用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于碳中和的中国林业碳汇交易市场研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在全球气候变暖的背景下,中国积极承诺并开展控制温室气体排放行动。林业经营管理中造林与再造林以及减少毁林和防止森林退化的措施,作为有效控制二氧化碳排放的手段而被各方关注,特别是随着世界碳排放权交易市场的发展,以及中国碳交易试点工作的开展,林业碳汇的市场功能预期被逐渐放大。为了更好的根据现有的经济理论设计一套符合中国国情的碳交易机制,调动排放主体参与的积极性,需要制定有效的碳交易市场的建立路径,将减排与森林碳汇生态服务结合。本研究将围绕着森林碳汇生态服务与工业减排的成本比较、林业碳汇市场的供给与需求、碳交易价格波动及收益风险等问题进行研究,以验证生态经济模式的可行性,从而探索出适合中国国情的,在牺牲经济代价最小的前提下,控制温室气体排放的路径。
     第一部分,研究主要介绍了基于林业碳中和建立中国碳排放权交易市场研究的背景、目的及意义。同时对相关的文献按照林业碳汇、碳排放权交易市场、林业碳汇交易三个方面进行文献综述,并对研究中所运用的理论进行必要的梳理。
     第二部分,创新的将碳汇市场的需求与供给相结合,重点回答林业碳中和经济可行性和中国林业碳汇供给能力两个问题。在林业碳中和经济可行性分析中,首先通过案例分析体现森林碳汇生态服务具有抵消工业排放的能力,提出循环经济的企业运行模式。其次通过长期能源规划模型,预测中国钢铁、水泥、化工及造纸等部门的减排需求,然后以钢铁行业为例,通过中观行业角度进行经济学意义上的短期、中长期成本效益分析,证明通过森林碳汇生态服务可以在不影响经济发展的前提下达到控制温室气体排放的目标。在中国林业碳汇供给分析中,首先综述目前林业碳汇项目的方法学,然后对中国CDM林业碳汇项目以及新西兰REDD项目进行案例分析,之后创新的运用了系统动力学模型模拟REDD项目下林业碳汇的供给以及土地经营者的收益,从供给的角度证明在中国有建立林业碳汇市场的基础,并在模型中引入价格序列波动,证明了碳市场的价格波动会影响林业碳汇收益。
     第三部分,国际碳交易市场的经验借鉴,包括国际主要碳市场价格波动分析及比较以及国际主要碳市场风险度量及比较。通过总结各类碳交易市场的价格波动和风险变化的特点,创新的以金融风险的角度,对国际目前主要的强制性和自愿性碳交易市场进行了比较,为中国建立自己的全国范围内的碳交易市场提供经验借鉴,重点解决中国应该建立什么类型的碳交易市场的问题。
     第四部分,即中国林业碳汇交易市场建立路径,首先根据第三部分的结论,为中国碳交易市场制定一个终极的蓝图,创新的利用演化经济学的理论,将中国碳交易市场划归三个阶段,制定一个可行的演进路径。在推演的过程中对碳市场的建立及监管涉及到的相关事项提出相应的政策建议。
Under the background of global warming, China actively commits to and carries out controlling greenhouse gas emissions. Forestry management is caught in the spotlight because of that afforestation and reforestation and reducing deforestation and forest degradation which are parts of it are considered as effective measures in reducing carbon dioxide emissions. Especially with the development of the carbon trade in the world and the pilot work of China's carbon market, the expectation of forestry carbon sinks in the market is being expended steply. In order to design a better carbon trading mechanism which is in line with China's national conditions based on the existing economic theory and to mobilize the enterprise emissions reduction initiative, it needs to plan a effective path of establishing a carbon trading market to combine emission reduction with forest carbon sequestration ecosystem services. This study focuses on cost comparison of forest ecosystem services and carbon sequestration of industrial emissions, supply and demand of forestry carbon market and fluctuations in the price and yield risks of carbon trading in order to verify the feasibility of ecological economic model and explore suitable ways for China to reduce emissions under the premise of minimal economic costs.
