用户名: 密码: 验证码:
就业、工资和福利权益:中国城市劳动力市场上的外来人口
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
改革开放以来,随着城乡之间和地区之间就业机会、收入差距的逐渐加大以及户籍等阻碍劳动力流动、导致劳动力市场分割的相关政策制度的松动,进入东部沿海城市但不具有流入地户口的外来人口数量逐年递增。作为经济增长的重要组成部分,大量的外来人口为中国经济和社会发展做出了巨大的贡献,据统计1978-1999年期间对经济增长贡献率达到了21%,对城市化发展的贡献率达到了75%。但是,众多调查研究表明,受户籍等制度性因素的影响,外来人口在就业岗位获得、工资收入和福利待遇等方面均受到了区别对待。伴随着外来人口规模的增加以及分布的集中化,歧视对经济和社会的发展、产业结构的调整升级、劳动力市场的发育以及社会的和谐稳定等产生了越来越严重的负面影响。
     因此,借鉴国内外相关研究经验,本研究以人口迁移理论、劳动力市场分割理论以及劳动力市场歧视理论为基础,利用多种微观计量方法,对外来人口的迁移选择性,以及受户籍等制度性因素的影响,外来人口及其内部女性劳动力在就业、工资和福利方面所受到的歧视程度和变化趋势进行了深入的研究。研究结果表明:
     (1)在迁移选择性方面,受教育程度对外来人口迁移行为的影响力度正在加强,不同地区的经济和社会发展对迁移概率的影响方向和影响程度不尽相同,人口流动加深了地区间和城乡间的不均衡,为更大规模的人口迁移流动埋下了伏笔。
     (2)在就业歧视方面,外来人口在职业获得上所受到的歧视程度总体上呈现上升的趋势。与本地市民相比,外来市民和农民工仅在技术人员以及办事人员两类职业的获得上存在歧视,且对后者的歧视程度要远大于前者。女性劳动力在专业技术人员、设备操作人员两种职业的获得上存在歧视,但歧视程度的变化趋势却截然相反,同时本地女性所遭受的歧视程度均大于外来女性。在行业进入上,与本地市民相比,外来市民和农民工在中等工资水平行业的进入上存在一定的歧视,并且前者所遭受的歧视程度要大于后者。与外来市民相比,农民工仅在中等以及高工资行业的进入上存在较严重的歧视。性别歧视方面,在低工资行业的进入上,外来市民内部的性别歧视程度要小于本地市民,而在中等工资水平行业的进入上略大于农民工。
     (3)在工资收入方面,群体之间以及群体内部男女劳动力之间的工资收入在整个工资分布上存在一定的差异,这在很大程度上是由户籍歧视和性别歧视造成的。群体间的分解结果显示,外来人口所受到的户籍歧视程度在各分位点上均表现为倒U型变化趋势。相对于本地市民,农民工中的中等及以上收入群体和外来市民中的中等及以下收入群体在工资获得上存在歧视,随着收入的提高和下降,歧视程度有所增加;相对于外来市民,农民工的各收入阶层在工资获得上均存在歧视,且歧视程度随着分位数的提高而增加。在对工资低估问题进行处理后,外来人口各收入阶层受到的歧视程度随着本地人口工资收入被低估程度的增加而增大。群体内部性别工资差异的分解结果显示,本地人口和外来人口中女性劳动力在整个工资分布上均存在歧视,但各自的变化趋势以及相对强弱程度有所不同。2000年以前,在中低收入阶层上,本地人口内部的性别歧视程度要远小于外来人口,而在中高收入阶层上反而远大于外来人口,2000年之后情况完全相反,并且在中低及以上收入阶层上的歧视程度不断增强。三群体的分解结果显示,本地市民、农民工和外来市民中女性劳动力所遭受的性别歧视程度存在“梯度”差异。
     (4)在福利待遇方面,50%以上的差异是由歧视造成的。与本地市民相比,农民工在劳动福利总量获得上受到歧视程度大于外来市民。在具体福利项目获得上,与本地市民和外来市民相比,农民工在各项福利的获得上均存在歧视,且与本地市民相比所受的歧视程度较大,而在假期等福利待遇上,农民工与外来市民相比不存在歧视。群体内部男女劳动力之间的分解结果表明,无论在福利总量还是具体福利项目获得上,外来市民内部的性别歧视程度要依次高于农民工和本地市民。
     最后,我们在分析国内现行反歧视法律和政策的基础上,借鉴国外所采取的措施和取得的经验,针对我国在反歧视法律和法规的制定和执行中存在的法律体系不完善、缺乏反就业歧视的专门机构和有效的救济途径等缺陷,提出了有针对性的政策建议。
Since the opening-up reform in1978, the income and employment inequalitiesbetween rural and urban areas as well as between regions have increased significantly.In the meantime, the hukou (household registration) system, which has impeded thefree flow of labour and led to the segmentation of labour market, has been loosened.Consequently, there has in recent decades been an increasing scale of people movingto a very small number of well-developed coastal regions and large cities, many ofwhom do not have local hukou (household registration). As an integral part ofChina’s economic growth, the large scale of floating population has contributedconsiderably to China’s socio-economic development, approximately21%of GDPgrowth and75%of the urbanization growth between1978and1999. However, manystudies reveal that the majority of migrant workers are treated differently from urbanlocals in the urban labour market due to their hukou status. Along with the increasingscale of migrant workers and centralized distribution, the discrimination againstmigrant workers has negative effect on socio-economic development, the industrialadjustment, labour market development and the social stability.
     Base on the migration theory, the discrimination theory and segmented labourmarket theory, this study utilizes different econometric models to examine themigration selectivity and the extent of discrimination against migrant workers andfemale workers in each group in employment, wage and welfare entitlement. Theresults suggest that:
     (1) In terms of migration selectivity, the factor of education has an increasing effecton migration propensity. The effects of socio-economic development on migrationpropensity are different in different regions. Population mobility has intensified theimbalance between rural and urban areas as well as between regions, which couldresult in a larger scale of population migration in the future.
     (2) With respect to employment, the extent of discrimination against migrantworkers shows an upward trend as a whole. Compared with urban locals, urbanmigrants and rural migrants face the mistreatment in engaging in professional and technical personnel and clerks. The extent of discrimination against the latter is muchlarger than that against the former. Female workers are discriminated in engaging inprofessional and technical personnel and equipment operators. However, thechanging patterns of the extent of discrimination are exactly opposite. In addition, theextent of discrimination against female urban locals is greater than that against femalemigrant workers. In terms of industrial attainment, migrant workers are discriminatedin entering the medium-wage industries compared with urban locals, and the extent ofdiscrimination against urban migrants is greater than that against rural migrants.Within the group of migrant workers, rural migrants face severe discrimination inentering the medium and high-wage industries compared with urban migrants. Theextent of discrimination against female urban migrants is much lower than thatagainst female urban locals in entering the low-wage industrial category, whileslightly greater than that against female rural migrants in entering the medium-wageindustrial category.
     (3) In terms of wage income, a significant wage distribution difference existsbetween groups and between male and female workers in each group, most of whichis the consequence of discrimination when all productivity-related factors arecontrolled. Between1993and2006, the extent of discrimination against migrantworkers showed an inverted U-shape at different quantiles. Compared with urbanlocals, rural migrants above medium income level and urban migrants below mediumlevel income tend to be discriminated against. The extent of discrimination increasesgradually as wage increases and decreases. Compared with urban migrants, ruralmigrants are discriminated at all income levels. The extent of discrimination increaseswith the increment of income levels. The similar decomposition results are obtainedafter considering the problem of undervaluation. The only differences are that migrantworkers change to be discriminated at some income levels and the extent ofdiscrimination becomes greater with the increment of underestimated degree in wagedistribution. The decomposition results of the gender wage gaps in each group showthat, female urban locals and migrant workers all have been discriminated in wageearnings since1993, but their changing patterns and the relative strength of the degreeof gender discrimination are different. Before2000at the lower-middle income level the extent of gender discrimination in the group of urban locals was far less than thatin the group of migrant workers. However, at the upper-medium income level thesituation was on the contrary. In addition, the gap between the two groups widenedgradually at lower-medium income level and above. From the decomposition resultswithin the three groups, it can be seen that there are “gradient” differences in theextent of gender discrimination in groups of urban locals, rural migrants and urbanmigrants.
