量子微波制备方法与实验研究进展
|
摘要
量子微波信号既保留了经典微波信号的空间远距离传播能力,又具有非经典的量子特性,为微波频段量子通信、量子导航及量子雷达等基于大尺度动态空间环境无线传输的量子信息技术提供了可资利用的重要信号源.按照腔量子电动力学系统、超导电路量子电动力学系统和腔–光(电)–力学系统三大类型实验平台,归纳、分析了微波单光子、纠缠微波光子以及压缩微波场和纠缠微波场的产生原理、方法和相关典型实验的进展,并探讨了非经典微波场在量子导航等自由空间传输系统应用中需重点解决的若干关键问题.
Based on the characteristics of superposition, entanglement, non-locality and non-clonality of quantum mechanics, quantum information science can break through the physical limits of classical information and open up a new information processing function different from classical electromagnetic application methods. Due to the advantages of high-energy single photon in practical applications, the research and application of optical quantum information technology dominates the development of current quantum information technology.However, the free-space transmission of light waves is greatly affected by weather conditions and atmospheric particles. Comparing with other wave bands, classical microwave signal shows good penetration ability when transmitting in free space. By introducing quantum mechanics, microwave signal also exhibits non-classical merits. As quantum microwave signal inherits both classical transmission performance and quantum nonclassical features, it can be utilized as a significant signal source for diverse applications in microwave domain,such as quantum communication, quantum navigation and quantum radar, which are based on quantum technologies in large scale and dynamic free space transmission. There are three main experimental platforms on which quantum microwave is studied and produced. They are cavity quantum electrodynamics(C-QED) system,circuit quantum electrodynamics(c-QED) system, and cavity electro-opto-mechanical(EOM) system, involving with several nonlinear effects such as Kerr effect, Casimir effect, three-wave mixing, etc. In this paper, the setups of these platforms and the preparation principles are introduced. Meanwhile, the preparation principles and methods of microwave single photon, entangled microwave photons, squeezed microwave fields and entangled microwave fields are summarized and analyzed in detail from three aspects. The present status of experimental progress in the relevant fields are summarized and listed as well. Besides, key problems in the application of quantum navigation in free space utilizing quantum microwave are probed. Among them, the most pressing ones are preparation ability, decoherence in transmission and detection of entangled quantum microwave signals, which are also discussed and analyzed in this paper. Finally, we look forward to the future development of quantum microwave technology. It mainly consists of manufacturing microwave detectors with high efficiency, designing thermal photon filters, and developing suitable antennas. We hope that this study can provide useful reference for scholars who are engaged in or interested in research related to quantum microwave technologies.
Based on the characteristics of superposition, entanglement, non-locality and non-clonality of quantum mechanics, quantum information science can break through the physical limits of classical information and open up a new information processing function different from classical electromagnetic application methods. Due to the advantages of high-energy single photon in practical applications, the research and application of optical quantum information technology dominates the development of current quantum information technology.However, the free-space transmission of light waves is greatly affected by weather conditions and atmospheric particles. Comparing with other wave bands, classical microwave signal shows good penetration ability when transmitting in free space. By introducing quantum mechanics, microwave signal also exhibits non-classical merits. As quantum microwave signal inherits both classical transmission performance and quantum nonclassical features, it can be utilized as a significant signal source for diverse applications in microwave domain,such as quantum communication, quantum navigation and quantum radar, which are based on quantum technologies in large scale and dynamic free space transmission. There are three main experimental platforms on which quantum microwave is studied and produced. They are cavity quantum electrodynamics(C-QED) system,circuit quantum electrodynamics(c-QED) system, and cavity electro-opto-mechanical(EOM) system, involving with several nonlinear effects such as Kerr effect, Casimir effect, three-wave mixing, etc. In this paper, the setups of these platforms and the preparation principles are introduced. Meanwhile, the preparation principles and methods of microwave single photon, entangled microwave photons, squeezed microwave fields and entangled microwave fields are summarized and analyzed in detail from three aspects. The present status of experimental progress in the relevant fields are summarized and listed as well. Besides, key problems in the application of quantum navigation in free space utilizing quantum microwave are probed. Among them, the most pressing ones are preparation ability, decoherence in transmission and detection of entangled quantum microwave signals, which are also discussed and analyzed in this paper. Finally, we look forward to the future development of quantum microwave technology. It mainly consists of manufacturing microwave detectors with high efficiency, designing thermal photon filters, and developing suitable antennas. We hope that this study can provide useful reference for scholars who are engaged in or interested in research related to quantum microwave technologies.
