用户名: 密码: 验证码:
旅游解说研究进展与差异分析
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:Progress and Difference Analysis of Tourism Interpretation
  • 作者:柯祯 ; 刘敏
  • 英文作者:KE Zhen;LIU Min;Tourism College, Beijing Union University;
  • 关键词:旅游解说系统 ; 综述 ; 概念与功能 ; 效果评估 ; 规划
  • 英文关键词:tourism interpretation;;review;;concept and function;;effect evaluation;;planning
  • 中文刊名:LYXK
  • 英文刊名:Tourism Tribune
  • 机构:北京联合大学旅游学院;
  • 出版日期:2019-02-06
  • 出版单位:旅游学刊
  • 年:2019
  • 期:v.34;No.270
  • 基金:教育部人文社会科学研究规划基金项目“精准扶贫战略下景区周边社区的自我可持续发展能力提升研究”(18YJAZH057);; 北京联合大学人才强校优选计划(BPHR2017CS10)共同资助~~
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:LYXK201902016
  • 页数:17
  • CN:02
  • ISSN:11-1120/K
  • 分类号:123-139
摘要
旅游解说不仅是旅游管理与服务的重要组成部分,也是游客体验的关键环节。近十余年来旅游解说系统研究出现了注重情感化、视角微观化、方法交叉性等新的趋势,需要对其进展进行总结与归纳。文章从旅游解说概念和功能、效果与规划3个层面阐述旅游解说是什么、怎么实现和如何规划3个问题。由于我国的解说系统研究相比境外尚有一定差距,因此文章通过创新性视角、热点内容和交叉性方法等进展分析,对比境内外研究差异及其产生原因以对我国未来旅游解说研究与发展进行展望。研究结果表明:(1)旅游解说深层次与广泛性的理解需要多元化视角的融合,不同学科理论的支持扩展了旅游解说存在的价值与意义;(2)遗产、真实性、体验、地方、可持续旅游等逐渐成为旅游解说相关领域高频词,保护与情感依附等关于环境可持续与个人成长等功能与作用将是旅游解说未来研究热点与趋势;(3)我国在缩小与境外旅游解说研究差距的同时,要着重关注中外文化差异导致的不同发展模式的需求与研究方法的适用性。
        The significance of tourism interpretation is gradually recognized by tourism operators and managers of scenic areas particularly in the regions with abundant tourism resources. Tourism interpretation is not only an important part of tourism management and service, but also key engines for promoting and enhancing the quality of the vistors' experience.As a product of information transmission and educational function, tourism interpretation has gradually become an important part of tourism management and tourism experience. Therefore, the research of tourism interpretation needs to be reviewed and summarized. Over the past decade, there have been new trends and contents in the tourism interpretation system research, such as emotional identification, microscopic perspectives and application of multivariate method.The article elaborated on three aspects of tourism interpretation:the concepts and functions of tourism interpretation, the effects and the planning.Through the elaboration of the above contents, three issues are illuminated, that is what tourism interpretation is, how to realize it and how to plan it.Compared with the theoretical findings and application to the tourism interpretation system, research in Mainland China is somewhat lagging behind. It is urgent to systematically review the trends and research contents on tourism interpretation research to put forward advanced conceptions and experiences, and provide guidelines for further research and practical application at the national level.What's more, the study of tourism interpretation should consider not only the differences but also the differences of cultural backgrounds at inbounel and outhound. Therefore, this paper analyzed the progress through innovative perspectives, hot topics, multiple methods, differences comparative analysis between domestic and western researches, and explain what make the differences.Three suggestions and observations were proposed in this paper:(1) Different disciplines theory can help expand the value and significance of tourism interpretation, thus the deep and extensive understanding of tourism interpretation requires the integration of multi-discipline perspectives;(2) By using the CiteSpace, conclusions could be drawn that heritage, authenticity, experience, place and the sustainable tourism have gradually become high-frequency words in tourism interpretation related fields, which shows that the functions and effects of conservation and emotional attachment that could promote environmental sustainability and personal growth will be the future research hotspots and trends in tourism interpretation;(3) More attention should be paid to the needs of different development models and the applicability of research methods caused by cultural conflict between inbound and outbound.
引文
[1]HAM S H.A perspective on the evolution of interpretive research[Z].Taiwan,U.S.and Australia International Symposium on Environmental Interpretation and Eco-tourism,2002.
    [2]WANG Jing,ZHONG Linsheng,CHEN Tian.Progress of tourism interpretation at home and abroad[J].Human Geography,2015,30(1):33-39.[王婧,钟林生,陈田.国内外旅游解说研究进展[J].人文地理,2015,30(1):33-39.]
    [3]ZHONG Yongde,LUO Fen.A literature review of tourism interpretation[J].World Regional Studies,2006,15(4):87-93.[钟永德,罗芬.国内外旅游解说研究进展综述[J].世界地理研究,2006,15(4):87-93.]
    [4]ZHANG Mingzhu,LU Song,LIU Penghe,et al.A study review on tourism interpretation system both at home and abroad[J].Tourism Tribune,2008,23(1):91-96.[张明珠,卢松,刘彭和,等.国内外旅游解说系统研究述评[J].旅游学刊,2008,23(1):91-96.]
    [5]TILDEN F.Interpreting Our Heritage[M].Chapel Hill,NC:University of North Carolina Press,1957:60-97.
    [6]SHARPE G W.An overview of interpretation[J].Clinical Kidney Journal,1982,9(1):29-38.