     The first part introduces the background, purpose and significance of analysis on carbon emission trading market in China based on carbon neutral by forest and reviews the references divided into three categories witch are about forestry carbon sequestration, carbon emissions trading market and forestry carbon sequestration transaction, as while as it also summarizes the research theory which the study based on.
     The second part combines demand of the carbon market with the supply innovatively and focuses on two issues those are economic feasibility of carbon neutral by forest and the ability of the supply of carbon credit by forestry carbon sequestration project in China. In the section of analysis of economic feasibility of carbon neutral by forest, it uses one case to prove that forest carbon sequestration ecosystem services have the ability in offset the industrial emissions and proposes enterprise operation mode of circular economy. It forecasts CO2emissions in iron and steel, cement, chemicals and paper production by LEAP model and then it commits the short-term and long-term cost-benefit analysis on iron and steel industry to prove it can achieve the emissions target by forestry carbon sequestration project without impact of economic development. In the section of the supply of carbon credit by forestry carbon sequestration project in China, it summarizes forestry carbon sequestration methodology and analysises two cases which are CDM afforestation and reforestation project in Guangxi province and REDD project in New Zealand. It simulates the benefits of the REDD project by using system dynamics model into witch price series are innovatively improved and it indicates that there is foundation of establishing forestry carbon market in China and price fluctuations will affect the income of forestry carbon sequestration.
     The third part is called experience in international carbon trading market and also includes two sections which are the analysis and comparison of price fluctuations in major international carbon market and the study on measuring the risk of major international carbon emissions trading market. It describes characteristics of various types of carbon trading market price fluctuations and risk and compares regulated carbon market and voluntary one in financial risk perspective innovatively. This part answers witch type market China should establish and provides experience.
     The forth part is called the path of China forestry carbon sequestration market established. It provides a blueprint for China forestry carbon sequestration market based on the consequences of the third part, divides the development of the Chinese carbon trading market into three stages based on evolutionary economics, plans an effective path to the target and proposes appropriate policy recommendations.
引文
[1]Aatola P, Ollikainen M, Toppinen A. Price determination in the EU ETS m arket:Theory and econometric analysis with market fundamentals[J]. Energy Ec onomics,2013,36:380-395.
    [2]Adams D M, Alig R J, McCarl B A, et al. Minimum cost strategies for se questering carbon in forests[J]. Land Economics,1999,75(3).
    [3]Alberola E, Chevallier J, Cheze B. Price drivers and structural breaks in Eu ropean carbon prices 2005-2007[J]. Energy Policy,2008,36(2):787-797.
    [4]Aldy J E, Krupnick A J, Newell R G, et al. Designing climate mitigation policy [R]. National Bureau of Economic Research,2009.
    [5]Alexandre Kossoy, Pierre Guigon. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2 012,76837[R].Carbon Finance at World Bank,2012
    [6]Blyth W, Bunn D. Coevolution of policy, market and technical price risks i n the EU ETS[J]. Energy Policy,2011,39(8):4578-4593.
    [7]Blyth W, Bunn D, Kettunen J, et al. Policy interactions, risk and price for mation in carbon markets[J]. Energy Policy,2009,37(12):5192-5207.
    [8]Bonenti F, Oggioni G, Allevi E, et al. Evaluating the EU ETS impacts on profits, investments and prices of the Italian electricity market[J]. Energy Policy, 2013,59:242-256.
    [9]Capoor K, Ambrosi P. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2006. World Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/ha ndle/10986/13408 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported.
    [10]Capoor K, Ambrosi P. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2007. Worl d Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/h andle/10986/13406 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported.
    [11]Capoor K, Ambrosi P.2008. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2008. World Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldban k.org/handle/10986/13404 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported.'