     (4) The decomposition results show that more than50%of welfare entitlementdifference is due to the discrimination. Compared with urban locals, the extent ofdiscrimination experienced by rural migrants in access to the total number of benefitswas greater than that experienced by urban migrants. In terms of individual items ofbenefits, compared with urban locals and urban migrants, rural migrants experiencethe discrimination in obtaining all individual items of benefits. The extent ofdiscrimination against rural migrants compared with urban locals is little higher thanthat compared with urban migrants. However, in access to public holidays andweekend leave, rural migrants are discriminated only compared with urban locals,while not compared with urban migrants. The decomposition results of thedifferences between male and female workers in each group show that in general theextents to which the gender discrimination against female urban migrants and ruralmigrants are higher than that against female urban locals.
     Finally, we summarize the measures taken by both Chinese and Western countriesto reduce or eliminate the discrimination and the experience they got. The study putsforward to some specific measures aimed at the defects, such as the imperfect ofexisting legal system in formulating and implementing anti-discrimination laws andregulations as well as lack of specialized agency and relief approaches inanti-employment discrimination, to reduce the discrimination in urban labour market.
引文
[1]张展新.劳动力市场的产业分割与劳动人口流动.中国人口科学,2004,(2):45-52.
    [2]张展新.从城乡分割到区域分隔-城市外来人口研究新视角.人口研究,2007,(6):16-23.
    [3]张车伟,薛欣欣.国有部门与非国有部门工资差异及人力资本的贡献.经济研究,2008,(4):15-25.
    [4]韩靓,原新.多重分割视角下外来人口就业与收入歧视分析.人口研究,2010,(1):62-71.
    [5]谢嗣胜,姚先国.劳动力市场中统计性歧视的模型分析.数量经济技术经济研究,2004,(9):111-119.
    [6]李实,马欣欣.中国城镇职工的性别工资差异与职业分割的经验分析.中国人口科学,2006,(5):2-13.
    [7]张世伟,郭凤鸣.城市劳动力市场中性别工资差异的变动——基于固定效应模型的研究途径.经济评论,2010,(4):66-72.
    [8]张丹丹.市场化与性别工资差异研究.中国人口科学,2004,(1):32-41.
    [9]王美艳.中国城市劳动力市场上的性别工资差异.经济研究,2005a,(12):35-44.
    [10]李利英,董晓媛.性别工资差异中的企业效应.经济研究,2008,(9):112-135.
    [11]姚先国,黄志岭.职业分割及其对性别工资差异的影响——基于2002年中国城镇调查队数据.重庆大学学报(社会科学版),2008,14(2):53-58.
    [12]梁吉娜.农村转移劳动力性别工资差异的影响因素分析.山东理工大学学报(社会科学版),2009,25(3):5-9.
    [13]黄志岭.农村迁移劳动力性别工资差异研究.农业经济问题,2010,(8):44-51.
    [14]葛玉好.工资分布的性别差异:分位数分解方法.上海经济研究,2007,(4):22-30.
    [15]刘生龙.教育和经验对中国居民收入的影响——基于分位数回归和审查分位数回归的实证研究.数量经济技术经济研究,2008,(4):75-85.
    [16]张世伟,郭凤鸣.分位数上的性别工资歧视—基于东北城市劳动力市场的经验研究.中国人口科学,2009,(6):69-79.
    [17]陈建宝,段景辉.中国性别工资差异的分位数回归分析.数量经济技术经济研究,2009,(10):87-97.
    [18]亓寿伟,刘志强.“天花板效应”还是“地板效应”——探讨国有与非国有部门性别工资差异的分布与成因.数量经济技术经济研究,2009,(11):63-77.
    [19]王震.基于分位数回归分解的农民工性别工资差异研究.世界经济文汇,2010,(4):51-63.
    [20]李建民.中国劳动力市场多重分隔及其对劳动力供求的影响.中国人口科学,2002,(2):1-7.
    [21]王美艳.城市劳动力市场上的就业机会与工资差异——外来劳动力就业与报酬研究.中国社会科学,2005b,(5):36-46.
