相关性判据与目标信息类型的关系分析
|
摘要
[目的/意义]相关性具有多维性,任何一个维度的改变都会对相关性判据产生相应的影响,目标信息类型是相关性概念诸多维度之一,然而二者之间缺乏足够数据的研究和相应的判断与解释。[方法/过程]通过对1990年以来文献的纵向分析和比较,描述了目标信息类型对相关性判断研究焦点以及研究成果存在影响的现象,提出了相关性判据研究受到目标信息类型变迁驱动,相关性判据集合呈现以文本相关性判据为主体、以目标信息相关的特异性判据为补充的整体结构。[结果/结论]研究提出了下一步相关性判据研究宜充分考虑数据已经成为主流目标信息类型的情况,同时应更重视相关性判据集合存在的跨目标信息类型的共性判据与目标信息类型相关的特异性判据两个子集合的情况。
[Purpose/Significance]Relevance is multidimensional. The change of any dimension will have a corresponding impact on the relevance criteria. Target imformation type is one of the dimensions of the relevance. However the study on the relationship between them lacks of enough data and the corresponding interpretation.[Method/Process]Through the longitudinal analysis and comparison of the related papers since 1990,we describe the influence of target information types on relevance judgment research focus and results. Then we put forward that relevance criteria reseach is driven by target information type,the overall structure of the relevance criteria set is characterized by literature relevance criteria as the main component,and the specific criteria related to target information as supplementary.[Result/Conclusion]The further research should give full consideration to the situation that data has become a main target information type,and should pay more attention to the common criteria across different target information types and the specific criteria which are related with the target information types.
[Purpose/Significance]Relevance is multidimensional. The change of any dimension will have a corresponding impact on the relevance criteria. Target imformation type is one of the dimensions of the relevance. However the study on the relationship between them lacks of enough data and the corresponding interpretation.[Method/Process]Through the longitudinal analysis and comparison of the related papers since 1990,we describe the influence of target information types on relevance judgment research focus and results. Then we put forward that relevance criteria reseach is driven by target information type,the overall structure of the relevance criteria set is characterized by literature relevance criteria as the main component,and the specific criteria related to target information as supplementary.[Result/Conclusion]The further research should give full consideration to the situation that data has become a main target information type,and should pay more attention to the common criteria across different target information types and the specific criteria which are related with the target information types.
引文
[1]Saracevic T.Why is relevance still the basic notion in information science?[M].M organ&Claypool Publishers,2010.
[2]Ingwersen P,Jrvelin K.The turn:Integration of information seeking and retrieval in context[M].Springer Publishing Company,Incorporated,2011.
[3]Barry,Carol L.User-defined relevance criteria:an exploratory study[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1994,45(3):149-159.
[4]Barry C L,Schamber L.Users'criteria for relevance evaluation:A cross-situational comparison[J].Information Processing&M anagenent.1998,34(2):219-236
[5]Burton V T,Chadwick S A.Investigating the practices of student researchers:patterns of use and criteria for use of internet and library sources[J].Computers&Composition 2000,17(3):309-328.
[6]Savolainen R,Kari J.User-defined relevance criteria in web searching[J].Journal of Documentation,2006,62(6):685-707.
[7]Rieh S Y.Judgment of information quality and cognitive authority in the Web[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2002,53(2):145-161.
[8]Hamid R,Thom J.Criteria that have an effect on users while making image relevance judgments[C].In Fifteenth Australasian Document Computing Symposium,School of Computer Science and IT,RM IT University,2010:8.
[9]Sedghi S,Sanderson M.Clough P.A study on the relevance criteria for medical images[J].Pattern Recognitiong Letters,2008,29(15):2046-2057.
[10]Sedghi S,Sanderson M,Clough P.Medical image resources used by health care professionals[J].Aslib Proceedings,2013,63(6):570-585.
[11]Sedghi S,Sanderson M,Clough P.How do health care professionals select medical images they need[J].Aslib Proceedings,2012,64(4):437-456
[12]成颖.相关性判据研究综述(2000-2010)[J].情报杂志,2011,30(9):79-84.
[13]Schamber L.Users'criteria for evaluation in a multimedia environment[C].In Asis M eeting,1991:126-133
[14]王健,王志强,刘茜,等.认知转向背景下用户相关性判断研究的方法论观察[J].图书情报工作,2014,58(18):66-76.
[15]Park T K.The Nature of Relevance in Information Retrieval:An Empirical Study[J].Library Quarterly,1993,63(3):318-351.
