东北三省城市土地利用效益评价及耦合协调关系研究
|
摘要
在阐述城市土地利用效益系统耦合协调性内涵及其交互作用机理的基础上,构建综合评价指标体系,运用均方差决策法、耦合协调度模型,对东北三省2003～2015年城市土地利用综合效益及其主成分间耦合协调关系进行测度,并分析其时空演化过程。研究认为:①城市土地利用综合效益表现出随时间"先升后降"的特征,区内三省间差异明显,中心和门户城市长期处于较高水平。②城市土地利用经济效益亦存在"先升后降"的时序变化特征,空间上表现为"南高北低",低值区范围缩减明显;社会效益差异不显著,在南北方向上表现出"凸"字型分布特征;区域生态环境效益整体较高,高值区由集中趋向分散。③城市土地利用经济、社会、生态环境效益间耦合协调关系在各时间节点均表现为失调,且以中度失调为主,但中心城市和门户城市的三效益耦合协调关系相对较好,向协调方向发展,哈长与辽中南城市群地区协调性优于其他区域,吉林省与辽宁省东部的部分城市协调关系趋向恶化。④城市土地利用效益间关系失调主要受复合因素的作用,经济效益滞后是制约土地利用效益耦合协调关系提升的主因,生态环境效益滞后不是限制土地利用效益耦合协调性提升的主要因素。
On the basis of the exposition to the coupling coordination connotation and interaction mechanism,we build a comprehensive evaluation index system, using the mean square deviation decision, coupling coordination degree model to measure the comprehensive urban land use efficiency in the three provinces of Northeast China, Heilongjiang, Jilin and Liaoning from 2003 to 2015 and analyses its spatio-temporal evolution process. The study found that: 1) The comprehensive efficiency of urban land use show the characteristics of‘first up, then down', and there are clearly difference between the three provinces. Besides, the center and the gateway city has long been at a higher level. 2) The change of the urban land utilization economic efficiency are similarity with the comprehensive efficiency, on the space, the low range is reduced obviously; the differences of social efficiency are not significant, but also showed a‘convex'word distribution on the space; the overall regional ecological and environmental efficiency is on a higher level, the high value area are changed from concentrated to disperse. 3) The economic, social and ecological environment of the urban land utilization efficiency in the coupling coordination relations between time nodes are characterized by disturbance, and give priority to moderate disorders, but the coupling coordination of different efficiency in center and the gateway city are relatively good and developing in a coordinated direction. Besides, Ha-Chang and the Mid-southern of Liaoning Province is better than that of other regions; 4) The imbalance relationship between urban land use efficiency is mainly affected by complex factors. Lagging of economic benefit is the main reason restricting the improvement of coupling and coordination relation of land use efficiency. The research results show that the current coupling coordination relationship between economic, social and ecological environment efficiency in northeast China is still in the stage of disorder. As a result, It has become the inevitable choice to promote urban land use system coordinated development of economy, society and ecological environmental efficiency in the process of future land use in northeast China. In this process, different types of region should form their own targeted path. For the full lagging region, the most important thing is to improve the economic efficiency of land use through the upgrading of industrial structure, which will increase the social efficiency and ecological efficiency. The social efficiency lagging region should strengthen the intensive use of limited construction land and enhance the level of infrastructure construction to improve urban internal conditions; The economic and social efficiency lagging regions should focus on strengthening the development of continuous industry and the industrial cooperation with the central city. For the other cities, promote clean production and circular economy, strengthen the ability of the central region agglomeration are the important ways to promote urban land use economic benefits.