    [12]Capoor K, Ambrosi P. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2009. Worl d Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/h andle/10986/13402 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported
    [13]Carpos, P. And L.Mantzos. The economic effects of emission trading to re duce greenhouse[R].Report to dg environment, E3M Laboratory 21 at ICCS/NT UA,2000
    [14]Chemyavs'k. Interaction of carbon and electricity pries under imperfect co mpetition [J]. IEFE working Paper No.2 Mary 2007 Swiss Finance Institute Re search Paper No.06-26
    [15]Chevallier J, Ielpo F, Mercier L. Risk aversion and institutional informatio n disclosure on the European carbon market:a case-study of the 2006 complia nce event[J]. Energy Policy,2009,37(1):15-28.
    [16]Chevallier J. Carbon futures and macroeconomic risk factors:a view from the EU ETS[J]. Energy Economics,2009,31(4):614-625.
    [17]Chomitz K M. Baseline, leakage and measurement issues:how do forestry and energy projects compare?[J]. Climate Policy,2002,2(1):35-49.
    [18]Cornwell A, Travis J, Gunasekera D. Framework for greenhouse emission trading in Australia[M]. Industry Commission,1997.
    [19]Costa P M, Wilson C. An equivalence factor between CO2 avoidedemissio ns and sequestration-description andapplications in forestry [J]. Mitigation and A daptation Strategies for Global Change,2000,5(1):51-60.
    [20]Cramton P, Kerr S. Tradeable carbon permit auctions:How and why to au ction not grandfather [J]. Energy policy,2002,30(4):333-345.
    [21]Dargusch P, Lawrence K, Herbohn J. A small-scale forestry perspective on constraints to including REDD in international carbon markets[J]. Small-Scale Forestry,2010,9(4):485-499.
    [22]Darius.M.Adams. Minimum Cost Strategies for Sequestering Carbon in For est[J].Land Economies,1999,8:14-21
    [23]De Jong B H J, Tipper R, Montoya-Gomez G. An economic analysis of t he potential for carbon sequestration by forests:evidence from southern Mexico [J]. Ecological Economics,2000,33(2):313-327.
    [24]Dhanda K K, Stranlund J. Endogenous Monitoring and Enforcement of Tra nsferable Emission Permit System[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,1999,38:267-282.
    [25]Diaz D, Hamilton K, Johnson E, et al. State of the forest carbon markets 2011:from canopy to currency[M]. Ecosystem Marketplace,2011.
    [26]Dewees D N. Emissions trading:ERCs or allowances?[J]. Land Economics, 2001,77(4):513-526.
    [27]Dopfer K.The evolutionary foundations of economics[M]. Cambridge Unive rsity Press,2005.
    [28]Dudek D, Tietenberg T. Climate Change:Designing a Tradable Permit Sys tem [M].Paris:OECD,1992
    [29]Dudley R G. A little REDD model to quickly compare possible baseline a nd policy scenarios for reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degrad ation[J]. Mitigation and adaptation strategies for global change,2010,15(1):53-69.
    [30]DuMouchel W H. Estimating the stable index a in order to measure tail t hickness:a critique[J]. The Annals of Statistics,1983:1019-1031.
    [31]Dutschke M, Schlamadinger B, Wong J L P, et al. Value and risks of exp iring carbon credits from afforestation and reforestation projects under the CD M[J]. Climate Policy,2005,5(1):109-125.
    [32]Feng Z H, Wei Y M, Wang K. Estimating risk for the carbon market via extreme value theory:An empirical analysis of the EU ETS[J]. Applied Energ y,2012,99:97-108.
    [33]Fischer C, Parry I W H, Pizer W A. Instrument choice for environmental protection when technological innovation is endogenous[J]. Journal of Environm ental Economics and Management,2003,45(3):523-545.
    [34]Goetz R U, Hritonenko N, Mur R, et al. Forest management for timber a nd carbon sequestration in the presence of climate change:The case of Pinus Sylvestris[J]. Ecological Economics,2013,88:86-96.
