科学传播研究的可视化分析
|
摘要
很多人都熟知弗朗西斯·培根曾说过“知识就是力量”这句名言,但很少有人提起他曾说过的另外一句话:“知识的力量不仅取决于其自身的价值,更取决于它是否被传播以及被传播的深度与广度。”
随着现代科学技术的迅猛发展,科学传播发生了一系列重大变革,然而,目前出现科学传播理念明显滞后于社会进步与科学技术腾飞要求的情况。由于缺乏随时更新的理论指导和观念支持,国家科学政策的制定出现被动局面,从而制约了科学对社会的推动作用。本文采用科学知识图谱的可视化方法——时间线、交叉图和地形式可视化技术,绘制科学传播研究领域的科学知识图谱,通过可视化分析,构建科学传播学的整体框架,以期为科学传播寻找到一个“整体解决方案”;在充分借鉴国外科学传播发展经验的基础上,引进和利用其他学科有效的研究范式和方法,促进科学传播学的发展进程。科学传播研究是社会现实发展的一种回应,通过对科学传播研究领域的文献计量和可视化分析,让科学传播理论研究与社会现实形成良性互动,为国家科学政策的制定提供借鉴。
本文采用时间线和交叉图技术,从科学传播学的内在结构变化、知识来源以及与外部相关学科互动三个方面来分析科学传播学发展的动因,揭示科学传播学发展演进的规律,从而为下一步探索科学传播领域的研究热点奠定基础。
本文采用论文-关键词交叉图技术,绘制科学传播领域的研究热点可视化图谱,并通过不同时间段标注的三幅图的对比分析,探寻科学传播研究热点的演进轨迹,即从“科学知识”到“传播策略”的演进,从“信任科学”到“促进创新”的演进,从“缺失模型”到“语境模型”的演进。
本文采用时间线和地形式可视化技术,绘制科学传播研究前沿可视化图谱,更加形象、清晰地将科学传播研究的前沿凸显出来,为探测未来科学传播研究的主题提供线索。目前,科学传播研究前沿关注四个主题:决定人们自身生活质量的“当代健康”和“环境保护”,科学知识转化为生产力的行业性知识转移,新技术支持下的新媒体与传统媒体在新时代的应用,科学传播学元研究。
Francis Bacon's saying of "Knowledge is power" is familiar to many people.However, few people refer that Bacon also said that the knowledge power not only lies on its own value, but also lies on its depth and width to be communicated.
With the rapid speed of science and technology,a series of changes happed in science communication.However,up to now,the idea of science communication is obviously lagging behind the social progress and the scientific and technological development.Because of being lack of the newly updated theories and ideas,the national science and technology policy or STP is lost in the passive situations.And it limits the science's important role in promoting the social development.The paper uses the mapping knowledge domains' visualization techniques,i.e.Timeline,Crossmap and Landscape to plot the knowledge domains of science communication research.By the visualized analysis,an integrated frame is constructed and an "overall problem resolving blueprint" is to be discovered.On the base of learning foreign countries' experiences in science communication,the paper takes advantages of the effective research paradigm and method in other specialties to promote the development of science communication research.Science communication research is a response to the social reality and development.Science communication research has a two-way interaction between that in theories and practices by visualizing and bibliometric analysis in science communication specialty to provide experiences for making the national STPs.
Using timeline and crossmap techniques,the paper analyzes the reasons of science communication's development in three aspects of the internal structural changes,knowledge sources and exterior related specialties' interplays.The revolution law in science communication is presented.And it also lays the foundation of the next step to explore the hotspots in science communication research.
The paper uses paper-keyword crossmap technique to map the knowledge domains of science communication research hotspots.By comparing the three time-related maps, innovated tracks for the changing hotspots are found,that is,the changing tracks from "Science Push" to "Policy Pull",from "Deficit Model" to "Context Model",from "popularization impetus" to "innovation impetus".
Timeline and landscape techniques are used to plot the research fronts visualization map in science communication research.Research fronts in science communication research are presented much more clearly and vividly.Many research fronts are found including the "modern health" and "environmental protection",industrial knowledge transfer,the new media supported by the high technology and the utilization of the traditional media in the new era,and the meta-research in science communication.
随着现代科学技术的迅猛发展,科学传播发生了一系列重大变革,然而,目前出现科学传播理念明显滞后于社会进步与科学技术腾飞要求的情况。由于缺乏随时更新的理论指导和观念支持,国家科学政策的制定出现被动局面,从而制约了科学对社会的推动作用。本文采用科学知识图谱的可视化方法——时间线、交叉图和地形式可视化技术,绘制科学传播研究领域的科学知识图谱,通过可视化分析,构建科学传播学的整体框架,以期为科学传播寻找到一个“整体解决方案”;在充分借鉴国外科学传播发展经验的基础上,引进和利用其他学科有效的研究范式和方法,促进科学传播学的发展进程。科学传播研究是社会现实发展的一种回应,通过对科学传播研究领域的文献计量和可视化分析,让科学传播理论研究与社会现实形成良性互动,为国家科学政策的制定提供借鉴。
本文采用时间线和交叉图技术,从科学传播学的内在结构变化、知识来源以及与外部相关学科互动三个方面来分析科学传播学发展的动因,揭示科学传播学发展演进的规律,从而为下一步探索科学传播领域的研究热点奠定基础。
本文采用论文-关键词交叉图技术,绘制科学传播领域的研究热点可视化图谱,并通过不同时间段标注的三幅图的对比分析,探寻科学传播研究热点的演进轨迹,即从“科学知识”到“传播策略”的演进,从“信任科学”到“促进创新”的演进,从“缺失模型”到“语境模型”的演进。
本文采用时间线和地形式可视化技术,绘制科学传播研究前沿可视化图谱,更加形象、清晰地将科学传播研究的前沿凸显出来,为探测未来科学传播研究的主题提供线索。目前,科学传播研究前沿关注四个主题:决定人们自身生活质量的“当代健康”和“环境保护”,科学知识转化为生产力的行业性知识转移,新技术支持下的新媒体与传统媒体在新时代的应用,科学传播学元研究。
Francis Bacon's saying of "Knowledge is power" is familiar to many people.However, few people refer that Bacon also said that the knowledge power not only lies on its own value, but also lies on its depth and width to be communicated.
