用户名: 密码: 验证码:
拱坝优化时基础变模敏感性及坝肩传力洞增稳效应研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
拱坝的基础设计在拱坝设计中占有重要地位。本文介绍了当前拱坝基础设计中存在的一些问题,指出了在拱坝基础参数选用和拱坝基础加固中存在的一些误区。对于拱坝基础岩体弹性模量的选用,文中通过对大量不同坝高和河谷形状的拱坝方案的优化和分析总结,探讨了各类拱坝的建基面岩体变形模量对体型设计和坝体应力的敏感性,获得了如下一些规律性的认识:随着坝高的加大,以拱坝工程量为目标的优化,其结果随基础岩体变形模量的增大而更优。相同高度的拱坝,在不同的宽高比地形条件下,其最适宜的岩体变模值变化不大。而不同的气温资料,对于拱坝建基面岩体最适宜变模并无影响;拱坝优化设计时,采用较低的岩体变形模量,并不能保证拱坝更安全。工程中采用的设计方案,其坝体应力应该留有一定的宽裕度,以适应实际岩体变形模量值与设计取用值之间的偏差。总体来说,当变形模量有增大的可能时,拱坝上游面拉应力和下游面压应力应留有裕度;当变形模量有降低的可能时,拱坝上游面压应力和下游面拉应力应留有裕度。
     对于拱坝基础的加固,论文主要讨论了传力洞对增强坝肩稳定和控制拱坝拱端位移方面的作用。在增强坝肩稳定方面,分析了传力洞轴线布置方向和传力洞截面对坝肩增稳幅度的敏感性,提出了传力洞轴线的确定方法以及传力洞对坝肩稳定增稳效应的评估方法;文中讨论了传力洞对拱坝基础中近坝区陡倾角结构面的加固效果。针对当前传力洞设计中一些误区,分析了传力洞两个要素—传力洞轴线方向和传力洞截面积大小改变时传力洞对坝肩的增稳效果变化情况。
     在控制拱端位移方面,提出了根据拱端允许变形量推求传力洞的预期压缩量进而拟定传力洞截面尺寸的设计原则,将围岩影响简化为抗力作用,利用最小势能原理,推导了求解传力洞截面尺寸的公式。论文还分析了传力洞的设置对拱坝坝体应力的影响。成果已应用于实际工程,并取得良好效果。
     论文最后还通过已经完建的工程实例验证了本文的一些相关结论。
It occupies an important position in the arch dam design that an arch dam foundation design. This paper introduces some of the problems in designing an arch dam foundation, and points out some mistaken ideas existing in choosing an arch dam foundation parameters and an arc dam foundation reinforcement. For choosing the value of the deformation elastic modulus reasonably during optimal designing an arch dam, the dissertation had optimized several arch dams with different height which supported by rock bases with various deformation modulus, and explores the types of an arch dam foundation rock deformation modulus on the shape design and the stress sensitivity, obtained some regularity understanding that during a dam height increasing, the arch dam optimization that the dam's volume is the objective, the result is better with the foundation rock deformation modulus increase. The same high arch dams, in a different width-height ratio topography conditions, the most suitable rock deformation modulus changes little. It has no effect to the most suitable modulus of an arch dam foundation rock mass that the temperature data chances; At the same time, the author had analyzed the stress of an arch dam which hold by rock bases with different deformation modulus. The conclusions are as follows, the arch dam will not be more safety though small value of deformation modulus has been chosen when it was designed, and the value of an arch dam's body stress should less than the tolerable value in case that the deformation modulus of the rock will change.
     For arch dam foundation reinforcement, this paper mainly discusses the role of the concret plug which acting on the reinforced abutment stability and control of arch dam abutment displacement. In reinforcing an arc dam abutment stability, a concrete plug axis direction and it's section on abutment stability effection sensitivity have been analysed, puts forward the method of determining the concrete plug axis and it's section on reinforcing an arch dam foundation; This paper has discussed the reinforcement effect to fault near the dam area of steep that the concret plug inhenced. In view of some error in the concrete plug design, the dissertation has analysed the concrete plug two elements-concrete plug axis direction and it's section that how to effect the stability of the arc dam basement.
