用户名: 密码: 验证码:
市场化改革环境下基于电力系统可靠性的协同监管问题研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
摘要:在传统的垂直一体化电力体制中,电力系统的运营与监管都由政府主管部门负责,此时,电力系统监管以保证电力需求的安全稳定供应为首要目标。电力市场化改革的推进,扩展了电力产业的发展目标,即在满足安全运行要求的同时,还要实现提高经济效率、优化资源配置以及实现节能减排等目标。在此情况下,需要重新梳理当前的电力监管体系,协调电力市场经济改革、环境保护与系统可靠性等多方面监管要求。
     对中国电力产业而言,如何确保系统可靠性的同时,将经济目标和环境目标纳入电力监管体系,完善中国电力监管构架,是面临的重要问题。为此,本文将以保证系统可靠性为论文研究的问题切入点,探究适合于当前中国电力监管特征的监管体系,避免出现美欧等国在市场化改革初期出现的重大可靠性危机,实现电力产业和谐稳定发展。具体而言,论文在分析国外电力市场化改革对系统可靠性造成的影响以及国外电力监管的基本现状与特点的基础上,立足中国电力产业和电力监管现状以及存在的问题,提出了考虑系统可靠性的电力监管的基本概念,并从电力投资、环境监管和多地区监管组织构架方面实现基于系统可靠性的协同监管:阐述了系统可靠性与电力投资协同监管问题,对系统可靠性的最优化投资进行探讨,在此基础上,通过构建可靠性投资模型,分析了竞争市场、垄断市场等多种市场情况下的可靠性投资问题;从环境监管与可靠性监管角度,建立考虑环境和电力系统可靠性的理论模型,分析了存在监管情况下、无监管情况下以及不考虑环境监管情况下的社会福利最优化问题,以探索电力可靠性与环境监管的协同,在一定程度上扩展了电力监管的内涵;从可靠性角度分析研究了存在多个地区输电系统组织结构的情况下,不同监管组织结构的监管有效性问题;结合中国电力产业发展的特殊性,对考虑系统可靠性的电力监管机制进行探讨,并提出了协同监管措施建议。研究表明,1)发电与输电投资规划的协同监管能有助于系统可靠性水平的提高,同时集中式的电力市场可靠性水平更高,为此,在市场化情况下更应注意对可靠性投资的监管;2)无论在何种市场环境情况下,可靠性与环境的协同监管又有助于在单一监管目标下实现更高的社会福利;3)对于存在多个地区输电系统组织结构的电力系统而言,在无监管偏好的情况下,协同监管组织结构更有利于监管目标的实现。
     本文的创新之处体现在:1)对发电投资与电网投资的相关性进行了分析,并将与输电相关的控制系统、辅助服务、运营协议和容量等投资纳入到统一的大系统中,确定为系统可靠性。在此基础上,构建了可靠性投资优化模型,分别从社会福利情况、垄断情况、次优情况以及非合作情况等多个假设条件下,研究最优的电力可靠性投资管制体制。2)基于效用函数提出了考虑可靠性和环境污染的理论模型。该模型将电力污染物依据其污染特性和控制方法分为全球污染物和一般污染物两类,并分别研究在管制情况下和自由竞争情况下的社会福利最大化的解决方案,分析了在何种情况下能达到最优化的社会福利。3)在集中式的大型输电系统中,从系统可靠性角度,分析存在多地区输电系统情况下的最优监管组织结构及其有效协同的问题。在此基础上,从输电系统可靠性的互补性与替代性角度,对输电运行组织结构的优化问题进行了探讨。
ABSTRACT:In the traditional vertically integrated electric power system, the government department is the unique one who is responsible for the operation and regulation of power system. And under this circumstance, the primary goal of power system supervision is to ensure the supply of electricity safely and stability. With the continually reforming of electricity market, the goal of development is extended, that is, economic efficiency shall be improved, resources allocation shall be optimized, energy conservation shall be achieved, etc. while the requirement of safe operation is met. Thus, the current electric supervision system must be rearranged, system reliability, and market reformation、environment protection and system reliability and other targets must be coordinated.