    [22]金城武.城镇劳动力市场上不同户籍就业人口的收入差异.中国人口科学,2009,(4):32-47.
    [23]张展新.城镇社会保障的“本地_外来”分割与外来人口社会保障缺失.开放导报,2006,(6):51-56.
    [24]陈映芳.“农民工”:制度安排与身份认同.社会学研究,2005,(3):119-132.
    [25]王凡.关注中国农民工社会保障权益.人口与经济增刊,2007,(4):125-126.
    [26]王元璋,盛喜真.农民工待遇市民化探析.人口与经济,2004,(2):7-14.
    [27]蔡昉,都阳,王美艳.户籍制度与劳动力市场保护.经济研究,2001,(12):41-49.
    [28]姚先国,赖普清.中国劳资关系的城乡户籍差异.经济研究,2004,(7):82-90.
    [29]高文书.进城农民工社会保障的影响因素研究.市场与人口分析,2007,13(5):66-71.
    [30]曹信邦.就业歧视对农民工社会保障制度构建的消极影响.人口与经济,2008,(1):56-60.
    [31]段成荣,杨舸.改革开放以来我国流动人口变动的九大趋势,人口研究,2008,(6):30-43.
    [32]蔡昉,王德文.作为市场化的人口流动——第五次全国人口普查数据分析,中国人口学,2003,(5):11-19.
    [33]杨云彦,陈金永,刘塔.中国人口迁移——多区域模型及实证分析,中国人口学,1999,(4):20-26.
    [34]周皓.资本形式、国家政策与省际人口迁移.中国人口科学,2006,(1):42-51.
    [35]刘建波,王桂新,魏星.基于嵌套Logit模型的中国省际人口二次迁移影响因素分析.人口研究,2004,(4):48-56.
    [36]唐家龙,马忠东.中国人口迁移的选择性—基于五普数据的分析.人口研究,2007,(5):42-51.
    [37]王桂新,刘建波.1990年代后期我国省际人口迁移区域模式研究.市场与人口分析,2003,(4):19-28.
    [38]李培.中国城乡人口迁移的时空特征及其影响因素.经济学家,2009,(1):50-57.
    [39]段成荣.影响我国省际人口迁移的个人特征分析——兼论“时间”因素在人口迁移研究中的重要性.人口研究,2000,(4):14-22.
    [40]庞丽华.多层次分析方法在人口迁移研究中的应用—省际劳动力迁移的多层次分析.中国农村观察,2001,(2):11-17.
    [41]杨桂宏,胡建国.农民工城市生活社会保障的实证研究——以北京市X区423名农民工为例.调研世界,2006,(8):24-28.
    [42]段成荣,杨舸.我国流动人口的流入地分布变动趋势研究.人口研究,2009,33(6):1-12.
    [43]张车伟.人力资本回报率变化与收入差距“马太效应”及其政策含义.经济研究,2006,(12):59-70.
    [44]岳希明,李实,史泰丽.垄断行业高收入问题探讨.中国社会科学,2010,(3):77-93.
    [45]蔡昉.二元劳动力市场条件下的就业体制转换.中国社会科学,1998,(2):4-14.
    [46]钟笑寒.劳动力流动与工资差异.中国社会科学,2006,(1):34-46.
    [47]徐玉龙,工志彬,郭斌.农民工就业歧视的经济学分析.财贸研究,2007,(1):38-43.
    [48]张抗私.就业性别歧视与人力资本投资倾向的交互作用分析.浙江大学学报,2009,(6):40-49.
    [49] Yao Yang. Social Exclusion and Economic Discrimination: The Status of Migrations inChina’s Coastal Rural Area. CCER Working Paper No.E2001005.2001.
    [50] Meng Xin, Zhang Junsen. The Two-Tier Labor Market in Urban China. Journal ofComparative Economics,2001,29(3):485-504.
    [51] Hashimoto, M., J. Raisian. Employment Tenure and Earnings Profiles in Japan and theUnited States: Reply. The American Economic Review,1992,82(1):346-354.
    [52] Henry S, F. Chapter37Mobility and stability: The dynamics of job change in labor markets.Handbook of Labor Economics. C. A. Orley and C. David, Elsevier. Volume3, Part B:2439-2483,1999.
