Objected Oriented Programming[C],Boston,MA:Kluwer Academic Publishers,2000
    [133]Jares T.E.,Numerical Modeling,Noise Trades and the swarm simulation system,In Luna,F.and Stefansson B.(eds.),Economic Simulations in swarm:Agent-Based Modelling and Objected Oriented Programming[C],Boston,MA:Kluwer Academic Publishers,2000
    [134]Schlueter-Langdon C.,Bruhn P.,Shaw M.J.,Online Supply Chain Modeling and Simulation,Advances in Computational Economics[C],Boston,MA;Kluwer Academic Publishers,2000
    [135]朱晔,叶民强,区域可持续发展预警的SWARM博弈仿真模拟探析[J],财经研究,Vol.28,No.1,2002,57-63.
    [136]王文举,任韬,二元劳动力市场资源优化配置模型与仿真研究[J],数量经济技术经济研究,No.2,2006,61-66.
    [137]王利,韩振国,基于主体的完全可竞争市场演化仿真模型[J],经济与管理研究,No.10,2005,66-70.
    [138]http://www.swarm.org[EB/OL].
    [139]Pryor R.J.,Basu N.,Quint T.,ASPEN:A Microsimulation Model of the Economy[J],Computational Economics,Vol.12.No.3,1998,223-241.
    [139]陈学彬,完善我国商业银行激励约束机制的SWARM模拟分析[J],财经研究,Vol.29,No.9,2003,68-74.
    [140]周庆,黄颖颖,陈剑,基于主体的动态竞争模型的设计与仿真[J],系统仿真学报,2005,Vol.17,No.8,1977-1981.
    [141]徐咏梅,钟拥军,基于Swarm的企业战略联盟的结构演化仿真[J],科技管理研究,No.3,2007.121-124.
    [142]Tobias Robert,Hofmann Carole.Evaluation of free Java-libraries for social-scientific agent based simulation.Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation Vol.7,No.1[EB/OL].2004.http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac_uk/7/1/6_html
    [143]黄芬,我国电信产业发展面临的问题[J],通信世界,No.14,2007,18-19.
    [144]Ellis F.,Relative Agricultural Prices and Urban Bias Model:A comparative Analysis of Tanzania and Fiji[J].Journal of Development Studies,Vol.20,No.3,1984,28-51.
    [145]黄逸珺,移动终端定制对产业链的影响因素分析[J],电信,No.9,2004,25-27.
    [146]彭林,第三代电信技术[M],电子工业出版社,2003.
    [147]吕彬,贾丹华,电信产业价值链演进之见[J],信息通信,No.3,2007,23-25.
    [148]Day R.,The emergence of chaos from classical economic growth[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economic,May,Vol.98,1983,201-203.
    [149]Baumol W.J.,Benhabib J.,Chaos significance,mechanism,and economic applications[J],Journal of Economic perspectives,Vol.3,No.1,1989,77-105.
    [150]尼科利斯.普利高津,非平衡系统的自组织(中译本)[M].科学出版社,1986.
    [151]邓英淘,动态经济系统的调节与演化[M],四川人民出版社,1985.
    [152]何磊,电信重复建设耗掉好儿个三峡,中国青年报网络版,2005,3,14.http://zqb.cyol.com/content/2005-03/14/content-1048121.htm

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700