引文
[1]Zhou Z W,Chen W,Sun F W,Xiang G Y,Li C F 2012Chin.Sci.Bull.57 1498(in Chinese)[周正威,陈巍,孙方稳,项国勇,李传锋2012科学通报57 1498]
[2]Wu H,Wang X B,Pan J W 2014 Scientia Sinica Informationis 44 296(in Chinese)[吴华,王向斌,潘建伟2014中国科学:信息科学44 296]
[3]Thomas B 2008 USA Patent 7359064
[4]Lanzagorta M 2011 Quantum Radar 1st edition(London:Morgan&Claypool Publishers)pp1-139
[5]Walther H,Varcoe B T H,Englert B G,Becker T 2006 Rep.Prog.Phys.69 1325
[6]Yang R C 2012 Ph.D.Dissertation(Taiyuan:Shanxi University)(in Chinese)[杨榕灿2012博士学位论文(太原:山西大学)]
[7]Joshi A,Min X 2017 Opt.Commun.393 284
[8]Bishop L S 2010 Ph.D.Dissertation(New Haven:Yale University)
[9]Hu J,Ke Q 2016 Optik(Munich,Ger.)127 3950
[10]Ghosh J,Sanders B C 2016 New J.Phys.18 033015
[11]Mi X,Cady J V,Zajac D M 2017 Appl.Phys.Lett.110 3502
[12]Zhang Y N 2014 Ph.D.Dissertation(Hefei:University of Science and Technology of China)(in Chinese)[张玉娜2014博士学位论文(合肥:中国科学技术大学)]
[13]Liu Y H 2014 Ph.D.Dissertation(Nanjing:Nanjing University)(in Chinese)[刘宇浩2016博士学位论文(南京:南京大学)]
[14]Chen X,Liu X W,Zhang K Y,Yuan C H,Zhang W P 2015Acta Phys.Sin.64 164211(in Chinese)[陈雪,刘晓威,张可烨,袁春华,张卫平2015物理学报64 164211]
[15]Zheng Q,Xu J W,Yao Y,Yong L 2016 Phys.Rev.A 94052314
[16]LaHaye M D,Rouxinol F,Hao Y,Shim S B,Irish E KQuantum Information and Computation XIII,the United States April 20,2015 p1
[17]Pu T,Wen C H,Xiang P 2015 Principles and Application of Microwave Photonics(Beijing:Electronic Industry Press)pp1-5(in Chinese)[蒲涛,闻传花,项鹏2015微波光子学原理与应用(北京:电子工业出版社)第1-5页]
[18]Duan Y S Quantum Field Theory(Beijing:High Education Press)pp88-90(in Chinese)[段一士2015量子场论(北京:高等教育出版社)第88-90页]
[19]Guo G C,Zhang H,Wang Q 2017 J.Nanjing Univ.Posts Tele.(Natural Sci.Ed.)37 1
[20]Su X L,Jia X J,Peng K C 2016 Prog.Phys.36 101(in Chinese)[苏晓龙,贾晓军,彭堃墀2016物理学进展36 101]
[21]Zhang G 2015 Ph.D.Dissertation(Beijing:Beijing Jiaotong University)(in Chinese)[张革2015博士学位论文(北京:北京交通大学)]
[22]Yamamoto N Y 2013 IEEE Photonics J.5 0701406
[23]Meschede D,Walther H,Muller G 1985 Phys.Rev.Lett.54551
[24]Lounis B,Orrit M 2005 Rep.Prog.Phys.68 1129
[25]Koroli V I,Ciorba V G 2006 Moldavian J.Phys.Sci.5 214
[26]Kuhn A,Ljunggren D 2010 Contemp.Phys.51 289
[27]Zhang Z M 2004 Chin.J.Quantum Electron.21 224(in Chinese)[张智明2004量子电子学报21 224]
[28]Zhang Z M 2006 Acta Sin.Quantum Opt.12 194
[29]Jones M L,Wilkes G J,Varcoe B T H 2009 J.Phys.B 425501
[30]Pechal M 2016 Ph.D.Dissertation(Zurich:Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich)
[31]Gu X,Kockum A F,Miranowicz A,Liu X Y,Nori F 2017Phys.Rep.718 1
[32]Wang X,Miranowicz A,Li H R 2016 Phys.Rev.A 94 053858
[33]Manninen A J,Kemppinen A,Enrico E 2014 29th Conference on Precision Electromagnetic Measurements(CPEM 2014)Rio de Janeiro Brazil,August 24,2014 p324