     For improving the design method of the concrete plug and seeking for the theoretical basis of the concrete plug designing, a design discipline was proposed in this paper that the displacement of the dam abutment should be equal to the compression of the concrete plug. The rock effects were simplified to the actions of resistance, and the formulas solving for the concrete plug's section size were derive according to principle of minimum potential energy. The results showed that the mathematical relationship between the thrust and the displacement on the top of the concrete plug manifested as linearity, and the section area of the concrete plug is included in the gradient of the formula. Hereby, we can obtain the section of the concrete plug.
     Finally the dissertation verified the conclusions by a project built.
引文
[1]ICOLD. The World Register of Dams.4th edition. Paris:1988.
    [2]吴佩佩,闫金良.国内拱坝的建设与发展.西北水电,2006(4),4-7;
    [3]潘家铮.中国大坝50年.北京:中国水利水电出版社.2000;
    [4]黎展眉.国内外拱坝建设与发展.贵州水利水电.2003,17(2),1-5.
    [5]汝乃华,姜胜忠.大坝事故与安全(拱坝).北京:中国水利水电出版社.1995;
    [6]李瓒,陈兴华,郑建波.混凝土拱坝设计.北京:中国电力出版社.2000;
    [7]朱伯芳,董品福.高拱坝应力控制标准研究.水力发电.2001(8):57-59;
    [8]柴军瑞.高拱坝坝肩颜体动力稳定性分析综述.辽宁工程技术大学学报(自然科学版),2001,20:502-504.
    [9]陈在铁,任青文.高坝与坝基稳定性研究方法分析.华东船舶工业学院学报(自然科学版),2005,19:15-20.
    [10]程浩,陈鹏,曾雄辉.向家坝大坝抗滑稳定分析及处理方案研究.湖北水力发电,2004,3:26-30.
    [11]吴事贵,张建海.断层f2对锦屏左岸坝坡静力稳定性的影响.水电站设计,2004,20:15-18.
    [12]李瓒,龙云霄.重力坝、拱坝基础岩体抗滑稳定分析中的一些问题的探讨.水利学报,2000,11:55-59.
    [13]王瑞骏.重力坝深层抗滑稳定性的空间极限平衡分析.西北水资源与水工程,1996,7(4):1-5.
    [14]Chen R H,Chameau J L.Three-dimensional limit equilibrium analysis of slopes.Geotechnique,1982,32(3):31-40.
    [15]Hutchinson J N,Sarma S K.Discussion on three-dimensional limit equilibrium analysis of slopes.Geotechnique,1985,35(6):215-216.
    [16]Xing Z.Three-dimensional stability analysis of concave slopes in plan view.J.Geotech Engng.,ASCE,1988,114(14):658-671.
    [17]Hungr O.An extension of Bishop's simplified method of slope stability analysis to three dimensions.Geotechnique,1987,37(1):113-117.
    [18]Lam L,Fredlund D G.A general limit equilibrium model for three-dimensional slope stability analysis.Can.Geotech.J.,1993,30(4):905-919.
    [19]Chen Zuyu,Wang Xiaogang,Haberfield C,et al.A three-dimensional slope stability method using the upper bound theorem, partⅠ:theory and methods. Int.J.Rock Mech Min Sci&Geomech Abstr,2001,38(3):369-378.
    [20]Chen Zuyu,Wang Jian,Wang Yujie.et al.A three-dimensional slope stability method using the upper bound theorem, partⅡ:numerical approaches. Applications and Extensions,2001, 38(3):379-397.
    [21]张光斗,刘光廷,周维恒等.拱坝坝肩稳定的理论与方法.北京:清华大学.1987,12;
    [22]陈兴华等.脆性材料结构模型试验.北京:水利电力出版社,1984,8;
    [23]陈国启,沈根龙,王东茂.拱坝坝肩的地质力学模型试验研究,1981,3;
    [24]武清玺,吕泰仁,王保田.拱坝坝肩整体稳定可靠度分析方法探讨.河海大学学报(自然科学版).1995(3):26-32;
    [25]武清玺,王德信.拱坝坝肩三维稳定可靠度分析.岩土力学.1995(3):26-32;
    [26]程心恕,李梅,方建瑞.拱坝坝肩稳定可靠度分析方法探讨.福州大学学报(自然科学版).2004(6):736-740;
    [27]吴世伟,张思俊等.拱坝失效模式与可靠度.河海大学学报.1992,20(2),88-95
    [28]杨令强,练继建.随机有限元与最大熵法联合求混凝土拱坝可靠度.水利水运工程学报,2003 2:24-28.