With the rapid speed of science and technology,a series of changes happed in science communication.However,up to now,the idea of science communication is obviously lagging behind the social progress and the scientific and technological development.Because of being lack of the newly updated theories and ideas,the national science and technology policy or STP is lost in the passive situations.And it limits the science's important role in promoting the social development.The paper uses the mapping knowledge domains' visualization techniques,i.e.Timeline,Crossmap and Landscape to plot the knowledge domains of science communication research.By the visualized analysis,an integrated frame is constructed and an "overall problem resolving blueprint" is to be discovered.On the base of learning foreign countries' experiences in science communication,the paper takes advantages of the effective research paradigm and method in other specialties to promote the development of science communication research.Science communication research is a response to the social reality and development.Science communication research has a two-way interaction between that in theories and practices by visualizing and bibliometric analysis in science communication specialty to provide experiences for making the national STPs.
Using timeline and crossmap techniques,the paper analyzes the reasons of science communication's development in three aspects of the internal structural changes,knowledge sources and exterior related specialties' interplays.The revolution law in science communication is presented.And it also lays the foundation of the next step to explore the hotspots in science communication research.
The paper uses paper-keyword crossmap technique to map the knowledge domains of science communication research hotspots.By comparing the three time-related maps, innovated tracks for the changing hotspots are found,that is,the changing tracks from "Science Push" to "Policy Pull",from "Deficit Model" to "Context Model",from "popularization impetus" to "innovation impetus".
Timeline and landscape techniques are used to plot the research fronts visualization map in science communication research.Research fronts in science communication research are presented much more clearly and vividly.Many research fronts are found including the "modern health" and "environmental protection",industrial knowledge transfer,the new media supported by the high technology and the utilization of the traditional media in the new era,and the meta-research in science communication.
引文
[1]李大光.英国科学家和工程师对科学传播的影响调查.科普研究,2007,(3):59-63.
[2]尹兆鹏.科学传播理论的概念辨析.自然辩证法研究,2004,20(6):69-77.
[3]刘兵,侯强.国内科学传播研究:理论与问题.自然辩证法研究,2004(5):80-84.
[4]http://www.people.cornell.edu/pages/bvll/,2007-02-06.
[5]http://communication.stanford.edu/faculty/fishkin.html,2007-02-06.
[6]刘华杰.大科学时代的科普理念.光明日报,2000-11-02(C02).
[7]翟杰全.国内科技传播研究:三大方向与问题.自然辩证法研究.2007,23(8):68-71.
[8]黄时进.哲学视野中的科学传播受众研究:(博士学位论文).上海:复旦大学,2005.
[9]Michael F.Weigold.Communicating Science—A Review of the Literature.Science Communication,2001,23(2):164-193.
[10]杰里·加斯顿.科学的社会运行.顾昕译.北京:光明日报出版社,1988.
[11]Hans E.Roosendaal,Peter A.Th.M.Developments in scientific communication:Considerations on the value chain.Geurts and Paul E.van der Vet.Information Services&Use,2001,(21):13-32.
[12]Burns T W,Connor D J,Stocklmayer S M.Science Communication:A Contemporary Definition.Public Understanding of Science,2003,(12):183-202.
[13]Daniel Charnay.The Centre for Direct Scientific Communication.Information Services & Use,2003,(23):133-137.
[14]Steve Miller.So Where's the theory:On the relationship between Science Communication Practice and Research.In:D.Cheng,ed.Communicating Science in Social Contexts.Springer Science and Busines Media,2007:275-287.
[15]韩建民.晚清科学传播的几种模式.上海交通大学学报,2003,(11):46-48.
[16]史革新.辛亥革命与近代科学传播.北京师范大学学报,2001,(6):25-35.
[17]孙宝寅.科技传播研究首届科技传播研讨会文集.北京:清华大学出版社,1996.
[18]吴国盛.从科学普及到科学传播.中国科技纵横,2003,(3):169-171.
[19]何郁冰.从系统论的角度论科学传播.系统辩证学学报,2004,(7):89-92.
[20]胡卫.“科学传播”和“技术传播”与国家创新体系.理论与改革,2001,(5):31-33.
[21]许志晋,毛宝铭.风险社会中的科学传播.科学学研究,2005,(8):439-433.
[22]司有和.中华人民共和国科技传播史.重庆:重庆出版社,2005.
[23]詹正茂,舒志彪.中国科学传播报告(2008科学传播蓝皮书).北京:社会科学文献出版社,2008.
[24]陈悦,刘则渊.悄然兴起的科学知识图谱.科学学研究,2005,23(2):149-154.
[25]Evelien Otte,Ronald Rousseau.Social network analysis:a powerful strategy,also for the information science.Journal of Information Science,2002,128(16):441-453.
[26]Noyons E,Van Raan A.Monitoring scientific developments from a dynamic perspective:self-organized structuring to map neural network research.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1998,49(1):68-81.