    [35]Grubb M, Seberinius J. Participation, Allocation and Adaptability in Intern ational Tradeable Emission Permit Systems for Greenhouse Gas control[R].Proce edings of OECD Workshop on Tradeable Emission Permits to Reduce Greenho use Gases. Paris.OECD,1992.
    [36]Gullison R E, Frumhoff P C, Canadell J G, et al. Tropical forests and cli mate policy [J]. Published online www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/1136163/DC 1,2007; 10.1126/science.1136163.
    [37]Hahn R W, Stavins R N. What Has Kyoto Wrought? The Real Architectur e of International Tradable Permit Markets. March. RFF Discussion Paper 99-3 0. Washington, DC:Resources for the Future. Available at SSRN:http://ssrn.co m/abstract= 152250 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.152250,1999.
    [38]Hamilton K, Bay on R, Turner G, et al. State of the voluntary carbon mar kets 2007[J]. Picking Up Steam. Washington DC, London, The EcoSystem Mar ktplace, New Carbon Finance,2007.
    [39]Hamilton K, Chokkalingam U, Bendana M, et al. State of Forest Carbon Markets 2009:Taking Root and Branching Out[M]. Ecosystem Marketplace,20 10.
    [40]Hamilton K, Sjardin M, Marcello T, et al. Forging a frontier:State of the voluntary carbon markets 2008[J]. Ecosystem Market Place and New Carbon Finance, San Francisco and London,2008.
    [41]Hamilton K, Sjardin M, Peters-Stanley M, et al. Building bridges:state of the voluntary carbon markets 2010[J]. Ecosystem Marketplace & Bloomberg N ew Energy Finance,2010,14.
    [42]Hamilton K, Sjardin M, Shapiro A, et al. Fortifying the foundation:state of the voluntary carbon markets 2009[J]. Fortifying the foundation:state of the voluntary carbon markets 2009,2009.
    [43]Heaps, C.G.,2012. Long-range Energy Alternatives Planning (LEAP) syste m. [Software version 2012.0049] Stockholm Environment Institute. Somerville, MA, USA. www.energycommunity.org
    [44]Hill B M. A simple general approach to inference about the tail of a distr ibution[J]. The annals of statistics,1975:1163-1174.
    [45]Jotzo F, Michaelowa A. Estimating the CDM market under the Marrakech Accords[J]. Climate Policy,2002,2(2):179-196.
    [46]Julien C, Carbon futures and macroeconomic risk factors:A view from the EU ETS, Energy Economics, Volume 31, Issue 4, July 2009, Pages 614-625
    [47]Karp L, Zhang J. Regulation of stock externalities with correlated abateme nt costs[J]. Environmental and Resource Economics,2005,32(2):273-300.
    [48]Keller K, Tan K, Morel F M M, et al. Preserving the ocean circulation:i mplications for climate policy[J]. Climatic Change,2000,47(1-2):17-43.
    [49]Kollmuss A, Zink H, Polycarp C. Making sense of the voluntary carbon market:A comparison of carbon offset standards[J]. WWF Germany,2008.
    [50]Kossoy A, Ambrosi P. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2010. Worl d Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.com/ handle/10986/13401 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported
    [51]Kossoy A, Guigon P. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2012. World Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/ha ndle/10986/13335 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported.
    [52]Lecocq F, Capoor K. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2005. World Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/ha ndle/10986/13410 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported.
    [53]Linacre N, Kossoy A, Ambrosi P.2011. State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2011. World Bank, Washington, DC. (?) World Bank. https://openknowle dge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/13399 License:CC BY 3.0 Unported
    [54]Lu J, Guo L, Liu X. Measuring the operational risk of Chinese commerci al banks using the semilinear credibility model[J]. Journal of Operational Risk Volume,2013,8(2):3-34.