    [29]陈刚,张林.基于人工神经网络的沙牌RCC拱坝可靠度分析.四川大学学报,2002,344:34-37.
    [30]武清玺,吕泰仁.拱坝坝肩整体稳定静力动力可靠度分析.岩土工程学报,1995,17(3),51-59.
    [31]程心恕,封伯昊.拱坝可靠度分析方法探讨.福州大学学报,1997,25(5):78-83.
    [32]LIANG R Y,NUSIER O K,MALKAWI A H.A reliability based approach for evaluating the slope stability of embankment dams.Engineering Geology,1999(54):271-285.
    [33]杨海霞.基于分载法的拱坝可靠度分析.河海大学学报:自然科学版.2000,28(6):23-26.
    [34]汝乃华,姜胜忠.大坝事故与安全(拱坝).北京:中国水利水电出版社.1995;
    [35]徐卫福,田斌.关于拱坝柔度系数的研究.人民长江.2007(1):41-42;
    [36]马以超,娄绍撑.拱坝柔度系数的统计规律及合理方量估算.大坝与安全.2005(6):1-3;
    [37]任青文,王柏乐.关于拱坝柔度系数的讨论.河海大学学报(自然科学版).2003(1):1-4;
    [38]周维恒,林鹏,周雅能等.高拱坝基础大垫座及周边缝设置研究.岩石力学与工程学报.2008(10).1959-1967;
    [39]白俊光.李家峡水电站大坝基础处理设计.水力发电.1997(6):29-31;
    [40]蒋锁红,白俊光,梁万林.李家峡拱坝河床坝基高压灌浆设计与实施.西北水电,1999(4):24-28;
    [41]VOIGHT B, FAUST C.Frictional heat and strength loss in some rapid landslides:error correction and affirmation of mechanism for the Vaiont Landslide. Geotechnique,1992,42(3): 641-643;
    [42]钟源清.意大利拱坝的混凝土垫座和周边缝.西北水电,1987(3):25-40;
    [43]赵永刚.沙牌水电站拱坝基础处理研究.水电站设计,2003(12):64-67;
    [44]周维恒,林鹏,王仁坤等.拱坝基础不对称性影响研究.岩石力学与工程学报.2006,25(6).1081-1085;
    [45]谢坤,谢居平,苗青等.玄庙观碾压混凝土拱坝基础处理设计.水利水电工程设计.2008,27(1):29-32;
    [46]Londe P. The Malpasset Dam Failure.Proc.Int.Worksop on Dam Failure,Elsevier,1987, 295-325.
    [47]Tinawi R, Guizani L. Formulationof hydrodynamic pressures in cracks due to earthquakes in concrete dams.Earthquake Eng and Struct Dyn,1993,23(7):699-716.
    [48]Bruhwiler E,Saouma V. Water fracture interaction in concrete. Part Ⅰ:fracture properties.ACI Mat J,1995,92(3):296-303.
    [49]Bruhwiler E,Saouma V. Water fracture interactionin concrete, part Ⅱ:hydrostatic pressure cracks.ACI Mat J,1995,92(4):383-390.
    [50]Volker V,Saouma V. Water pressure in propagating concrete cracks.J of Struct Eng,2000, 126(2):235-242.