     For China's electric power industry, how to take the economic and environmental goals into supervision system and perfect China's electricity regulatory framework, while how to ensure system reliability, is the important issue what faced now. Therefore, this paper will set the ensuring of system reliability as the breakthrough point, to explore a regulatory system suited the current China's electricity market, to avoid the happening of terrible reliability crises (just like what happened in United States, Europe etc. in the early stage of market reforming), and finally to realize a harmonious and stable development in electric power industry. Specifically, this paper firstly analyses the impacts of foreign power market reformation on system reliability and the current status at home and abroad and characteristics of foreign electricity regulation. Then, based on the status and problems existed in China's electricity industry and power supervision, the paper proposes the basic conception of electric power regulation considering system reliability. Secondly, the paper describes system reliability and synergistic regulation of power investment, and discusses the optimal investment of system reliability. Then, on this basis, the paper analyses reliability investment issues in different markets (such as competitive market, monopoly market, etc.) by building a reliability investment model. Thirdly, in order to explore synergistic regulation between environment and system reliability, social welfare optimization problem (under different circumstances:supervision, no supervision and without considering environment supervision) is analyzed by building a theoretical model considering environment and system reliability, from the perspective of environment supervision and system reliability regulation. Fourthly, from the viewpoint of reliability, the paper analyzes and studies the regulatory efficiency of different supervisory organization structure under the multiple regional transmission system. Finally, based on the specificity of China's electric power industry development, the paper discusses the mechanism of electric power supervision with considering system reliability, and proposes suggestions on synergistic regulation measures.
     Research shows:1) Synergistic regulation of investment planning of generation and transmission could raise the level of system reliability; meanwhile, the reliability level of concentrate power market is higher. Therefore, in the case of the market, supervision on reliability investment should be paid more attention.2) No matter under what market conditions, regulation between reliability and environment would contribute to achieve higher social welfare under a single regulatory objective.3) For the power system with a multi-regional transmission structure, without regulatory preferences, synergistic regulatory structure is more advantageous to the realization of the supervisory target.
     The innovations of this paper are:1) The correlation between grid investment and power generation investment is analyzed. What's more, control system, auxiliary services, operation agreement, capacity, etc. which are relevant to transmission are considered into the united system to identify system reliability. On this basis, reliability investment optimization model is built to study the optimal investment control system of power reliability, respectively from the hypothesis of social welfare, monopoly, sub-optimal, non-cooperation, etc.2) Theoretical model based on the utility function and considered reliability and pollution is proposed. In this model, electric pollutants are classified into two types:global pollutants and general pollutants, according to pollution features and pollution control methods. And the solutions of social welfare optimization are studied under the different circumstances of control and free competition separately, and in what circumstance the social welfare is optimal is discussed.3) In the large concentrated transmission system, optimal supervisory organization structure existing multi-regional transmission system and its effective coordination issues are analyzed from the viewpoint of reliability. And on this basis, optimization of transmission operation organization structure is discussed from the perspective of the reliability and alternative of transmission system.
引文
[1]国家电力监督委员会编.《国外电力市场规则和发电业务许可制度》[M].北京:中国电力出版社,2004.10
    [2]朱成章,杨名舟,黄元生.《电力工业管制与市场监管》[M].北京:中国电力出版社,2003.1-320
    [3]陈建长.电力市场监管理论与实践的探讨[J].电力技术经济.2007,(1):32-36
    [4]戴维·M·纽伯里.《网络产业的重组与规制》[M].北京:人民邮电出版社,2002
    [5]刘小兵.《政府管制的经济分析》[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2004.P1-169
    [6]世界银行(2001).《中国电力部门管制框架研究报告》[R],中国电力行业监管国际研讨会
    [7]潘敬东,赵源,欧国立.中国电力产业的监管改革.北京交通大学学报(社会科学版).2005Vol.4 No.1 P.10-13
    [8]U.S-Canada Power system outage task force. Finalre Porton the August 14,2003 Black out in the United States and Canada:causes and recommendations[EB/OL]. http://www.nere.com/, 2004
    [9]鲁宗相.解析莫斯科大停电.中国电力企业管理,2005,(7):20,30-31
    [10]赵希正.提升服务能力服务行业发展.中国电力企业管理,2005,(7):27
    [11]馋伟华,艾芋,周玉光,等.莫斯科5·25大停电对中国电力市场发展的启示[J].华东电力,2005,33(7):45-45
    [12]顾培亮.系统分析与协调[M].天津:天津大学出版社,1998
    [13]曾健,张一方.社会协同学[M].北京:科学出版社,2000
    [14]德]H.哈肯著.协同学引论——物理学、化学和生物学中的非平衡相变和自组织[M].徐锡申等译.北京:原子能出版社,1984
    [15][德]H.哈肯著.高等协同学[M].郭治安译.北京:科学出版社,1989
    [16]Stirling A C.A general framework for analyzing diversity in science,technology and society [J]Journal of the Royal Society Interface,2007.