    [7]CARR A.Mountain places,cultural spaces:The interpretation of culturally significant landscapes[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2004,12(5):432-459.
    [8]BEAUMONT N.Ecotourism and the conservation ethic:Recruiting the uninitiated or preaching to the converted?[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2001,9(4):317-341.
    [9]BENTON G M.From principle to practice four conceptions for interpretation[J].Journal of Interpretation Research,2009,14(1):7-31.
    [10]National Association for Interpretation.Mission,vision,and core values[EB/OL].www.interpnet.com/nai/About/What_We_Believe/nai/_About/Mission_Vision_and_Core_Values.aspx?hkey=ef5896dc-53e4-4dbb-929e-96d45bdb1cc1.2014-05-21.
    [11]Interpretation Australia.What is interpretation?[EB/OL].www.interpretationaustralia.asn.au/?cat=-11&s=What+is+interpretation&search-type=general.2014-05-21.
    [12]Apps K,Dimmock K,Lloyd D J,et al.Is there a place for education and interpretation in shark-based tourism?[J].Tourism Recreation Research,2017,42(3):327-343.
    [13]CHEN Yujun.The relationship between tourist satisfaction and revisit intentions on heritage interpretation system in Tainan city[J].Chia-nan Annual Bulletin:Humanity,2013,(39):369-379.[陈俞君.台南市古迹解说系统满意度与重游意愿之关系[J].嘉南学报:人文类,2013,(39):369-379.]
    [14]WU Bihu,JIN Hua,ZHANG Li.Planning and management of tourism interpretation system[J].Tourism Tribune,1999,14(1):44-46.[吴必虎,金华,张丽.旅游解说系统的规划和管理[J].旅游学刊,1999,14(1):44-46.]
    [15]XU Shizhang,CHEN Shubao.The interpretive evaluation of ecological exhibits in the main vistior center of Taroko Park[J].Journal of Outdoor Recreation Study,2002,15(4):49-73.[许世璋,陈淑宝.游客中心展示馆之解说评估:以太鲁阁公园生态展示馆为例[J].户外游憩研究,2002,15(4):49-73.]
    [16]ZHANG Liming,ZHAO Liming.Construction of tourist interpretation system of National Forest Park[J].Journal of Northwest A&F University:Social Science Edition,2006,6(2):88-92.[张立明,赵黎明.国家森林公园旅游解说系统的构建[J].西北农林科技大学学报:社会科学版,2006,6(2):88-92.]
    [17]DENG Mingyan,QIN Yan.An optimization of tourist interpretation system in heritage scenic areas based on demand analysis:Taking Mt.Emei scenic area as an example[J].Tourism Tribune,2010,25(7):35-40.[邓明艳,覃艳.基于需求分析的遗产景区旅游解说系统优化研究:以峨眉山景区为例[J].旅游学刊,2010,25(7):35-40.]
    [18]ZHAO Minyan,YE Wen,DONG Suocheng,et al.Research progress of differences in ecotourism interpretation between China and Western countries and localization of interpretation[J].Progress in Geography,2016,35(6):691-701.[赵敏燕,叶文,董锁成,等.中西生态旅游解说系统差异化研究进展及本土化路径[J].地理科学进展,2016,35(6):691-701.]
    [19]LIN Xiaoxian.Survey of tourist satisfaction,service quality,interpretation skills and cognition of Lugang Community guidance for higher vocational students[J].Journal of Recreation and Wellness,2016,(15):30-43.[林效贤.高职生鹿港社区导览解说的游客满意度、服务品质、解说技巧与认知之调查[J].休闲保健期刊,2016,(15):30-43.]
    [20]FU Jing,GAO Jun.On the origin,development and research methodology of interpretation function[J].Tourism Science,2017,31(1):86-95.[付晶,高峻.解说缘起、发展与研究方法进展[J].旅游科学,2017,31(1):86-95.]
    [21]HAM S H.Interpretation as the centrepiece of sustainable wildlife tourism[C]//HARRIS R,GRIFFIN T,WILLIAMS P,Sustainable Tourism:A Global Perspective.London:Taylor and Francis Ltd,2002:35-44.
    [22]TANG Mingdi.A framework for interpretation system in tourist areas[J].Tourism Tribune,2006,21(1):64-68.[唐鸣镝.景区旅游解说系统的构建[J].旅游学刊,2006,21(1):64-68.]
    [23]TANG Jiala.An initial discussion about tourist interpretation system:A case study of Yinlusong Scenic Spot in Mt.Daowu[J].Tourism Tribune,2003,18(3):14-17.[唐伽拉.旅游解说系统规划初探:以浏阳道吾山引路松景区为例[J].旅游学刊,2003,18(3):14-17.]
    [24]BECK L,Cable T.The meaning of interpretation[J].Journal of Interpretation Research,2002,7(1):7-10.
    [25]MOSCARDO G.Interpretation and tourism:Holy grail or emperor’s robes?[J].International Journal of Culture Tourism&Hospitality Research,2014,8(4):462-476.
    [26]LI Ling,LI Hongbo.An analysis of tourism interpretation function and its development trend:Based on the theory of communication[J].Journal of Leshan Teachers College,2010,25(2):85-88.[李玲,李洪波.旅游解说功能及其发展趋势探析:基于传播学理论[J].乐山师范学院学报,2010,25(2):85-88.]
    [27]HAM S H,SEWING D R.Barriers to Environmental Education[J].Journal of Environmental Education,1988,19(2):17-24.
    [28]ORAMS M B.Using interpretation to manage nature-based tourism[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,1996,4(2):81-94.