    [51]张永军,张振业.丙凝化学灌浆在石泉水电站大坝基础防渗处理中的应用.西北电力技术.2002(6):47-49;
    [52]刘万锁.化学灌浆在大坝基础处理中的应用.西北水电.2001(2):5-7;
    [53]杨学祥,李焰.三峡大坝基础帷幕化学灌浆技术及其效果分析.水利与建筑工程学报.2006,4(1):44-47;
    [54]Zienklewlcz.O.C, The Finite Elenent Method, MeGraw Hill Inc,1977
    [55]Christian.J.T, Ladd.C.C. Reliability applied to slope stability analysis. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences & Geomechanics,1995;
    [56]王光纶等.高拱坝沿建基面抗滑稳定分析的研究.水利水电技术.1998(8):22-26;
    [57]燕柳斌.结构分析的有限元及无限元法.武汉:武汉工业大学出版社.1997;
    [58]张允真.简明有限元.辽宁科学技术出版社.1984;
    [59]丁皓江等.弹性和塑性力学中的有限元法.北京:机械工业出版社.1992;
    [60]洪永文,李玲云.小湾拱坝建基面抗滑稳定分析.云南水力发电.1997(2):54-57;
    [61]徐芝纶.弹性力学简明教程(第二版).北京:高等教育出版社.1983;
    [62]Randolph, M.F. and Wroth, C. P, Analysis of deformation of Vertically load poles, J. Geltech. Engng, ASCE, Vol.104, No GT12,1978;
    [63]李瓒.玛尔巴塞拱坝的破坏与拱坝上滑稳定分析.水电站设计.2002(6):15-18;
    [64]蔡元奇,朱以文等.地质缺陷对拱坝及坝基力学行为的影响.岩石力学与工程学报.2002,21(12):1805-1809
    [65]RYDZEWSKIJR, Theory of arch dams, sumposium publications division, London:Pregamon. 1964;
    [66]邹广电.地基弹性模量、拱圈形式对拱坝坝肩稳定、应力、变形影响的研究.水利水运工程学报.1987(2):44-46;
    [67]赵炳祯,郑建波等.黄河龙羊峡重力拱坝基础处理设计.西北水力发电.1986(2)
    [68]白俊光.李家峡水电站大坝基础处理设计.水力发电.1997(6);
    [69]毛国权.李家峡水电站左坝肩基础处理及效果分析.西北水力发电.2002(9)
    [70]王宙,陈兴华等.龙羊峡重力拱坝和基础变形过程特征研究.水力发电学报.1994(1);
    [71]USBR. Treatise on Dams-Chapter 10 Arch Dams. USA:Department of the Interior, BUREAU OF RECLA mation,1948;
    [72]Ru Naihua, Arch Dam Upslide-Failure & Saretu criterion. Proceeding of International Workshop on Arch Dams[C]. Coimbra,Portugal,1987;
    [73]Serafim, J. L. et al, Statistics of Dam Failure, A Preliminary Report, Water Power and Dam Construction, Vol.41,No.4, April 1989.
    [74]Zienkiewics O C, Taylor C, Gallico A, Three dimersional finite element analysis of the Tachien arch dam. Water Power,1970(5):173-180;
    [75]Sundquist K J.Notes on the economy and safety of different types of concrete dams. ICOLD Congress 6,Question 17,Report 36,Vol.2[C]. Paris:IMPRIMERIE GAUTHIER-VILLARS, 1955,228-246;
    [76]E.S.Kalustyan. Determining the reliability of concrete dams through diagnosis of their bedrock. Hydrotechnical Construction,1994;
    [77]邹丽春;喻建清等.小湾拱坝设计及基础处理.水力发电,2004(10);
    [78]任青文,夏宁.高拱坝破坏与安全度的研究进展.水电2006国际研讨会论文集.2006;
    [79]徐年丰,周和清.三峡工程大坝基础处理设计.人民长江,1997(10);
    [80]周涛.溪洛渡水电站拱坝基础综合变模分析.四川水力发电,2001(2):22-26;
    [81]郑波.满天星拱坝复杂地基基础开挖与处理.湖南水利水电,2002(1);
    [82]朱伯芳,历易生.高拱坝新型合理体型的研究和应用.水力发电,2001(8);
    [83]李瓒.拱坝设计中值得注意的几个问题.水电站设计,2002(1);
    [84]郭怀志.岩体滑动过程的可靠性分析.岩土工程学报,1990(9);
    [85]陈强,刘光廷.软弱地基上的碾压混凝土拱坝应力与位移分析.清华大学学报(自然科学版).2004(3);
    [86]耿克群,吴永平.基于原型观测资料的拱坝及其基础的有限元综合分析.水利学报.2001(4):
    [87]王志刚.新安江大坝右岸坝基页岩泥化问题研究.大坝与安全,1995(3);
    [88]康建,余常新.响洪甸水电站大坝左坝肩F2断层处理与效果分析.大坝与安全.1997(4);
    [89]薛利军,计家荣等.锦屏一级拱坝基础处理有限元分析.第八次全国岩石力学与工程学术大会论文集.2004;
    [90]张楚汉.高坝—岩基系统的安全稳定性.中国岩石力学与工程学会第七次学术大会论文集.2002;
    [91]徐荣桥.结构分析的有限元法与MATLAB程序设计.北京:人民交通出版社.2006;
    [92]曾攀.有限元分析及其应用.北京:清华大学出版社.2004;
    [93]李董辉,董小娇,万中.数值最优化.北京:科学出版社.2005;
    [94]中国水利水电科学研究院.著名水利工程.中国水利国际合作与科技网;
    [95]刘健,谢新生,王旭.基础约束对拱坝应力影响规律的研究.西北水电.2009,(1):58-60.