    [17]Alfredo Garcia, Luis E.Arbelaez.Market power analysis for the Colombian electricity market[J].Energy Economics,2002(24):217-229
    [18]Carolyn A, Berry, Benjamin F, Hobbs, et al.Understanding how market power can arise in network competition:a game theoretic approach[J].Utilities Policy,1998(8):139-158
    [19]王维国,协调发展的理论与方法研究,中国财政经济出版社,2001
    [20]阮大伟.电力体制改革与供应链管理.北京:中国经济出版社,2006
    [21]Jeffrey H, Grobman, Janis M.Carey.Price caps and investment:long-run effects in the electric generation industry[J].Energy Policy,2001(29):545-552
    [22]刘翔.协同管理方法研究[J].技术经济与管理研究,2004(5):87-88
    [23]谢亮,彭本红,胡若.非资产型第三方物流的协同管理研究[J].科技管理研究,2006(4):213-216
    [24]刘纯,贺佐成.高校电子政务协同模式研究[J].中国教育信息化,2007(7):43-46
    [25]林跃翔,邱祥锋等.基于协同管理的水利信息化研究[J].测绘科学,2007增刊:51-54,62
    [26]赵晓敏.基于多智体代理的供应链协同管理[J].商业研究,2006.21-24
    [27]丁铭华.企业集团资源协同管理环状机制模型研究[J].上海经济研究,2010(2):75-81
    [28]吴弘、胡伟著:《市场监管法论——市场监管法的基础理论与基本制度》,北京大学出版2006年1月版
    [29]Edward J. Kane, Ethical Foundations of Financial Regulation[Z], NBER Working Paper 6020,1997, p3
    [30]Kahn, A. E. (1970), The Economics of Regulation:Principles and Institutions [J], New York: Wiley
    [31]Baumol.W. J, Panzar and R .D. Willig (1982), Contestable Markets and the Theory of Industry Structure[J], New York:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
    [32]Laffont and Tirole,1993:A Theory of Incentives in Procurement and Regulation MIT Press
    [33]文福栓,吉兴全,王钦.电力工业改革对电力系统可靠性的影响[J].电力科学与技术学报,2007,22(3):1-11
    [34]Mariano Ventosa, alvaro Baillo, Andres Ramos, Michel Rivier. Electricity market modeling trends[J].Energy Policy,2005(33):897-913
    [35]Nahman J, Skokljev I. Probabilistic steady-state power system security indices [J].Electrical Power and Energy Systems,1999,21(7):515-522
    [36]Bazanella A S, Silva A S E. Coordinated design of damping controllers for robustness of power systems stability[J].Electric Power and Energy Systems,2001,23(1):69-79
    [37]Wacker G, Billinton R. Customer cost of electric service interruptions, proceedings of the IEEE,1989,77(6):919-930
    [38]R Billinton, L Salvaderi, J D McCalley, et al. Reliability Issues In Today's Electric Power Utility Enviroment[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,1997,12(4):1708-1714
    [39]Risheng Fang, David J Hill. A New Strategy for Transmission Expansion in Competitive Electricity Markets. Power Systems, IEEE Transactions on,2003,18(1):374-380
    [40]R Billinton, L Cui, Z Pan. Quantitative reliability considerations in the determination of performance-based rates and customer service disruption payments[J]. Generation,Transmission and Distribution,2002,149(6):640-644
    [41]T Detroz. Does Power Quality Monitoring provide financial return?[C],IEEE Conference Publication,2001,2(482):4
    [42]Asher A, Blass, Saul Lach, Charles F. Manski. USING ELICITED CHOICE PROBABILITIES TO ESTIMATE RANDOM UTILITY MODELS:PREFERENCES FOR ELECTRICITY RELIABILITY[J]. International Economic Review,2010(2):421-440
    [43]K Okada, R Yokoyama, T Niimura. Reliability-based Impact Analysis of Independent Power Producers for Power System Operations Under Deregulation[C]. Proceedings of the 1999 IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering. Piscataway, NJ, USA,1999.1325-1330
    [44]Wang P, Billinton R. Implementation of non-uniform reliability in a deregulated power market[C]. Proceedings of Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc,2001:857-862
    [45]McCalley J D, Fouad A A, Agrawal B L, et al. Risk-based security index for determining operating limits in stability-limited electric power systems[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,1997,12(3):1210-1219
    [46]Kariuki K, Allan R. Evaluation of reliability worth and calue of lost load[J]. IEEE proceedings on Generation, Transmission and Distribution,1996 (2):171-180
    [47]David A K, Liu Xujun. Dynamic security enhancement in power market system[J]. IEEE Trans. Power Systems,2002 (2):432-438.