    [53] Knight, J., L. Yueh, Y. Job Mobility of Residents and Migrants in Urban China, Universityof Oxford, Department of Economics,2003.
    [54] Chiswick, B. R., Y. L. Lee, et al. A Longitudinal Analysis of Immigrant OccupationalMobility: A Test of the Immigrant Assimilation Hypothesis1. International migration review,2005,39(2):332-353.
    [55] Cao, Y., C.-Y. Hu. Gender and Job Mobility in Postsocialist China: A Longitudinal Study ofJob Changes in Six Coastal Cities. Social Forces,2007,85(4):1535-1560.
    [56] Wu, Y. Labor Market Segmentation, Job Mobility and the Two-track Model of ChineseUrban Workers’ Acquisition of Economic Status. Social Sciences in China,2011,32(3):74-86.
    [57] Guo, F.,&Cheng, Z. Labour Market Disparity, Poverty, and Inequality in Urban China.China Perspectives,2010,16-31.
    [58] Meng, X. Gender Occupational Segregation and Its Impact on the Wage Differential amongRural-Urban Migrant: A Chinese Case Study. Applied Economics,1998(30):741-752.
    [59] Maurer-Fazio, M., T. G. Rawski, et al. Inequality in the Rewards for Holding up Half theSky: Gender Wage Gaps in China's Urban Labour Market,1988-1994. The China Journal,1999,(41):55-88.
    [60] Gustafsson, B., S. Li. Economic Transformation and the Gender Earnings Gap in UrbanChina. Population Economics,2000,(13):305-329.
    [61] Rozelle, S., X.-y. Dong, et al. Gender Wage Gaps in Post-Reform Rural China. PacificEconomic Review2002,7(1):157-179.
    [62] Wang, M., F. Cai. Gender Wage Differentials in China's Urban Labour Market. WorldInstitute for Development Economic Research (UNU-WIDER).2006.
    [63] Ge, Y. Wage Distribution for Sexual Distinction: The Method of Quantile Decomposition.Shanghai Economic Review,2007,(4):22-30.
    [64] Tzannatos, Z. The Long-Run Effects of the Sex Integration of the UK Labor Market. Journalof Economic Studies.1989,15(1):5-18.
    [65] Rayford Logan. The Negro in the United States: A Brief History. Princeton: D. VanNostrand.1957.
    [66] Fawcett, M. The Position of Women in Economic Life. in W.H. Dawson(ed.). After WarProblems. London: Allen&Unwin,1917,191-215.
    [67] Fawcett, M. Equal Pay for Equal Work. Economic Journal,1918,(28):1-6.
    [68] Edgeworth, F.Y. Equal Pay to Men and Women for Equal Work. Economic Journal,1922,(32):431-457.
    [69] Bergmann, B. The Effect on White Incomes of Discrimination in Employment. Journal ofPolitical Economy,1971,(79):294-313.
    [70] Florence, P.S. A Statistical Contribution to the Theory of Women’s Wages. EconomicJournal,1931,(41):19-37.
    [71] Pigou, A.C. Essays in Economics. Lodon: Macmillan,1952.
    [72] Robinson, J.E. The Economics of Imperfect Competition. London: Macmillan,1933.
    [73] Walker, F.A. Statistics and Economics. American Statistical Association,1888,24-28.
    [74] Hoffman, F. Vital Statistics of the Negro. The Arena,1892,529-542.
    [75] Stone, A.H. A Plantation Experiment.in A.H. Stone (ed.), Studies in the American RaceProblem. New York: Negro Universities Press,1969,125-148.
    [76] Coamn, M. Equal Pay for Equal Work. Economic Journal,1904,(28):1-6.
    [77] Becker, G.S. The Economics of Discrimination. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.1957.
    [78] Black S.E, Strahan P.E. The Division of Spoils: Rent-Sharing and Discrimination in aRegulated Industry. American Economic Review,2001,91(4):814-831.
    [79] Peoples J, Talley W.K. Black-White Earnings Differentials: Privatization versusDeregulation. American Economic Review,2001,91(2):164-168.