On the basis of the exposition to the coupling coordination connotation and interaction mechanism,we build a comprehensive evaluation index system, using the mean square deviation decision, coupling coordination degree model to measure the comprehensive urban land use efficiency in the three provinces of Northeast China, Heilongjiang, Jilin and Liaoning from 2003 to 2015 and analyses its spatio-temporal evolution process. The study found that: 1) The comprehensive efficiency of urban land use show the characteristics of‘first up, then down', and there are clearly difference between the three provinces. Besides, the center and the gateway city has long been at a higher level. 2) The change of the urban land utilization economic efficiency are similarity with the comprehensive efficiency, on the space, the low range is reduced obviously; the differences of social efficiency are not significant, but also showed a‘convex'word distribution on the space; the overall regional ecological and environmental efficiency is on a higher level, the high value area are changed from concentrated to disperse. 3) The economic, social and ecological environment of the urban land utilization efficiency in the coupling coordination relations between time nodes are characterized by disturbance, and give priority to moderate disorders, but the coupling coordination of different efficiency in center and the gateway city are relatively good and developing in a coordinated direction. Besides, Ha-Chang and the Mid-southern of Liaoning Province is better than that of other regions; 4) The imbalance relationship between urban land use efficiency is mainly affected by complex factors. Lagging of economic benefit is the main reason restricting the improvement of coupling and coordination relation of land use efficiency. The research results show that the current coupling coordination relationship between economic, social and ecological environment efficiency in northeast China is still in the stage of disorder. As a result, It has become the inevitable choice to promote urban land use system coordinated development of economy, society and ecological environmental efficiency in the process of future land use in northeast China. In this process, different types of region should form their own targeted path. For the full lagging region, the most important thing is to improve the economic efficiency of land use through the upgrading of industrial structure, which will increase the social efficiency and ecological efficiency. The social efficiency lagging region should strengthen the intensive use of limited construction land and enhance the level of infrastructure construction to improve urban internal conditions; The economic and social efficiency lagging regions should focus on strengthening the development of continuous industry and the industrial cooperation with the central city. For the other cities, promote clean production and circular economy, strengthen the ability of the central region agglomeration are the important ways to promote urban land use economic benefits.
引文
[1]宋戈,高楠.基于DEA方法的城市土地利用经济效益分析--以哈尔滨市为例[J].地理科学,2008,28(2):185-188.[Song Ge,Gao Nan.Economic benefit analysis of urban land utilization based on DEA method-A case of Harbin in city.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2008,28(2):185-188.]
[2]陈士银,陈爱珠,周飞.区域土地利用的社会效益及其时空特征研究[J].资源开发与市场,2008,24(11):975-978.[Chen Shiyin,Chen Aizhu,Zhou Fei.Study on social benefit of regional land-use and its space-time characters.Resource Development&Market,2008,24(11):975-978.]
[3]朱珠,张琳,叶晓雯,等.基于TOPSIS方法的土地利用综合效益评价[J].经济地理,2012,32(10):139-144.[Zhu Zhu,Zhang Lin,Ye Xiaowen et al.Evaluation of comprehensive land use efficiency based on TOPSIS.Economic Geography,2012,32(10):139-144.]
[4]刘畅,师学义,梁旭琴,等.基于物元模型的资源型城市土地利用效益动态评价研究[J].水土保持研究,2015,22(4):122-126.[Liu Chang,Shi Xueyi,Liang Xuqin et al.Research on dynamic assessment of land use benefits of resource-typed city based on Matter Element Model.Research of Soil and Water Conservation,2015,22(4):122-126.]
[5]贾琦,运迎霞,尹泽凯.城市群土地利用效益与城镇化水平的时空耦合分析--我国三大城市群的实证分析[J].现代城市研究,2014,(08):9-13.[Jia Qi,Yun Yingxia,Yin Zekai.Spatial and temporal coupling analysis of land use efficiency and urbanization level of city-regions-An empirical study of three big city-regions in China.Modern Urban Research,2014,(08):9-13.]
[6]史坤博,杨永春,张伟芳,等.城市土地利用效益与城市化耦合协调发展研究--以武威市凉州区为例[J].干旱区研究,2016,33(3):655-663.[Shi Kunbo,Yang Yongchun,Zhang Weifang et al.Coupling mechanism between urban land use benefits and urbanization in the Shiyang River Basin:A case study in Liangzhou Wuwei.Arid Zone Research,2016,33(3):655-663.]
[7]张明斗,莫冬燕.城市土地利甩效益与城市化的耦合协调性分析--以东北三省34个地级市为例[J].资源科学,2014,36(1):8-16.[Zhang Mingdou,Mo Dongyan.Coupling coordination degree of urban land use benefitand urbanization.Resources Science,2014,36(1):8-16.]