    [48]谭伦农,张宝会等.市场环境下电力系统的安全可靠性问题[J].电力系统自动化,2002,3(6)
    [49]牛辉,程浩忠,张焰等.电网扩展规划的可靠性和经济性研究综述.2000,24(1):51-56
    [50]张保会,王立永,谭伦农等.市场环境下电力系统安全可靠性措施的经济当量[J].中国电机工程学报,2005,25(24):41-46
    [51]高燕,康重庆,钟金等.发输电系统扩展中可靠性的经济价值评估与决策[J].中国电机工程学报,2007,27(25):56-60
    [52]任震,冉立,李正然.交直流并联系统可靠性与概率动态安全分析(Ⅰ)——可靠性的概念、指标及模型.华南理工大学学报(自然科学版),1997, Vol.25 No.6:1-5
    [53]任震,冉立,李正然.交直流并联系统可靠性与概率动态安全分析(Ⅱ)——模拟的时序结构及并行分解算法.华南理工大学学报(自然科学版),1997, Vol.25 No.6:6-11
    [54]赵儆,康重庆,夏清等.电力市场中可靠性问题的研究现状与发展前景[J].电力系统自动化,2004(5):6-10
    [55]康重庆,林伟明.电力市场环境下电力系统可靠性分析的框架探讨[J].陕西电力,2007(4):1-7
    [56]何剑,程林,孙元章.电力系统运行可靠性成本价值评估[J].电力系统自动化,2009(2):5-9
    [57]李禹鹏,严正,贾燕冰,王亮.多区域互联电力系统可靠性评估方法综述[J].华东电力,2009(11):1848-1854
    [58]Wu F, Varaiya P. Spiller P, Oren S. Folks theorems on transmission access:proofs and counterexamples[J]. Journal of Regulation Economic 1996(10):5-24
    [59]YUAN Zhi-qiang, HOU Zhi-jian, SONG Yi-qun, JIANG Chuan-wen, TAI Neng-ling. Analysis of Coumot Equilibrium Considering Transmission Constrains [J]. Proseedings of the CSEE,2004 (6):73-79
    [60]ZHANG Shao-hua, WANG Xian, LI Yu-ceng. Price wise linear supply function equilibrium model for power generation markets with forward contracts [J]. Automation of Electric Power System,2003 (21):17-22
    [61]杜立民.电力库交易模式述评[J].浙大经济学刊,2005(4):3-17
    [62]王燕,李文兴.网络产业价格规制对投资行为的扭曲及改进方案[J].中国软科学,2004(s):92-96.
    [63]杨志荣.能源电力要与经济和环境协调发展[J].电力需求侧管理,2001,(04):5-8
    [64]Wacker G, Billinton R. Customer cost of electric service interruptions. Proceedings of the IEEE,1989,77(6):919-930
    [65]Sullivan M J, Vardell T, Suddeth B N, et al. Interruption costs, customer satisfaction and expectations for service reliability [J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,1996,11(2): 989-995
    [66]Joskow P L.The Regulation of Natural MonoPolies:forthcoming Handbook of Law and Economies [EB/OL].2005,http://web.mit.edu/pjoskow/www/
    [67]Hogan W. Transmission market design. Kennedy School of Govemnent[R]. Harvard Electricity Poliey Group, HarvardUniversity,2003, Working Paper-
    [68]范合君.我国输电网络扩展的激励规则与市场化方法的比较研究[J].产业经济研究,2004(2):45-49.
    [69]郑风雷,文福拴,吴复立.电力市场环境下的输电投资与扩展规划[J].电力系统自动化,2006,30(9):95-104
    [70]Rudnick,H.,Donoso,J.A.Integration of price cap and yards tick competition schemes in electrical distribution regulation[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2000,15(4):1428-1433
    [71]Hogan, William W. Contract Networks for Electric Power Transmission[J]. Journal of Regulatory Economics 1992(4):211-242
    [72]阚光辉.网络扩展激励研究:以输电网络为例[J].经济研究,2004(1):102-111
    [73]Rebelo R, de Mira&C, Kroeze.Greenhouse gas emissions from willow-based electricity:a scenario analysis for Portugal and The Netherlands[J].Energy Policy,2006(34):1367-1377.
    [74]H Spencer Banzhaf, Dallas Burtraw,Karen Palmer. Efficient emission fees in the US electricity sector[J].Resource and Energy Economics,2004(3):317-341
    [75]Martimort D. Exclusive Dealing,Common Agency and Multiprincipals Incentive Theory[J]. Rand Journal of Economics,1996,27:1-31.