    [80] Arrow, K.J. Models of Job Discrimination. in A.H. Pascal (ed.).Racial Discrimination inEconomic Life. Lexington Mass.:D.C.Health,1972,83-102.
    [81] Arrow, K.J. The Theory of Discrimination. in O. Ashenfelter and A. Rees (eds).Discrimination in Labor Markets. New Jersey: Princeton University Press,1973,3-33.
    [82] Kahn, L. Customer Discrimination and Affirmative Action. Economic Inquiry,1991,555-571.
    [83] Phelps, E.S. The Statistical Theory or Racism and Sexism. American Economic Review,1972,(62):659-661.
    [84] Aigner, D.J., Cain, G.G. Statistical Theories of Discrimination in the Labor Markets.Industrial and Labor Relations Review,1977,30(2):175-187.
    [85] Spence, M. Job Market Signaling. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1973,87(3):355-374.
    [86] Piore, M.J. The Dual Labor Market: Theory and Applications. in R. Barringer and S.H. Beer(eds). The State and the Poor. Cambridge Mass.: Winthrop,1970.
    [87] Bulow J.I., Summers L.H. A Theory of Dual Labor Markets with Application to IndustrialPolicy, Discrimination, and Keynesian Unemployment. Journal of Labor Economics,1986,4(3):376-414.
    [88] Goldin C. Monitoring Costs and Occupational Segregation by Sex: A Historical Analysis.Journal of Labor Economics,1986,4(1):1-27.
    [89] Rebitzer, J. Radical Political Economy and the Economics of Labor Markets. Journal ofEconomic Literature,1993,31(3):1394-1434.
    [90] McKenna, C. Uncertainty and the Labor Market: Recent Developments in Job Search Theory.Brighton: Wheatsheaf,1985.
    [91] McKenna, C. Models of Search Market Equilibrium. in J.D. Hey and P.J. Lambert (eds)Surveys in the Economics of Uncertainty. Oxford: Basil Blackwell,1987.
    [92] Black D.A. Discrimination in an Equilibrium Search Model. Journal of Labor Economics,1995,13(2):309-334.
    [93] Duncan, O.D., Duncan, B. A Methodological Analysis of Segregation Indices. AmericanSociological Review,1955,20(2):210-217.
    [94] Karmel, T., Maclachlan, M. Occupational Sex Segregation-Increasing or Decreasing.Economic Record,1988,(64):187-195.
    [95] Hutchens, R. Numerical Measures of Segregation: Desirable Properties and TheirImplications. Mathematical Social Sciences,2001,(42):13-29.
    [96] Oaxaca R. Male-female Wage Differentials in Urban Labor Markets. International EconomicReview,1973,14(3):693-709.
    [97] Blinder, A.S. Wage Discrimination: Reduced Form and Structural Estimates. Journal ofHuman Resources,1973,8(4):436-455.
    [98] Cotton, J. On the Decomposition of Wage Differentials. Review of Economics and Statistics,1988,70(2):236-243.
    [99] Brown R.S., Moon M., Zoloth, B.S. Occupational Attainment and Segregation by Sex.Industrial and Labor Relations Review,1980,33(4):506-517.
    [100] Choudhury, S. Reassessing the Male-Female Wage Differential: A Fixed Effects Approach.Southern Economic Journal,1993,60(2):327-340.
    [101] Kim, M., Polachek, S.W. Panel Estimates of Male-Female Earnings Functions. The Journalof Human Resources, Special Issue: Women's Work, Wages, and Well-Being,1994,29(2):406-428.
    [102] Neal, D., Johnson, W. The Role of Pre-market Factors in Black-White Wage Differences.Journal of Political Economy,1996,(104):869-895.
    [103] Koenker, Roger, W., Bassett, Gilbert, Jr. Regression Quantiles. Econometrica,1978,46(1):33-50.
    [104] Buchinsky, Moshe. Changes in the U.S. Wage Structure1963-1987: Application ofQuantile Regression. Economnetrica,1994,62(2):405-458.
    [105] Abadie, Alberto. Changes in Spanish Labor Income Structure during the1980’s: AQuantile Regression Approach. Investigaciones Economicas,1997,21(2):253-272.