    [29]WANG Min,WEI Dong Ying,CHEN Chen.The study of implement environmental education through environmental interpretation[J].Environmental Education,2005,(5):4-7.[王民,蔚东英,陈晨.通过环境解说实施环境教育的研究[J].环境教育,2005,(5):4-7.]
    [30]MUNRO J K,MORRISONSAUNDERS A,HUGHES M.Environmental interpretation evaluation in natural areas[J].Journal of Ecotourism,2008,7(1):1-14.
    [31]TAO Wei,DU Xiaofang,HONG Yan.Interpretation:An important tactics for heritage conservation[J].Tourism Tribune,2009,24(8):47-52.[陶伟,杜小芳,洪艳.解说:一种重要的遗产保护策略[J].旅游学刊,2009,24(8):47-52.]
    [32]MICHON D,ELANTABLY A.It’s hard to be down when you’re up:Interpreting cultural heritage through alternative media[J].International Journal of Heritage Studies,2013,19(1):16-40.
    [33]ABABNEH A.Heritage management and interpretation:Challenges to heritage site-based values,reflections from the heritage site of Umm Qais,Jordan[J].Archaeologies,2016,12(1):38-72.
    [34]BALLANTYNE R,UZZELL D.International trends in heritage and environmental interpretation:Future directions for Australian research and practice[J].Journal of Interpretation Research,1999,4(1):59-75.
    [35]BALLANTYNE R,PACKER J,HUGHES K.Tourists’support for conservation messages and sustainable management practices in wildlife tourism experiences[J].Tourism Management,2009,30(5):658-664.
    [36]MOSCARDO G.Stories of people and places:Interpretation,tourism and sustainability[J].Encyclopedia of Tourism,2015,9(1):294-301.
    [37]WANG Hui,ZHANG Jiachen,LIU Xiaoyu,et al.Interpretation and education in the U.S.National Park:A case study of the Theodore Roosevelt National Park[J].Tourism Tribune,2016,31(5):119-126.[王辉,张佳琛,刘小宇,等.美国国家公园的解说与教育服务研究:以西奥多·罗斯福国家公园为例[J].旅游学刊,2016,31(5):119-126.]
    [38]MANU I.Testing a model of effective interpretation to boost the heritage tourism experience:A case study in Macao[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2013,21(6):900-914.
    [39]YANG Yingqin,CHEN Yumei,YAN Yiyin.Recreation experience,interpretation and recognition of ecotourism in ErJen River,Kaohsiung[J].Journal of Leisure,Tourism,Sport,&Health,2016,6(3):92-113.[杨英钦,陈玉美,颜怡音.二仁溪游憩体验、导览解说与生态旅游认知[J].休闲观光与运动健康学报,2016,6(3):92-113.]
    [40]WANG Xin.About the designing of traveling guide of the scenic region[J].Human Geography,2002,17(3):44-46.[王昕.旅游景区的旅游活动“导引”设计探讨:以都江堰为例[J].人文地理,2002,17(3):44-46.]
    [41]WANG Yayu.The research of tourists willingness to pay for interpretative service at the Chou-Cai Wetland Park[J].Journal of Commercial Modernization,2007,4(1):34-43.[王雅俞.游客对解说导览人员之付费意愿:以高雄市洲仔湿地公园为例[J].商业现代化学刊,2007,4(1):34-43.]
    [42]CHEN Kuanyu,LIN Shifeng.The moderating effect of impulsive trait on the relation between interpretation satisfaction and purchase intention[J].Technology Museum Review,2012,16(1):71-94.[陈宽裕,林士丰.博物馆解说服务满意度对纪念品购买意愿的影响:冲动性特质的干扰效果[J].科技博物,2012,16(1):71-94.]
    [43]LI Xinjian.The characteristics of tourism products,the technique of consumption and the interpretation system tourism attraction[J].Human Geography,2004,19(2):43-46.[厉新建.旅游产品特点、消费技术与景区解说系统[J].人文地理,2004,19(2):43-46.]
    [44]CUI Xiangtian.A feasibility study of provide interpretation service freely for historical and cultural scenic spots[J].Science&Technology Economy Market,2016,(4):138-138.[崔向天.历史人文景区免费提供讲解服务的可行性探究[J].科技、经济、市场,2016,(4):138-138.]
    [45]CABLE T T,KNUDSON M D,STEWART J D.The economic benefits to visitors of an interpretive facility[J].Journal of Environmental Education,1984,15(15):32-37.
    [46]APPS K,DIMMOCK K,LLOYD D,et al.In the water with white sharks:Participants’beliefs toward cage-diving in Australia[J].Anthrozoos A Multidisciplinary Journal of the Interactions of People&Animals,2016,29(2):231-245.
    [47]DELGADO A B,PACOS A S.Heritage,tourism and management interpretation of protected areas:Some approaches[J].Turismo E Sociedade,2013,6(2):300-323.
    [48]BOYLE S C.Opening minds:Interpretation and conservation[J].Museum International,2004,56(3):85-93.
    [49]JACOBS M H,HARMS M.Influence of interpretation on conservation intentions of whale tourists[J].Tourism Management,2014,42:123-131.
    [50]WIGHT A C,LENNON J J.Selective interpretation and eclectic human heritage in Lithuania[J].Tourism Management,2007,28(2):519-529.
    [51]MOSCARDO G.Interpretation and sustainable tourism:Functions,examples and principles[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2003,14(1):112-123.