    [55]McNeil A J. Estimating the tails of loss severity distributions using extrem e value theory [J]. Astin Bulletin,1997,27(1):117-137.
    [56]Michaelowa A, Stronzik M, Eckermann F, et al. Transaction costs of the Kyoto Mechanisms [J]. Climate policy,2003,3(3):261-278.
    [57]Molly Peters-Stanley and Daphne Yin. Maneuvering the Mosaic-State of th e Voluntary Carbon Markets 201 [R]. Forest Trends'Ecosystem Marketplace & Bloomberg New Energy Finance,2013.
    [58]Moulton R J, Richards K R. Costs of sequestering carbon through tree pla nting and forest management in the United States[J]. General technical report WO,1990.
    [59]Moura.Costa.P. and C. Wilson."An Equivalence Factor between C02 Avoide d Emissions and Sequestration. Description and Applications in Forestry." Mitig ation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change2000 5 (1):51-60
    [60]Murray B C, Newell R G, Pizer W A. Balancing cost and emissions certa inty:An allowance reserve for cap-and-trade[J]. Review of Environmental Econ omics and Policy,2009,3(1):84-103.
    [61]Nathan E. HULTMAN,Simone PULVER,Leticia GUIMARaES, et al.Carbon Market Risks and Rewards:Firm Perceptions of Cdm Investment Decisions in Brazil and India[J].Energy Policy,2012,40(0):90-102.
    [62]Nathan E. HULTMAN.Geographic Diversification of Carbon Risk-a Meth odology for Assessing Carbon Investments Using Eddy Correlation Measuremen ts[J].Global Environmental Change,2006,16(1):58-72.
    [63]Newell R G, Pizer W A. Regulating stock externalities under uncertainty [J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,2003,45(2):416-43 2.
    [64]Newell R G, Stavins R N. Climate change and forest sinks:factors affecti ng the costs of carbon sequestration[J]. Journal of environmental economics an d management,2000,40(3):211-235.
    [65]Perschel R T, Evans A M, Summers M J. Climate change, carbon, and th e forests of the Northeast[M]. Santa Fe, NM:Forest Guild,2007.
    [66]Peters-Stanley M, Hamilton K, Marcello T, et al. Back to the Future:State of the Voluntary Carbon Markets 2011[J].Ecosystem Marketplace & Bloomberg New Energy Finance,2012.
    [67]Peters-Stanley M, Hamilton K, Marcello T, et al. Developing dimension:S tate of the voluntary carbon markets 2012[J]. Ecosystem Marketplace & Bloom berg New Energy Finance,2012.
    [68]Peters-Stanley M, Yin D. Maneuvering the mosaic. State of the voluntary carbon markets 2013[J]. A Report by Forest Trends'Ecosystem Marketplace & Bloomberg New Energy Finance, Washington, DC,2013:126.
    [69]Phillips G, Aalders E, Lubrecht I. Forestry Issues outstanding from COP 6 [J]. SGS Climate Change Program,2001.
    [70]Phillips. Forestry Issues outstanding from COP6.SGS Climate Change Prog ram.2001
    [71]Piris-Cabezas P, Keohane N. Reducing emissions from deforestation and fo rest degradation:implications for the carbon market[J]. Environmental Defense Fund, Washington DC,2008.
    [72]Plantinga A J, Mauldin T. A method for estimating the cost of CO2 mitig ation through afforestation [J]. Climatic Change,2001,49(1-2):21-40.
    [73]Ramazan G, Faruk S, Abdurrahman U. EVIM:A Software Package for Ex treme Value Analysis in MATLAB[J]. Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics & Econo metrics,2001,5(3):1-29.
    [74]Ruimy A, Saugier B, Dedieu G. Methodology for the estimation of terrestr ial net primary production from remotely sensed data[J]. Journal of Geophysica 1 Research:Atmospheres (1984-2012),1994,99(D3):5263-5283.