[27]刘军.社会网络分析导论.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2004.
[28]刘林青.作品共被引分析与科学地图的绘制.科学学研究,2005,23(2):155-159.
[29]Kretascher H.Coauthorship networks of invisible colleges and institutionalized communities.Scientometrics,1994,30(1):363-369.
[30]Kretschmer H.Types of two-dimensional and three-dimensional collaboration pattern.Proceedings of the Seventh Conference of the International Society of Scientometrics and Informetrics.Mexico,1999.
[31]http://vw.indiana.edu/sackler03/,2008-01-08.
[32]Chen C M.Information Visualization Research:A Citation and Co-Citation Perspective.InfoVis,2004.
[33]侯海燕.基于知识图谱的科学计量学进展研究:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2006.
[34]刘则渊,陈悦,侯海燕等.科学知识图谱:方法与应用.北京:人民出版社,2008.
[35]陈悦,刘则渊,陈劲等.科学知识图谱的发展历程.科学学研究,2008,26(3):449-460.
[36]Kuhn.The structure of science.Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1970.
[37]刘则渊.现代科学技术与发展导论.大连:大连理工大学出版社,2003:106-116.
[38]Thomas R.Lindlof,Bryan C.Taylor.Qualitative communication research methods.UK:Sage Publications,2002.
[39]Byron Reeves,Christine L.Borgman.A bibliometric evaluation of core journals in communication research.Human Communication Research,1983(1):119-136.
[40]William Paisley.Bibliometrics,Scholarly Communication and Communication Research.Communication Research,1989,16(5):701-717.
[41]Christine L.,Borgman.Scholarly Communication and Bibliometrics.UK:Sage Publications,1990.
[42]柯惠新,祝建华.传播统计学.北京:北京广播学院出版社,2003.
[43]GL(A|¨)NZEL W,THUS B,SCHLEMMER B.A bibliometric Approach to the role of author self-citations in scientific communication.Scientometrics,2004,59(1):63-77.
[44]Craig W.,Trumbo.Research Methods in Mass Communication Research:A census of eight Journals 1990-2000.Journal and Mass Communication Quarterly,2004,81(2):417.
[45]黄旦,丁未.传播学科“知识地图”的绘制和建构——20世纪80年代以来中国大陆传播学译著的回顾.现代传播,2005,(2):23-29.
[46]Kessler M M.Bibliographic Coupling Between Scientific Papers.Aemrica:American Society for Information Science,1960.
[47]H Small,B C Griffith.The Structure of Scientific Literatures Ⅰ:Identifying and Graphing Specialties.Science Studies,1974,4(1):17-40.
[48]K.W.McCain.Neural networks research in context:A longitudinal journal cocitation analysis of an emerging interdisciplinary field.Scientometrics,1998,41(3):389-410.
[49]Price D.Science Since Babylon.New Haven:Yale University Press,1961.
[50]倪延年.知识传播学.南京:南京师范大学出版社,1999.
[51]侯海燕,刘则渊,陈悦等.当代国际科学学主流学术群体及其代表人物.科学学研究,2006,24(2):161-165.
[52]B.V.Lewenstein.The meaning of "public understanding of science" in the United Sates after World War Ⅱ.Public Understanding of Science,1992(1),45-68.
[53]Office of Science and Technology and the Wellcome Trust.Science and the Public:a Review of Science Communication and Public Attitudes toward Science in Britain.Public Understanding of Science,2001,(10):315-330.
[54]吴国盛.科学传播与科学文化再思考.http://www.csc.pku.edu.cn/art/php,2008-03-08.
[55]Tubbs S L,Moss S.Human Communication.McGraw-Hill,1991.
[56]http:www.sagepub.com,2007-06-06.
[57]刘华杰.整合两大传统:兼谈我们所理解的科学传播.哲学研究,2002(10):15-20.
[58]Morris S A.Unified Mathematical Treatment of Complex Cascaded Bipartite Networks:The Case of Collections of Journal Papers:[dissertation].Oklahoma:Oklahoma State University,2005.
[59]Morris S A,Martens B V.Mapping research specialties.In:B Cronin,ed.Annual Review of Infomation Science and Technology,2008,(42):213-295.
[60]Morris S A,Boyack K W.Visualizing 60 years of anthrax research.10th International Conference of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics,Sweden:Karolinska University Press,2005:45-55.
[61]Morris S A,Yen G,Wu Z,Asnake,B.Timeline visualization of research fronts.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2003,54(5):413-422.
[62]Egghe L,Rousseau R.Co-citation,bibliographic coupling and a characterization of lattice citation networks.Scientometrics,2002,55(3):349-361.
[63]Persson O.The intellectual base and research fronts of JASIS 1986-1990.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1994,45(1):31-38.
[64]Mubeen M A.Bibliographic coupling:an empirical study of economics.Annals of Library.Science and Documentation,1995,42(2):41-53.
[65]Mu-Hsuan Huang.Constructing a patent citation map using bibliographic coupling:A study of Taiwan' s high-tech companies.Scientometrics,2003,58(3):195-221.
[66]Glanzel W,Czerwon H J.A new methodological approach to bibliographic coupling and its application to the national,regional and institutional level.Scientometrics,1996,37(2):195-221.
[67]Morris,S.A.,& Yen,G.Crossmaps:Visualization of overlapping relationships in collections of journal papers.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States,101(suppl.1),5291-5296.
[68]Bo Jameving.A comparison of two bibliometric methods for mapping of the research front.Scientometrics,2005,65(2):245-263.