[8]刘善开,韦素琼,高月华,等.基于耦合模型的城市土地集约利用与城市化协调发展研究--以福建省9个设区市为例[J].福建师范大学学报:自然科学版,2015,31(2):96-105.[Liu Shankai,Wei Suqiong,Gao Yuehua et al.Study on the coordinative development between urban land intensive utilization and urbanization based on coupling model-A case study of 9 cities districts in Fujian Province.Journal of Fujian Normal University(Natural Science Edition),2015,31(2):96-105.]
[9]白硕,杨永春,史坤博,等.中国西部河谷型城市土地利用效益与城市化耦合协调发展研究[J].世界地理研究,2016,25(6):87-95.[Bai Shuo,Yang Yongchun,Shi Kunbo et al.The research on the coupling and coordination development between urban land use benefits and urbanization of valley city in western China.World Regional Studies,2016,25(6):87-95.]
[10]梁红梅,刘卫东,刘会平,等.土地利用社会经济效益与生态环境效益的耦合关系--以深圳市和宁波市为例[J].中国土地科学,2008,22(2):42-48.[Liang Hongmei,Liu Weidong,Liu Huiping et al.Coupling relationship between social economic benefit and ecological benefit of land use:A case study of Shenzhen and Ningbo.China Land Science,2008,22(2):42-48.]
[11]梁红梅,刘卫东,刘会平,等.深圳市土地利用社会经济效益与生态环境效益的耦合关系研究[J].地理科学,2008,28(5):636-641.[Liang Hongmei,Liu Weidong,Liu Huiping et al.Coupling relationship between social economic benefit and ecological benefit of land use in Shenzhen City.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2008,28(5):636-641.]
[12]曹堪宏,朱宏伟.基于耦合关系的土地利用效益评价--以广州和深圳为例[J].中国农村经济,2010(8):58-66.[Cao Kanhong,Zhu Hongwei.The study on evaluation of land use efficiency:Guangzhou and Shenzhen cases study.Chinese Rural Economy,2010(8):58-66.]
[13]仇娟东,赵景峰,吴建树.基于耦合关系的中国区域土地利用效益水平测度[J].中国人口资源与环境,2012,22(1):103-110.[Qiu Juandong,Zhao Jingfeng,Wu jianshu.Measurement on the benefits of regional land use in China based on coupling relationship.China Population Resources and Environment,2012,22(1):103-110.]
[14]王国刚,刘彦随,方方.环渤海地区土地利用效益综合测度及空间分异[J].地理科学进展,2013,32(4):649-656.[Wang Guogang,Liu Yansui,Fang Fang.Comprehensive evaluation and spatial distinction of land use efficiency around Bohai Rim in China.Progress in geography,2013,32(4):649-656.]
[15]倪维秋.中国三大城市群城市土地利用经济,社会,生态效益的耦合协调性及其空间格局[J].城市发展研究,2016,23(12):69-77.[Ni Weiqiu.The coupling and coordination relationship and their spatial pateern of urban land use economic,social and ecological benefits of cities in three largest urban agglomerations in China.Urban Studies,2016,23(12):69-77.]
[16]宋成舜,谈兵,韩冰华,等.基于变异系数TOPSIS法的土地利用效益测度研究--以武汉城市圈为例[J].水土保持研究,2015,22(01):286-291.[Song Chengshun,Tan Bing,Han Binghua et al.Comprehensive evaluation of land use benefits based on the variance coefficient topsis method in Wuhan Metropolitan Area.Res Soil Water Conserv.,2015,22(1):286-291.]
[17]郭付友,李诚固,陈才,等.2003年以来东北地区人口城镇化与土地城镇化时空耦合特征[J].经济地理,2015,35(9):49-56.[Guo Fuyou,Li Chenggu,Chen Cai et al.Spatial-temporal coupling characteristics of population urbanization and land urbanization in Northeast China.Economic Geography,2015,35(9):49-56.]
[18]梁红梅,刘卫东,林育欣,等.土地利用效益的耦合模型及其应用[J].浙江大学学报(农业与生命科学版),2008,34(02):230-236.[Liang Hongmei,Liu Weidong,Lin Yuxin et al.Coupling model of land use benefits and its application.Journal of Zhejiang University(Agric.&LifeSci.),2008,34(2):230-236]
[19]国家统计局.中国城市统计年鉴[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2003-2016.[National Bureau of Statistics of China.China City statistical yearbook.Beijing:China Statistics Press,2003-2016.]