    [75]Samuel Fankhansera, Cameron HePbumb, Designing Carbon markets Part 1: Carbon market in time [J]. Journal of the Air and Waste Management Associati on 2006(56)
    [76]Sedjo R,Solomon A.Climate and Forests[J].Greenhouse Warming:Abatemen t and Adaptation P 105-119(see N 92-10228 01-45),1991
    [77]Sovacool B K. The policy challenges of tradable credits:A critical review of eight markets[J]. Energy Policy,2011,39(2):575-585.
    [78]Stavins R N. Harnessing market forces to protect the environment[J]. Envir onment:Science and Policy for Sustainable Development,1989,31(1):5-35.
    [79]Stavins R N. Transaction costs and tradeable permits[J]. Journal of environ mental economics and management,1995,29(2):133-148.
    [80]Sun B, Sohngen B. Set-asides for carbon sequestration:implications for pe rmanence and leakage[J]. Climatic change,2009,96(3):409-419.
    [81]Svendsen G T, Vesterdal M. How to design greenhouse gas trading in the EU?[J]. Energy Policy,2003,31(14):1531-1539.
    [82]Tasehini Milunoviek. Europe Carbon Market Trading Mechanism [J].The E nergy Journal 28(3)
    [83]Tietenberg T H. Emissions trading, an exercise in reforming pollution polic y[M]. Resources for the Future,1985.
    [84]Van Kooten G C, Sohngen B, Sexton S E, et al. Economics of forest eco system carbon sinks:a review[J].2007.
    [85]Vatn A, Vedeld P O. National governance structures for REDD+[J]. Global Environmental Change,2013,23(2):422-432.
    [86]曹吉鑫,田赞,王小平,孙向阳.森林碳汇的估算方法及其发展趋势[J].生态环境学报,2009,(05):2001-2005.
    [87]曹开东.中国林业碳汇市场融资交易机制研究[D].:北京林业大学,2008.
    [88]陈冲影.森林碳汇与农户生计——以全球第一个森林碳汇项目为例[J].世界林业研究,2010,(05):15-19.
    [89]陈继红,宋维明.中国CDM林业碳汇项目的评价指标体系[J].东北林业大学学报,2006,(01):87-88.
    [90]樊根耀.生态环境治理的制度分析[M].杨凌:西北农林科技大学出版社,2003
    [91]范英,魏一鸣.基于R/S分析的中国股票市场分形特征研究[J].系统工程,2004,(11):46-51.
    [92]方精云,陈安平.中国森林植被碳库的动态变化及其意义[J].植物学报,2001,(09):967-973
    [93]冯亮明,刘伟平,肖友智.基于森林资源保护的碳排放权交易问题的研究[J].林业经济问题,2009,(01):15-19.
    [94]冯险峰,刘高焕,陈述彭,周文佐.陆地生态系统净第一性生产力过程模型研究综述[J].自然资源学报,2004,(03):369-378.
    [95]凤振华,魏一鸣.欧盟碳市场系统风险和预期收益的实证研究[J].管理学报,2011,(03):451-455.
    [96]凤振华.碳市场复杂系统价格波动机制与风险管理研究[D].:中国科学技术大学,2012.
    [97]高莹,周鑫,金秀GARCH-EVT模型在动态VaR中的应用[J].东北大学学报(自然科学版),2008,(04):601-604.
    [98]国家林业局办公室.林业应对气候变化“十二五”行动要点[EB/OL].http://www.gov.cn/zwgk/2012-01/20/content_2049496.htm,2012-01-20
    [99]国家林业局应对气候变化和节能减排工作领导小组办公室.造林项目碳汇计量与监测指南[M].北京:中国林业出版社,2008.
    [100]郝怡.演化经济学对竞争力的解释[J].经济问题,2006,(10):5-6.
    [101]何英.森林固碳估算方法综述[J].世界林业研究,2005,(01):22-27.