[16]Park H.Relevance of science information:origins and dimensions of relevance and their implications to information retrieval[J].Information Processing&M anagement,1997,33(3):339-352.
[17]Cool C,Belkin N J,Frieder O,et al.Characteristics of text affecting relevance judgments[J].Automotive New s,1993,17(4):77-84.
[18]Barry C L.The identification of user criteria and document characteristics:Beyond the topical approach to information retrieval[J].School of Information Studies:Dissertations,1993:42.
[19]Barry C L.A preliminary examination of clues to relevance criteria w ithin document representations[J].Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,1993,30(1):81-86.
[20]Barry C L.Document representations and clues to document relevance[J].Journal of American Society for Information Science,1998,49(14):1293-1303
[21]Wang P,Soergel D.A cognitive model of document use during a research project.studyⅠdocument selection.[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1998,49(2):115-133.
[22]Wang P,White M D.A cognitive model of document use during a research project.studyⅡdecisions at the reading and citing stages[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1999,50(2):98-114.
[23]Schamber L,Bateman J.User criteria in relevance evaluation:Tow ard development of a measurement scale[C]//Asis M eeting,1996:218-225.
[24]Westbrook L.Faculty relevance criteria:Internalized user needs[J].Library Trends,2001,50(2):197-206.
[25]Taylor A R,Cool C,Belkin N J,et al.Relationships between categories of relevance criteria and stage in task completion[J].Information Processing&M anagement an International Journal,2007,43(4):1071-1084.
[26]Taylor A.Relevance criterion choices in relation to search progress[J].Dissertations&Theses-Gradw orks,2009,26:203-208.
[27]Taylor A.User relevance criteria choices and the information search process[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2012,48(1):136-153.
[28]Taylor A.Examination of work task and criteria choices for the relevance judgment process[J].Journal of Documentation,2013,69(4):523-544.
[29]Xu Y,Yin H.Novelty and topicality in interactive information retrieval[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2008,59(2):201-215.
[30]Tombros A,Ruthven I,Jose J M.Searchers'criteria For assessing w eb pages[C]//International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Informaion Retrieval.ACM,2003:385-386.
[31]Crystal A,Greenberg J.Relevance criteria identified by health information users during Web searches[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2006,57(10):1368-1382.
[32]Mizzaro S.Relevance:The whole history[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1997,48(9):810-832.
[33]Savolainen R.Source preferences in the context of seeking problem-specific information[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2008,44(1):274-293.
[34]Papaeconomou C,Zijlema A F,Ingwersen P.Searchers'relevance judgments and criteria in evaluating w eb pages in a learning style perspective[C]//International Symposium on Information Interaction in Context.ACM,2008:123-132.
[35]Balatsoukas P,Ruthven I.What eyes can tell about the use of relevance criteria during predictive relevance judgment?[C]//Symposium on Information Interaction in Context.ACM,2010:389-394.
[36]Balatsoukas P,Ruthven I.The use of relevance criteria during predictive judgment:An eye tracking approach[J].Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2010,47(1):1-10.
[37]Balatsoukas P,Ruthven I.An eye-tracking approach to the analysis of relevance judgments on the Web:The case of Google search engine[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2012,63(9):1728-1746.
[38]Park Y K S.User-based Relevance and Irrelevance Criteria during the Task Pursuing of M iddle School Students[J].,2014,48(3).
[39]Markkula M,Sormunen E.End-user searching challenges indexing practices inthe digital new spaper photo archive[J].Information Retrieval,2000,1(4):259-285.
[40]Choi Y,Rasmussen E M.User's relevance criteria in image retrieval in American history[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2002,38(5):695-726.
[41]Hung T,Zoeller C.Lyon S.Relevance judgments for image retrieval in the field of journalism:A pilot study[J].Digital Libraries:Implementing Strategies and Sharing Experiences,Proceedings 2005,3815(3):72-80.
[42]Awang H R A T J A I D.Effects of relevance criteria and subjective factors on w eb image searching behavior[J].Journal of Information Science 2016,43(6):786-800.
[43]Laplante A.Users'relevance criteria in music retrieval in everyday life:An exploratory study[C]//International Society for M usic Information Retrieval Conference,Ismir 2010,Utrecht,Netherlands,August.DBLP,2012:601-606.
[44]Inskip C,Macfarlane A,Rafferty P.Creative professional users'musical relevance criteria[J].Journal of Information Science.2010,36(4):517-529.