[34]Sathyamoorthy S R,Thomas M S,Goran J 2016 C.R.Phys.17 756
[35]Bozyigit D,Lang C,Steffen L,Fink J M,Eichler C,Baur M,Bianchetti R,Leek P J,Filipp S,Silva M P,Blais A,Wallraff A 2011 Nat.Phys.7 154
[36]Eichler C,Bozyigit D,Lang C,Steffen L,Fink J,Wallraff A2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.106 220503
[37]Peng Z H,Graaf S E,Tsai J S,Astafiev O V 2016 Nat.Commun.7 12588
[38]Yin Y,Chen Y,Sank D,O’Malley P J J,White T C,Barends R,Kelly J,Lucero E,Mariantoni M,Megrant A,Neill C,Vainsencher A,Wenner J,Korotkov A N,Cleland A N,Martinis J M 2013 Phys.Rev.Lett.110 107001
[39]Koshino K,Inomata K,Lin Z,Nakamura Y,Yamamoto T2015 Phys.Rev.A 91 043805
[40]Inomata K,Lin Z R,Koshino K,Oliver W D 2016 Nat.Commun.7 12303
[41]Guo W J 2016 Ph.D.Dissertation(Chengdu:Southwest Jiaotong University)(in Chinese)[郭伟杰2016博士学位论文(成都:西南交通大学)]
[42]Stace T M,Milburn G J,Barnes C H W 2001 Phys.Rev.B67 085317
[43]Johne R,Gippius N A 2009 Phys.Rev.B:Condens.Matter Mater.Phys.79 155317
[44]Predojevic A,Huber T,Jezek M,Jayakumar H 2013Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe and International Quantum Electronics Conference Munich,May16,2013 p6801613
[45]Emary C,Trauzettel B 2005 Phys.Rev.Lett.95 127401
[46]Shi L K,Chang K,Sun C P 2016 APS March Meeting 2016Baltimore,Maryland,March 14-18,pG1.00283
[47]Wilson C M,Johansson G,Pourkabirian A,Simoen M,Johansson R,Duty T L,Nori F,Delsing P 2011 Nature 479376
[48]Johansson J R,Johansson G,Wilson C M 2010 Phys.Rev.A82 052509
[49]Johansson J R,Johansson G,Wilson C M,Delsing P,Nori F2010 Phys.Rev.A 87 043804
[50]Lang C,Eichler C,Steffen L,Fink J M,Woolley M J,Blais A,Wallraff A 2013 Nat.Phys.9 345
[51]Dambach S,Kubala B,Ankerhold J 2017 New J.Phys.19023027
[52]Yang C P,Su Q P,Zheng S B,Han S Y 2013 Phys.Rev.A87 022320
[53]Eichler C,Lang C,Fink J M,Govenius J,Filipp S,Wallraff A 2014 Phys.Rev.Lett.109 240501
[54]Flurin E,Roch N,Pillet J D,Mallet F,Huard B 2014 Phys.Rev.Lett.114 090503
[55]Zhang H,Liu Q,Xu X S,Xiong J,Alsaedi A,Hayat T,Deng F G 2017 arXiv:1709.00120v2[quant-ph]
[56]Regal C A,Lehnert K W,2011 J.Phys.:Conf.Ser.264012025
[57]Liu Y 2016 M.S.Dissertation(Wuhan:Central China Normal University)(in Chinese)[刘艳2016硕士学位论文(武汉:华中师范大学)]
[58]Gu W J 2014 Ph.D.Dissertation(Wuhan:Central China Normal University)(in Chinese)[谷文举2014博士学位论文(武汉:华中师范大学)]
[59]Palomaki T A,Teufel J D,Simmonds R W,Lehnert K W2013 Science 342 710
[60]Tian L 2015 Ann.Phys.527 1
[61]Barzanjeh S,Guha S,Weedbrook C,Vitali D,Shapiro J H,Pirandola S 2015 Phys.Rev.Lett.114 080503
[62]Barzanjeh S,de Oliveira M C,Pirandola S 2014arXiv:1410.4024v1[quant-ph]