[69]Bo Jameving.The cognitive structure of current cardiovascular research.Scientometrics,2001,50(3):365-389.
[70]杨立英．科技论文共现理论研究与应用：(博士论文)．北京：中国科学院研究生院,2007．
[71]Yang L Y,Morris S A,Barden E M.Mapping institutions and their weak ties in a research specialty:A case study of Cystic Fibrosis body composition research.Proceedings of the 11th International Conference of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics,Madrid,Spain,2007.
[72]Yang L Y,Morris S A,Jin B.Extraction,analysis,and mapping institutions from Web of Science data:A practical procedure.10th International Conference on Science and Technology Indicators,Vienna,Austria,2008.
[73]Small,H,Greenlee E.A Co-citation study of AIDS research.Communication Research,1989,16(5):642-666.
[74]R R Braam,H F Moed,A F J van Raan.Mapping of science by combined co-citation and word analysis.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1991,42(4):233-251.
[75]Morris S M,Michel L,Goldstein.Manifestation of Research Teams in Journal Literature:A Growth Model of Papers,Authors,Collaboration,Coauthorship,Weak Ties,and Lotka' s Law.Journal of the American Society for information science and technology,2007,58(12):1764-1782.
[76]Borner K,Chen C,Boyack K W.Visualizing knowledge domains.Annual Review of Information Science and Technology,2003,37:179-255.
[77]http://zjz06.yculblog.com/archive.p4.html,2006-08-09.
[78]W James Potter,Roger Cooper,Michel Dupagne.The three paradigms of mass media research in mainstream communication journals.Communication theory,1993(4):317-335.
[79]翟杰全.让科技跨越时空——科技传播与科技传播学.北京:北京理工大学出版社,2002:10-11.
[80]史玉民,徐飞.英国《公众理解科学》文献计量研究.中国科技期刊研究,2007,18(3):398-401.
[81]http://int1-pus.sagepub.com/,2007-06-06.
[82]Morris S A,DeYong C,Wu Z,Salman S,Yemenu D.DIVA:a visualization system for exploring document databases for technology forecasting.Computers and Industrial Engineering,2002,43(4):841-862.
[83]张婷,郑保章,王续琨.科学传播的兴起与发展.新闻记者,2007,(9):17-19.
[84]NELKIN D.An uneasy relationship:The tensions between medicine and the media.Lancet,1996(347):1600-1603.
[85]孙宝寅.科技传播导论.北京:清华大学出版杜,1997.
[86]翟杰全.科技传播研究:疆域的扩张.科学学研究,2005,(2):21-22.
[87]王续琨,张婷.论国家科学交流体系.河南大学学报(社会科学版).2006(3):123-126.
[86]Reports of Engineering and technology.London:The Committee to review the contribution of scientists and engineers to the public understanding of science,1995.
[87]迈诺尔夫·迪尔克斯,格罗特.公众、科学与技术——在理解与信赖之间.田松译.北京:北京理工大学出版社,2006.
[88]Hans,Peter A,Paul E.Developments in scientific communication considerations on the value chain.Infermation services & Use,2001(21):13-32.
[89]Daniel Chanay.The center for direct scientific communication.Information Services and use.2003(23):33-137.
[90]Jack P C,Willem Van Groenendal.Measuring the quality of publications:new methodology and case study.Information Processing and Management,2000(36):551-570.
[91]张婷,郑保章,王续琨.电子媒体时代的科学传播.新闻界,2007(3):16-18.
[92]Rob Kling,Geoffrey McKim.Not just a matter of time:field differences and the shaping of electronic media in supporting scientific communication,2000(4):1-13.
[93]Nora Jacobson.Social Epistemology:Theory for the "Fourth Wave" of Knowledge Transfer and Exchange research.Science Communication,2007(29):116-227.
[94]Yohanes E,I Hakan Yetkiner.A Market Mechanism for Scientific Communication Reply.KYKLOS,2003(3):401-404.
[95]White H D,McCain K W.Bibliometrics.Annual Review of Information Science and Technology,1989(24):119-186.
[96]普赖斯,M 戈德史密斯,A L 马凯.科学的科学.赵红州,蒋国华译.北京:科学出版社,1985:227-245.
[97]约翰·齐曼.元科学导论.刘珺珺译.长沙:湖南人民出版社,1988.
[98]许良英、范岱年编译.爱因斯坦文集:第一卷.北京:商务印书馆,1977:480.
[99]贝尔纳.科学的社会功能.陈体芳译.桂林:广西师范大学版社,2003:369.
[100]郑保章,刘乃仲.试论科技新闻传播如何实现社会化及大众化.大连理工大学学报(社会科学版),2000,21(2):69-72.
[101]王续琨.交叉学科、交叉科学及其在科学体系中的地位.自然辩证法研究,2000,16(1):10-15.
[102]翟杰全,杨志坚.对“科学传播”概念的若干分析.北京理工大学学报(社会科学版),2001,4(3):86-89.
[103]Michael F.Weigold.Communicating Science:A review of the Literature.Science Communication,2001,23(2):164.
[104]马丁,艾琳·伯林·雷,芭芭拉·沙夫.健康传播:个人、文化与政治的综合视角.龚文痒,李立群译.北京:北京大学出版社,2006.
[105]E C M Noyons,R K Buter,A F J van Raan.Mapping the Field of Neurosciences.TSER CT96-1035(Project1053)[EB/OL].http://www.cwts.nl/ed/ns2/ns0.html,2007.
[106]马妍春,黄可心.科技论文摘要、关键词及参考文献的规范化.情报科学,1999,17(6):625-627.
