学术期刊机构指数AAI与影响力关系研究——以图书馆情报文献学期刊为例

详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |

英文篇名：Research on the Relationship between AAI and Influence of Academic Journal——Taking Library and Information Science Journals for Example 作者：俞立平 ; 郭强华 ; 万晓云 ; 刘骏 英文作者：Yu Liping;Guo Qianghua;Wan Xiaoyun;Liu Jun;School of Statistics and Mathematics,Zhejiang Gongshang University;School of Economics,Yunnan University;Management Science School,Guizhou University of Finance and Economics; 关键词：机构指数 ; 影响因子 ; h指数 ; 被引频次 ; 影响力 英文关键词：AAI;;impact factor;;h-index;;citation frequency;;journal influence 中文刊名：XDQB 英文刊名：Journal of Modern Information 机构：浙江工商大学统计与数学学院;云南大学经济学院;贵州财经大学管理科学学院; 出版日期：2019-03-01 出版单位：现代情报 年：2019 期：v.39;No.333 基金：宁波市与中国社科院合作共建中心预研究项目“宁波市社会发展的机遇与挑战”(项目编号:ZX2015000099) 语种：中文; 页：XDQB201903016 页数：6 CN：03 ISSN：22-1182/G3 分类号：146-151

摘要

[目的/意义]研究机构指数(Author Affiliation Index)与主要文献计量指标关系具有重要意义,可以进一步推进机构指数的应用。[方法/过程]本文以图书馆情报与文献学期刊CSSCI期刊为例,基于中国知网CNKI引文数据库,计算出各期刊的机构指数,并采用相关系数、偏最小二乘法对其与影响因子、h指数、被引次数的关系进行了分析。[结果/结论]研究发现:机构指数与影响因子正相关但拟合优度不高,与h指数、被引频次不相关,说明机构指数能够提供除期刊影响力以外的其他信息;机构指数具有较好的统计学评价指标特征,可以作为期刊评价指标;机构指数的相关研究有待进一步加强。
        [Purpose/Significance] AAI(Author Affiliation Index),a bibliometric indicator proposed by American scholars but lack utilization in China,is necessary to study its characteristics and the relationship of bibliometrics indexes.[Method/Process] Based on the database of CNKI(China National Knowledge Infrastructure),this paper,taking the CSSCI journal of Library and Information Sciences for example,calculated the AAI of each journal and analyzed the relationship between AAI,impact factor,h-index and citation frequency through the method of correlation coefficient and partial least square. [Result/Conclusion] The study showed that: AAI was positively related to the impact factor but had a low fitting degree,and was not related to the h-index and the frequency of citations. It explaind that the AAI could provide other information than the journal influence; the AAI had the better statistical evaluation index characteristics which could be used as evaluation indicators for periodicals; the relevant research on AAI needed to be further strengthened.

引文

[1]Harless D,Reilly R.Revision of the Journal List for Doctoral Designation[C].Unpublished Technical Report.Richmond,VA:Virginia Commonwealth University,1998,(17):2008.
    [2]Moore W J.The Relative Quality of Economics Journals:A Suggested Rating System[J].Economic Inquiry,1972,10(2):156-169.
    [3]Ferratt T W,Gorman M F,Kanet J J,et al.Is Journal Quality Assessment Using the Author Affiliation Index[J].Communications of the Association for Information Systems,2007,(19):7.
    [4]Gorman M F,Kanet J J.Evaluating Operations Management-related Journals Via the Author Affiliation Index[J].Manufacturing&Service Operations Management,2005,7(1):3-19.
    [5]Gorman M F,Kanet J J.Evaluating Operations Management-related Journals Via the Author Affiliation Index[J].Manufacturing&Service Operations Management,2005,7(1):3-19.
    [6]Chen C R,Huang Y.Author Affiliation Index,Finance Journal Ranking,and the Pattern of Authorship[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,2007,13(5):1008-1026.
    [7]柯青,朱婷婷.基于作者机构指数的期刊评价研究述评[J].图书与情报,2017,(2):109-119.
    [8]Agrawal V K,Agrawal V,Rungtusanatham M.The Oretical and Interpretation Challenges to Using the Author Affiliation Index Method to Rank Journals[J].Production&Operations Management,2011,20(2):280-300.
    [9]Cronin B,Meho L I.Applying the Author Affiliation Index to Library and Information Science Journals[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science&Technology,2008,59(11):1861-1865.
    [10]Wold S,Martens H,Wold H.The Multivariate Calibration Problem in Chemistry Solved By the PLS Method[M].Edited by ARule and B Kagstron,Springer-Verlag,Heidelberg,1983.
    [11]Glnzel W.On the H-index-A Mathematical Approach to a New Measure of Publication Activity and Citation Impact[J].Scientometrics,2006,67(2):315-321.