    [76]Martimort D. The Multiprincipal Nature of Government[J].European Economic Review, 1996,40:673-685.
    [77]薛志钢,郝吉明等.火电厂对城市空气质量的影响模拟.环境工程,2003,21(6):72-75
    [78]陈明慈.火力发电厂环境影响评价中存在的若干问题[J].上海环境科学,1994,(05):1-3
    [79]Mrozek, Janusz R, Keeler, Andrew G. Pooling of uncertainty:Enforcing tradable permits regulation when emissions are stochastic[J].Environmental and Resource Economics,2004, (10):459-481.
    [80]陈文颖,高鹏飞,何建坤.用MARKAL-MACRO模型研究碳减排对中国能源系统的影响[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2004(03):103-106
    [81]F Q Zhang.Methodological issue in cross-country region decomposition of energy and environment indicators[J]. Energy Economics,2001,23,179-190
    [82]H Qudrat-Uiiah,Pal I.Davidsen,understand the dynamics of electricity supply,resources and pollutiong:Pakistan's case[J]. Energy,2001.26,595-606
    [83]王银凤.中国的工业化与环境保护[J].世界经济情况,2004.(22),29-33
    [84]高宏,王浣尘.电力可持续发展系统分析[J].水电能源科学,1999.(03):35-38
    [85]张福伟.电力工业可持续发展指标体系与评价方法研究[D].北京科技大学,2001
    [86]朱达.能源—环境的经济分析与政策研究[M].中国环境科学出版社,2000.(03)
    [87]于良春.中国发电能源结构与电力生产可持续性分析[J].山东社会科学,2006.(01):92-95
    [88]范金,胡汉辉.环境Kuznets曲线研究及应用[J].数学的实践与认识,2002,(6):944-951
    [89]Fullerton, Don Framework to Compare Environmental Policies[R]. NBER Working Paper, 2001(8).1-36
    [90]Fullerton, Don, Garth Heutel. The General Equilibrium Incidence of Environmental Taxes[R]. NBER Working Paper,2005(5):1-23
    [91]Fullerton, Don, Garth Heutel. The General Equilibrium Incidence of Environmental Mandates[R].Working Paper,University of texas at Austin,2006(3):1-37
    [92]赵勇,罗云峰等.寡头垄断条件下的排污权交易博弈模型闭[J].系统工程理论与实践,2003(4):27-31
    [93]张国友.一般均衡模型中排污权收费对行业产出的不确定性影响[J].数量经济技术经济研 究,2004(5):156-161
    [94]张国友,郑玉歆.中国排污权收费征收改革的一般均衡分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2005(5):3-16
    [95]肖江文,严浩.寡头垄断条件下的排污权交易博弈模型[J].系统工程理论与实践,2003(4):27-31
    [96]赵冬初.排污费该睡与环保技术创新[J].社会科学家.2006(2):58-61
    [97]姚启平,蒲勇健.不对称信息下”被挂靠企业”监管行为分析[J].建筑经济,2008(5)
    [98]Bernheim D, M Whinston. Menu Auctions,Resource Allocations and Economic Influence [J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1986,101:1-31.
    [99]Bernheim B D,M D Whinston. Common Agency[J].Econometrica,1986,54(4):923-942.
    [100]任玉珑,丁亮,阳忠明.发电侧市场力的模糊综合评判[J].工业工程,2007(2):81-83
    [101]Bergemann D, J Valimaki. Dynamic Common Agency [J]. Journal of Economic Theory, 2003,1 11(1):23-48.
    [102]Bloch F. Endogenous Structures of Association in Oligopolies[J].Rand Journal of Economics, 1997,27:537-556.
    [103]Bouwer R, Dijkstra. Political Competition,Rent Seeking and the Choice of Environmental Policy Instruments:Comment[J].Environmental&Resource Economics,2004,29:39-56.
    [104]Laffont J J, J Tirole. A Theory of Incentives in Procurement and Regulation[M]. Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press,1993
    [105]Baron D, R Myerson. Regulating a Monopolist with Unknown Costs[J].Econometrica, 1982,50:911-930.
    [106]Laffont J J, J Tirole, Using Cost Observation to Regulate Firms[J].Journal of Political Economy,1986,94:614-641.
    [107]T. Pinto, H. Morais, P. Oliveira, Z. Vale, I. Praca, C. Ramos. A new approach for multi-agent coalition formation and management in the scope of electricity markets[J]. Energy,2011 (8):5004-5015
    [108]王邴辉,李书颖.不对称信息市场下的企业营销策略[J].企业活力.2008(4):52-53
    [109]OECD. Towards a Sustainable Energy Future[Z]. OECD,2001,Paris.