[63]Li X,Wu D W,Miao Q,Zhu H N,Wei T L 2018 Acta Phys.Sin.67 240301(in Chinese)[李响,吴德伟,苗强,朱浩男,魏天丽2018物理学报67 240301]
[64]Wolfgramm F,Cere A,Beduini F A,Predojevi'c A,Koschorreck M,Mitchell M W 2010 Phys.Rev.Lett.105053601
[65]Tang B,Zhang B C,Zhou L,Wang J,Zhan M S 2015 Res.Astron.Astrophys.15 333
[66]Pielawa S,Morigi G,Vitali D,Davidovich L 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett.98 240401
[67]Li P B,Li F L 2010 Phys.Rev.A 81 035802
[68]Li P B,Li F L 2010 The 14th National Conference on Quantum Optics Qufu,Shandong,August 5-8,2010 p36(in Chinese)[李蓬勃,李福利2010第十四届全国量子光学学术会议山东曲阜,2010年8月5-8日,第36页]
[69]Yamamoto T,Inomata K,Watanabe M,Matsuba K,Miyazaki T,Oliver W D,Nakamura Y,Tsai J S 2008 Appl.Phys.Lett.93 042510
[70]Zhong L,Menzel E P,Candia R D,Eder P,Ihmig M,Baust A,Haeberlein M,Hoffmann E,Inomata K,Yamamoto T,Nakamura Y,Solano E,Deppe F,Marx A,Gross R 2013 New J.Phys.15 125013
[71]Menzel E P,Candia R D,Deppe F,Zhong L,Ihmig M,Haeberlein M,Baust A,Hoffmann E,Ballester D,Inomata K,Yamamoto T,Nakamura Y,Solano E,Marx A,Gross R 2012Phys.Rev.Lett.109 250502
[72]Hoffmann E,Deppe F,Niemczyk T,Wirth T,Menzel E P,Wild G,Huebl H,Mariantoni M,Wei?l T,Lukashenko A,Zhuravel A P,Ustinov A V,Marx A,Gross R 2010 Appl.Phys.Lett.97 222508
[73]Eichler C,Bozyigit D,Lang C,Baur M,Steffen L,Fink J M,Filipp S,Wallraff A 2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.107 113601
[74]Ku H S,Kindel W F,Mallet F,Glancy S,Irwin K D,Hilton G C,Vale L R,Lehnert K W 2015 Phys.Rev.A 91 042305
[75]Bergeal N,Vijay R,Manucharyan V E,Siddiqi I,Schoelkopf R J,Girvin S M,Devoret M H 2010 Nat.Phys.6 296
[76]Bergeal N,Schackert F,Metcalfe M,Vijay R,Manucharyan V E,Frunzio L,Prober D E,Schoelkopf R J,Girvin S M,Devoret M H 2010 Nature 465 64
[77]Roch N,Flurin E,Nguyen F,Morfin P,Campagne-Ibarcq P,Devoret M H,Huard B 2012 Phys.Rev.Lett.108 147701
[78]Flurin E,Roch N,Mallet F,Devoret M H,Huard B 2012Phys.Rev.Lett.109 183901
[79]Alessandro F,Francesco C,Rosario F 2014 Phys.Rev.A 89022335
[80]Yousif T,Zhou W J,Zhou L 2016 Int.J.Theor.Phys.55 901
[81]Caspar O K,Erno D,Juha-Matti P,Tero H,Francesco M,Mika S 2017 Phys.Rev.Lett.118 103601
[82]Li P B,Gao S Y,Li F L 2013 Phys.Rev.A 88 043802
[83]Sete E A,Eleuch H 2014 Phys.Rev.A 89 013841
[84]Aggarwal N,Debnath K,Mahajan S,Bhattacherjee A B,Mohan M 2014 Int.J.Quantum Inf.12 1450024
[85]Pan G X,Xiao R J,Zhou L 2016 Int.J.Theor.Phys.55 329
[86]Palomaki T A,Harlow J W,Teufel J D,Simmonds R W,Lehnert K W 2013 Nature 495 210
[87]Wang Y D,Clerk A A 2013 Phys.Rev.Lett.110 253601
[88]Abdi M,Tombesi P,Vitali D 2015 Ann.Phys.527 139
[89]Li X,Wu D W,Miao Q,Zhu H N,Wei T L 2018 IEEEPhotonics J.10 6101107
[90]Li X,Wu D W,Wei T L,Miao Q,Zhu H N,Yang C Y 2018AIP Adv.8 065217