[45]Hirsh S G.Children's relevance criteria and information-seeking on electronic resources[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1999,50(14):1265-1283.
[46]黄莺,面向用户的检索相关性判断中主要判据的应用研究[J].人才资源开发,2015(14):137-138.
[47]Yang M,Marchionini G.Exploring users'video relevance criteria—A pilot study[J].Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2010,41(1):229-238.
[48]Choi Y,Rasmussen E M.User's relevance criteria in image retrieval in American history[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2002,38(5):695-726.
[49]Tombros A,Ruthven I,Jose J M.How users assess Web pages for information seeking[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2005,56(4):327-344.
[50]Ferguson L E,Brten I,StrmsH I.Epistemic cognition when students read multiple documents containing conflicting scientific evidence:A think-aloud study[J].Learning&Instruction 2012,22(2):103-120.
[51]尹湘舟.面向Web图片检索的文本和图片信息融合技术研究[D].湘潭:湘潭大学,2009
[52]林丰芬.在多媒体情境下,图片和策略文字对英语词汇学习的影响[D].福州:福建师范大学,2009.
[53]高飞,石蕾,王健,等.农业科学数据用户相关性线索与标准之间关系探索[J].图书情报工作,2017(15):72-80.
[2]Ingwersen P,Jrvelin K.The turn:Integration of information seeking and retrieval in context[M].Springer Publishing Company,Incorporated,2011.
[3]Barry,Carol L.User-defined relevance criteria:an exploratory study[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1994,45(3):149-159.
[4]Barry C L,Schamber L.Users'criteria for relevance evaluation:A cross-situational comparison[J].Information Processing&M anagenent.1998,34(2):219-236
[5]Burton V T,Chadwick S A.Investigating the practices of student researchers:patterns of use and criteria for use of internet and library sources[J].Computers&Composition 2000,17(3):309-328.
[6]Savolainen R,Kari J.User-defined relevance criteria in web searching[J].Journal of Documentation,2006,62(6):685-707.
[7]Rieh S Y.Judgment of information quality and cognitive authority in the Web[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2002,53(2):145-161.
[8]Hamid R,Thom J.Criteria that have an effect on users while making image relevance judgments[C].In Fifteenth Australasian Document Computing Symposium,School of Computer Science and IT,RM IT University,2010:8.
[9]Sedghi S,Sanderson M.Clough P.A study on the relevance criteria for medical images[J].Pattern Recognitiong Letters,2008,29(15):2046-2057.
[10]Sedghi S,Sanderson M,Clough P.Medical image resources used by health care professionals[J].Aslib Proceedings,2013,63(6):570-585.
[11]Sedghi S,Sanderson M,Clough P.How do health care professionals select medical images they need[J].Aslib Proceedings,2012,64(4):437-456
[12]成颖.相关性判据研究综述(2000-2010)[J].情报杂志,2011,30(9):79-84.
[13]Schamber L.Users'criteria for evaluation in a multimedia environment[C].In Asis M eeting,1991:126-133
[14]王健,王志强,刘茜,等.认知转向背景下用户相关性判断研究的方法论观察[J].图书情报工作,2014,58(18):66-76.
[15]Park T K.The Nature of Relevance in Information Retrieval:An Empirical Study[J].Library Quarterly,1993,63(3):318-351.
[16]Park H.Relevance of science information:origins and dimensions of relevance and their implications to information retrieval[J].Information Processing&M anagement,1997,33(3):339-352.
[17]Cool C,Belkin N J,Frieder O,et al.Characteristics of text affecting relevance judgments[J].Automotive New s,1993,17(4):77-84.
[18]Barry C L.The identification of user criteria and document characteristics:Beyond the topical approach to information retrieval[J].School of Information Studies:Dissertations,1993:42.
[19]Barry C L.A preliminary examination of clues to relevance criteria w ithin document representations[J].Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,1993,30(1):81-86.
[20]Barry C L.Document representations and clues to document relevance[J].Journal of American Society for Information Science,1998,49(14):1293-1303
[21]Wang P,Soergel D.A cognitive model of document use during a research project.studyⅠdocument selection.[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1998,49(2):115-133.
[22]Wang P,White M D.A cognitive model of document use during a research project.studyⅡdecisions at the reading and citing stages[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1999,50(2):98-114.
[23]Schamber L,Bateman J.User criteria in relevance evaluation:Tow ard development of a measurement scale[C]//Asis M eeting,1996:218-225.
[24]Westbrook L.Faculty relevance criteria:Internalized user needs[J].Library Trends,2001,50(2):197-206.