[107]李文兰,杨祖国.中国情报学期刊论文关键词词频分析.情报科学,2005,23(1):68-70.
[108]安秀芬,黄晓鹂.期刊工作文献计量学学术论文的关键词分析.中国科技期刊研究,2002,13(6):505-506.
[109]陈立新.力学期刊群的内外关系与学科结构:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2008:38.
[110]Werner Marx,Manuel Cardona.The impact of Solid State Communications in view of the ISI citation data.Solid State Communications,2003(127):323-336.
[111]周爱民.从2006年中文文献关键词看知识管理领域研究热点的变迁.现代情报,2007,(10):110-112.
[112]黄小燕.情报领域研究热点透视——情报领域论文关键词词频分析(1999-2003)[J].图书情报,2005,(6):83-85.
[113]张晶,尹兆鹏.科学传播理论的历史考察:将“传播”理念引入“科学”的历程.自然辩证法研究,2006,22(5).
[114]钟华.传播亦如下棋:法国科学传播重策略.科学时报.http://www.isp.cas.cn/html/Dir/2004/08/16/0902.htm,2004-08-16.
[115]刘霁堂.科学家职业演变与科普责任.自然辩证法研究,2004,20(8):43-47.
[116]Price D J D.Little Science,Big Science.New York:Columbia University Press,1963.
[117]Garfield E.Research fronts.Current contents,1994,9(4):3-7.
[118]Chen C M.CiteSpace Ⅱ:Detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):359-377.
[119]Ying,Schubert Foo,Gobinda.A bibliometric analysis of collaboration in the field of information retrieval.International Information and Library Review,1999,(30):367-376.
[120]Chen C M.The rising landscape:A visual exploration of superstring revolutions in physics.Journal of the American Society for information science and technology,2003,54(5):435-446.
[121]Jack Stilgoe.The(Co-) Production of Public Uncertainty:UK Scientific Advice on Mobile Phone Health Risks.Public Understanding of Science,2007(16):63-78.
[122]Stephen R J,Sheppard.Landscape visualisation and climate change:the potential for influencing perceptions and behaviour.Environmental Science and Policy,2005,8(6):637-654.
[123]郑新奇,姚慧,王筱明.20世纪90年代以来《Science》关于全球气候变化研究述评.生态环境,2005,14(3):422-428.
[124]罗杰斯.创新的扩散.北京:中央编译出版社,2002.
[125]Mulkay M J.The model of branching.Sociological Review,1976,24(1):125-133.
[126]蒋劲松.科学实践哲学视野中的科学传播.科学学研究,2007,25(1):9-13.
[127]Martin W.Bauer,Nick Allum,Steve Miller.What can we learn from 25 years of PUS Survey Research? Liberating and expanding the Agenda.Public Understanding of Science,2007,16(3):299-322.
[128]Nora Jacobson.Social Epistemology:Theory for the "frouth Wave" of Knowledge Transfer and Exchange Research.Science Communication,2007,29(1):116-127.
[129]J Bryant,D Miron.Theory and research in mass communication.Journal of Communication,2004,52(4):662-704.
[130]Robert T.Craig.Communication theory as a field.Communication Theory,1999(2):119-160.
[131]Nick Perry.Scientific Communication,Innovation Networks and Organization Structures.Journal of Management Studies,1993(9) 6-30.
[132]Gregory J,Sheperd.Advances in communication Theory:A critical review.Journal of Communication,1999:156-163.
[133]Daniel Patrick Thurs.Tini Tech,Transcendent Tech:Nanotechnology,Science Fiction,and the limits of modern science talk.Science Communications2007,29(1):65-95.
[134]王续琨,田宇力.中国科学学元研究成果的统计分析.科学学研究,2008,26(3):500-505.
[135]陈悦.管理学学科演进的科学计量研究:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2006.
[136]P.Kalaitzidakis,T.P.Mamuneas,T.Stengos.Rankings of Academic Journals and Instit-utions in Economics.http://www.econ.ucy.ac.cy/papers/0110.pdf,2006-07-17.
[2]尹兆鹏.科学传播理论的概念辨析.自然辩证法研究,2004,20(6):69-77.
[3]刘兵,侯强.国内科学传播研究:理论与问题.自然辩证法研究,2004(5):80-84.
[4]http://www.people.cornell.edu/pages/bvll/,2007-02-06.
[5]http://communication.stanford.edu/faculty/fishkin.html,2007-02-06.
[6]刘华杰.大科学时代的科普理念.光明日报,2000-11-02(C02).
[7]翟杰全.国内科技传播研究:三大方向与问题.自然辩证法研究.2007,23(8):68-71.
[8]黄时进.哲学视野中的科学传播受众研究:(博士学位论文).上海:复旦大学,2005.
[9]Michael F.Weigold.Communicating Science—A Review of the Literature.Science Communication,2001,23(2):164-193.
[10]杰里·加斯顿.科学的社会运行.顾昕译.北京:光明日报出版社,1988.
[11]Hans E.Roosendaal,Peter A.Th.M.Developments in scientific communication:Considerations on the value chain.Geurts and Paul E.van der Vet.Information Services&Use,2001,(21):13-32.
[12]Burns T W,Connor D J,Stocklmayer S M.Science Communication:A Contemporary Definition.Public Understanding of Science,2003,(12):183-202.
[13]Daniel Charnay.The Centre for Direct Scientific Communication.Information Services & Use,2003,(23):133-137.