[91]Li X,Wu D W,Zhu H N,Miao Q,Wei T L 2018 Results Phys.11 920
[2]Wu H,Wang X B,Pan J W 2014 Scientia Sinica Informationis 44 296(in Chinese)[吴华,王向斌,潘建伟2014中国科学:信息科学44 296]
[3]Thomas B 2008 USA Patent 7359064
[4]Lanzagorta M 2011 Quantum Radar 1st edition(London:Morgan&Claypool Publishers)pp1-139
[5]Walther H,Varcoe B T H,Englert B G,Becker T 2006 Rep.Prog.Phys.69 1325
[6]Yang R C 2012 Ph.D.Dissertation(Taiyuan:Shanxi University)(in Chinese)[杨榕灿2012博士学位论文(太原:山西大学)]
[7]Joshi A,Min X 2017 Opt.Commun.393 284
[8]Bishop L S 2010 Ph.D.Dissertation(New Haven:Yale University)
[9]Hu J,Ke Q 2016 Optik(Munich,Ger.)127 3950
[10]Ghosh J,Sanders B C 2016 New J.Phys.18 033015
[11]Mi X,Cady J V,Zajac D M 2017 Appl.Phys.Lett.110 3502
[12]Zhang Y N 2014 Ph.D.Dissertation(Hefei:University of Science and Technology of China)(in Chinese)[张玉娜2014博士学位论文(合肥:中国科学技术大学)]
[13]Liu Y H 2014 Ph.D.Dissertation(Nanjing:Nanjing University)(in Chinese)[刘宇浩2016博士学位论文(南京:南京大学)]
[14]Chen X,Liu X W,Zhang K Y,Yuan C H,Zhang W P 2015Acta Phys.Sin.64 164211(in Chinese)[陈雪,刘晓威,张可烨,袁春华,张卫平2015物理学报64 164211]
[15]Zheng Q,Xu J W,Yao Y,Yong L 2016 Phys.Rev.A 94052314
[16]LaHaye M D,Rouxinol F,Hao Y,Shim S B,Irish E KQuantum Information and Computation XIII,the United States April 20,2015 p1
[17]Pu T,Wen C H,Xiang P 2015 Principles and Application of Microwave Photonics(Beijing:Electronic Industry Press)pp1-5(in Chinese)[蒲涛,闻传花,项鹏2015微波光子学原理与应用(北京:电子工业出版社)第1-5页]
[18]Duan Y S Quantum Field Theory(Beijing:High Education Press)pp88-90(in Chinese)[段一士2015量子场论(北京:高等教育出版社)第88-90页]
[19]Guo G C,Zhang H,Wang Q 2017 J.Nanjing Univ.Posts Tele.(Natural Sci.Ed.)37 1
[20]Su X L,Jia X J,Peng K C 2016 Prog.Phys.36 101(in Chinese)[苏晓龙,贾晓军,彭堃墀2016物理学进展36 101]
[21]Zhang G 2015 Ph.D.Dissertation(Beijing:Beijing Jiaotong University)(in Chinese)[张革2015博士学位论文(北京:北京交通大学)]
[22]Yamamoto N Y 2013 IEEE Photonics J.5 0701406
[23]Meschede D,Walther H,Muller G 1985 Phys.Rev.Lett.54551
[24]Lounis B,Orrit M 2005 Rep.Prog.Phys.68 1129
[25]Koroli V I,Ciorba V G 2006 Moldavian J.Phys.Sci.5 214
[26]Kuhn A,Ljunggren D 2010 Contemp.Phys.51 289
[27]Zhang Z M 2004 Chin.J.Quantum Electron.21 224(in Chinese)[张智明2004量子电子学报21 224]
[28]Zhang Z M 2006 Acta Sin.Quantum Opt.12 194
[29]Jones M L,Wilkes G J,Varcoe B T H 2009 J.Phys.B 425501
[30]Pechal M 2016 Ph.D.Dissertation(Zurich:Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich)
[31]Gu X,Kockum A F,Miranowicz A,Liu X Y,Nori F 2017Phys.Rep.718 1
[32]Wang X,Miranowicz A,Li H R 2016 Phys.Rev.A 94 053858
[33]Manninen A J,Kemppinen A,Enrico E 2014 29th Conference on Precision Electromagnetic Measurements(CPEM 2014)Rio de Janeiro Brazil,August 24,2014 p324