    [52]HUGHES K,BOND N,BALLANTYNE R.Designing and managing interpretive experiences at religious sites:Visitors’perceptions of Canterbury Cathedral[J].Tourism Management,2013,36:210-220.
    [53]WALKER K,MOSCARDO G.Moving beyond sense of place to care of place:The role of indigenous values and interpretation in promoting transformative change in tourists’place images and personal values[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2016,24(8-9):1243-1261.
    [54]MARSCHALL S,GRANQUIST S M,BURNS G L.Interpretation in wildlife tourism:Assessing the effectiveness of signage on visitor behaviour at a seal watching site in Iceland[J].Journal of Outdoor Recreation&Tourism,2016,17:11-19.
    [55]WIJERATNE A J C,DIJK P A V,KIRKBROWN A,et al.Rules of engagement:The role of emotional display rules in delivering conservation interpretation in a zoo-based tourism context[J].Tourism Management,2014,42(2):149-156.
    [56]MARTIN S.Interactive visual media for geomorphological heritage interpretation,theoretical approach and examples[J].Geoheritage,2014,6(2):149-157.
    [57]LIU Yang,SHI Xinxin,MA Yuanyuan,et al.The research on plants and landscape interpretation system in Beijing Taoranting Park[J].Journal of Capital Normal University:Natural Science Edition,2016,37(5):53-57.[刘洋,史新欣,马媛媛,等.北京陶然亭公园植物及其景观解说系统的调查与研究[J].首都师范大学学报:自然科学版,2016,37(5):53-57.]
    [58]SHI Dingfang.Research on the Content Construction of Karst Caves Guide Commentary[D].Chongqing:Southwest University,2013.[石定芳.喀斯特洞穴导游解说词内容构建研究[D].重庆:西南大学,2013.]
    [59]YANG Wenhua.Construction of a tourism interpretation system for cultural heritage sites in the perspective of authenticity[J].Journal of Yunnan Nationalities University:Social Sciences Edition,2016,33(3):54-59.[杨文华.基于原真性视角的文化遗产景区旅游解说系统构建[J].云南民族大学学报:哲学社会科学版,2016,33(3):54-59.]
    [60]WANG Shufang,GU Huimin.Planning and management of English interpretation system for scenic spots[J].Journal of Beijing International Studies University,2006,(3):76-80.[王淑芳,谷慧敏.景区英文解说系统的规划和管理[J].北京第二外国语学院学报,2006,(3):76-80.]
    [61]MARTIN D,ALURI A,Woodside A G,et al.Etic interpreting of emic reports of tourism behaviour:Cross-cultural introspections of Hawaii[J].International Journal of Tourism Anthropology,2015,4(1):44-66.
    [62]CHEREM G J.The professional interpreter:Agent for an awakening giant[J].Journal of Interpretation,1977,2(1):3-16.
    [63]LIU Yanhong.Structuring interpretation system of ancient ruins[J].Journal of Northwest Normal University:Natural Science Edition,2009,45(1):112-116.[刘艳红.遗址旅游解说系统的构建[J].西北师范大学学报:自然科学版,2009,45(1):112-116.]
    [64]ZHAO Jianchang.Framework for tourist interpretation system: A case of the Great Wild Goose Pagoda[J].Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2011,39(7):4091-4093.[赵建昌.旅游景区解说系统构建研究:以西安大雁塔文化休闲旅游景区为例[J].安徽农业科学,2011,39(7):4091-4093.]
    [65]VEVERKA J A.Interpretive Master Planning[M].Helena:Falcon Press,1994:24-40.
    [66]WANG Hui.Designing of travelling explanation system:A case study of Jinyunshan,Chongqing[J].Areal Research and Development,2004,23(1):56-58.[王辉.旅游解说系统的设计探讨:以重庆缙云山为例[J].地域研究与开发,2004,23(1):56-58.]
    [67]LIU Fan.Research Based on the Tourists’Perception of the Cultural Heritage Interpretation Applicability:Take Nanjing Mingxiaoling Mausoleum as Example[D].Dalian:Dongbei University of Finance and Economics,2012.[刘樊.基于游客感知的文化遗产解说适用性研究[D].大连:东北财经大学,2012.]
    [68]ZHANG Ling,WU Chengji,Peng Yongxiang,et al.Research on interpretation demand and at geological relics sights:A case study of Cuihuashan National Geo-park in Shaanxi Province[J].Tourism Science,2010,24(6):39-46.[张玲,吴成基,彭永祥,等.游客对地质遗迹景观的解说需求研究:以翠华山国家地质公园为例[J].旅游科学,2010,24(6):39-46.]
    [69]WU Bihu,JIN Hua,ZHANG Li.Tourism interpretation system:A case study of Beijing[J].Human Geography,1999,14(2):27-29.[吴必虎,金华,张丽.旅游解说系统研究:以北京为例[J].人文地理,1999,14(2):27-29.]
    [70]ZOTICA M,M?l?escu S.The reenactment as tourism exploitation through heritage interpretation of heritage sites in transylvania[J].Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai,Geographia,2015,60(1):175-186.
    [71]FANG Xiaozhe.A Study on the Interpretative Effects of Interpreter on Heritage Tourism:A Case Study on Ding Tomb[D].Beijing:Beijing Forestry University,2009.[方晓喆.文化遗产人员解说效果研究:以明定陵人员解说为例[D].北京:北京林业大学,2009.]