    [110]European Commission.2003.2003/796/EC:Commission Decision of 11 November 2003 on establishing the European Regulators Group for Electricity and Gas,Brussels.
    [111]Thatcher M.Regulation after Delegation:Independent Regulatory Agencies in Europe [J]. Journal of European Public Policy,2002,9(6):954-972.
    [112]Gilardi F. The Institutional Foundations of Regulatory Capitalism:The Diffusion of Independent Regulatory Agencies in Western Europe[J].The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,2005,598(1):84-101.
    [113]Anders L, Lene H P, et al. Independent regulatory authorities in European electricity markets[J]. Energy policy,2006,34:2858-2870.
    [114]冯飞.加快能源管理体制改革,建立现代监管制度[R].电监会网站,1http://www.serc.gov.cn/ opencms/serc/jgyj/zcyj/news/zcyj0003.html
    [115]国家电力监管委员会,中华人民财政部,世界银行.中国电力监管能力建设研究报告[M].北京:中国水利水电出版社,2007.
    [116]韩水.电力市场环境下输电价格确定的理论与方法的研究[D].东北大学博士论文,2002
    [117]郭国川.统一调度是我国电网调度模式的理性选择.电网技术[J].2002,26(4):1-8
    [118]汤玉东.电力市场下输电服务、市场稳定性的研究[D].东南大学博士论文,2002
    [119]杨凤.中国现代电力监管体制的研究[D].辽宁大学博士论文,2004
    [120]陈志宏.试论电力监管制度的构建策略。广西质量监督导报,2008,4,100-102
    [121]李虹.中国电力工业监管体制改革研究[J].学者论坛,2004,6:21-23
    [122]杨林,建立完善的电力监管体制,中国电力教育,2008,14:38-39
    [123]何永贵,乞建勋.电力可持续发展与反垄断的经济学分析[J].华北电力大学学报.2004(6):81-84
    [124]刘谦.电力行业的监管及其法律问题.经济社会体制比较[J].2002(6):58-63
    [125]陈建长.电力市场监管理论与实践的探讨[J].电力技术经济,2007,19(1):2-6.
    [126]葛秀芳.论新时期如何完善我国电力监管体制[J].华北电力大学学报(社会科学版),2009(3):1-3
    [127]龙生平,张立荣,张方,张雁,葛社伦.西方电力监管制度的分析与启示[J].经济研究,2009(7):43-44
    [128]季红.我国电力体制改革的动因及模式比较.改革[J].2001(6):40-48
    [129]曾鸣,童明光,张艳馥等.我国未来电力市场中的经济风险-市场力风险及其防范问题[J].电网技术,2004,28(9):44-49
    [130]李雯.西方规制理论评[J].南开经济研究,2002(3):59-63
    [131]周浩,文福拴.电力市场风险管理—建模分析与预防策略.[M].浙江大学出版社,2006
    [132]胡鞍钢.我国电力体制改革环境和总体思路[J].价格理论与实践.2001(5):4-6
    [133]曹乐人.改革必须突破现有体制.中国电力企业管理.2004(5):15-16
    [134]电力改革直逼行政壁垒——“打破垄断与区域电力市场建立模式”研讨会.中国改革.2004(4):49-54
    [135]李金颖.电力-经济-环境协调与监管研究[D].天津大学,2005
    [136]薛禹胜.综合防御由偶然故障演化为电力灾难—北美“8.14”大停电的警示.电力系统自动化,2003,27(18):1-5
    [137]郭永基.加强电力系统可靠性的研究和应用—北美东部大停电的思考.电力系统自动化,2003,27(19):1-5
    [138]Crew, Michael A, Paul R. Economic Depreciation and the Regulated Firm under Competition and Technological Change[J]. Journal of Regulatory Economics 1992(4):51-61
    [139]潘敬东,韩福坤,李运平,杨小煜.华北电网多区域自动发电控制与在线经济调度的研究.电力自动化设备.2004,24(11),87-89
    [140]潘敬东,谢开,华科.计及用户响应的实时电价模型及其内点法实现.电力系统自动化.2005,29(23),8-14
    [141]Kleindorfer, Paul R, Chitru S. Fernando. Peak-Load Pricing and Reliability Under Uncertainty[J]. Journal of Regulatory Economics 1993(5):5-23
    [142]Shitovitz B, M. Spiegel. Stable Provision vs. Cournot-Nash Equilibrium in Pure Public Good Economies[J]. Journal of Public Economics Theory 2001(3):219-224
    [143]Eric Allen, Je_rey Lang, Marija Ili'c. A Combined Equivalenced-Electric, Economic, and Market Representation of the Northeastern Power Coordinating Council U.S. Electric Power System[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2008,23(3):896-907