[14]Steve Miller.So Where's the theory:On the relationship between Science Communication Practice and Research.In:D.Cheng,ed.Communicating Science in Social Contexts.Springer Science and Busines Media,2007:275-287.
[15]韩建民.晚清科学传播的几种模式.上海交通大学学报,2003,(11):46-48.
[16]史革新.辛亥革命与近代科学传播.北京师范大学学报,2001,(6):25-35.
[17]孙宝寅.科技传播研究首届科技传播研讨会文集.北京:清华大学出版社,1996.
[18]吴国盛.从科学普及到科学传播.中国科技纵横,2003,(3):169-171.
[19]何郁冰.从系统论的角度论科学传播.系统辩证学学报,2004,(7):89-92.
[20]胡卫.“科学传播”和“技术传播”与国家创新体系.理论与改革,2001,(5):31-33.
[21]许志晋,毛宝铭.风险社会中的科学传播.科学学研究,2005,(8):439-433.
[22]司有和.中华人民共和国科技传播史.重庆:重庆出版社,2005.
[23]詹正茂,舒志彪.中国科学传播报告(2008科学传播蓝皮书).北京:社会科学文献出版社,2008.
[24]陈悦,刘则渊.悄然兴起的科学知识图谱.科学学研究,2005,23(2):149-154.
[25]Evelien Otte,Ronald Rousseau.Social network analysis:a powerful strategy,also for the information science.Journal of Information Science,2002,128(16):441-453.
[26]Noyons E,Van Raan A.Monitoring scientific developments from a dynamic perspective:self-organized structuring to map neural network research.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1998,49(1):68-81.
[27]刘军.社会网络分析导论.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2004.
[28]刘林青.作品共被引分析与科学地图的绘制.科学学研究,2005,23(2):155-159.
[29]Kretascher H.Coauthorship networks of invisible colleges and institutionalized communities.Scientometrics,1994,30(1):363-369.
[30]Kretschmer H.Types of two-dimensional and three-dimensional collaboration pattern.Proceedings of the Seventh Conference of the International Society of Scientometrics and Informetrics.Mexico,1999.
[31]http://vw.indiana.edu/sackler03/,2008-01-08.
[32]Chen C M.Information Visualization Research:A Citation and Co-Citation Perspective.InfoVis,2004.
[33]侯海燕.基于知识图谱的科学计量学进展研究:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2006.
[34]刘则渊,陈悦,侯海燕等.科学知识图谱:方法与应用.北京:人民出版社,2008.
[35]陈悦,刘则渊,陈劲等.科学知识图谱的发展历程.科学学研究,2008,26(3):449-460.
[36]Kuhn.The structure of science.Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1970.
[37]刘则渊.现代科学技术与发展导论.大连:大连理工大学出版社,2003:106-116.
[38]Thomas R.Lindlof,Bryan C.Taylor.Qualitative communication research methods.UK:Sage Publications,2002.
[39]Byron Reeves,Christine L.Borgman.A bibliometric evaluation of core journals in communication research.Human Communication Research,1983(1):119-136.
[40]William Paisley.Bibliometrics,Scholarly Communication and Communication Research.Communication Research,1989,16(5):701-717.
[41]Christine L.,Borgman.Scholarly Communication and Bibliometrics.UK:Sage Publications,1990.
[42]柯惠新,祝建华.传播统计学.北京:北京广播学院出版社,2003.
[43]GL(A|¨)NZEL W,THUS B,SCHLEMMER B.A bibliometric Approach to the role of author self-citations in scientific communication.Scientometrics,2004,59(1):63-77.
[44]Craig W.,Trumbo.Research Methods in Mass Communication Research:A census of eight Journals 1990-2000.Journal and Mass Communication Quarterly,2004,81(2):417.
[45]黄旦,丁未.传播学科“知识地图”的绘制和建构——20世纪80年代以来中国大陆传播学译著的回顾.现代传播,2005,(2):23-29.
[46]Kessler M M.Bibliographic Coupling Between Scientific Papers.Aemrica:American Society for Information Science,1960.
[47]H Small,B C Griffith.The Structure of Scientific Literatures Ⅰ:Identifying and Graphing Specialties.Science Studies,1974,4(1):17-40.
[48]K.W.McCain.Neural networks research in context:A longitudinal journal cocitation analysis of an emerging interdisciplinary field.Scientometrics,1998,41(3):389-410.
[49]Price D.Science Since Babylon.New Haven:Yale University Press,1961.
[50]倪延年.知识传播学.南京:南京师范大学出版社,1999.
[51]侯海燕,刘则渊,陈悦等.当代国际科学学主流学术群体及其代表人物.科学学研究,2006,24(2):161-165.
[52]B.V.Lewenstein.The meaning of "public understanding of science" in the United Sates after World War Ⅱ.Public Understanding of Science,1992(1),45-68.
[53]Office of Science and Technology and the Wellcome Trust.Science and the Public:a Review of Science Communication and Public Attitudes toward Science in Britain.Public Understanding of Science,2001,(10):315-330.
[54]吴国盛.科学传播与科学文化再思考.http://www.csc.pku.edu.cn/art/php,2008-03-08.
[55]Tubbs S L,Moss S.Human Communication.McGraw-Hill,1991.
[56]http:www.sagepub.com,2007-06-06.
[57]刘华杰.整合两大传统:兼谈我们所理解的科学传播.哲学研究,2002(10):15-20.
[58]Morris S A.Unified Mathematical Treatment of Complex Cascaded Bipartite Networks:The Case of Collections of Journal Papers:[dissertation].Oklahoma:Oklahoma State University,2005.