    [106] Javier Gardeazabal, Arantza Ugidos. Gender Wage Discrimination at Quantiles. Journal ofPopulation Economics,2005,18(1):165-179.
    [107] José A. F. Machado, José Mata, Counterfactual Decomposition of Changes in WageDistribution Using Quantitle Regression. Journal of Applied Econometrics,2005,20(4):445-465.
    [108] Miller, P.W. The Wage Effect of the Occupational Segregation of Women in Britain. TheEconomic Journal,1987,(97):885-896.
    [109] Oaxaca R., Ransom M.R. On Discrimination and the Decomposition of Wage Differentials.Journal of Econometrics,1994,61(1):5-21.
    [110] Mukherjee, Dipa. Post-reform Trends in Wage-Differentials: A Decomposition Analysisfor India. MPRA Paper12754, University Library of Munich, Germany,2007.
    [111] Martin ihák, Gender Wage Differentials in the Czech Republic. Czech Journal ofEconomics and Finance (Finance a uver), Charles University Prague, Faculty of SocialSciences,2000,50(5):294-297.
    [112] Mendes, Raquel Vale. The wage gap among male and female top managers. EconomiaGlobal e Gest o,2008,13(2):121-133.
    [113] Albrechet, J, A.Vuuren, S.Vroman. Counterfactual Distributions with Sample SelectionAdjustments: Econometric Theory and Application to the Netherlands. Working Paper,2006.
    [114] Kunze. Gender Wage Gap Studies: Consistency and Decomposition. Working Paper,2006.
    [115] Currie, J. Gender Gaps in Benefits Coverage. in David Lewin, Daniel Mitchell, MahmoodZaidi, et al.(eds). The Human Resource Management Handbook. Conn.: JAI Press,1995.
    [116] Vanik. Borooah, John Mangan. An Analysis of Occupational Outcomes for Indigenous andAsian Employees in Australia. Economic Record,2002,(78):1-19.
    [117] Velling Johannes. Wage discrimination and occupational segregation of foreign maleworkers in Germany. No95-04, ZEW Discussion Papers from ZEW-Zentrum fürEurop ische Wirtschaftsforschung/Center for European Economic Research,1995.
    [118] Chapman, B. and R.R. Iredale. Immigrant Qualifications: Recognition and Relative WageOutcomes. International Migration Review,1993,27(2):359-387.
    [119] Evans, M.D.R., Jonathan Kelley. Immigrants' Work: Equality and Discrimination in theAustralian Labour Market. Australia and New Zealand Journal of Sociology,1986,(22):187-207.
    [120] Bell, Brian D. The Performance of Immigrants in the United Kingdom: Evidence from theGHS. The Economic Journal,1997,107(441):333-44.
    [121] Junankar, P.N., S. Paul, Wahida Yasmeen. Are Asian Migrants Discriminated Against inthe Labour Market? A Case Study of Australia. IZA Discussion Paper No.1167,2004.
    [122] Lesleyanne Hawthorne. The question of discrimination skilled migrants' access toAustralian employment. International Migration,1997,35(3):395-420.
    [123] International labor office. International Migration Papers. Geneva: International MigrationProgramme,1995-2010.
    [124] Kevin J Denny, Colm P Harmon, Maurice Roche. The Distribution of Discrimination inImmigrant Earnings-Evidence from Britain1974-93. Economics, Finance and AccountingDepartment Working Paper Series n690897, Department of Economics, Finance andAccounting, National University of Ireland-Maynooth,1997.
    [125] Kee, Peter. Native-Immigrant Wage Differentials in the Netherlands: Discrimination?.Oxford Economic Papers, Oxford University Press,1995,47(2):302-17.
    [126] Gaute Erichsen, Jeremy Wakeford. Racial Wage Discrimination in South Africa: Beforeand After the First Democratic Election. Working Papers9673, Cape Town: University ofCape Town, Development Policy Research Unit.2001.
    [127] Moll, Peter G. Primary Schooling, Cognitive Skills and Wages in South Africa. Economica,1998,65(258):263-84.
    [128] Hinks, T., Watson, D. A Multinomial Logit No-Discrimatory Approach to EstimatingRacial Wage and Occupational Discrimination. Papers67, London: Middlesex University,1999.