    [72]LIU Qunyue,HUANG Qitang,CHEN Hao.Two-Dimensional code technology application in city park interpretation system[J].Chinese Landscape Architecture,2015,31(9):80-84.[刘群阅,黄启堂,陈豪.基于二维码技术在城市公园导示解说系统的应用研究[J].中国园林,2015,31(9):80-84.]
    [73]GAO Jiongqi.A discussion on the effect of voice guidance in Taipei County Yingge Ceramics Museum[C]//Tian Jingting.Proceedings of the Management Academic Symposium.Taichung:Chaoyang University of Technology,2003:381-395.[高炯琪.台北县县立莺歌陶瓷博物馆语音导览解说效果探讨[C]//田静婷.管理学域学术研讨会论文集.台中:朝阳科技大学管理学院,2003:381-395.]
    [74]ZHANG Qian.A Study of the Evaluation of Museum Interpretation:A Case Study of Hunan Provineial Museum[D].Changsha:Hunan Normal University,2009.[张茜.博物馆解说效果研究[D].长沙:湖南师范大学,2009.]
    [75]WU Anxiang,WANG Xi.Development of ornamental plants multimedia explanation system and application in science popularization tour[J].Tourism Forum,2013,6(1):107-109.[吴安湘,王晞.观赏植物多媒体解说系统开发及其旅游科普应用[J].旅游论坛,2013,6(1):107-109.]
    [76]LI Fengliang.System analysis and implementation of 3D virtual reality:A case study of Tainan Bay Cultural Asset Center in Anping,Tainan City[C]//Li Yanbai.A Proceedings of the Seminar on the Development and Prospect of the Tourism Industry in Local Villages and Towns in Taiwan.Xinbei:Jingwen University of Science and Technology,2004:182-187.[李丰良.3D虚拟实境导览解说系统分析与实作:以台南市安平台湾屋文化资产馆为例[C]//李彦百.台湾地方乡镇观光产业发展与前瞻学术研讨会论文集.新北:景文科技大学,2004:182-187.]
    [77]XU Yixuan.An inquiry on interpretation effects via different digital exhibits in National Museum of Marine Biology and Aquarium:A case of the‘Ancient Ocean Gallery’[J].Science and Technology Museum,2014,18(2):5-37.[许毅璇.国立海洋生物博物馆数位展示解说成效之初探:以“古代海洋”展示为例[J].科技博物,2014,18(2):5-37.]
    [78]YANG Tingting.The effectiveness of an interpretative brochure of the‘Big Cage’of Taipei Zoo[J].Journal of Outdoor Recreation Study,1996,9(1):31-56.[杨婷婷.台北市立动物园大鸟笼解说折页解说效果之探讨[J].户外游憩研究,1996,9(1):31-56.]
    [79]BUHALIS D,LEUNG D,ROB L,et al.Tourism:Critical information and communication technologies for tourism destinations[J].Annals of Tourism Research,2011,29(1):275-277.
    [80]KIM D Y,PARK J,MORRISON A M.A model of traveller acceptance of mobile technology[J].International Journal of Tourism Research,2008,10(5):393-407.
    [81]KANG M,GRETZEL U.Effects of podcast tours on tourist experiences in a national park[J].Tourism Management,2012,33(2):440-455.
    [82]YANG Shunwen.User behavior intention toward interpretation application system[J].Journal of Outdoor Recreation Study,2014,27(3):83-108.[杨舜雯.解说导览APP系统使用行为意象之研究[J].户外游憩研究,2014,27(3):83-108.]
    [83]TAN E,LAW R.mLearning as a softer visitor management approach for sustainable tourism[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2016,24(1):132-152.
    [84]KOUNAVIS C D,KASIMATI A E,ZAMANI E D.Enhancing the tourism experience through mobile augmented reality:Challenges and prospects[J].International Journal of Engineering Business Management,2012,4(10):1-6.
    [85]MOHD N S,ISMAIL H N,HALIM N A.Mobile augmented reality:A tool for effective tourism interpretation in enhancing tourist experience at urban tourism destination[J].Journal Alam Bina,2015,2(3):237-244.
    [86]Moscardo G.Mindful visitors:Heritage and tourism[J].Annals of Tourism Research,1996,23(2):376-397.
    [87]STEWART E J,HAYWARD B M,DEVLIN P J.The‘place’of interpretation:A new approach to the evaluation of interpretation[J].Tourism Management,1998,19(3):257-266.
    [88]CHEN H J,HWANG S N,LEE C.Visitors’characteristics of guided interpretation tours[J].Journal of Business Research,2006,59(10):1167-1181.
    [89]Nielsen K.Approaches to seniors’tourist behaviour[J].Tourism Review,2014,69(2):111-121.
    [90]Ham S,Weiler B.Isolating the role of on-site interpretation in a satisfying experience[J].Journal of Interpretation Research,2007,12(2):5-24.
    [91]WU Zhonghong.Exploring visitors’satisfaction on the interpretive media at Science and Technology Museum[J].Journal of Taichung Teachers College,2004,18(1):159-183.[吴忠宏.游客对解说媒体满意度之研究:以科学工艺博物馆为例[J].台中师院学报,2004,18(1):159-183.]
    [92]JIANG Ning,CHEN Jianmin.Research on the interpretational system of eco-tourist areas from tourist involvement[J].Tourism Forum,2006,17(5):585-587.[江宁,陈建明.从游客涉入角度对生态旅游景区解说系统满意度研究[J].旅游论坛,2006,17(5):585-587.]
    [93]DORFMAN P W.Measurement and meaning of recreation satisfaction[J].Environment&Behavior,1979,11(4):483-510.