    [102]洪玫.森林碳汇产业化初探[J].生态经济,2011,(01):113-115+124.
    [103]胡品平,徐正春,刘成香.森林碳汇服务的经济学分析——基于产权角度看森林碳汇服务交易[J].中国林业经济,2007,(02):34-37.
    [104]花拥军,张宗益.基于峰度法的POT模型对沪深股市极端风险的度量[J].系统工程理论与实践,2010,(05):786-796.
    [105]华志芹,温作民.基于碳市场模式构建生态经济增长模型[J].生态经济,2011,(05):56-58+88.
    [106]简盖元,冯亮明,王文烂,卢素兰.森林碳汇价值与农户林业收入增长的分析[J].林业经济问题,2010,(04):304-308.
    [107]焦树林,艾其帅.黔中喀斯特地区退耕还林项目的碳汇经济效益分析[J].生态经济,2011,(10):69-72.
    [108]焦小平.欧盟排放交易体系规则[M].北京.中国财政经济出版社,2010
    [109]雷小燕.从演化经济学看我国国有商业银行组织结构的变革[D].:武汉大学,2004.
    [110]李殿伟,文桂江.自然资本、碳排放权与我国的碳交易能力建设[J].经济体制改革,2011,(03):15-19.
    [111]李建华.碳汇林的交易机制、监测及成本价格研究[D].:南京林业大学,2008.
    [112]李怒云,宋维明.气候变化与中国林业碳汇政策研究综述[J].林业经济,2006,(5).
    [113]李怒云,王春峰,陈叙图.简论国际碳和中国林业碳汇交易市场[J].中国发展,2008,(03):9-12.
    [114]李淑霞,周志国.森林碳汇市场的运行机制研究[J].北京林业大学学报(社会科学版),2010,(02):88-93.
    [115]李新,程会强.基于交易成本理论的森林碳汇交易研究[J].林业经济问题,2009,(03):269-273.
    [116]梁建忠,文冰.森林碳汇市场与碳税影响分析[J].林业经济,2007,(11):47-51.
    [117]林德荣.森林碳汇服务市场化研究[D].:中国林业科学研究院,2005.
    [118]刘璨.我国森林环境服务市场构建与私人参与的选择[J].自然资源学报,2002,(02):246-252.
    [119]刘婧.基于强度减排的我国碳交易市场机制研究[D].:复旦大学,2010.
    [120]刘凯旋,金笙.国内森林碳汇市场交易定价方法比较研究[J].农业工程,2011,(02):96-100.
    [121]刘凯旋.我国森林碳汇市场的构建与定价研究[D].:北京林业大学,2012.
    [122]莫祝平,王春峰,童德文.清洁发展机制下造林再造林项目实施障碍分析与对策建议——以中国广西珠江流域治理再造林项目为例[J].林业经济,2012,(06):57-63.
    [123]彭喜阳,左旦平.关于建立我国森林碳汇市场体系基本框架的设想[J].生态经济,2009,(08):184-187.
    [124]王灿,陈吉宁,邹骥.基于CGE模型的CO_2减排对中国经济的影响[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2005,(12):1621-1624.
    [125]王静,沈月琴,朱臻,陈炎根,鲍泽钦,后必成.公众对森林碳汇服务的认知与支付意愿分析[J],浙江林学院学报,2010,(06):910-915.
    [126]王静.基于社区的森林碳汇交易机制研究[D].:浙江农林大学,2010.
    [127]王恺,邹乐乐,魏一鸣.欧盟碳市场期货价格分布特征分析[J].数学的实践与认识,2010,(12):59-65.
    [128]王克,王灿,吕学都,陈吉宁.基于LEAP的中国钢铁行业CO2减排潜力分析[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2006,(12):1982-1986.
    [129]王伟光,郑国光.应对气候变化报告(2012)——气候融资与低碳发展[M].北京社会科学文献出版社,2012.