[59]Morris S A,Martens B V.Mapping research specialties.In:B Cronin,ed.Annual Review of Infomation Science and Technology,2008,(42):213-295.
[60]Morris S A,Boyack K W.Visualizing 60 years of anthrax research.10th International Conference of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics,Sweden:Karolinska University Press,2005:45-55.
[61]Morris S A,Yen G,Wu Z,Asnake,B.Timeline visualization of research fronts.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2003,54(5):413-422.
[62]Egghe L,Rousseau R.Co-citation,bibliographic coupling and a characterization of lattice citation networks.Scientometrics,2002,55(3):349-361.
[63]Persson O.The intellectual base and research fronts of JASIS 1986-1990.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1994,45(1):31-38.
[64]Mubeen M A.Bibliographic coupling:an empirical study of economics.Annals of Library.Science and Documentation,1995,42(2):41-53.
[65]Mu-Hsuan Huang.Constructing a patent citation map using bibliographic coupling:A study of Taiwan' s high-tech companies.Scientometrics,2003,58(3):195-221.
[66]Glanzel W,Czerwon H J.A new methodological approach to bibliographic coupling and its application to the national,regional and institutional level.Scientometrics,1996,37(2):195-221.
[67]Morris,S.A.,& Yen,G.Crossmaps:Visualization of overlapping relationships in collections of journal papers.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States,101(suppl.1),5291-5296.
[68]Bo Jameving.A comparison of two bibliometric methods for mapping of the research front.Scientometrics,2005,65(2):245-263.
[69]Bo Jameving.The cognitive structure of current cardiovascular research.Scientometrics,2001,50(3):365-389.
[70]杨立英．科技论文共现理论研究与应用：(博士论文)．北京：中国科学院研究生院,2007．
[71]Yang L Y,Morris S A,Barden E M.Mapping institutions and their weak ties in a research specialty:A case study of Cystic Fibrosis body composition research.Proceedings of the 11th International Conference of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics,Madrid,Spain,2007.
[72]Yang L Y,Morris S A,Jin B.Extraction,analysis,and mapping institutions from Web of Science data:A practical procedure.10th International Conference on Science and Technology Indicators,Vienna,Austria,2008.
[73]Small,H,Greenlee E.A Co-citation study of AIDS research.Communication Research,1989,16(5):642-666.
[74]R R Braam,H F Moed,A F J van Raan.Mapping of science by combined co-citation and word analysis.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1991,42(4):233-251.
[75]Morris S M,Michel L,Goldstein.Manifestation of Research Teams in Journal Literature:A Growth Model of Papers,Authors,Collaboration,Coauthorship,Weak Ties,and Lotka' s Law.Journal of the American Society for information science and technology,2007,58(12):1764-1782.
[76]Borner K,Chen C,Boyack K W.Visualizing knowledge domains.Annual Review of Information Science and Technology,2003,37:179-255.
[77]http://zjz06.yculblog.com/archive.p4.html,2006-08-09.
[78]W James Potter,Roger Cooper,Michel Dupagne.The three paradigms of mass media research in mainstream communication journals.Communication theory,1993(4):317-335.
[79]翟杰全.让科技跨越时空——科技传播与科技传播学.北京:北京理工大学出版社,2002:10-11.
[80]史玉民,徐飞.英国《公众理解科学》文献计量研究.中国科技期刊研究,2007,18(3):398-401.
[81]http://int1-pus.sagepub.com/,2007-06-06.
[82]Morris S A,DeYong C,Wu Z,Salman S,Yemenu D.DIVA:a visualization system for exploring document databases for technology forecasting.Computers and Industrial Engineering,2002,43(4):841-862.
[83]张婷,郑保章,王续琨.科学传播的兴起与发展.新闻记者,2007,(9):17-19.
[84]NELKIN D.An uneasy relationship:The tensions between medicine and the media.Lancet,1996(347):1600-1603.
[85]孙宝寅.科技传播导论.北京:清华大学出版杜,1997.
[86]翟杰全.科技传播研究:疆域的扩张.科学学研究,2005,(2):21-22.
[87]王续琨,张婷.论国家科学交流体系.河南大学学报(社会科学版).2006(3):123-126.
[86]Reports of Engineering and technology.London:The Committee to review the contribution of scientists and engineers to the public understanding of science,1995.
[87]迈诺尔夫·迪尔克斯,格罗特.公众、科学与技术——在理解与信赖之间.田松译.北京:北京理工大学出版社,2006.
[88]Hans,Peter A,Paul E.Developments in scientific communication considerations on the value chain.Infermation services & Use,2001(21):13-32.
[89]Daniel Chanay.The center for direct scientific communication.Information Services and use.2003(23):33-137.
[90]Jack P C,Willem Van Groenendal.Measuring the quality of publications:new methodology and case study.Information Processing and Management,2000(36):551-570.
[91]张婷,郑保章,王续琨.电子媒体时代的科学传播.新闻界,2007(3):16-18.
[92]Rob Kling,Geoffrey McKim.Not just a matter of time:field differences and the shaping of electronic media in supporting scientific communication,2000(4):1-13.
[93]Nora Jacobson.Social Epistemology:Theory for the "Fourth Wave" of Knowledge Transfer and Exchange research.Science Communication,2007(29):116-227.
[94]Yohanes E,I Hakan Yetkiner.A Market Mechanism for Scientific Communication Reply.KYKLOS,2003(3):401-404.
[95]White H D,McCain K W.Bibliometrics.Annual Review of Information Science and Technology,1989(24):119-186.