[34]Sathyamoorthy S R,Thomas M S,Goran J 2016 C.R.Phys.17 756
[35]Bozyigit D,Lang C,Steffen L,Fink J M,Eichler C,Baur M,Bianchetti R,Leek P J,Filipp S,Silva M P,Blais A,Wallraff A 2011 Nat.Phys.7 154
[36]Eichler C,Bozyigit D,Lang C,Steffen L,Fink J,Wallraff A2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.106 220503
[37]Peng Z H,Graaf S E,Tsai J S,Astafiev O V 2016 Nat.Commun.7 12588
[38]Yin Y,Chen Y,Sank D,O’Malley P J J,White T C,Barends R,Kelly J,Lucero E,Mariantoni M,Megrant A,Neill C,Vainsencher A,Wenner J,Korotkov A N,Cleland A N,Martinis J M 2013 Phys.Rev.Lett.110 107001
[39]Koshino K,Inomata K,Lin Z,Nakamura Y,Yamamoto T2015 Phys.Rev.A 91 043805
[40]Inomata K,Lin Z R,Koshino K,Oliver W D 2016 Nat.Commun.7 12303
[41]Guo W J 2016 Ph.D.Dissertation(Chengdu:Southwest Jiaotong University)(in Chinese)[郭伟杰2016博士学位论文(成都:西南交通大学)]
[42]Stace T M,Milburn G J,Barnes C H W 2001 Phys.Rev.B67 085317
[43]Johne R,Gippius N A 2009 Phys.Rev.B:Condens.Matter Mater.Phys.79 155317
[44]Predojevic A,Huber T,Jezek M,Jayakumar H 2013Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe and International Quantum Electronics Conference Munich,May16,2013 p6801613
[45]Emary C,Trauzettel B 2005 Phys.Rev.Lett.95 127401
[46]Shi L K,Chang K,Sun C P 2016 APS March Meeting 2016Baltimore,Maryland,March 14-18,pG1.00283
[47]Wilson C M,Johansson G,Pourkabirian A,Simoen M,Johansson R,Duty T L,Nori F,Delsing P 2011 Nature 479376
[48]Johansson J R,Johansson G,Wilson C M 2010 Phys.Rev.A82 052509
[49]Johansson J R,Johansson G,Wilson C M,Delsing P,Nori F2010 Phys.Rev.A 87 043804
[50]Lang C,Eichler C,Steffen L,Fink J M,Woolley M J,Blais A,Wallraff A 2013 Nat.Phys.9 345
[51]Dambach S,Kubala B,Ankerhold J 2017 New J.Phys.19023027
[52]Yang C P,Su Q P,Zheng S B,Han S Y 2013 Phys.Rev.A87 022320
[53]Eichler C,Lang C,Fink J M,Govenius J,Filipp S,Wallraff A 2014 Phys.Rev.Lett.109 240501
[54]Flurin E,Roch N,Pillet J D,Mallet F,Huard B 2014 Phys.Rev.Lett.114 090503
[55]Zhang H,Liu Q,Xu X S,Xiong J,Alsaedi A,Hayat T,Deng F G 2017 arXiv:1709.00120v2[quant-ph]
[56]Regal C A,Lehnert K W,2011 J.Phys.:Conf.Ser.264012025
[57]Liu Y 2016 M.S.Dissertation(Wuhan:Central China Normal University)(in Chinese)[刘艳2016硕士学位论文(武汉:华中师范大学)]
[58]Gu W J 2014 Ph.D.Dissertation(Wuhan:Central China Normal University)(in Chinese)[谷文举2014博士学位论文(武汉:华中师范大学)]
[59]Palomaki T A,Teufel J D,Simmonds R W,Lehnert K W2013 Science 342 710
[60]Tian L 2015 Ann.Phys.527 1
[61]Barzanjeh S,Guha S,Weedbrook C,Vitali D,Shapiro J H,Pirandola S 2015 Phys.Rev.Lett.114 080503
[62]Barzanjeh S,de Oliveira M C,Pirandola S 2014arXiv:1410.4024v1[quant-ph]
[63]Li X,Wu D W,Miao Q,Zhu H N,Wei T L 2018 Acta Phys.Sin.67 240301(in Chinese)[李响,吴德伟,苗强,朱浩男,魏天丽2018物理学报67 240301]