    [94]HUANG Shujun.The impact of the level of involvement of interpretive content on visitors’environmental cognition,recreational experience,and satisfaction:A case of fish trail in Yangmingshan Park[J].Journal of Tourism Studies,2003,9(1):79-90.[黄淑君.解说内容之涉入程度对游客之环境认知、游憩体验和满意度之影响:以阳明山公园鱼路古道为例[J].观光研究学报,2003,9(1):79-90.]
    [95]SU Jianjun,WANG Lifang,LI Xiaoli,et al.Empirical study on tourists’satisfaction of the interpretation system in tourist attractions[J].Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2010,38(18):9803-9805.[苏建军,王丽芳,李小丽,等.旅游景区解说系统游客满意度的实证研究:以运城解州关帝庙为例[J].安徽农业科学,2010,38(18):9803-9805.]
    [96]YANG Wenhui.Study on visitors’satisfaction degree with interpretation in guided ecotours[C]//Tourism Health Institute.Proceedings of the Symposium on Tourism and Health.Taipei:Taipei University of Nursing and Health Sciences,2014:128-146.[杨文慧.红树林生态教育馆生态导览解说之满意度研究[C]//旅游健康研究所.旅游与健康学术研讨会论文集.台北:台北护理健康大学,2014:128-146.]
    [97]FALLON L D,KRIWOKEN L K.Community involvement in tourism infrastructure:The case of the Strahan Visitor Centre,Tasmania[J].Tourism Management,2003,24(3):289-308.
    [98]BITGOOD S.Designing effective exhibits:Criteria for success,exhibit design approaches,and research stategies[J].Visitor Behavior,1994,9(4):4-15.
    [99]GUO Jianying.Study on Evaluation of the Scenic Tourism Interpretation System[D].Nanjing:Nanjing Forestry University,2011.[郭剑英.旅游景区旅游解说系统评价研究[D].南京:南京林业大学,2011.]
    [100]PORIA Y,BIRAN A,REICHEL A.Visitors’preferences for interpretation at heritage sites[J].Journal of Travel Research,2009,48(1):92-105.
    [101]WONG C U I.The sanitization of colonial history:Authenticity,heritage interpretation and the case of Macau’s tour guides[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2013,21(6):915-931.
    [102]BALLANTYNE R,HUGHES K,DING P,et al.Chinese and international visitor perceptions of interpretation at Beijing built heritage sites[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2014,22(5):705-725.
    [103]NUNKOO R,RAMKISSOON H,GURSOY D.Use of structural equation modeling in tourism research:Past,present,and future[J].Journal of Travel Research,2013,52(6):759-771.
    [104]SMITH K R,SCARPACI C,SCARR M J,et al.Scuba diving tourism with critically endangered grey nurse sharks(Carcharias taurus)off eastern Australia:Tourist demographics,shark behaviour and diver compliance[J].Tourism Management,2014,45(1):211-225.
    [105]BALLANTYNE R,HUGHES K,LEE J,et al.Visitors’values and environmental learning outcomes at wildlife attractions:Implications for interpretive practice[J].Tourism Management,2018,64(2):190-201.
    [106]PUTNEY A D,WAGAR J A.Objectives and evaluation in interpretive planning[J].The Journal of Environmental Education,1973,5(1):43-44.
    [107]GONCALVES O M F.Interpretation plan of the Jacobean routes in the Barcelos medieval down town(Portugal)[J].International Journal of Management Cases,2013,15(4):170.
    [108]ZHANG Shufu.Introducing the CIS into scenic spots plan[J].Resource Development&Market,2000,16(2):116-118.[张树夫.浅析景区规划的CIS导入[J].资源开发与市场,2000,16(2):116-118.]
    [109]MENG Minghao,YU Yiwu,GU Xiaoyan,et al.Case study of composing interpretation system for tourist attractions[J].Journal of Zhejiang Forestry College,2005,22(5):572-576.[孟明浩,俞益武,顾晓艳,等.旅游景区环境解说系统设计方法及个案探讨[J].浙江农林大学学报,2005,22(5):572-576.]
    [110]LUO Fen,ZHONG Yongde,LI Jian,et al.Subject-oriented tourism interpretation program‘Seven-step Method’[J].Social Scientist,2008,(4):103-105.[罗芬,钟永德,李健,等.主旨导向的旅游解说规划“七步法”[J].社会科学家,2008,(4):103-105.]
    [111]ZHANG Bo.Construction of the humanism tour interpretive services system based on means-end theory[J].Human Geography,2011,(5):143-147.[张波.基于手段-目的理论的人本化旅游解说系统构建[J].人文地理,2011,(5):143-147.]
    [112]YANG Qiang,YANG Zhenzhi.Designed elements research on the self-guided interpretation system:Taking the former residence of DENG Xiaoping as an example[J].Resource Development&Market,2004,20(3):227-228.[杨强,杨振之.自导式解说系统设计要素研究:以邓小平故居景区为例[J].资源开发与市场,2004,20(3):227-228.]
    [113]LIN Mingtai.Geopark illustration system plan and construction[J].Journal of Xi’an University of Architecture&Technology:Social Science Edition,2007,26(2):29-33.[林明太.地质公园解说系统的规划与建设[J].西安建筑科技大学学报:社会科学版,2007,26(2):29-33.]
    [114]LI Lina.Study on the Framework of Tourism Interpretation System in Shennongjia Nature Reserve[D].Beijing:Beijing Forestry University,2008.[李丽娜.神农架自然保护区旅游解说系统构建研究[D].北京:北京林业大学,2008.]