    [130]王效科,冯宗炜,欧阳志云.中国森林生态系统的植物碳储量和碳密度研究[J].应用生态学报,2001,(01):13-16.
    [131]王效科,冯宗炜.中国森林生态系统中植物固定大气碳的潜力[J].生态学杂志,2000,(04):72-74.
    [132]王杏芝,高建中.从市场主体角度探析森林碳汇市场发展[J].林业调查规划,2011,(01):117-119+139.
    [133]王学瓅,胡昳,姜洋.浅谈碳汇的确认、计量与定价[J].绿色财会,2009,(08):3-5.
    [134]王妍.林业碳汇市场风险信息披露研究[D].:东北林业大学,2011.
    [135]王毅刚,葛兴安,邵诗洋,李亚东.碳排放交易制度的中国道路——国际实践与中国应用[M].北京经济管理出版社,2011.
    [136]温博慧.国内外黄金价格波动性及其演化的实证研究——以中国上海和英国伦敦黄金市场为例[J].世界经济情况,2008,(10):59-64.
    [137]温博慧.虚拟经济复杂性与风险预警研究[D].:天津财经大学,2006.
    [138]吴建国,张小全,徐德应.土地利用变化对生态系统碳汇功能影响的综合评价[J].中国工程科学,2003,(09):65-71+77.
    [139]伍楠林.黑龙江省发展森林碳汇贸易实证研究[J].国际贸易问题,2011,(07):116-123.
    [140]伍楠林.中国开展森林碳汇贸易的实证研究[J].国际商务(对外经济贸易大学学报),2010,(05):5-11.
    [141]武曙红.CDM林业碳汇市场前景及碳信用的交易策略[J].林业科学,2010,(11):152-157.
    [142]郗婷婷,李顺龙.黑龙江省森林碳汇潜力分析[J].林业经济问题,2006,(06):519-522+526.
    [143]杨水清,文冰,娄玉娥.浅析政府在森林碳汇贸易项目建设中的作用——以云南腾冲试点项目为例[J].西南林学院学报,2007,(05):64-68.
    [144]杨志,陈波.碳交易市场走势与欧盟碳金融全球化战略研究[J].经济纵横,2011,(01):25-29.
    [145]殷维,谭志雄.基于森林碳汇的中国碳交易市场模式构建研究[J].湖北社会科学,2011,(04):96-99.
    [146]尹敬东,周兵.碳交易机制与中国碳交易模式建设的思考[J].南京财经大学学报,2010,(02):6-10.
    [147]于楠,杨宇焰,王忠钦.我国碳交易市场的不完整性及其形成机理[J].财经科学,2011,(05):79-87.
    [148]于同申,张欣潮,马玉荣.中国构建碳交易市场的必要性及发展战略[J].社会科学辑刊,2010,(02):90-94.
    [149]袁嘉祖,范晓明.中国森林碳汇功能的成本效益分析[J].河北林果研究,1997,(01):23-27.
    [150]张茂震,王广兴,周国模,葛宏立,徐丽华,周元中.基于森林资源清查、卫星影像数据与随机协同模拟尺度转换方法的森林碳制图[J].生态学报,2009,(06):2919-2928.
    [151]张颖,吴丽莉,苏帆,杨志耕.我国森林碳汇核算的计量模型研究[J].北京林业大学学报,2010,(02):194-200.
    [152]张祯波,王明友,王猛.产权视角下碳交易市场的建立与完善[J].特区经济,2011,(01):157-158.
    [153]赵林,殷鸣放,陈晓非,王大奇.森林碳汇研究的计量方法及研究现状综述[J].西北林学院学报,2008,(01):59-63.
    [154]赵玉焕,刘月.基于投入产出法的中国出口产品隐含碳测算[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2011,(12):8-14.
    [155]周隽,王志强,朱臻.全球气候变化与森林碳汇研究概述[J].陕西林业科技,2011,(02):47-52.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700