    [96]王清亮,唐辉明,胡丽新.地基变形模量对碾压混凝土拱坝应力分布的影响.地球科学:中国地质大学学报.2007(3):409-414.
    [97]王进廷,杨剑,王吉焕.二滩拱坝应力仿真及参数敏感性分析.水利学报.2007,38(7):832-837.
    [98]刘国华,汪树玉.拱坝体型优化设计方法及工程应用.计算结构力学及其应用.1994,11(4):461-469.
    [99]刘国华,汪树玉,杜王盖.拱坝多目标优化的研究与应用.水利学报.2001(10):48-53.
    [100]任青文,王柏乐.关于拱坝柔度系数的讨论.河海大学学报(自然科学版).2003,31(1):1-4.
    [101]刘健,练继建.李家峡拱坝坝体弹性模量及基岩变形模量的反演.岩石力学与工程学报.2005,24(24):4466-4471.
    [102]白俊光,林鹏,周维恒.李家峡拱坝复杂地基处理效果和反馈分析.岩石力学与工程学报.2008,27(5):903-912.]
    [103]周涛.溪洛渡水电站拱坝基础综合变模分析.四川水力发电.2001(2):22-26.
    [104]王进廷,杨剑,王吉焕.基于混合模型的铜头拱坝多参数反演分析.水力发电学报.2008,27(5):64-67.
    [105]罗加谦.坝体弹模及坝基变模对小湾双曲拱坝坝体应力的影响.云南水力发电.1993(1):35-40.
    [106]朱济祥,练继建,赵琪.大吨位预应力锚索对拱坝坝肩稳定的作用分析.水力发电学报.2004,23(2):69-72.
    [107]马连军,种秀玲,梁慧兰.复杂地基上砼拱坝三维非线性有限元稳定分析.水电能源科学.2004,28(4):75-77.
    [108]厉易生.拱坝优化体型的坝体最小体积.水利水电技术.1995(10):23-25.
    [109]郑波.满天星拱坝复杂地基基础开挖与处理.湖南水利水电.2002(1):12-15.
    [110]陈英儒,杨强,包劲清,等.高拱坝坝基断层加固力研究.水力发电学报.2008,27(6):62-67.
    [111]何建明,智立新,孙磊.构皮滩水电站左坝肩地质缺陷深层处理.人民长江.2008,39(9):26-28.
    [112]宁宇,徐卫压,吴关叶,等.白鹤滩水电站拱坝及坝肩加固效果分析及整体安全度评价.岩石力学与工程学报.2008,27(9):1890-1898.
    [113]周维恒,林鹏,周雅能,等.高拱坝基础大垫座及周边缝设置研究.岩石力学与工程学报.2008,27(10):1959-1967.
    [114]白俊光,林鹏,周维恒,等.李家峡拱坝复杂地基处理效果和反馈分析.岩石力学与工程学报.2008,27(5):903-912.
    [115]胡海昌.弹性力学的变分原理及其应用.北京:科学出版社,1981
    [116]刘先珊,周创兵,王军.复杂条件下高拱坝应力及坝肩稳定分析.岩土力学.2008,29(1):225-229.
    [117]RANDOLPH M F, WROTH C P. Analysis of vertical deformation of pile groups. Geotechnique,1979,29(4):423-439.
    [118]刘国华,吴党中,王茂荣.拱坝优化时建基面岩体变模的合理选用.四川大学学报.2011,43(6):48-52.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700