[96]普赖斯,M 戈德史密斯,A L 马凯.科学的科学.赵红州,蒋国华译.北京:科学出版社,1985:227-245.
[97]约翰·齐曼.元科学导论.刘珺珺译.长沙:湖南人民出版社,1988.
[98]许良英、范岱年编译.爱因斯坦文集:第一卷.北京:商务印书馆,1977:480.
[99]贝尔纳.科学的社会功能.陈体芳译.桂林:广西师范大学版社,2003:369.
[100]郑保章,刘乃仲.试论科技新闻传播如何实现社会化及大众化.大连理工大学学报(社会科学版),2000,21(2):69-72.
[101]王续琨.交叉学科、交叉科学及其在科学体系中的地位.自然辩证法研究,2000,16(1):10-15.
[102]翟杰全,杨志坚.对“科学传播”概念的若干分析.北京理工大学学报(社会科学版),2001,4(3):86-89.
[103]Michael F.Weigold.Communicating Science:A review of the Literature.Science Communication,2001,23(2):164.
[104]马丁,艾琳·伯林·雷,芭芭拉·沙夫.健康传播:个人、文化与政治的综合视角.龚文痒,李立群译.北京:北京大学出版社,2006.
[105]E C M Noyons,R K Buter,A F J van Raan.Mapping the Field of Neurosciences.TSER CT96-1035(Project1053)[EB/OL].http://www.cwts.nl/ed/ns2/ns0.html,2007.
[106]马妍春,黄可心.科技论文摘要、关键词及参考文献的规范化.情报科学,1999,17(6):625-627.
[107]李文兰,杨祖国.中国情报学期刊论文关键词词频分析.情报科学,2005,23(1):68-70.
[108]安秀芬,黄晓鹂.期刊工作文献计量学学术论文的关键词分析.中国科技期刊研究,2002,13(6):505-506.
[109]陈立新.力学期刊群的内外关系与学科结构:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2008:38.
[110]Werner Marx,Manuel Cardona.The impact of Solid State Communications in view of the ISI citation data.Solid State Communications,2003(127):323-336.
[111]周爱民.从2006年中文文献关键词看知识管理领域研究热点的变迁.现代情报,2007,(10):110-112.
[112]黄小燕.情报领域研究热点透视——情报领域论文关键词词频分析(1999-2003)[J].图书情报,2005,(6):83-85.
[113]张晶,尹兆鹏.科学传播理论的历史考察:将“传播”理念引入“科学”的历程.自然辩证法研究,2006,22(5).
[114]钟华.传播亦如下棋:法国科学传播重策略.科学时报.http://www.isp.cas.cn/html/Dir/2004/08/16/0902.htm,2004-08-16.
[115]刘霁堂.科学家职业演变与科普责任.自然辩证法研究,2004,20(8):43-47.
[116]Price D J D.Little Science,Big Science.New York:Columbia University Press,1963.
[117]Garfield E.Research fronts.Current contents,1994,9(4):3-7.
[118]Chen C M.CiteSpace Ⅱ:Detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):359-377.
[119]Ying,Schubert Foo,Gobinda.A bibliometric analysis of collaboration in the field of information retrieval.International Information and Library Review,1999,(30):367-376.
[120]Chen C M.The rising landscape:A visual exploration of superstring revolutions in physics.Journal of the American Society for information science and technology,2003,54(5):435-446.
[121]Jack Stilgoe.The(Co-) Production of Public Uncertainty:UK Scientific Advice on Mobile Phone Health Risks.Public Understanding of Science,2007(16):63-78.
[122]Stephen R J,Sheppard.Landscape visualisation and climate change:the potential for influencing perceptions and behaviour.Environmental Science and Policy,2005,8(6):637-654.
[123]郑新奇,姚慧,王筱明.20世纪90年代以来《Science》关于全球气候变化研究述评.生态环境,2005,14(3):422-428.
[124]罗杰斯.创新的扩散.北京:中央编译出版社,2002.
[125]Mulkay M J.The model of branching.Sociological Review,1976,24(1):125-133.
[126]蒋劲松.科学实践哲学视野中的科学传播.科学学研究,2007,25(1):9-13.
[127]Martin W.Bauer,Nick Allum,Steve Miller.What can we learn from 25 years of PUS Survey Research? Liberating and expanding the Agenda.Public Understanding of Science,2007,16(3):299-322.
[128]Nora Jacobson.Social Epistemology:Theory for the "frouth Wave" of Knowledge Transfer and Exchange Research.Science Communication,2007,29(1):116-127.
[129]J Bryant,D Miron.Theory and research in mass communication.Journal of Communication,2004,52(4):662-704.
[130]Robert T.Craig.Communication theory as a field.Communication Theory,1999(2):119-160.
[131]Nick Perry.Scientific Communication,Innovation Networks and Organization Structures.Journal of Management Studies,1993(9) 6-30.
[132]Gregory J,Sheperd.Advances in communication Theory:A critical review.Journal of Communication,1999:156-163.
[133]Daniel Patrick Thurs.Tini Tech,Transcendent Tech:Nanotechnology,Science Fiction,and the limits of modern science talk.Science Communications2007,29(1):65-95.
[134]王续琨,田宇力.中国科学学元研究成果的统计分析.科学学研究,2008,26(3):500-505.
[135]陈悦.管理学学科演进的科学计量研究:(博士学位论文).大连:大连理工大学,2006.
[136]P.Kalaitzidakis,T.P.Mamuneas,T.Stengos.Rankings of Academic Journals and Instit-utions in Economics.http://www.econ.ucy.ac.cy/papers/0110.pdf,2006-07-17.