[25]Taylor A R,Cool C,Belkin N J,et al.Relationships between categories of relevance criteria and stage in task completion[J].Information Processing&M anagement an International Journal,2007,43(4):1071-1084.
[26]Taylor A.Relevance criterion choices in relation to search progress[J].Dissertations&Theses-Gradw orks,2009,26:203-208.
[27]Taylor A.User relevance criteria choices and the information search process[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2012,48(1):136-153.
[28]Taylor A.Examination of work task and criteria choices for the relevance judgment process[J].Journal of Documentation,2013,69(4):523-544.
[29]Xu Y,Yin H.Novelty and topicality in interactive information retrieval[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2008,59(2):201-215.
[30]Tombros A,Ruthven I,Jose J M.Searchers'criteria For assessing w eb pages[C]//International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Informaion Retrieval.ACM,2003:385-386.
[31]Crystal A,Greenberg J.Relevance criteria identified by health information users during Web searches[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2006,57(10):1368-1382.
[32]Mizzaro S.Relevance:The whole history[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1997,48(9):810-832.
[33]Savolainen R.Source preferences in the context of seeking problem-specific information[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2008,44(1):274-293.
[34]Papaeconomou C,Zijlema A F,Ingwersen P.Searchers'relevance judgments and criteria in evaluating w eb pages in a learning style perspective[C]//International Symposium on Information Interaction in Context.ACM,2008:123-132.
[35]Balatsoukas P,Ruthven I.What eyes can tell about the use of relevance criteria during predictive relevance judgment?[C]//Symposium on Information Interaction in Context.ACM,2010:389-394.
[36]Balatsoukas P,Ruthven I.The use of relevance criteria during predictive judgment:An eye tracking approach[J].Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2010,47(1):1-10.
[37]Balatsoukas P,Ruthven I.An eye-tracking approach to the analysis of relevance judgments on the Web:The case of Google search engine[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2012,63(9):1728-1746.
[38]Park Y K S.User-based Relevance and Irrelevance Criteria during the Task Pursuing of M iddle School Students[J].,2014,48(3).
[39]Markkula M,Sormunen E.End-user searching challenges indexing practices inthe digital new spaper photo archive[J].Information Retrieval,2000,1(4):259-285.
[40]Choi Y,Rasmussen E M.User's relevance criteria in image retrieval in American history[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2002,38(5):695-726.
[41]Hung T,Zoeller C.Lyon S.Relevance judgments for image retrieval in the field of journalism:A pilot study[J].Digital Libraries:Implementing Strategies and Sharing Experiences,Proceedings 2005,3815(3):72-80.
[42]Awang H R A T J A I D.Effects of relevance criteria and subjective factors on w eb image searching behavior[J].Journal of Information Science 2016,43(6):786-800.
[43]Laplante A.Users'relevance criteria in music retrieval in everyday life:An exploratory study[C]//International Society for M usic Information Retrieval Conference,Ismir 2010,Utrecht,Netherlands,August.DBLP,2012:601-606.
[44]Inskip C,Macfarlane A,Rafferty P.Creative professional users'musical relevance criteria[J].Journal of Information Science.2010,36(4):517-529.
[45]Hirsh S G.Children's relevance criteria and information-seeking on electronic resources[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,1999,50(14):1265-1283.
[46]黄莺,面向用户的检索相关性判断中主要判据的应用研究[J].人才资源开发,2015(14):137-138.
[47]Yang M,Marchionini G.Exploring users'video relevance criteria—A pilot study[J].Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2010,41(1):229-238.
[48]Choi Y,Rasmussen E M.User's relevance criteria in image retrieval in American history[J].Information Processing&M anagement,2002,38(5):695-726.
[49]Tombros A,Ruthven I,Jose J M.How users assess Web pages for information seeking[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2005,56(4):327-344.
[50]Ferguson L E,Brten I,StrmsH I.Epistemic cognition when students read multiple documents containing conflicting scientific evidence:A think-aloud study[J].Learning&Instruction 2012,22(2):103-120.
[51]尹湘舟.面向Web图片检索的文本和图片信息融合技术研究[D].湘潭:湘潭大学,2009
[52]林丰芬.在多媒体情境下,图片和策略文字对英语词汇学习的影响[D].福州:福建师范大学,2009.
[53]高飞,石蕾,王健,等.农业科学数据用户相关性线索与标准之间关系探索[J].图书情报工作,2017(15):72-80.