    [129] Hinks, J., Atkins, J.P., Allanson, P. A multilateral decomposition of racial wagedifferentials in the1994South African labour market. Journal of Development Studies,2000,37(1):93-120.
    [130] Neuman, Shoshana, Oaxaca, Ronald L. Wage Differentials in the1990s in Israel:Endowments, Discrimination, and Selectivity Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA): IZADiscussion Papers1362,2004.
    [131] Muhammad Asali. Wage Differentials in Israel: Endowments, Occupational Segregation,Discrimination, and Selectivity. International School of Economics at TSU, Tbilisi,Republic of Georgia: Working Papers011-08,2008.
    [132] Rulof Burger, Rachel Jafta. Returns to Race: Labour Market Discrimination inPost-Apartheid South Africa. Stellenbosch University: Working Papers04/2006,2006.
    [133] Guenter Lang. Native-Immigrant Wage Differentials in Germany-Assimilation,Discrimination, or Human Capital?. Universitaet Augsburg: Discussion Paper Series197,2000.
    [134] G. Reza Arabsheibani, Jie Wang. Asian-white male wage differentials in the United States.Taylor and Francis Journals,2010,17(1):37-43.
    [135] D.H. Blackaby, D.G. Leslie, P.D. Murphy. White-ethnic minority earnings andemployment differentials in Britain: evidence from the LFS, Oxford Economic Papers,Oxford University Press,2002,54(2):270-297.
    [136] Maurer-Fazio, M. Hughes, J. The Effect of Market Liberalization on the Relative Earningsof Chinese Women. Journal of Comparative Economics,1999,(30):709-731.
    [137] Liu, Pak-Wai, Xin Meng, Junsen Zhang. Sectorial Gender Wage Differentials andDiscrimination in the Transitional Chinese Economy Journal of Population Economics,2000,(13):331-352.
    [138] Solinger D.J. Citizenship Issues in China’s Internal Migration: Comparisons with Germanyand Japan. Political Science Quarterly,1999,114(3):455-478.
    [139] Margaret Maurer-Fazio, Ngan Dinh. Differential rewards to, and contributions of,education in urban China's segmented labor markets. Pacific Economic Review, BlackwellPublishing,2004,9(3):173-189.
    [140] Todaro, M.P. A Model of Migration and Urban Unemployment in Less DevelopedCountries. American Economic Review,1969,59(1):138-148.
    [141] Harris, J., Todaro, M. Migration, unemployment and development: a two-sector analysis.American Economic Review,1970,60(1):126-142.
    [142] Nabi, Ijaz. Village-end considerations in rural-urban migration. Journal of DevelopmentEconomics,1984,14(1):129-145.
    [143] Rosenzweig, Mark R., Oded Stark. Consumption Smoothing, Migration, and Marriage:Evidence from Rural India. The Journal of Political Economy,1989,97(4):905-926.
    [144] Stark O, Taylor J E. Migration incentives, migration types: the role of relative deprivation.The Economic Journal,1991,(101):1163-1178.
    [145] Lee E S. A theory of migration. Demography,1966,(1):47-57.
    [146] Schultz T.W. Restoring Economic Equilibrium, Human Capital and the ModernizingEconomy. Oxford: Basil Blackwell,1990.
    [147] Williamson, Jeffrey G. Migration and Urbanization. In Handbook of DevelopmentEconomics, ed. H. Chenery and T. N. Srinivasan. Vol.1. Amsterdam: North-Holland,1988.
    [148] Liang Zai, Michael J. White. Market Transition,Government Policies and InterprovincialMigration in China:1983-1988. Economic Development and Culture Change,1997,45(2):321-339.
    [149] Yang Xiushi, Guo Fei. Gender difference in determinants of temporary labor migration inChina. International Migration Review,1999,33(4):929-953.
    [150] Saul D. Hoffman, Greg J. Duncan. Multinomial and Conditional Logit Discrete-ChoiceModels in Demography. Demography,1988,25(3):415-427.
    [151] Daniel A. Powers, Yu Xie. Statistical Methods for Categorical Data Analysis. USA:Academic Press,2000.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700