[20]龙冬平,李同昇,于正松,等.基于微观视角的乡村发展水平评价及机理分析--以城乡统筹示范区陕西省高陵县为例[J].经济地理,2013,33(11):115-120.[Long Dongping,Li Tongsheng,Yu Zhengsong et al.Assessment of rural development level and mechanism analysis based on microperspective-A case study of the demonstration area of urban-rural intergrationin Gaoling County of Shaanxi Province.Economic Geography,2013,33(11):115-120.]
[21]张旺,周跃云,胡光伟.超大城市“新三化”的时空耦合协调性分析--以中国十大城市为例[J].地理科学,2016,33(5):562-569.[Zhang Wang,Zhou Yueyun,Hu Guangwei.Coupling mechanism and space-time coordination of new-approach urbanization,new-approach industrialization and service industry modernization in megacity behemoths:a case study of ten cities in China.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2016,33(5):562-569.]
[22]Valerie Illingworth.The penguin dictionary of physics[M].Beijing:Foreign Language Press,1996:92-93.
[23]廖重斌.环境与经济协调发展的定量评判及其分类体系--以珠江三角洲城市群为例[J].热带地理,1999,19(2):171-177.[Liao Chongbin.Quantitaitve judgement and classification system for coordinated development of environment and economy-A case study of the city group in the Pearl River Delta.Tropical Geography,1999,19(2):171-177.]
[24]黄悦,李秋雨,梅林,等.东北地区资源型城市资源诅咒效应及传导机制研究[J].人文地理,2015,30(6):121-125.[Huang Yue,Li Qiuyu,Mei Lin et al.Resource curse effect and transmission mechanism ofresource-Based cities in Northeast China.Human Geography,2015,30(6):121-125.]
[25]刘艳军,田俊峰,付占辉,等.哈大巨型城市带要素集聚程度与生态环境水平关系演变[J].地理科学,2017,37(2):172-180.[Liu Yanjun,Tian Junfeng,Fu Zhanhui et al.The evolution of the relationship between the degree of element agglomeration and the level of the ecological environment in the Harbin-Dalian Giant Urban Belt.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2017,37(2):172-180.]
[26]孙斌栋,李琬.城市规模分布的经济绩效--基于中国市域数据的实证研究[J].地理科学,2016,36(3):328-334.[Sun Bindong,Li Wan.City size distribution and economic performance:evidence from city-regions in China.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2016,36(3):328-334.]
[27]孙平军.中国城市建设用地空间扩展的非协调性识别与调控[D].长春:东北师范大学,2014.[Sun Pingjun.The identification and regulation of non-coordination in China’s urban spatial expansion.Changchun:Northeast Normal University,2014.]
[28]陈岗,雷磊,邹华.辽中南城市群城市竞争力综合评价与时间演变分析[J].地域研究与开发,2013,32(1):52-55.[Chen Gang,Lei Lei,Zou Hua.Analysis of comprehensive evaluation of urban competitiveness and temporal evolution in mid-southern urban agglomerations of Liaoning Province.2013,32(1):52-55.]
[2]陈士银,陈爱珠,周飞.区域土地利用的社会效益及其时空特征研究[J].资源开发与市场,2008,24(11):975-978.[Chen Shiyin,Chen Aizhu,Zhou Fei.Study on social benefit of regional land-use and its space-time characters.Resource Development&Market,2008,24(11):975-978.]
[3]朱珠,张琳,叶晓雯,等.基于TOPSIS方法的土地利用综合效益评价[J].经济地理,2012,32(10):139-144.[Zhu Zhu,Zhang Lin,Ye Xiaowen et al.Evaluation of comprehensive land use efficiency based on TOPSIS.Economic Geography,2012,32(10):139-144.]
[4]刘畅,师学义,梁旭琴,等.基于物元模型的资源型城市土地利用效益动态评价研究[J].水土保持研究,2015,22(4):122-126.[Liu Chang,Shi Xueyi,Liang Xuqin et al.Research on dynamic assessment of land use benefits of resource-typed city based on Matter Element Model.Research of Soil and Water Conservation,2015,22(4):122-126.]