    [144]Pollitt, M. The Arguments For and Against Ownership Unbundling of Energy Trans-mission Networks[J]. Energy Policy 2008(36):704-713
    [145]Yamashita, T. Mechanism Games with Multiple Principals and Three or More Agents[J]. Econometrica,2010(78),791-801
    [146]Severinov S. The Value of Information and Optimal Organization[J]. RAND Journal of Economics,2008(39),238-265
    [147]汤萌,沐明.美国电力市场化的实践及其启示[J].中国投资,2004(5):113-115
    [148]唐松林,任玉珑,汪洋.美国电力监管制度及启示[J].经济纵横,2007(1):58-59
    [149]张春煜.英国电力产业的政府监管[J].世界经济研究,2004(5):84-88
    [150]刘戒骄.英国电力产业的放松管制及其对我国电力改革的启示[J].经济管理,2003(22):84-90
    [151]Hope. Market dominance and market power in electric power markets[R]. Swedish Competition Authority,2005
    [152]Joskow, Paul L, and Jean Tirole:Merchant transmission investment[J]. Journal of Industrial Economics,2005,53(2),233-264
    [153]Jamasb T, W Nuttall,M Pollitt. Future electricity technologies andsystems[M]. Cambridge University Press,2006
    [154]Pollitt Michael. The arguments for and against ownership unbundling of energy transmission networks[J]. Cambridge Working Papers in Economics,2007
    [155]赵会茹,乞建勋,曾鸣,刘万福.输配电价格管制模型研究[J].中国电机工程学报,2003,23(10):89-93
    [156]欧国立.美国铁路产业管制与变迁[J].产业经济研究,2003(6):46-51
    [157]欧国立.中国铁路运输业引入竞争机制的理论依据及可行性分析[J].世界经济,2004(4):46-50
    [158]潘敬东,谢开.节点边际电价的优化原理.电力系统自动化.2005,30(22),38-42
    [159]盛慧慧,潘敬东,檀英辉,杨静.电力日前交易中多时段优化策略研究.电力科学与工程.2009(2),19-23
    [160]潘敬东,谢开,华科.旋转备用的经济分配及其内点法实现.电力系统自动化.2005,29(7),17-23
    [161]许诺,颜汉荣,文福拴,A.K.David.基于绩效的管制模式及其应用[J].电力系统自动化[J],2003(5):13-19,30
    [162]Hindi H, Greene D, Laventall C. Coordinating regulation and demand response in electric power grids using multirate model predictive control[R]. Innovative Smart Grid Technologies, 2011(1):1-8
    [163]Wang Xiaoying, Zhang Yanyan. An empirical study on the effect of electric power industry regulation reform[J]. Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management,2011(1):367-371.
    [164]Liu Faquan, Zhang Huifeng. A Refined Regulation Model for Incentive Regulation of Electric Power Transmission and Distribution[C]. Power and Energy Engineering Conference,2009(4): 1-5
    [165]陈德裕.输电电价的计算[J].电力系统自动化,2001,(7):44-47
    [166]王伟,张粒子,程瑜,麻秀范.电力市场长期交易的限价制定方法研究[J].华东电力,2007,35(3):28-30
    [167]Tetsuo Ono. The Political Economy of Environmental Taxes with an Aging Population[J]. Environmental & Resource Economics,2005(30):165-194
    [168]Thatcher M. Regulation after Delegation:Independent Regulatory Agencies in Europe[J]. Journal of European Public Policy,2002(9):954-972
    [169]Jeffrey H, Grobman, Janis M Carey. Price caps and investment:long-run effects in the electric generation industry[J].Energy Policy,2001(29):545-552
    [170]Damania R. Political Competition,Rent Seeking and the Choice of Environmental Policy Instruments [J].Environmental and Resource Economics,1999(13):415-433
    [171]David Salant. Auctions and Regulation:Reengineering of regulatory mechanisms[J]. Journal of Regulatory Economics,2000(173):195-204
    [172]杨建梅.利益协调软系统方法论-立论依据与逻辑步骤[J].控制理论与应用,1999(1):52-61.