    [115]ZHU Huasheng,FU Jing,WU Junyi.Improvement of tourist interpretation system of China classical garden:A case of the Humble Administrator’s Garden in Suzhou[J].Tourism Forum,2010,3(6):687-691.[朱华晟,付晶,吴骏毅.中国古典园林旅游解说系统改进:以苏州拙政园为例[J].旅游论坛,2010,3(6):687-691.]
    [116]XIAO Guangming.An analysis of the exploitation of tourism products in the nature reserves:Taking the Dinghushan Biological Cycle nature reserve as an example[J].Tourism Tribune,2001,16(3):72-75.[肖光明.自然保护区的旅游产品开发浅析:以鼎湖山生物圈保护区为例[J].旅游学刊,2001,16(3):72-75.]
    [117]LUO Fen,ZHONG Yongde,WU Zhonghong,et al.Tourism interpretive demand of visitors in world natural heritage site:Take Wulingyuan as an example[J].Tourism Tribune,2008,23(8):69-73.[罗芬,钟永德,吴忠宏,等.世界自然遗产地游客旅游解说需求之研究:以湖南武陵源风景名胜区为例[J].旅游学刊,2008,23(8):69-73.]
    [118]ZHU Xuan,ZHU Haisen.The reconstruction of Chinese Natural Heritage interpretation system:Focusing on the education function[J].Areal Research and Development,2011,30(3):134-139.[朱璇,朱海森.国内自然遗产地的解说系统重构:注重启智教育功能开发[J].地域研究与开发,2011,30(3):134-139.]
    [119]PACKER J,BALLANTYNE R,HUGHES K.Chinese and Australian tourists’attitudes to nature,animals and environmental issues:Implications for the design of naturebased tourism experiences[J].Tourism Management,2014,44:101-107.
    [120]HUANG Youjie,ZHANG Yujuan.A study on the establishment of professional competence indicators of interpreters[J].Journal of Sport and Recreation Research,2011,6(4):77-92.[黄有杰,张瑜娟.解说人员专业能力指标建立之研究[J].运动与游憩研究,2011,6(4):77-92.]
    [121]BAI Zongyi.Exploring visitors’satisfaction of interpreter service of tourism factory[J].Journal of Zhongyuan Institute of Physical Education,2015,(7):32-44.[白宗易.观光工厂解说导览人员满意度之探讨[J].中原体育学报,2015,(7):32-44.]
    [122]KUO N T,CHANG K C,CHENG Y S,et al.Effects of tour guide interpretation and tourist satisfaction on destination loyalty in Taiwan.s Kinmen battlefield tourism:Perceived playfulness and perceived flow as moderators[J].Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2016,33(S1):103-122.
    [123]BYUNGGOOK K.The effectiveness of a training program for the self-evaluated job performance of cultural tourism interpreters[J].Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality&Tourism,2014,15(4):382-398.
    [124]BROCKMAN,C F.Park naturalists and the evolution of national park service interpretation through World War II[J].Journal of Forest History,1978,22(1):24-43.
    [125]MACKINTOSH B.The national park service moves into historical interpretation[J].Public Historian,1987,9(2):51-63.
    [126]Homer Wu Homepage.Special lecture section[EB/OL].http://www.ntcu.edu.tw/hcwu/.2014-09-16.[吴忠宏首页.专题讲座信息[EB/OL].http://www.ntcu.edu.tw/hcwu/,2014-09-16.]
    [127]ABLETT P G,DYER P K.Heritage and hermeneutics:Towards a broader interpretation of interpretation[J].Current Issues in Tourism,2009,12(3):209-233.
    [128]PERNCKY T,Jamal T.(Hermeneutic)Phenomenology in tourism studies[J].Annals of Tourism Research,2010,37(4):1055-1075.
    [129]HEALY N,RIPER C J V,BOYD S W.Low versus high intensity approaches to interpretive tourism planning:The case of the Cliffs of Moher,Ireland[J].Tourism Management,2016,52:574-583.
    [130]LIANG Ping,ZHANG Yin.The types of interpretation audiences and their demands based on the use of interpretation:A case study of Beijing Botanical Garden[J].Journal of Beijing Forestry University:Social Sciences Edition,2016,15(1):46-50.[梁萍,张茵.基于信息利用的解说受众类型及解说需求研究:以北京植物园为例[J].北京林业大学学报:社会科学版,2016,15(1):46-50.]
    [131]GAN Lu,LU Tianling.Study on visitors’expectations,use and evaluation to museum interpretation system:An analysis based on knowledge needs[J].Tourism Tribune,2012,27(9):56-64.[甘露,卢天玲.博物馆解说系统的游客期望、使用和评价研究:基于知识需求的分析[J].旅游学刊,2012,27(9):56-64.]
    [132]LUO Yan.Empirical study on tourism interpretation system of Zhouzhuang[J].Resource Development&Market,2008,24(8):753-756.[罗燕.周庄古镇旅游解说系统实证研究[J].资源开发与市场,2008,24(8):753-756.]
    [133]LI Zhenpeng,WANG Min,HE Yaqiong.Study on the establishment of interpretation system in national parks of China[J].Areal Research and Development,2013,32(1):86-91.[李振鹏,王民,何亚琼.我国风景名胜区解说系统构建研究[J].地域研究与开发,2013,32(1):86-91.]