[5]贾琦,运迎霞,尹泽凯.城市群土地利用效益与城镇化水平的时空耦合分析--我国三大城市群的实证分析[J].现代城市研究,2014,(08):9-13.[Jia Qi,Yun Yingxia,Yin Zekai.Spatial and temporal coupling analysis of land use efficiency and urbanization level of city-regions-An empirical study of three big city-regions in China.Modern Urban Research,2014,(08):9-13.]
[6]史坤博,杨永春,张伟芳,等.城市土地利用效益与城市化耦合协调发展研究--以武威市凉州区为例[J].干旱区研究,2016,33(3):655-663.[Shi Kunbo,Yang Yongchun,Zhang Weifang et al.Coupling mechanism between urban land use benefits and urbanization in the Shiyang River Basin:A case study in Liangzhou Wuwei.Arid Zone Research,2016,33(3):655-663.]
[7]张明斗,莫冬燕.城市土地利甩效益与城市化的耦合协调性分析--以东北三省34个地级市为例[J].资源科学,2014,36(1):8-16.[Zhang Mingdou,Mo Dongyan.Coupling coordination degree of urban land use benefitand urbanization.Resources Science,2014,36(1):8-16.]
[8]刘善开,韦素琼,高月华,等.基于耦合模型的城市土地集约利用与城市化协调发展研究--以福建省9个设区市为例[J].福建师范大学学报:自然科学版,2015,31(2):96-105.[Liu Shankai,Wei Suqiong,Gao Yuehua et al.Study on the coordinative development between urban land intensive utilization and urbanization based on coupling model-A case study of 9 cities districts in Fujian Province.Journal of Fujian Normal University(Natural Science Edition),2015,31(2):96-105.]
[9]白硕,杨永春,史坤博,等.中国西部河谷型城市土地利用效益与城市化耦合协调发展研究[J].世界地理研究,2016,25(6):87-95.[Bai Shuo,Yang Yongchun,Shi Kunbo et al.The research on the coupling and coordination development between urban land use benefits and urbanization of valley city in western China.World Regional Studies,2016,25(6):87-95.]
[10]梁红梅,刘卫东,刘会平,等.土地利用社会经济效益与生态环境效益的耦合关系--以深圳市和宁波市为例[J].中国土地科学,2008,22(2):42-48.[Liang Hongmei,Liu Weidong,Liu Huiping et al.Coupling relationship between social economic benefit and ecological benefit of land use:A case study of Shenzhen and Ningbo.China Land Science,2008,22(2):42-48.]
[11]梁红梅,刘卫东,刘会平,等.深圳市土地利用社会经济效益与生态环境效益的耦合关系研究[J].地理科学,2008,28(5):636-641.[Liang Hongmei,Liu Weidong,Liu Huiping et al.Coupling relationship between social economic benefit and ecological benefit of land use in Shenzhen City.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2008,28(5):636-641.]
[12]曹堪宏,朱宏伟.基于耦合关系的土地利用效益评价--以广州和深圳为例[J].中国农村经济,2010(8):58-66.[Cao Kanhong,Zhu Hongwei.The study on evaluation of land use efficiency:Guangzhou and Shenzhen cases study.Chinese Rural Economy,2010(8):58-66.]
[13]仇娟东,赵景峰,吴建树.基于耦合关系的中国区域土地利用效益水平测度[J].中国人口资源与环境,2012,22(1):103-110.[Qiu Juandong,Zhao Jingfeng,Wu jianshu.Measurement on the benefits of regional land use in China based on coupling relationship.China Population Resources and Environment,2012,22(1):103-110.]
[14]王国刚,刘彦随,方方.环渤海地区土地利用效益综合测度及空间分异[J].地理科学进展,2013,32(4):649-656.[Wang Guogang,Liu Yansui,Fang Fang.Comprehensive evaluation and spatial distinction of land use efficiency around Bohai Rim in China.Progress in geography,2013,32(4):649-656.]
[15]倪维秋.中国三大城市群城市土地利用经济,社会,生态效益的耦合协调性及其空间格局[J].城市发展研究,2016,23(12):69-77.[Ni Weiqiu.The coupling and coordination relationship and their spatial pateern of urban land use economic,social and ecological benefits of cities in three largest urban agglomerations in China.Urban Studies,2016,23(12):69-77.]