    [173]付蓉,王蓓蓓,李扬,唐国庆.电网约束条件下基于古诺博奕的市场力分析[J].华北电力,2007(5):20-25
    [174]丁乐群,王艳波,周波,常冬玲.电力市场中发电商市场力的博弈分析[J].电力技术经济.2006(6):28-31
    [175]欧家坤,李庆昌,范杰.电力市场中市场力的辨识及监管[J].江苏电机工程,2005(6):58-61
    [176]Spatti D.H., da Silva I.N., Usida W.F., Flauzino R.A.. Real-Time Voltage Regulation in Power Distribution System Using Fuzzy Control[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery,2010(2): 1112-1123.
    [177]Hugh F. Schmidt. What Regulation May be Appropriate to Support Sustainable Energy Inputs for Electric Generation? [C]. Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS) 42nd,2009
    [178]William M. Dugger. Progressive Alternatives To Re-Regulation[J]. Journal of economic issues, 2010 (2):441-448
    [179]张集,张粒子,于亮.电力市场中的市场力分层评价指标体系[J].中国电机工程学报,2006(6):123-128
    [180]何永贵,张占国,王向阳.基于层次和模糊综合的电力市场力评价研究[J].华北电力大学学报,2007(4):76-79
    [181]洪晖虹.发电企业市场营销风险评估研究[D].2006
    [182]傅书逷,王海宁.区域共同电力市场建设中若干问题的探讨[J].电力系统自动化.2005(21):1-4
    [183]Parkkinen, Joni. Evaluating Smart Grid Development for Incentive Regulation[J]. Diplomityo, 2010(10):139
    [184]Malcolm Abbotta, Bruce Cohenb. Utility regulation—The scope and structure of electrical safety regulation[J]. Energy Policy,2011 (9):4956-4961
    [185]Kyle W Danish, Douglas W Smith, Kaitlin A Gregg. Upcoming EPA Regulations and Potential Impacts on Electric Reliability [J]. The Electricity Journal,2011 (3):7-21
    [186]Juan Rosellona, Zdenka Myslikovaa, Eric Zen6n. Incentives for transmission investment in the PJM electricity market:FTRs or regulation (or both?)[J]. Utilities Policy,2011 (1):3-13
    [187]Paroma Sanyala, Laarni T. Bulan. Regulatory risk, market uncertainties, and firm financing choices:Evidence from U.S. Electricity Market Restructuring[R]. The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,2011 (3):248-268
    [188]汪穗峰,任震,黄福全,高志华.用潮流追踪研究电力市场中的市场力[J].广东电力,2003 (5):1-5
    [189]绍华,任继勤.区域电力市场制度创新与政府干预分析[J].北京交通大学学报(社会科学版),2006(1):23-26
    [190]刘敦楠,武亚光等.安全约束对区域电力市场的影[V].电力系统自动化.2005,29(21):5-9
    [191]Posner, Richard A. Natural Monopoly and Its Regulation[J] Stanford Law Review,1969 (3):548-643
    [192]Borenstein, Severin, James Bushnell, Frank Wolak. Measuring Market Inefficiencies in California's Restructured Wholesale Electricity Market[J] American Economic Review,2002 (5):1376-1405
    [193]向海平,赵学顺.从澳大利亚看电力改革和加强监管能力[J].中国电力企业管理,2006(2):8-11
    [194]周凤翱,许婷.外国电力监管机构设置的模式[J].中国电力教育,2005(3):18-20
    [195]Hogan, William. Electricity Market Restructuring:Reforms of Reforms[J]. Journal of Regulatory Economics,2002 (1):103-132.
    [196]Fraser, Hamish. The Importance of an Active Demand Side in the Electric Industry[J]. The Electricity Journal,2001 (9):52-73
    [197]Bode, Sven, Groscurth, Helmuth-M. On the Re-regulation of the Liberalised Power Market in Europe[R]. CCLR The Carbon & Climate Law Review,2009 (2):188-197
    [198]Baldick R, Chowdhury B, Dobson I, etc. Vulnerability assessment for cascading failures in electric power systems[C]. Power Systems Conference and Exposition,2009(3):1-9
    [199]M El Ouariachi, T Mrabti. Regulation of the electric power provided by the panels of the photovoltaic systems [J]. International Journal of Physical Sciences,2009 (5):294-309
    [200]Anna Ter-Martirosyan, John Kwoka. Incentive regulation, service quality, and standards in U.S. electricity distribution[J]. Journal of Regulatory Economics,2010 (3):258-273
    [201]苏文凤,卢凤君,卫春增,陈宏明.电力企业效绩评价决策支持系统设计研究[J].现代电力,2003(3):123-128
    [202]任玉珑,杨菲菲,周滢露.从经济学视角看店里监管合谋[J].能源技术经济,2010(4):39-42

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700