    [134]WANG Ping,LI li,OUYANG Xuelian,et al.The utility factors in building forest park tourism interpretation system:Acontrastive analysis between Chinese and Western recreationists[J].Forestry Economics,2017,(1):57-61.[王屏,栗丽,欧阳雪莲,等.森林公园旅游解说系统构建效用因子研究:基于中西方游憩者比较分析[J].林业经济,2017,(1):57-61.]
    [135]WANG Honggang,TANG Gongzhi.Languages,thinking and comparative studies of Chinese and Western cultures[J].Journal of Shenyang University of Technology:Social Science Edition,2010,3(1):94-96.[王洪刚,唐功志.语言、思维与中西文化比较[J].沈阳工业大学学报:社会科学版,2010,3(1):94-96.]
    [136]ZENG Shen.Tourists’Satisfaction Interpretation Service on Museum Interpreters[D].Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2007.[曾伸.游客对博物馆解说员解说服务满意度研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2007.]
    [137]QIU Yixin.Study of interpretation service quality for tourists loyalty[C]//Leisure and Exercise Studies International Conference:Trends in PE Recreation and Sport Management Conference Journal.Yunlin:Yunlin University of Science and Technology,2013:247-262.[邱怡欣.解说服务品质对游客忠诚度影响之研究[C].2013国际休闲游憩与运动管理发展趋势研讨会专刊.云林:云林科技大学,2013:247-262.]
    [138]ZHAI Baohua.Application of information interaction service in cultural heritage interpretation[C]//Urban Planning Society of China.Proceedings of Urban and Rural Governance and Planning Reform China Urban Planning Annual Conference[C].Haikou:China Architecture&Building Press,2014:1-11.[翟宝华.信息交互服务在文化遗产解说中的应用[C]//中国城市规划学会.城乡治理与规划改革中国城市规划年会论文集.海口:中国建筑工业出版社,2014:1-11.]
    [139]ROJAS C D,CAMARERO C.Visitors’experience,mood and satisfaction in a heritage context:Evidence from an interpretation center[J].Tourism Management,2008,29(3):525-537.
    [140]RONG Na,YUAN Zhengxin.A probe into the influence of tourism interpretation on tourism in ethnic areas:A case study of Xiangxi[J].Modern Business,2014,(20):115-116.[荣娜,袁正新.旅游解说对民族地区旅游业的影响力探究:以湘西为例[J].现代商业,2014,(20):115-116.]
    [141]BUCKLEY R.Evaluating the net effects of ecotourism on the environment:A framework,first assessment and future research[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2009,17(6):643-672.
    [142]WU Yadong.Research on the Construction of Eco-tourism Area Environmental Interpretation System Based on Environmental Education Function[D].Beijing:Beijing Jiaotong University,2010.[吴亚东.基于环境教育功能的生态旅游区环境解说系统构建研究[D].北京:北京交通大学,2010.]
    [143]BALLANTYNE R,PACKER J,HUGHES K.Environmental awareness,interests and motives of botanic gardens visitors:Implications for interpretive practice[J].Tourism Management,2008,29(3):439-444.
    [144]WEILER B,SMITH L.Does more interpretation lead to greater outcomes?An assessment of the impacts of multiple layers of interpretation in a zoo context[J].Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2009,17(1):91-105.
    [145]LIU Lihua,HE Jun.Construction of museum interpretation system based on visitor management Perspective[J].Museum Research,2009,(1):11-15.[刘丽华,何军.基于游客管理视角的博物馆解说系统构建[J].博物馆研究,2009,(1):11-15.]
    [146]LYNGDOH S,MATHUR V B,SINHA B C.Tigers,tourists and wildlife:Visitor demographics and experience in three Indian tiger reserves[J].Biodiversity&Conservation,2017,26(9):2187-2204.
    [147]DAI Youde,LIN Weirong,CHEN Guanyang.Does nostalgia emotion need authenticity in heritage tourism?Also on the moderating role of interpretation service[J].Journal of Outdoor Recreation Study,2010,23(3):61-86.[戴有德,林潍榕,陈冠仰.袭产观光中的怀旧情感是否需要真实性?兼论解说之调节角色[J].户外游憩研究,2010,23(3):61-86.]
    [148]PAN Zhiqiang,Liang Baoer.The influence function of the effects of signage interpretative validity on tourists’place identity and place loyalty:A case study of Shanghai’s historic district[J].Tourism Tribune,2016,31(4):97-108.[潘植强,梁保尔.标识牌解说效度对游客地方认同感和忠诚度的影响作用-以上海历史街区为例[J].旅游学刊,2016,31(4):97-108.]
    [149]BALLANTYNE R,PACHER J,SUTHERLAND L A.Visitors’memories of wildlife tourism:Implications for the design of powerful interpretive experiences[J].Tourism Management,2011,32(4):770-779.
    (1)图中作者对应文献:服务(曾伸[136]、邱怡欣[137]、翟宝华[138]、Ham等[90]、Rojas等[139]),经济(王雅俞[41]、陈宽裕等[42]、荣娜等[140]、崔向天[44]、Buckley[141]),教育(吴亚东[142]、朱璇等[118]、甘露等[131]、王辉等[37]、Ballantyne等[143]、Weiler等[144]、Hughes等[52]、Jacobs等[49]、Apps等[46]),管理(刘丽华等[145]、Ballantyne等[35]、Kim等[80]、Delgado等[47]、Ababneh等[33]、Lyngdoh等[146]),情感(戴有德等[147]、潘植强等[148]、Wight等[50]、Ballantyne等[149]、Wijeratne等[55]、Kuo等[122]、Moscardo[36]、Walker等[53]、Apps等[12])。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700