[16]宋成舜,谈兵,韩冰华,等.基于变异系数TOPSIS法的土地利用效益测度研究--以武汉城市圈为例[J].水土保持研究,2015,22(01):286-291.[Song Chengshun,Tan Bing,Han Binghua et al.Comprehensive evaluation of land use benefits based on the variance coefficient topsis method in Wuhan Metropolitan Area.Res Soil Water Conserv.,2015,22(1):286-291.]
[17]郭付友,李诚固,陈才,等.2003年以来东北地区人口城镇化与土地城镇化时空耦合特征[J].经济地理,2015,35(9):49-56.[Guo Fuyou,Li Chenggu,Chen Cai et al.Spatial-temporal coupling characteristics of population urbanization and land urbanization in Northeast China.Economic Geography,2015,35(9):49-56.]
[18]梁红梅,刘卫东,林育欣,等.土地利用效益的耦合模型及其应用[J].浙江大学学报(农业与生命科学版),2008,34(02):230-236.[Liang Hongmei,Liu Weidong,Lin Yuxin et al.Coupling model of land use benefits and its application.Journal of Zhejiang University(Agric.&LifeSci.),2008,34(2):230-236]
[19]国家统计局.中国城市统计年鉴[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2003-2016.[National Bureau of Statistics of China.China City statistical yearbook.Beijing:China Statistics Press,2003-2016.]
[20]龙冬平,李同昇,于正松,等.基于微观视角的乡村发展水平评价及机理分析--以城乡统筹示范区陕西省高陵县为例[J].经济地理,2013,33(11):115-120.[Long Dongping,Li Tongsheng,Yu Zhengsong et al.Assessment of rural development level and mechanism analysis based on microperspective-A case study of the demonstration area of urban-rural intergrationin Gaoling County of Shaanxi Province.Economic Geography,2013,33(11):115-120.]
[21]张旺,周跃云,胡光伟.超大城市“新三化”的时空耦合协调性分析--以中国十大城市为例[J].地理科学,2016,33(5):562-569.[Zhang Wang,Zhou Yueyun,Hu Guangwei.Coupling mechanism and space-time coordination of new-approach urbanization,new-approach industrialization and service industry modernization in megacity behemoths:a case study of ten cities in China.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2016,33(5):562-569.]
[22]Valerie Illingworth.The penguin dictionary of physics[M].Beijing:Foreign Language Press,1996:92-93.
[23]廖重斌.环境与经济协调发展的定量评判及其分类体系--以珠江三角洲城市群为例[J].热带地理,1999,19(2):171-177.[Liao Chongbin.Quantitaitve judgement and classification system for coordinated development of environment and economy-A case study of the city group in the Pearl River Delta.Tropical Geography,1999,19(2):171-177.]
[24]黄悦,李秋雨,梅林,等.东北地区资源型城市资源诅咒效应及传导机制研究[J].人文地理,2015,30(6):121-125.[Huang Yue,Li Qiuyu,Mei Lin et al.Resource curse effect and transmission mechanism ofresource-Based cities in Northeast China.Human Geography,2015,30(6):121-125.]
[25]刘艳军,田俊峰,付占辉,等.哈大巨型城市带要素集聚程度与生态环境水平关系演变[J].地理科学,2017,37(2):172-180.[Liu Yanjun,Tian Junfeng,Fu Zhanhui et al.The evolution of the relationship between the degree of element agglomeration and the level of the ecological environment in the Harbin-Dalian Giant Urban Belt.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2017,37(2):172-180.]
[26]孙斌栋,李琬.城市规模分布的经济绩效--基于中国市域数据的实证研究[J].地理科学,2016,36(3):328-334.[Sun Bindong,Li Wan.City size distribution and economic performance:evidence from city-regions in China.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2016,36(3):328-334.]
[27]孙平军.中国城市建设用地空间扩展的非协调性识别与调控[D].长春:东北师范大学,2014.[Sun Pingjun.The identification and regulation of non-coordination in China’s urban spatial expansion.Changchun:Northeast Normal University,2014.]
[28]陈岗,雷磊,邹华.辽中南城市群城市竞争力综合评价与时间演变分析[J].地域研究与开发,2013,32(1):52-55.[Chen Gang,Lei Lei,Zou Hua.Analysis of comprehensive evaluation of urban competitiveness and temporal evolution in mid-southern urban agglomerations of Liaoning Province.2013,32(1):52-55.]