[64]Wolfgramm F,Cere A,Beduini F A,Predojevi'c A,Koschorreck M,Mitchell M W 2010 Phys.Rev.Lett.105053601
[65]Tang B,Zhang B C,Zhou L,Wang J,Zhan M S 2015 Res.Astron.Astrophys.15 333
[66]Pielawa S,Morigi G,Vitali D,Davidovich L 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett.98 240401
[67]Li P B,Li F L 2010 Phys.Rev.A 81 035802
[68]Li P B,Li F L 2010 The 14th National Conference on Quantum Optics Qufu,Shandong,August 5-8,2010 p36(in Chinese)[李蓬勃,李福利2010第十四届全国量子光学学术会议山东曲阜,2010年8月5-8日,第36页]
[69]Yamamoto T,Inomata K,Watanabe M,Matsuba K,Miyazaki T,Oliver W D,Nakamura Y,Tsai J S 2008 Appl.Phys.Lett.93 042510
[70]Zhong L,Menzel E P,Candia R D,Eder P,Ihmig M,Baust A,Haeberlein M,Hoffmann E,Inomata K,Yamamoto T,Nakamura Y,Solano E,Deppe F,Marx A,Gross R 2013 New J.Phys.15 125013
[71]Menzel E P,Candia R D,Deppe F,Zhong L,Ihmig M,Haeberlein M,Baust A,Hoffmann E,Ballester D,Inomata K,Yamamoto T,Nakamura Y,Solano E,Marx A,Gross R 2012Phys.Rev.Lett.109 250502
[72]Hoffmann E,Deppe F,Niemczyk T,Wirth T,Menzel E P,Wild G,Huebl H,Mariantoni M,Wei?l T,Lukashenko A,Zhuravel A P,Ustinov A V,Marx A,Gross R 2010 Appl.Phys.Lett.97 222508
[73]Eichler C,Bozyigit D,Lang C,Baur M,Steffen L,Fink J M,Filipp S,Wallraff A 2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.107 113601
[74]Ku H S,Kindel W F,Mallet F,Glancy S,Irwin K D,Hilton G C,Vale L R,Lehnert K W 2015 Phys.Rev.A 91 042305
[75]Bergeal N,Vijay R,Manucharyan V E,Siddiqi I,Schoelkopf R J,Girvin S M,Devoret M H 2010 Nat.Phys.6 296
[76]Bergeal N,Schackert F,Metcalfe M,Vijay R,Manucharyan V E,Frunzio L,Prober D E,Schoelkopf R J,Girvin S M,Devoret M H 2010 Nature 465 64
[77]Roch N,Flurin E,Nguyen F,Morfin P,Campagne-Ibarcq P,Devoret M H,Huard B 2012 Phys.Rev.Lett.108 147701
[78]Flurin E,Roch N,Mallet F,Devoret M H,Huard B 2012Phys.Rev.Lett.109 183901
[79]Alessandro F,Francesco C,Rosario F 2014 Phys.Rev.A 89022335
[80]Yousif T,Zhou W J,Zhou L 2016 Int.J.Theor.Phys.55 901
[81]Caspar O K,Erno D,Juha-Matti P,Tero H,Francesco M,Mika S 2017 Phys.Rev.Lett.118 103601
[82]Li P B,Gao S Y,Li F L 2013 Phys.Rev.A 88 043802
[83]Sete E A,Eleuch H 2014 Phys.Rev.A 89 013841
[84]Aggarwal N,Debnath K,Mahajan S,Bhattacherjee A B,Mohan M 2014 Int.J.Quantum Inf.12 1450024
[85]Pan G X,Xiao R J,Zhou L 2016 Int.J.Theor.Phys.55 329
[86]Palomaki T A,Harlow J W,Teufel J D,Simmonds R W,Lehnert K W 2013 Nature 495 210
[87]Wang Y D,Clerk A A 2013 Phys.Rev.Lett.110 253601
[88]Abdi M,Tombesi P,Vitali D 2015 Ann.Phys.527 139
[89]Li X,Wu D W,Miao Q,Zhu H N,Wei T L 2018 IEEEPhotonics J.10 6101107
[90]Li X,Wu D W,Wei T L,Miao Q,Zhu H N,Yang C Y 2018AIP Adv.8 065217
[91]Li X,Wu D W,Zhu H N,Miao Q,Wei T L 2018 Results Phys.11 920